Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone the parent of a child with asd and not seeking a diagnosis?

664 replies

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 13:37

Not looking for a bun fight. Just trying to sort out my thinking. Anyone with any of their own insight that they'd be willing to share?

OP posts:
Mumofsend · 02/10/2022 09:09

I'm very very glad both of my children are diagnosed.

They are both well supported in school regardless of diagnosis. However, it really benefits their sense of identity, not thinking they are stupid. It helps people be far more understanding.

It isn't about labelling them but ensuring they can access the full support and understanding. I think it's selfish to deny a child that.

Sirzy · 02/10/2022 09:03

Ds got his ehcp before he had the autism diagnosis. However the information we had from the ongoing autism assessment certainly influenced the plan and the main reason we got one was the Ed psych report school had commissioned knowing the issues we where facing.

however if a parent is dead set against embarking on the process of a potential diagnosis would they agree to the level of assessments and observations needed for an ehcp to even be considered? The bar may be set pretty low of the needs assessment but for a plan worth its salt to be put into place there will be a lot of professional reports highlighting the areas of struggle

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 08:58

Parents don’t have to accept schools and LAs acting unlawfully. They can challenge it, and it doesn’t require a diagnosis to do so. As you say DC whose parents who know the system and can advocate for them get better support. But all parents should be supported to advocate for their DC.

In my borough, without a diagnosis, a child will not get one. It’s that simple.

No, it’s not. EHCPs are based on needs, not diagnosis. Parents can challenge a refusal to assess or issue and SENDIST will not consider “they don’t have a diagnosis” to be an acceptable defence.

Then you have to look at how mainstream schools actually use the funding that comes attached to an EHCP. A lot of schools (I would say the majority of secondary schools) use the individual child’s funding to fund TA support that they then spread thinly among children without an EHCP, often without a diagnosis, but with significant needs.

Again parents should be supported to enforce the EHCP.

ScentOfSawdust · 02/10/2022 08:57

I thought that DD2 might have ASD when she was still quite small but DH didn’t agree. She was doing fine at school so I didn’t push it. I wish I had.

She found secondary school increasingly difficult and then had a full scale mental health crisis in GCSE year that we are still clawing our way back from. She still doesn’t have a formal diagnosis (5 months to go on the waiting list) but every professional who’s seen her is pretty certain that ASD is at the root of her anxiety. She is desperate for a diagnosis so she can have proof that she’s not just ‘weird’ and so she can have a shorthand for explaining herself to others.

Conversely, her elder sister also shows some autistic traits. I have asked her if she’s like an assessment but she doesn’t want one. I won’t push it but let her know that it’s always an option open to her if she changes her mind. I was very similar to her as a kid and it would have made so much difference if my parents had recognised the differences I saw in myself.

There are so many kids these days with diagnoses of neurodiversity that there is no judgement from their peers. It’s not something to be scared of.

Notplayingball · 02/10/2022 08:56

I don't want a child to "just about manage" I want him/her to thrive.

Notplayingball · 02/10/2022 08:53

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 08:46

which locks them out of support completely.

No it doesn’t, it may mean parents have to enforce their child’s rights, but they don’t have to accept the school’s decision.

My child struggles to stay focused, and is very impulsive. Apparently "just about managing" is fine for him. They say they address his needs, they are assessed regularly like all other pupils.

Without a diagnosis, I don't see how the situation for him will change.

HenryPlease · 02/10/2022 08:51

Schools do break the law, every day. I’ve worked in mainstream secondary education for 20 years. Things have never been worse. There is not enough funding. There are woefully inadequate resources. The school I work in currently has to fight to get the EP in once or twice a year to see a handful of children.

EHCP applications are routinely turned down. In my borough, without a diagnosis, a child will not get one. It’s that simple. There are too many children WITH diagnoses fighting for one for the LA to be bothered to consider giving that money to those without.

Even for the children who get an EHCP, getting adequate funding attached and good quality expert advice written into it is very, very hard.

Then you have to look at how mainstream schools actually use the funding that comes attached to an EHCP. A lot of schools (I would say the majority of secondary schools) use the individual child’s funding to fund TA support that they then spread thinly among children without an EHCP, often without a diagnosis, but with significant needs.

Is this morally wrong? Is it illegal? Yes.
But this is the reality of mainstream SEND provision in England, at least.

In my experience, only children with vocal, educated parents who fight tooth and nail to get a diagnosis, get an EHCP and hold the LA and school to account at every annual review get the support they need and are entitled to.

It’s a bleak picture.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 08:46

which locks them out of support completely.

No it doesn’t, it may mean parents have to enforce their child’s rights, but they don’t have to accept the school’s decision.

Notplayingball · 02/10/2022 08:38

Lovelyricepudding · 01/10/2022 23:01

If your schools require a diagnosis to provide support then they are failing to follow the law.

Or you have schools who claim that your child is not classed as a "priority", which locks them out of support completely. Without a diagnosis, what hope do you have?

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 08:34

The vague needs and provision in EHCPs isn’t due to a lack of diagnosis. It is due to vague, woolly &/or absence of reports from SALT, OT, EP. It is more than possible to have a detailed, specified and quantified B&F without a diagnosis.

With the exception of admission to specialist ASD schools that require a diagnosis and sometimes LA’s specialist autism teaching service, EHCPs are based on needs, not diagnosis.

cansu · 02/10/2022 08:29

A diagnosis opens the door to more help. The other part is parents being open to looking at specialist placements. If your child is struggling on mainstream you need to be the person who pushes for professional assessments or who goes to other schools and sees what is out there. I have come across children who even with support from a TA and other adaptations are not thriving. They are unhappy and uncomfortable in a large busy school that is not set up to meet their needs. Often they are three years or more behind their peers and it is not good for them. They often have vague ' social and communication needs' identified as their parents have not sought a diagnosis. Yes a diagnosis would help open the door to a more appropriate provision. My children's asd specialist school requires a diagnosis of autism for entry.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 08:17

Notplayingball · 02/10/2022 08:06

Exactly.

There are many ways to prove an impairment without a diagnosis.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 08:16

BlankTimes · 02/10/2022 02:19

@Lovelyricepudding
"If your schools require a diagnosis to provide support then they are failing to follow the law."

That's fine in theory, most parents are aware of that, but they are also aware that it doesn't work for many pupils in reality.

For example, how would you get education providers to present information to a child in a way they could understand it, without documented proof of that need?
Are you saying a parent's request is enough?

Say a child has slow processing speed. Which of these scenarios is most likely to to have school provide the support this child needs?

A. Parent, with no evidence, suspects their child may have slow processing speed, so asks school for their child to be seated at the front of the class, then all instructions to be delivered to child by teacher firstly gaining their attention by saying their name, then giving them a verbal and written sheet of one-step instructions for that lesson.

B. Parent sends school a comprehensive report undertaken by SaLT outlining which tests were used to determine processing speed, what the child's score was and the SaLT's professional recomendations based on their assessment, - child to be seated at the front of the class, then all instructions to be delivered to child by teacher firstly gaining their attention by saying their name, then giving them a verbal and written sheet of one-step instructions for that lesson.

Parents should be supported to understand the law and how they can challenge the LA via SENDIST as SENDIST certainly don’t require a diagnosis.

Documented proof doesn’t have to be a diagnosis. Both of your scenarios could occur without a formal ASD diagnosis.

Notplayingball · 02/10/2022 08:06

eyeteevee · 01/10/2022 17:27

Protections until the equality act are based on disability not diagnosis

But without the diagnosis how do you prove disability?

Exactly.

TigerRag · 02/10/2022 06:44

Porcupineintherough · 01/10/2022 22:50

If my teen assaulted someone as a result of autistic overstimulation (he wouldnt but for the sake of arguement ) then his autism would mean he would be classed as vulnerable. That would affect the way the police deal with him, how he was questioned, and who would be with him during questioning. It wouldn't stop him being charged or cautioned unless his disability was such that he was considered not competent (ie lacking in capacity). His autism might be considered a mitigating circumstance during sentencing if convicted, I guess depending on the exact circumstances.

I had someone harass me and the police refused to do anything because he has Autism and therefore, doesn't understand. We're not talking about someone who doesn't talk, needs supervision 24/7, etc. Thankfully when I spoke up at the group we met at, they did kick out. Several people had raised their concerns.

I didn't bother going to the police when a different person harassed me. When I raised my concerns at a different group, I was told it was "ok" because he has mental health problems.

fluffytoe · 02/10/2022 06:42

Swept under the rug*

fluffytoe · 02/10/2022 06:29

We are not. I suspect myself and dh are also autistic well it's pretty obvious tbh.
But if dh and I were to have had a diagnosis, it would have been a negative thing imo to have one. When we work all over the world, I'm not sure all countries are as accepting of a diagnosis as others.

I also wonder if we'd have been refused to work in some jobs but would be under the guise of something else and self under the rug.
However we do have to work around a lot of things but have simply devised a lifestyle around autism instead of trying to force ourselves to live 'normal' lives. Still called odd but went into jobs that have others like us. We don't socialise at all outside of work because it's too much. We feel like we know exactly what we're doing with our one dc.
We also only have one dc as we wouldn't cope with more than one because we dedicate so much time to them. We will be raising them to know what we think and then it will be their choice hopefully as an adult when they can have the full consequences & benefits of a diagnosis put to them.

We have enough money not to worry too much though. School have mentioned it but again we've worked around it however they are very bright and at a private school with small classes so most of it is going ok so far. If there are any serious issues affecting dc or others who have to deal with dc we'd reconsider the benefits/consequences again then.

LilyPAnderson · 02/10/2022 05:07

Yes that's true. If somebody is a danger to the public, then they will still be taken away from the general public, but if they have mitigating circumstances that can be treated, then instead of a prison they might be taken to a secure hospital for medication.
Although at my social I attend after I was diagnosed in middle age, there's a young lad, and I don't want to sound over judgemental but putting it blunt, he often ruins the evening by going into a meltdown. Once we had just had meals served in a restaurant, and had to leave them because he didn't like the subject we were talking about, and started waving his knife and fork in his hands, scaring others.
As a person who has had a strict upbringing and had no excuses for not acting how society expects me to, I can't help being judgemental and wondering if he has been made to feel that he can have an excuse to act like that.

It's quite confusing when the spectrum is so wide. I have many problems with over stimulation and anxiety, but feel too embarrassed to act antisocial in public and wonder why some people feel it's OK. I know it can he stressful to put on a normality mask, and then I like to spend time on my own such as reading to relax, but I can still do it, as I think some people on the spectrum think too much of themselves than how their behaviour affects others. In my opinion people on the spectrum should be taught that they should also think of others, as I realised that I was spending too much only caring about myself.

sazza76 · 02/10/2022 04:49

Part of the reason for wanting our son diagnosed (or not if if that turned out to be the case) as his issues arose was based on the experiences of several wider family members who were diagnosed as adults. They had loving, supportive parents but felt that this didn’t stop the outside world being cruel and damaging their self esteem beyond repair. They felt different, were treated different and grew up thinking they were ‘abnormal’. Both were diagnosed during a mental health crisis and one had made several suicide attempts during their lifetime. They didn’t blame anyone but felt with hindsite (which I know is a wonderful thing) that knowing they were autistic would have hugely benefitted them growing up.

Some of the comments on this thread from people who have been diagnosed as adults have been really insightful, thank you for posting them.

LilyPAnderson · 02/10/2022 02:43

LilyPAnderson · 02/10/2022 02:37

As a person with Asperger's who wasn't diagnosed until middle age, I feel angry people who were diagnosed as children had lots of help and support, while I had nothing but emotional damage from being punished and blamed for the symptoms.
Apart from the main symptoms such as having bad executive functions, there are other things connected, such as being clumsy and being made to spend hours in handwriting classes and still being confused why no matter how hard I tried my writing still looked dumb. It made me less confident when taking exams, but if I'd had a diagnosis I could have had an excuse why my writing was bad.

Although as a person who wasn't diagnosed until middle age, now I attend social groups with younger people who have had lots of help and support, I feel bad that I'm judgemental towards they have so much support, while I had to do it all myself.
Maybe I'm a bit bitter and twisted, but when I had people laughing my quirks when younger, it forced me to try to act more normal, while I see them as not bothering to act what people see as normal and having more excuses to do less.
Then again, I wonder if I might have been able to be more successful in life if I'd been allowed to be myself more, so it's confusing.

LilyPAnderson · 02/10/2022 02:37

As a person with Asperger's who wasn't diagnosed until middle age, I feel angry people who were diagnosed as children had lots of help and support, while I had nothing but emotional damage from being punished and blamed for the symptoms.
Apart from the main symptoms such as having bad executive functions, there are other things connected, such as being clumsy and being made to spend hours in handwriting classes and still being confused why no matter how hard I tried my writing still looked dumb. It made me less confident when taking exams, but if I'd had a diagnosis I could have had an excuse why my writing was bad.

BlankTimes · 02/10/2022 02:19

@Lovelyricepudding
"If your schools require a diagnosis to provide support then they are failing to follow the law."

That's fine in theory, most parents are aware of that, but they are also aware that it doesn't work for many pupils in reality.

For example, how would you get education providers to present information to a child in a way they could understand it, without documented proof of that need?
Are you saying a parent's request is enough?

Say a child has slow processing speed. Which of these scenarios is most likely to to have school provide the support this child needs?

A. Parent, with no evidence, suspects their child may have slow processing speed, so asks school for their child to be seated at the front of the class, then all instructions to be delivered to child by teacher firstly gaining their attention by saying their name, then giving them a verbal and written sheet of one-step instructions for that lesson.

B. Parent sends school a comprehensive report undertaken by SaLT outlining which tests were used to determine processing speed, what the child's score was and the SaLT's professional recomendations based on their assessment, - child to be seated at the front of the class, then all instructions to be delivered to child by teacher firstly gaining their attention by saying their name, then giving them a verbal and written sheet of one-step instructions for that lesson.

alltheevennumbers · 02/10/2022 01:11

Both my children have been functionally incapacitated by health conditions in a way which has significantly affected their day to day participation in education over the long term.

Neither received support or understanding from their schools whilst undiagnosed. One met the threshold for higher levels of intervention from CAMHS, but was still off-rolled by their Sixth Form, supported by the local authority. Whilst this was potentially unlawful they were too unwell to consider going to a panel with a disability discrimination claim within the 6 month period. This school didn't understand the difference between not having a condition and being undiagnosed, despite letters from clinicians and being sent the relevant SEND guidance. This child never met the SENCO.

The other child now has multiple diagnoses. The school they attend attempts to assert that they are 'fine in school' despite horrendous anxiety linked to ASD. However they are on the SEND register and some adjustments have been agreed.

The reality is, by secondary school, when problems for autistic children often dramatically increase, you have to fight for EVERYTHING. In practice, diagnoses, and the supportive health care professionals that can come with them, do make a difference to how kids are treated. The risk is if things get significantly more difficult, you may then sit on a waiting list for an assessment for 2 years + whilst your child's self esteem and confidence at school plummets.

Jadebanditchillipepper · 01/10/2022 23:45

My 16 year old son has ASD which was diagnosed a year ago. He has had problems in school since about year 3 in primary school. We didn't see it then, just thought things would get better when he went to secondary school. They didn't get better, they got worse. He became more and more isolated and reluctant to go to school. When he was in year 8, I asked them to assess him for ASD - they laughed at me and told me I was making a fuss about nothing.

So we moved him in year 9. The new school were a lot more receptive, but the problems continued (even though he liked the new school a lot more) while we waited for assessment. He started having panic attacks and refusing school. Eventually, he was diagnosed last summer between year 10 and 11. He managed to do well in his GCSEs despite about 70% attendance, largely due to the support from the school and the excellent teachers.

He's now moved to a small independent school for sixth form because he just couldn't cope with being in a large comprehensive school any longer (and thankfully is a lot happier).
The last three or four years have been hugely stressful for us as a family. Dealing with his anxiety and school refusal, never knowing if we were doing the right thing for him or not.

I strongly feel that if someone had spotted it earlier, or if the original school had listened to me when I first suggested it, a lot of the problems would never have happened because he would have got support earlier.

Kids with ASD often function fine in primary school, then run into problems when they start secondary. Just because a child is OK now, doesn't mean they will continue to be fine.

Because of my experience, I would always recommend getting a diagnosis. It could avoid so many issues in the future.

Sickoffamilydrama · 01/10/2022 23:24

Lovelyricepudding · 01/10/2022 23:01

If your schools require a diagnosis to provide support then they are failing to follow the law.

Unfortunately they will use any excuse and ultimately it's hard to hold them accountable as they don't really receive a punishment for breaking the law.

Our council initially refused to assess DD for an EHCP because her school attendence was 100% they actually wrote that down which I was surprised by. As that has no relevance to the fact she needs extra support in fact it actually shows that even though she was always in school she was about 3/4 years behind her peers. She nosedived during the pandemic luckily the new school seems to be working 🤞