Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone the parent of a child with asd and not seeking a diagnosis?

664 replies

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 13:37

Not looking for a bun fight. Just trying to sort out my thinking. Anyone with any of their own insight that they'd be willing to share?

OP posts:
BlankTimes · 06/10/2022 20:50

@Summerlaundry

ASD is not a mental health condition.
It's neurodiversity. Very differnt.

Summerlaundry · 06/10/2022 20:42

Celiac disease has definitive biomarkers though. Honestly, given the history of psychiatry, and the behaviour of pharmaceutical companies, it's perfectly reasonable for people to be cautious about the mental health industry. Diagnoses suit some people really well but not others.

Sirzy · 06/10/2022 20:06

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 06/10/2022 19:54

I have diagnoses of, among other things, ASD and coeliac disease. I'm trying to imagine a thread called "Is anyone the parent of a child with coeliac disease and not seeking a diagnosis?" and to be honest a lot of the types of things people say when it's ASD would just never fly.

Like:

  • I don't want a coeliac diagnosis because I don't want to put a label on her, she's a lovely girl
  • We have a gluten free home and put him on packed lunches and he's fine, so he doesn't really need the label and the testing is stressful
  • The label will give him an excuse for things like his picky eating and spending so much time in the bathroom, it's better if he learns how to behave
  • I didn't want her to have the coeliac label because I don't want her to feel there's something wrong with her, or to put limits on her
  • He might want to go into the army when he's older and having an official coeliac diagnosis would prevent that, so we're avoiding that label
  • The label is given out too freely these days, people with barely any symptoms get a coeliac diagnosis. She's not like those poor kids with real coeliac disease suffering obvious malnutrition, who would've had that diagnosis even thirty years ago.
  • If he had the coeliac label, other people would make assumptions about him that aren't true — they might assume he's lactose-intolerant just because lots of other coeliacs are.
  • You don't need a diagnosis, access to gluten free meals in schools/hospitals/prisons/wherever should be provided based on need, so nowhere should be insisting you produce a medical diagnosis before supplying specialist meals
  • If she has a label I'm concerned she'll feel different to her friends, and she's actually really good at coping with the diarrhoea

Very well put!

R0BYN · 06/10/2022 19:58

😬@FurryDandelionSeekingMissile

FurryDandelionSeekingMissile · 06/10/2022 19:54

I have diagnoses of, among other things, ASD and coeliac disease. I'm trying to imagine a thread called "Is anyone the parent of a child with coeliac disease and not seeking a diagnosis?" and to be honest a lot of the types of things people say when it's ASD would just never fly.

Like:

  • I don't want a coeliac diagnosis because I don't want to put a label on her, she's a lovely girl
  • We have a gluten free home and put him on packed lunches and he's fine, so he doesn't really need the label and the testing is stressful
  • The label will give him an excuse for things like his picky eating and spending so much time in the bathroom, it's better if he learns how to behave
  • I didn't want her to have the coeliac label because I don't want her to feel there's something wrong with her, or to put limits on her
  • He might want to go into the army when he's older and having an official coeliac diagnosis would prevent that, so we're avoiding that label
  • The label is given out too freely these days, people with barely any symptoms get a coeliac diagnosis. She's not like those poor kids with real coeliac disease suffering obvious malnutrition, who would've had that diagnosis even thirty years ago.
  • If he had the coeliac label, other people would make assumptions about him that aren't true — they might assume he's lactose-intolerant just because lots of other coeliacs are.
  • You don't need a diagnosis, access to gluten free meals in schools/hospitals/prisons/wherever should be provided based on need, so nowhere should be insisting you produce a medical diagnosis before supplying specialist meals
  • If she has a label I'm concerned she'll feel different to her friends, and she's actually really good at coping with the diarrhoea
BlankTimes · 06/10/2022 19:14

@containsnuts

My DD is scared of everything EXCEPT 40mph traffic where she'd rather launch herself into the road than brush past a branch or step over a pavement anomaly.
I could really do with funding for an occasional taxi since I don't drive and DD can't go on the bus re noises, movement, smells, that large step up with her motor skills being as they are she needs lifted which is getting harder as she gets bigger.

Do use the Cerebra guide for DLA it's very helpful.

cerebra.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/DLA-cerebra-dla-guide-jun21.pdf

containsnuts · 06/10/2022 17:06

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 06/10/2022 16:47

she isn't eligible for any mobility related benefits or adaptations so diagnosis won't change that

Are you sure about that? We received DLA with a mobility allowance for DD, not because she has any physical problems - she has none - but because she was not safe outside alone: she had no sense of danger and was not safe near traffic unless constantly monitored.

My DD is scared of everything EXCEPT 40mph traffic where she'd rather launch herself into the road than brush past a branch or step over a pavement anomaly.

I could really do with funding for an occasional taxi since I don't drive and DD can't go on the bus re noises, movement, smells, that large step up with her motor skills being as they are she needs lifted which is getting harder as she gets bigger. Maybe I'll apply again.

EndlessTea · 06/10/2022 16:51

It may be that different areas have different things, but our CAMHS offered parent groups, liaison with the school, social skills training, signposting to local services (we the diagnosis during lockdowns so it was all a bit weird - stuff that would normally be face to face was done online, certain groups weren’t available, etc), they call us every few months to check-in with how she’s doing, how she’s coping socially, how she’s handling growing up, etc. We didn’t take a lot of it up because they didn’t necessarily suit her or our needs. They shared quite a lot of resources.

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 06/10/2022 16:47

she isn't eligible for any mobility related benefits or adaptations so diagnosis won't change that

Are you sure about that? We received DLA with a mobility allowance for DD, not because she has any physical problems - she has none - but because she was not safe outside alone: she had no sense of danger and was not safe near traffic unless constantly monitored.

containsnuts · 06/10/2022 16:45

EndlessTea · 06/10/2022 16:37

Awaiting assessment for DD but in the meantime school has already implimented an 'autism plan' which is working really well so diagnosis was not needed.

Would all that support be put in place if you weren’t seeking a diagnosis?

@EndlessTea

Good question. It was the school that advised I seek diagnosis and they put the 'plan' in place to manage the situation in the meantime.

Mumofsend · 06/10/2022 16:41

EndlessTea · 06/10/2022 16:37

Awaiting assessment for DD but in the meantime school has already implimented an 'autism plan' which is working really well so diagnosis was not needed.

Would all that support be put in place if you weren’t seeking a diagnosis?

Yes.

It is all need based, regardless of seeking diagnosis or not.

EndlessTea · 06/10/2022 16:37

Awaiting assessment for DD but in the meantime school has already implimented an 'autism plan' which is working really well so diagnosis was not needed.

Would all that support be put in place if you weren’t seeking a diagnosis?

containsnuts · 06/10/2022 16:29

I'm interested to hear more about what additional support is available for DCs after diagnosis? Awaiting assessment for DD but in the meantime school has already implimented an 'autism plan' which is working really well so diagnosis was not needed. Despite having confirmed delayed gross motor skills she's not bad enough to need 1:1 support and she isn't eligible for any mobility related benefits or adaptations so diagnosis won't change that. Speech and language say she understands language enough to communicate her wishes and they won't do anything about her stammer or weird accent since she's too young. Peadiatrician advised there are no outpatient psychology services for children so no help for her anxiety. Is this just my experience?

WahineToa · 06/10/2022 11:53

Plus a lot of kids without conditions just don’t get on well at school, myself included! I don’t wish to deny anyones personal experience so hopefully I’ve not written anything that comes across that way.

WahineToa · 06/10/2022 11:48

Yes, a lot of parents ignore signs a child needs help, I do understand that and that extends beyond this subject. But my DD is a late teenage diagnosis, she’s an adult now, and at primary level I really didn’t see signs she needed help and no teacher raised anything. When I started to raise questions at the end of primary, with professionals including doctors, other explanations were given which I think stemmed from at the time it being seen as exclusively a male issue. Then we waited on the NHS a long time before our school paid for it privately. In my DHs case, he has Asperger’s, his mother died when he was young so a lot of his social issues were explained by that. I actually think his parents were awful in general, but I can’t blame them for not asking for help or diagnosis for something that at the time didn’t exist in the medical field. They just thought he was quiet, intelligent and maybe had hearing problems. I’m obviously not commenting on members here who are discussing their own lives and were genuinely neglected, I’m making more general comments about parents of now adults. Things were still hard to understand or know about 10 years ago. There wasn’t much autism awareness.

eyeteevee · 06/10/2022 11:32

The only downside is dealing with the knowledge of how different life could have been had our parents made sure we had this support as children instead of struggling for decades.

I can understand that. However, we haven’t known enough about autism for parents of people in I guess their 40’s or older to have any clue you needed help or had this condition.

I agree, we didn't know enough about autism, but at the same time so many parents were not naturally child focused. My own experience is extreme as I did suffer neglect but the element of 'why did you not help?' still applies to those with ordinary parents. They wouldn't have know it was autism, no, but they absolutely would have known their child's struggles in certain areas, and the majority were disciplined and left unsupported. So they didn't know it was autism, not a hell of a lot of parents ignored the signs that their child needed help.

WahineToa · 06/10/2022 11:24

The only downside is dealing with the knowledge of how different life could have been had our parents made sure we had this support as children instead of struggling for decades.

I can understand that. However, we haven’t known enough about autism for parents of people in I guess their 40’s or older to have any clue you needed help or had this condition.

Doona · 06/10/2022 11:05

The only downside is dealing with the knowledge of how different life could have been had our parents made sure we had this support as children instead of struggling for decades.

What support could you have had?

autienotnaughty · 06/10/2022 08:46

It's swings and roundabouts. If your child is autistic they will undoubtably have traits that will be recognisable to others. By not having a label your child may well just get a different label - naughty, weird etc. a diagnosis would explain those behaviours. It also depends if your child needs support- 1-1 etc. it is hard on public schools to get that support, no diagnosis may make things harder.. it's also part of a persons identity, not accepting a part of your child can be damaging to them.

firef1y · 06/10/2022 05:29

I used to think there were so many things "wrong" with me. Socially awkward. Miscommunications with people. Told I have SAD (sensory issues). Told I have depression. Told I have anxiety. I felt I was so messed up to have so many problems and overwhelmed by the idea that I should "fix" them

This so could have been be talking. I went in to my autism assessment with diagnosis of social anxiety disorder and clinical depression. Was medicated for them with drugs that made me feel like a zombie and had tried several different types of therapy, which just made me feel worse. No I don't want to draw a picture of how I'm feeling, or talk about emotions I don't understand thank you very much.
Strangely enough since getting my ASD dx I've come off all meds, just the knowing is enough.

BeserkGiraffe · 06/10/2022 01:30

In short the autism itself is the specific need presenting. The autistic person needs to be able to understand and accept themself and focus on their strengths, be kind to themselves about their weaknesses and fundamentally to gain the self-understanding of why their experience is like that.

I used to think there were so many things "wrong" with me. Socially awkward. Miscommunications with people. Told I have SAD (sensory issues). Told I have depression. Told I have anxiety. I felt I was so messed up to have so many problems and overwhelmed by the idea that I should "fix" them.

No. I had undiagnosed autism. Having the diagnosis has been life changing. I can now understand myself, what I need, why I am different, what I struggle with (and be ok with that) and what I excel at (rather than beating myself up about the things I can't do and bashing my head on metaphorical walls trying to get better at those things when I literally can't no matter how hard I try.

All of my friends diagnosed later in life have a similar story to tell.

It is the people who say that a diagnosis is a "label" who are perpetuating the stigma that autistic people face. Diagnosis and proper support is such a relief. And all of the autistic women I know who were diagnosed in our late 20s- 40s or even 50s in some cases have found it so positive. The only downside is dealing with the knowledge of how different life could have been had our parents made sure we had this support as children instead of struggling for decades.

BeserkGiraffe · 05/10/2022 22:51

What is expected from a diagnosis of a very broad spectrum issue such as autism. Why not look at diagnosing anxiety for example - or the specific need presenting?

Because then there is inappropriate treatment in many cases because the anxiety is a symptom of autism. It isn't the underlying problem. Things like CBT which are commonly recommended for anxiety because they help a large percentage of NT people are unhelpful to a large proportion of autistic people and in some cases actually cause further harm, because the implication is that you can control the anxiety by changing how you think. But autistic people generally experience anxiety for very different reasons - it is caused by their external environment and not possible to rationalise away. This then makes them feel they have failed. Again.

Autism can't be "cured" and isn't an illness. There is plenty of research on the damage that is done to autistic girls/ women in particular from being diagnosed with anxiety and depression etc and the real issue they need appropriate support with - their autism - being missed repeatedly. This is bad enough when it happens due to medical staff with insufficient knowledge, but to actively recommend that the autism diagnosis process is avoided when there are indicators of autism on purpose is bonkers. For what purpose? If the person doesn't have autism, then the process will clarify that for them. People aren't getting diagnoses given out randomly, the criteria are very clear and strict. If you have any data on the number of people that have been diagnosed in error - to support your claim that it is over-diagnosed - then please do share it.

I won't hold my breath, because we both know there is no data to support your assertion.

Sickoffamilydrama · 05/10/2022 20:19

P0MP0M · 05/10/2022 01:41

Nope. That would be classic discrimination: assuming that because some of X group of people do this, all do.

No, that is not reasonable, and frankly it's shocking that you think that it is. Try adding another word for X in place of autistic.

Don't attack me I didn't make the decision.

I didn't say I agreed with it I said I understand why they might as a blunt instrument it makes sense they probably don't want to spend time and money assessing each individual. Just as they discriminate for other things such as mild asthma ( my nephew was refused due to this hasn't had an attack in years)

I then went on to say that it isn't fair to the majority of autistic people who aren't violent.

Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow · 05/10/2022 13:09

EndlessTea · 05/10/2022 11:00

I find it very moving hearing about late diagnosed women. I know that hearing your stories online was an absolute clincher for me getting my daughter diagnosed and I am so glad I did. I think it is giving her a solid basis to develop self-awareness and self-understanding enabling her to develop helpful strategies for navigating life into the future. I feel so happy that we are able to help her with this while she is still at home with us.

My husband got an informal diagnosis at the same time (it was deliberate when we did) and that has been so beneficial too. He is now able to look at his past mistakes with warmth and humour instead of the judgemental self-hating talk from before.

As for over diagnosis I find it quite curious. I think there have always been a significant number of people who would be labelled eccentric, highly strung or outsiders who I think were on the spectrum and there have been many families tip-toeing around the peculiarities of a controlling autistic patriarch - afraid to make noise or get something out of place, but because most societies are patriarchal, autistic fathers/grandfathers could be indulged and seen as a ‘character’, or someone who likes everything to be ‘just so’. I also reckon a lot of women having nervous breakdowns and being diagnosed as PD or BP are actually autistic women in a patriarchal society where female low social status means their peculiarities are never indulged. The ongoing stress is corrosive.

Also, I think the internet is a great leveller because you don’t need to rely on subtle social cues, so autistic people who might be quiet and withdrawn or isolated irl are able to socialise comfortably, so I would guess that a disproportionate number of words on the internet are written by ND people compared to NT people, so it can feel like everyone is claiming to be autistic online.

Completely agree with this.

EndlessTea · 05/10/2022 11:00

I find it very moving hearing about late diagnosed women. I know that hearing your stories online was an absolute clincher for me getting my daughter diagnosed and I am so glad I did. I think it is giving her a solid basis to develop self-awareness and self-understanding enabling her to develop helpful strategies for navigating life into the future. I feel so happy that we are able to help her with this while she is still at home with us.

My husband got an informal diagnosis at the same time (it was deliberate when we did) and that has been so beneficial too. He is now able to look at his past mistakes with warmth and humour instead of the judgemental self-hating talk from before.

As for over diagnosis I find it quite curious. I think there have always been a significant number of people who would be labelled eccentric, highly strung or outsiders who I think were on the spectrum and there have been many families tip-toeing around the peculiarities of a controlling autistic patriarch - afraid to make noise or get something out of place, but because most societies are patriarchal, autistic fathers/grandfathers could be indulged and seen as a ‘character’, or someone who likes everything to be ‘just so’. I also reckon a lot of women having nervous breakdowns and being diagnosed as PD or BP are actually autistic women in a patriarchal society where female low social status means their peculiarities are never indulged. The ongoing stress is corrosive.

Also, I think the internet is a great leveller because you don’t need to rely on subtle social cues, so autistic people who might be quiet and withdrawn or isolated irl are able to socialise comfortably, so I would guess that a disproportionate number of words on the internet are written by ND people compared to NT people, so it can feel like everyone is claiming to be autistic online.

Swipe left for the next trending thread