Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone the parent of a child with asd and not seeking a diagnosis?

664 replies

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 13:37

Not looking for a bun fight. Just trying to sort out my thinking. Anyone with any of their own insight that they'd be willing to share?

OP posts:
orbitalcrisis · 01/10/2022 15:21

This whole thing of not 'labelling' a child is ridiculous, humans label everything, it's how language evolved! We all know that what you mean is you don't want an undesirable label attached to your child. Your ablism will not help them come to terms with their autism in the future.

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 15:19

Miffee · 01/10/2022 15:18

I went back and forth and ultimately started the process twice only to disengage both times.

They're 18 now and doing really well. They had a lot of protective factors primarily because of their personality, family and interests.

It was a risk benefit analysis for for me and it was razor thin. The primary risk for not getting one was although they didn't need support now they may need it in future and it would be much harder to get. I lived (and still live to a lesser extent) in fear I made the wrong choice. I have spoken to them directly about it and they are happy without it at the moment.

Another thing to mention is that, although in retrospect it was glaringly obvious, I didn't see it until they were 11. Once I did I was amazed I was so oblivious. The school tried to get them on the pathway when they were in infants but I thought they were mad.

Currently I feel I made the right choice but I cannot say for sure. I wouldn't offer advice. I think it is top dependent on a number of things.

Not getting a diagnosis seemed to work out well for my child but that is due to a very specific set of circumstances.

Obviously because they don't have a diagnosis I cannot say for sure they have ASD.....but they do... nobody I have spoken to about it has ever raised a doubt. They're fairly textbook.

What became obvious at 11?

OP posts:
PomegranateSeed · 01/10/2022 15:19

I’m accredited in the use of standard autism assessment tools, the AOS-2 and ADI-R both of which are used as part of a neurodevelopmental assessment. It is a very lengthy and thorough process in my experience. I became interested in this specialty partly due to my core profession but mainly due to my lived experience of having an autistic child who has been severely let down by the school system and is recovering from school trauma.

My child is very academically able and without a diagnosis it would have been very difficult to access the necessary support and get an EHCP. They will need this in order to finish their A Levels. It has also given them a context for feeling out of synch with their peers, that is they know they find certain things a bit more difficult at the moment because they are autistic. The alternative narrative for them was they were a failure. I know which one is preferable to them.

Autism isn’t a superpower, it can be disabling due to a number of reasons. Thankfully we have a neuroaffirmatve wider family who are totally accepting.

A lot of my colleagues write reports for people wanting to join the military. It’s nonsense really because of course there are a lot of undiagnosed autistic people in the military.

orbitalcrisis · 01/10/2022 15:19

@Thatboymum You really should get your son diagnosed. The waiting list is years long, by the time he needs help it will be too late. There is no such things as mild autism and I assume you mean he has a high IQ when you say 'high-functioning' (functioning labels were based on the person's IQ as measured by a standard IQ test which is no measure of anything but how good you are at passing IQ tests. It is an unhelpful and insulting measure. We now say low support needs.) but mainly that means that he is masking. His mask will slip.

Miffee · 01/10/2022 15:18

I went back and forth and ultimately started the process twice only to disengage both times.

They're 18 now and doing really well. They had a lot of protective factors primarily because of their personality, family and interests.

It was a risk benefit analysis for for me and it was razor thin. The primary risk for not getting one was although they didn't need support now they may need it in future and it would be much harder to get. I lived (and still live to a lesser extent) in fear I made the wrong choice. I have spoken to them directly about it and they are happy without it at the moment.

Another thing to mention is that, although in retrospect it was glaringly obvious, I didn't see it until they were 11. Once I did I was amazed I was so oblivious. The school tried to get them on the pathway when they were in infants but I thought they were mad.

Currently I feel I made the right choice but I cannot say for sure. I wouldn't offer advice. I think it is top dependent on a number of things.

Not getting a diagnosis seemed to work out well for my child but that is due to a very specific set of circumstances.

Obviously because they don't have a diagnosis I cannot say for sure they have ASD.....but they do... nobody I have spoken to about it has ever raised a doubt. They're fairly textbook.

Howeverdoyouneedme · 01/10/2022 15:18

Agree you need to stop caring what other people think. My youngest has a diagnosis and receives 1-2-1 support at school. I tell people so they understand, it all helps. Helps my child be accepted and adapted for and pave the way for a better future for children with these sort of needs.

Mummummummumyyyyy · 01/10/2022 15:18

eyeteevee · 01/10/2022 13:46

It's an utter disgrace that refusing a medical assessment is even an option.

We live in a free society thankfully.

Thatboymum · 01/10/2022 15:16

Punxsutawney · 01/10/2022 15:10

he’s high functioning and extremely mild.

'Mild' will be the way you and others experience his difficulties.

I am autistic myself diagnosed as a young adult and we are worlds apart from each other. His only difficulty this far is loud noises. He is extremely clever sociable and well beyond his years meeting every milestone Both school and camhs agree that there is nothing they can offer him and he would be waiting years for a formal diagnosis which would offer no support to him as he doesn’t need it. To meet him you would not directly ever even assume he was autistic. Of course it’s down on his medical records that camhs suspect autism and if at any point i feel he needs support or firm diagnosis at any point in his life I would get it for him whether that means having to go private etc But at this point he has no need and nobody including myself has any concerns

Bearsporridge · 01/10/2022 15:13

Gysophilla · 01/10/2022 15:02

I agree OP. In between the nhs diagnosis and subsequent revision, DD was labelled autistic as a slur by some very mean children (so she now sees it as an insult), and some parents told me they wouldn’t have her over as they “didn’t know how to handle” autistic children. I was the subject of a lot of gossip. Absolutely awful.

I’m sorry that you met such ignorance. There’s still a long way to go in shifting the paradigm from “let’s beat up the weird kid” to accepting and treasuring neuro divergence.

It’s really hard having to advocate. I can only do it in spurts. Looking at the people I know, the creators of web content that I consume and famous people, I’m concluding that all the interesting, creative people are neurodivergent. For a long time I thought of it as something wrong (and don’t get me wrong, it can be hard and very, very challenging) but it’s a really important neurological variation.

And as parents we have to get schools and services to buck up, and not fail our kids because the world needs them.

ChocolateSpreadOnToast · 01/10/2022 15:11

I think you need to stop caring what other people think. A diagnosis enables me to push for additional support or ensure reasonable adjustments are made. I don’t give a shit what anyone else thinks. Equally I’m
tired.

Punxsutawney · 01/10/2022 15:10

he’s high functioning and extremely mild.

'Mild' will be the way you and others experience his difficulties.

Gysophilla · 01/10/2022 15:08

I should add that a diagnosis is helpful, as DD gets extra time for (inter alia) severe processing delay. I guess my point is that the quality of nhs assessments in such a over stretched system can be questionable and I would suggest seeking second opinions or looking at specifically targeting any of the behaviours that impact learning and social skills. Eg SALT can help with social stories, an OT can help with sensory processing. These essential therapies are not automatically offered with an ASD diagnosis, one would have to be seriously impaired and at a specialist school for autism to access them in the area of London we live. I note it may vary wildly from one postcode to another.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 01/10/2022 15:05

Thatboymum · 01/10/2022 13:49

I have one with diagnosed adhd who is medicated and I actively sought that support but also have another who school referred to camhs as they believed he was autistic and camhs after 2 appts confirmed they agreed but couldn’t diagnose and asked me if I wanted him referred further and explained it’s a huge wait list and I said no . My reasons for that is because he’s high functioning and extremely mild, has amazing school support and I don’t feel he needs additional input or a label as for him it would change nothing However his younger brother desperately needed support and input so I got it

And when he struggles with relationships or gets fired from work because his 'high functioning' is no defence against abuse or immensely stressful environments - do you then wait for him to find out its not because he's incompetent at particular things and say once he's fallen to bits 'oh yeah, we did think it but you were so good at spelling, I didn't see the point in getting you legal protections or any foreknowledge of potential adult needs'?

My brother was 'odd' from infancy until death. No, he was Autistic, but it would have been too embarrassing for her to have admitted having a substandard child in her eyes. Might have saved him bullying at work, got higher qualifications and a job more appropriate for his intelligence, maybe he'd have had a relationship.

ChocolateSpreadOnToast · 01/10/2022 15:04

Moonshine5 · 01/10/2022 14:10

We live in a free country, as parents we decide. Why should people be forced to be labelled either way? And I say this with no vested interest. No judgement, only support.

Would you say the same if the child was diabetic though or had Cystic fibrosis or anorexia? Or are those ‘proper’ medical conditions.

Morph22010 · 01/10/2022 15:04

eyeteevee · 01/10/2022 14:31

I'm on the fence. A diagnosis could be held against them in future.

Can you explain?

I don’t think they can join the army with an autism diagnosis unless it changed recently. Not sure about other emergency services.

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 15:02

Gysophilla · 01/10/2022 14:55

I understand OP. We have been down an unusual route. Formal, official NHS diagnosis of ASD when DD aged 10. We did not chase it but as DD had been involved with hospital and community paeds from age 2 due to medical issues, her paeds team put her forward for assessment.

We and DD’s senior teacher at school did not feel the diagnosis was quite right. We also didn’t like the reaction of many people to the label.

We then went down the route of getting a proper private multidisciplinary assessment by a team of 7 different specialists who assessed DD over a number of weeks. Around 20 hours of assessment in total. All the professionals had both NHS and private practices. Compare and contrast with the NHS assessment: a total of 4 hours that DD spent with two different SALT, the one hour we spent with the psychiatrist (who didn’t speak to DD) and a survey completed by the school.

DD came out of the private process with a very nuanced and complex set of diagnoses but NOT ASD. The GOSH paediatrician who oversaw the whole process said that he often saw the nhs put an ASD label on children who did not have it and it then meant they went down a certain route and closed off therapeutic aspects. For our part, DD has benefitted hugely from targeted (private) OT which we would not have considered had we accepted the initial ASD label.

Thank you. Yes we have outside factors to consider too.

OP posts:
Gysophilla · 01/10/2022 15:02

I agree OP. In between the nhs diagnosis and subsequent revision, DD was labelled autistic as a slur by some very mean children (so she now sees it as an insult), and some parents told me they wouldn’t have her over as they “didn’t know how to handle” autistic children. I was the subject of a lot of gossip. Absolutely awful.

rumbypumby · 01/10/2022 15:02

No. We are going for a diagnosis.

TigerRag · 01/10/2022 15:01

Pengwinn · 01/10/2022 13:44

My parents didn't push for a diagnosis for my brother. The result was fucking up his education as he couldnt access support he should have been entitled to, he spent many years in turmoil trying to understand why he was different to his peers which led to a lot of issues, amongst other things. Getting a diagnosis as an adult is incredibly challenging and in my opinion too late in many ways in terms of ensuring you have the support you need going through school and those formative years. I'd ask someone considering this why- having a diagnosis or not won't change the child just that one hinders and one enhances their chances.

This is what I found too. My parents had great difficulty getting a diagnosis for my brother and getting a different diagnosis for me as a child so they didn't bother. As a result, my education suffered a lot.

itsgettingweird · 01/10/2022 14:59

But maybe they are just stating fact.

Neither of those 2 examples are blaming the ND child.

In fact knowing other parents included my autistic ds made others feel more relaxed to do so.

Especially when they realised he was a dream guest as he would NEVER break a rule and keep others in check Grin

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 14:57

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 01/10/2022 14:47

Can you give an example of where you think a "diagnosis would be held against them?"

All of the time in our school gate community I hear things like, 'Bobby is coming for a play, he is autistic', or ''Amelia and Jenny fell out, Jenny has adhd'. It makes me very uncomfortable how communities take that information and use it to judge. In spite of lots of kindness nobody ever uses the label as a compliment.

OP posts:
Gysophilla · 01/10/2022 14:57

And the “support” offered to us/dd when diagnosed by the nhs: nothing for dd at school and a pamphlet and a highly depressing day course for me.

NameChange30 · 01/10/2022 14:56

"I think diagnosis is really important so that the child/person understands themselves fully and doesn't constantly wonder why they might be different to their peers or struggle with/cannot do things others manage with ease."

This. And lots of things many others have said about the advantages of diagnosis.

Like a PP, I feel strongly that failing to pursue a diagnosis when autism (or any kind of neurodiversity) is suspected is neglectful and is failing your child.

Do people not care about the child's self esteem and mental health? Surely growing up autistic without knowing there's a perfectly normal explanation for being "different" is more than likely to lead to all sorts of unhappiness?

romdowa · 01/10/2022 14:56

As an adult with asd and adhd who wasn't diagnosed until adulthood, you are being very unfair to your child. You are basically denying them a part of their identity and probably setting them up for a life time of trauma and shame. Not knowing why you are different and struggling is incredibly difficult, you spend years wondering what is wrong with me.
I come from a time where girls were rarely diagnosed, I was labelled difficult, naughty and lazy. If I found out that my mother and father suspected for a minute I was neurodiverse and didn't do anything about it, I'd be furious and gutted.
Your being incredibly selfish here and I do hope you reconsider doing this to your child.

Gysophilla · 01/10/2022 14:55

I understand OP. We have been down an unusual route. Formal, official NHS diagnosis of ASD when DD aged 10. We did not chase it but as DD had been involved with hospital and community paeds from age 2 due to medical issues, her paeds team put her forward for assessment.

We and DD’s senior teacher at school did not feel the diagnosis was quite right. We also didn’t like the reaction of many people to the label.

We then went down the route of getting a proper private multidisciplinary assessment by a team of 7 different specialists who assessed DD over a number of weeks. Around 20 hours of assessment in total. All the professionals had both NHS and private practices. Compare and contrast with the NHS assessment: a total of 4 hours that DD spent with two different SALT, the one hour we spent with the psychiatrist (who didn’t speak to DD) and a survey completed by the school.

DD came out of the private process with a very nuanced and complex set of diagnoses but NOT ASD. The GOSH paediatrician who oversaw the whole process said that he often saw the nhs put an ASD label on children who did not have it and it then meant they went down a certain route and closed off therapeutic aspects. For our part, DD has benefitted hugely from targeted (private) OT which we would not have considered had we accepted the initial ASD label.

Swipe left for the next trending thread