Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone the parent of a child with asd and not seeking a diagnosis?

664 replies

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 13:37

Not looking for a bun fight. Just trying to sort out my thinking. Anyone with any of their own insight that they'd be willing to share?

OP posts:
Lovelyricepudding · 01/10/2022 23:01

OddshoesOddsocks · 01/10/2022 22:56

There will be certain things that will not be available to him without a diagnosis.
Whilst dd’s schools (primary and now secondary) have seen supportive, a diagnosis unlocks ‘level 2 of support’ if you like.

If your schools require a diagnosis to provide support then they are failing to follow the law.

OddshoesOddsocks · 01/10/2022 22:56

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 22:06

I think I can get him all of this professional understanding without the label.

There will be certain things that will not be available to him without a diagnosis.
Whilst dd’s schools (primary and now secondary) have seen supportive, a diagnosis unlocks ‘level 2 of support’ if you like.

Lovelyricepudding · 01/10/2022 22:55

If they assaulted someone seriously and you said 'it was autism that made me do it" then you may be sent to a secure mental hospital rather than prison. You might not think this was a better outcome. Especially if the time you would need to spend at the latter was open ended.

Porcupineintherough · 01/10/2022 22:50

If my teen assaulted someone as a result of autistic overstimulation (he wouldnt but for the sake of arguement ) then his autism would mean he would be classed as vulnerable. That would affect the way the police deal with him, how he was questioned, and who would be with him during questioning. It wouldn't stop him being charged or cautioned unless his disability was such that he was considered not competent (ie lacking in capacity). His autism might be considered a mitigating circumstance during sentencing if convicted, I guess depending on the exact circumstances.

RobertaFirmino · 01/10/2022 22:30

Say a teen whose parents had declined past opportunities for diagnosis got into trouble with the police. Let's say they assaulted someone after becoming over-stimulated. What would happen to them? I'm assuming that autism as a mitigating circumstance simply wouldn't wash.

Didiplanthis · 01/10/2022 22:13

I have ADHD. Diagnosed as an adult. I also know I have ASD. I know that as a child it would have been far less damaging to be 'labelled' as having ADHD/ASD then being labelled as I was as 'lazy, careless, scruffy, silly, immature, messy' my entire childhood was miserable not because I was those things but because every adult blamed me for not trying harder, being better. I could no more change them than fly. My mental health is irreparably damaged as a result and my life changed because of it. My children have ADHD and ASD... they are all those things too but I can say it's OK, well done for trying, I can clear up the mess without shouting because I know their executive function is delayed. I can help them be the best they can be and feel OK about being them. It's not a 'label' its an explanation and it helps us steer the boat through the rocky waters with a little bit of a map.

SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 01/10/2022 22:10

FMSucks · 01/10/2022 19:06

My DS12 is due to be assessed next month. I strongly suspect his Dad is autistic. When I explained to my DS what was happening and explained ASD/Asperger’s to him I could see the relief in his face, I could literally see the stress leaving his body. Like he finally could find some validation and reason for the way he thinks and feels and it has had nothing but a positive affect on him since, he has embraced it! I think he’ll read the riot act to the psychologist if she says he doesn’t have ASD 😂

He is so like his Dad, my ex, who is undiagnosed and I suspect will remain that way no matter what comes from my DS being assessed. If we had known my ex had ASD we could have gotten help to work together as a couple, so I could understand what he needed in a relationship and he could understand my needs. Unfortunately we were like two aliens to each other. I spent most of our marriage lost at sea, not understanding why he acted the way he did and why he said the things he did. It makes me so sad to know that I could have spent my life with the man who will always be the love of my life but as I’d no idea and thought he just didn’t care or love me, I eventually ended it.

I feel that if my DS does get a diagnosis and eventually goes on to meet someone who is NT they could work together and understand the needs of each other and learn to live harmoniously, something I wish I had been given in my marriage, had I known. This in itself is why it’s so important for my DS to be assessed. It’s for his future.

I know what you’re saying, but for us having a suspicion that this is the case also gives us all a better understanding of why DS is like he is. We can make exceptions for him because he struggles with certain things without needing to name it.

He and his GF both discuss the traits and events that have led us to suspect he would have been diagnosed with Asperger’s (when that was a thing.). She understands and hopefully she, or any future partners, will bear in mind that he doesn’t think about things the same way as most people, and they can work with that, diagnosis or not.

TBH once my XH (his dad) was told that he should consider getting a diagnosis, he used that as his get out of jail card and the marriage was essentially over. We’d been in counselling and he was told that he wasn’t suited to counselling because it relies on empathy and he didn’t appear to have any! Looking back I can see so many signs, but at the time I was banging my head against the wall trying to get him to see things from my POV!

Once ASD was a possibility he would use it whenever I asked him to get involved, help out, spend time with me and the DCs etc. It turned out he just wasn’t suited to family life, and that potential ‘label’ meant he could opt out because it made him uncomfortable. He is now much happier as a part time dad, and the DCs understand that he has some limitations on what they can expect from him, so nobody is disappointed!

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 22:07

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 22:06

I think I can get him all of this professional understanding without the label.

Wonersh, rather than think.

OP posts:
coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 22:06

zurala · 01/10/2022 20:31

As an autistic woman diagnosed two years ago, I think not getting a diagnosis for your child is basically ableism.
Knowing who you are and why enables you to get support and make the right choices. Why would you deny your child that? I think it's abusive discrimination, frankly.

I think I can get him all of this professional understanding without the label.

OP posts:
Miffee · 01/10/2022 21:28

@Haffiana

That sounds about right. The school tried to refer my child on from an initial EP assessment when they were 5. I said no as I honestly just thought they were being OTT. That was, of course, because they seemed "normal" to me because they were like me and I am "normal".

6 years on when I realised they were certainly autistic I did a lot of research about it trying to decide if to pursue a diagnosis and a lot of it... sounded very familiar and I realised the flaw in my logic.

As I said earlier I still decided against pursuing diagnosis.

Vgbeat · 01/10/2022 21:20

I can see why you might not. Everyone seems desperate to give children labels nowadays and I can see why someone may not want to.

R0BYN · 01/10/2022 21:08

Heathershimmerwasmyshade · 01/10/2022 18:18

My daughter has just turned 10. For years Iv thought she was on the spectrum. No one else can see it apart from me and her dad. I’ll give an example, very sensitive to clothes, if it dosent feel right, she won’t wear. Hates baths and washing hair as hates the wetness when she gets out. Struggles with showing emotion. Dosent make any conversation. Has a close few friends, but I feel like she’s a spare part. Very quiet. It’s getting more noticeable as she’s getting older. She’d be utterly devastated if she had autism, I don’t mean that in disrespect. I think because she’d be singled out in her class. I’m going to have a quiet word with her teacher. I feel like Iv buried it for too long.

She doesn’t have to tell anyone in her class.

And she might not be devastated. She might be relieved to have an explanation of why she feels “different “.

You say she’d be singled out in her class. Why do you think that? Are you sure that there are no other neurodiverse kids in her class? That’s surprising, unless its a very small class.

OddshoesOddsocks · 01/10/2022 20:48

(I also say that as someone in her 30s seeking an ADHD diagnosis for herself)

OddshoesOddsocks · 01/10/2022 20:47

Haven’t read the full thread but just to put my own 2 pence worth in…

I have suspected Dd has ASD since she was little, something was always ‘a little off’ but the results were usually positive (very good and early speaker, high reading level etc) so it was never a ‘problem’ until one day it was a BIG problem.
Shes now 11 with MH issues, struggling with the transition to high school and on a huge waiting list to be assessed so she can access the proper help.

So, I understand why you haven’t jumped on the chance to assess him but my advice is to do it now so you’re ahead of the game in case one day it all turns and you find that the help you desperately need NOW is years away.

eyeteevee · 01/10/2022 20:35

I feel like women diagnosed as adults who wish they were diagnosed as a child don't understand the reality of a 90s diagnosis. I was offered no support. I knew of no female autistic role models.

I totally get that. It reframed my life experiences and made me understand my vulnerability. When I say I wish I had known, I suppose I mean I wish I had known with the added benefit of all the knowledge that we have now.

MinervaTerrathorn · 01/10/2022 20:32

I feel like women diagnosed as adults who wish they were diagnosed as a child don't understand the reality of a 90s diagnosis. I was offered no support. I knew of no female autistic role models.

zurala · 01/10/2022 20:31

As an autistic woman diagnosed two years ago, I think not getting a diagnosis for your child is basically ableism.
Knowing who you are and why enables you to get support and make the right choices. Why would you deny your child that? I think it's abusive discrimination, frankly.

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 20:26

FMSucks · 01/10/2022 19:06

My DS12 is due to be assessed next month. I strongly suspect his Dad is autistic. When I explained to my DS what was happening and explained ASD/Asperger’s to him I could see the relief in his face, I could literally see the stress leaving his body. Like he finally could find some validation and reason for the way he thinks and feels and it has had nothing but a positive affect on him since, he has embraced it! I think he’ll read the riot act to the psychologist if she says he doesn’t have ASD 😂

He is so like his Dad, my ex, who is undiagnosed and I suspect will remain that way no matter what comes from my DS being assessed. If we had known my ex had ASD we could have gotten help to work together as a couple, so I could understand what he needed in a relationship and he could understand my needs. Unfortunately we were like two aliens to each other. I spent most of our marriage lost at sea, not understanding why he acted the way he did and why he said the things he did. It makes me so sad to know that I could have spent my life with the man who will always be the love of my life but as I’d no idea and thought he just didn’t care or love me, I eventually ended it.

I feel that if my DS does get a diagnosis and eventually goes on to meet someone who is NT they could work together and understand the needs of each other and learn to live harmoniously, something I wish I had been given in my marriage, had I known. This in itself is why it’s so important for my DS to be assessed. It’s for his future.

That sounds very positive.

OP posts:
ParrotPoppy · 01/10/2022 20:25

I am not taking over you or invalidating you. This is a discussion forum and I am pointing out a diagnosis isn’t necessary to be covered by the Equality Act.

eyeteevee · 01/10/2022 20:19

@ParrotPoppy

I feel as if I am being talked over repeatedly, my experience invalidated, and that ended with my diagnosis, so I'm going to step away.

ParrotPoppy · 01/10/2022 20:14

I keep coming back to this but not quite knowing what to say. I'm not sure why you are unwilling to accept my viewpoint which has been my real life experience.

Because you seem to be insisting that you needed a diagnosis in order to be covered under the Equality Act, which isn’t correct. You acknowledge you had difficulties, you just didn’t know they were attributed to autism, therefore those impairments would have been covered by the Equality Act (or it’s predecessor depending on the year) before you were diagnosed. That is fact, not related to your “viewpoint”.

I didn't though, for about 40 years. Back in the 90s when I was running out of school nobody helped, I was punished. When I got my first job and needed help it wasn't there. I don't suspect autism, I thought I was fucking weird. Not ok. Abnormal. I struggled through my life because I did not know.

You are misunderstanding. I didn’t say you had to suspect autism from childhood. I said if you didn’t have any difficulties you wouldn’t have suspected autism or pursued an assessment and diagnosis.

You posted you had/have difficulties and you must have suspected autism at some point otherwise why would you pursue an assessment and diagnosis. As the criteria for diagnosis is difficulties that “limit and impair everyday functioning”. Why would anyone without any difficulties think they may be autistic as they wouldn’t meet the criteria.

The law may have been on my side but realistically if I had walked into work and said X is difficult, can you arrange Y, the first thing they would have looked for would be a reason, and I did not have that.

You did have a reason. The reason doesn’t need to have a diagnosis. The impairments themselves are reason enough.


Knowing who you are is one of the most important things a person could ever have.

Please quote where I have posted otherwise?

KnitFastDieWarm · 01/10/2022 20:11

I am autistic. I wasn’t diagnosed as a child. I was, however, ‘labelled’ as weird, odd, crazy, strange, stuck up, boring, etc etc. It took me years to shake the trauma of the bullying and exclusion I endured.

As a happily autistic adult, I bloody LOVE my autistic label. It’s me! It’s validation that i’m not any of the above things; i’m just different and that’s ok.

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 01/10/2022 20:01

Heathershimmerwasmyshade · 01/10/2022 18:18

My daughter has just turned 10. For years Iv thought she was on the spectrum. No one else can see it apart from me and her dad. I’ll give an example, very sensitive to clothes, if it dosent feel right, she won’t wear. Hates baths and washing hair as hates the wetness when she gets out. Struggles with showing emotion. Dosent make any conversation. Has a close few friends, but I feel like she’s a spare part. Very quiet. It’s getting more noticeable as she’s getting older. She’d be utterly devastated if she had autism, I don’t mean that in disrespect. I think because she’d be singled out in her class. I’m going to have a quiet word with her teacher. I feel like Iv buried it for too long.

There are some great Neurodiversity speakers these days, Google Ellie Middleton - Maybe hearing young women like her speak will help your daughter in time. Lots on instagram too

eyeteevee · 01/10/2022 19:58

That’s my point, the impairments were there prior to diagnosis and therefore were covered by the Equality Act even though you didn’t have a diagnosis.

I keep coming back to this but not quite knowing what to say. I'm not sure why you are unwilling to accept my viewpoint which has been my real life experience.

Someone without any difficulties wouldn’t have suspected autism, pursued an assessment and wouldn’t get a diagnosis. Mental illness can be a disability anyway.

I didn't though, for about 40 years. Back in the 90s when I was running out of school nobody helped, I was punished. When I got my first job and needed help it wasn't there. I don't suspect autism, I thought I was fucking weird. Not ok. Abnormal. I struggled through my life because I did not know.

The law may have been on my side but realistically if I had walked into work and said X is difficult, can you arrange Y, the first thing they would have looked for would be a reason, and I did not have that.

Knowing who you are is one of the most important things a person could ever have.

MinervaTerrathorn · 01/10/2022 19:57

ParrotPoppy · 01/10/2022 18:50

Yes, if you can prove the impairment in other ways e.g. via occupational health or did you mention it when you registered with a GP in the UK? It’s difficult to say exactly what evidence without knowing the exact situation and you/your history. Do you know who assessed you? If so, you could see if they still hold the records.

I have literally nothing except the diagnosis as far as I remember. I have never mentioned it to any GP. I don't know who assessed me. Apparently the records would only have to be kept until my 25th birthday in the country I was diagnosed.