Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone the parent of a child with asd and not seeking a diagnosis?

664 replies

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 13:37

Not looking for a bun fight. Just trying to sort out my thinking. Anyone with any of their own insight that they'd be willing to share?

OP posts:
cansu · 01/10/2022 19:52

Have two with asd both diagnosed. My partner is not diagnosed and it has had a massive impact on him. As a teacher I see many undiagnosed kids. I think it is very sad to see these kids struggle through school. The diagnosis could allow them a smoother path through the system.

Frazzledmummy123 · 01/10/2022 19:52

I can understand why you wouldn't want to diagnose or 'label' your child as it can create certain negative perceptions and may hinder opportunities. However, there is a flip side. As others have said, it can also hinder people from getting support they need, and sometimes the diagnosis is needed.

I have close family members in their 60s who I suspect may on the spectrum, they have most traits and can't look after themselves. Their behaviour is off the wall, and they clearly emotionally struggle a lot. This is what happens when autism traits go unchecked and diagnosed. It is also why I got my daughter assessed, and I have no regrets.

cansu · 01/10/2022 19:50

I think it is a mistake. I have

GG1986 · 01/10/2022 19:28

I have a patient at work who has moderate to severe ASD who wasn't diagnosed until he was nearly 15! When he first came to see us I was shocked he hadn't been diagnosed already as it was very obvious he was autistic. Parents struggled to get him to school most days or leave the house in general. He had no access to help or was able to attend a special school. Personally I would be pushing for a diagnosis sooner rather than later, I think your child would thank you for it in the future. It also is a long road to get to diagnois, my child is 7 and has had issues since nursery and we are still waiting for our first appointment! Good luck x

FMSucks · 01/10/2022 19:06

My DS12 is due to be assessed next month. I strongly suspect his Dad is autistic. When I explained to my DS what was happening and explained ASD/Asperger’s to him I could see the relief in his face, I could literally see the stress leaving his body. Like he finally could find some validation and reason for the way he thinks and feels and it has had nothing but a positive affect on him since, he has embraced it! I think he’ll read the riot act to the psychologist if she says he doesn’t have ASD 😂

He is so like his Dad, my ex, who is undiagnosed and I suspect will remain that way no matter what comes from my DS being assessed. If we had known my ex had ASD we could have gotten help to work together as a couple, so I could understand what he needed in a relationship and he could understand my needs. Unfortunately we were like two aliens to each other. I spent most of our marriage lost at sea, not understanding why he acted the way he did and why he said the things he did. It makes me so sad to know that I could have spent my life with the man who will always be the love of my life but as I’d no idea and thought he just didn’t care or love me, I eventually ended it.

I feel that if my DS does get a diagnosis and eventually goes on to meet someone who is NT they could work together and understand the needs of each other and learn to live harmoniously, something I wish I had been given in my marriage, had I known. This in itself is why it’s so important for my DS to be assessed. It’s for his future.

Heathershimmerwasmyshade · 01/10/2022 19:02

Sickoffamilydrama
thanks. I just don’t think she would like being singled out in her class. She already goes to a little class at school for social confidence and hates that. She’s very good at reading and spelling. It’s definitely the social skills she hasn’t got. There is another girl in her class who has autism. I just need to get things moving before she starts the local high school. I want to speak to her teacher about my concerns. Or maybe she’s just really shy. Obviously I can’t say she has autism without being diagnosed but I’d say I was 70% sure.

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 01/10/2022 19:01

My child wouldn't be in the right educational provision now if it weren't for diagnosis. It was an admissions requirement. Otherwise they would have been forced into a PRU which is wholly unsuited to their needs.

ParrotPoppy · 01/10/2022 18:50

MinervaTerrathorn · 01/10/2022 18:42

Is there a way to get accommodations at work with an overseas childhood diagnosis you have no record of and when you have never received support of any kind?

Yes, if you can prove the impairment in other ways e.g. via occupational health or did you mention it when you registered with a GP in the UK? It’s difficult to say exactly what evidence without knowing the exact situation and you/your history. Do you know who assessed you? If so, you could see if they still hold the records.

Sickoffamilydrama · 01/10/2022 18:49

Heathershimmerwasmyshade · 01/10/2022 18:18

My daughter has just turned 10. For years Iv thought she was on the spectrum. No one else can see it apart from me and her dad. I’ll give an example, very sensitive to clothes, if it dosent feel right, she won’t wear. Hates baths and washing hair as hates the wetness when she gets out. Struggles with showing emotion. Dosent make any conversation. Has a close few friends, but I feel like she’s a spare part. Very quiet. It’s getting more noticeable as she’s getting older. She’d be utterly devastated if she had autism, I don’t mean that in disrespect. I think because she’d be singled out in her class. I’m going to have a quiet word with her teacher. I feel like Iv buried it for too long.

DD is very similar, she initially was uncomfortable talking about her diagnosis now she has become more comfortable with it as she gets older, even telling me about the other autistic girl in her class. It also really helps her with the more social complexity of early teens to know she might find things harder or misunderstand.

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 18:46

NameChange30 · 01/10/2022 17:55

OP is clearly taking on board every post that corresponds with her opinion and ignoring those that don't! OP is only replying to those comments she likes. Typical.

Typical of what? I'm not experiencing any of the situations described in many of the posts but I don't have to validate them all for the information to be important to the person who wrote them. I have also explained that we have other personal circumstances that make our situation harder to manage. Often a diagnosis is exactly the right thing. Sometimes it isn't. To some people anyway.

OP posts:
Porcupineintherough · 01/10/2022 18:46

Lovelyricepudding · 01/10/2022 17:16

Protections until the equality act are based on disability not diagnosis

But how do you prove a need due to disability rather than a preference for, say, flexible working or a permanent desk rather than hot desking?

MinervaTerrathorn · 01/10/2022 18:42

ParrotPoppy · 01/10/2022 17:53

No, you can’t tell them you are autistic if you aren’t diagnosed. But you could, for example, inform work you have a disability that means you struggle to process verbal information therefore require written instructions rather than verbal instructions, thank you. Then if asked you could provide e.g. a schools IEP (for which a diagnosis isn’t required) with that noted on there or an email chain from college showing the same. The same for other reasonable adjustments that are required due to the disability.

People could also use the same evidence they use to apply for DLA, PIP, blue badge, disabled bus pass, access card… without having a diagnosis.

The Equality Act specifically states the cause of impairment doesn’t need to be established, so they must accept it is possible to prove disability without a diagnosis.

Is there a way to get accommodations at work with an overseas childhood diagnosis you have no record of and when you have never received support of any kind?

ParrotPoppy · 01/10/2022 18:41

I’m not saying a diagnosis isn’t life changing, but it isn’t necessary to be covered by the Equality Act.

'for whatever reasons' being the fact that I am autistic?

For some yes, but there’s also other reasons people don’t feel able to advocate for themselves. It was a comment, not a criticism.

Had no idea for a long long time and when you don't know what is 'wrong' you don't know how to fix it. It's all good and well sating what I could do legally but the reality is I had no understanding, no voice. My diagnosis gave me that.

A diagnosis isn’t necessary for giving people a voice, having the information on the law and how to advocate for themselves/others can do that without a diagnosis.


I didn't know for many years those difficulties were autism, a lot of it was put down to my abuse and neglect in childhood. A lot of it was considered, by me, to be mental illness. I had no idea. Until my second child was going through the diagnostic process (very different to my first) and I saw something, mentioned it to DH and then we started investigating which led to diagnosis?

That’s my point, the impairments were there prior to diagnosis and therefore were covered by the Equality Act even though you didn’t have a diagnosis. Someone without any difficulties wouldn’t have suspected autism, pursued an assessment and wouldn’t get a diagnosis. Mental illness can be a disability anyway.

eyeteevee · 01/10/2022 18:23

Yes, you could have. Again, reasonable adjustments are based on needs not diagnosis. You not feeling able to, for whatever reasons, isn’t the same as legally being unable to.

'for whatever reasons' being the fact that I am autistic? Had no idea for a long long time and when you don't know what is 'wrong' you don't know how to fix it. It's all good and well sating what I could do legally but the reality is I had no understanding, no voice. My diagnosis gave me that.

It’s highly unlikely you didn’t have any difficulties and evidence otherwise how did you suspect you were autistic and how did you get a diagnosis? Because in order to be diagnosed one must have persistent difficulties that “limit and impair everyday functioning”.

I didn't know for many years those difficulties were autism, a lot of it was put down to my abuse and neglect in childhood. A lot of it was considered, by me, to be mental illness. I had no idea. Until my second child was going through the diagnostic process (very different to my first) and I saw something, mentioned it to DH and then we started investigating which led to diagnosis.

It's changed my life. None of which would have happened without it.

Heathershimmerwasmyshade · 01/10/2022 18:21

She’s been able to mask it at school. But she’s getting older, I can see it more. Just want her to get the help she needs.

Heathershimmerwasmyshade · 01/10/2022 18:18

My daughter has just turned 10. For years Iv thought she was on the spectrum. No one else can see it apart from me and her dad. I’ll give an example, very sensitive to clothes, if it dosent feel right, she won’t wear. Hates baths and washing hair as hates the wetness when she gets out. Struggles with showing emotion. Dosent make any conversation. Has a close few friends, but I feel like she’s a spare part. Very quiet. It’s getting more noticeable as she’s getting older. She’d be utterly devastated if she had autism, I don’t mean that in disrespect. I think because she’d be singled out in her class. I’m going to have a quiet word with her teacher. I feel like Iv buried it for too long.

ParrotPoppy · 01/10/2022 18:08

eyeteevee · 01/10/2022 17:57

No, you can’t tell them you are autistic if you aren’t diagnosed. But you could, for example, inform work you have a disability that means you struggle to process verbal information therefore require written instructions rather than verbal instructions, thank you. Then if asked you could provide e.g. a schools IEP (for which a diagnosis isn’t required) with that noted on there or an email chain from college showing the same. The same for other reasonable adjustments that are required due to the disability.

I have nothing to provide. I'm autistic. I can communicate my needs because I know that. For the 40+ years prior though, I wasn't able to ask anyone for anything.

People could also use the same evidence they use to apply for DLA, PIP, blue badge, disabled bus pass, access card… without having a diagnosis.

Can't even get these things with a diagnosis

The Equality Act specifically states the cause of impairment doesn’t need to be established, so they must accept it is possible to prove disability without a diagnosis.

You make it all sound so easy but in the real world it isn't so.

I didn’t say it was easy, I said it was possible, because it is.

I have nothing to provide. I'm autistic. I can communicate my needs because I know that. For the 40+ years prior though, I wasn't able to ask anyone for anything.

Yes, you could have. Again, reasonable adjustments are based on needs not diagnosis. You not feeling able to, for whatever reasons, isn’t the same as legally being unable to. It’s highly unlikely you didn’t have any difficulties and evidence otherwise how did you suspect you were autistic and how did you get a diagnosis? Because in order to be diagnosed one must have persistent difficulties that “limit and impair everyday functioning”.

eyeteevee · 01/10/2022 17:57

No, you can’t tell them you are autistic if you aren’t diagnosed. But you could, for example, inform work you have a disability that means you struggle to process verbal information therefore require written instructions rather than verbal instructions, thank you. Then if asked you could provide e.g. a schools IEP (for which a diagnosis isn’t required) with that noted on there or an email chain from college showing the same. The same for other reasonable adjustments that are required due to the disability.

I have nothing to provide. I'm autistic. I can communicate my needs because I know that. For the 40+ years prior though, I wasn't able to ask anyone for anything.

People could also use the same evidence they use to apply for DLA, PIP, blue badge, disabled bus pass, access card… without having a diagnosis.

Can't even get these things with a diagnosis

The Equality Act specifically states the cause of impairment doesn’t need to be established, so they must accept it is possible to prove disability without a diagnosis.

You make it all sound so easy but in the real world it isn't so.

GrumpyInsomniac · 01/10/2022 17:55

I wish I had been diagnosed as a child because it would have helped to know that there was a good reason for my being different and that I wasn’t just weird. I wouldn’t have spent so much effort just trying to appear ‘normal’ and I might have had accommodations for things like executive dysfunction that I suffer from to this day, despite being someone who was always academically gifted and who people always think has their shit together.

I may look HF, but I’ve got numerous suicide attempts behind me and struggle in so many ways that aren’t visible on the outside, no matter how competent I may appear. Discovering there was support at university when I returned for my MSc was amazing. I really wish I’d had it available to me as an undergrad.

NameChange30 · 01/10/2022 17:55

OP is clearly taking on board every post that corresponds with her opinion and ignoring those that don't! OP is only replying to those comments she likes. Typical.

ParrotPoppy · 01/10/2022 17:53

eyeteevee · 01/10/2022 17:41

Because all the same impairments will be present whether someone has a diagnosis or not and the impairments will have the same effects on the individual whether diagnosed or not. How one can evidence the impairment and the effects of that impairment depends on what the impairment is but it could include any of GP notes, school reports, emails, occupational health assessment.

I couldn't just elk into my work and tell them I'm autistic and need x/y/z adjusted though, without a diagnosis. I have very little to evidence on my GP notes as, is commonly seen, I rarely seek help. As a child I was 'shy' - I was also neglected and abused.

Or are you saying you don’t think anyone without a diagnosis can never be classed as disabled?

No I definitely didn't say that. I asked how you prove it.

No, you can’t tell them you are autistic if you aren’t diagnosed. But you could, for example, inform work you have a disability that means you struggle to process verbal information therefore require written instructions rather than verbal instructions, thank you. Then if asked you could provide e.g. a schools IEP (for which a diagnosis isn’t required) with that noted on there or an email chain from college showing the same. The same for other reasonable adjustments that are required due to the disability.

People could also use the same evidence they use to apply for DLA, PIP, blue badge, disabled bus pass, access card… without having a diagnosis.

The Equality Act specifically states the cause of impairment doesn’t need to be established, so they must accept it is possible to prove disability without a diagnosis.

Haffiana · 01/10/2022 17:52

My SENCO niece told me recently that of the families she worked with who did not want to pursue a diagnosis for their clearly ASD children, it was in every case opposed by an equally clearly undiagnosed ASD parent.

Sirzy · 01/10/2022 17:47

Given the nature of the diagnostic criteria the chances of someone being misdiagnosed with autism/adhd or similar are remote. Many more people will slip through the net than are caught that shouldn’t be!

its not a label it’s a diagnosis. Unless you think asthma is a label? Or diabetes?

LuffleGro · 01/10/2022 17:47

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 01/10/2022 14:47

Can you give an example of where you think a "diagnosis would be held against them?"

I believe they can't join the RAF which is a shame for my eldest as it would be a good way for them to pursue their chosen career.

Rosesandstars · 01/10/2022 17:45

I can see where you're coming from with this- it's attempting to avoid a label being placed on your child and trying to prevent people from viewing them as different or disabled (i am disabled, I'm not being ablest) . It makes sense but then that has to weighed up with the benefits of diagnosis, which usually far outweigh the disadvantages.

Swipe left for the next trending thread