Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone the parent of a child with asd and not seeking a diagnosis?

664 replies

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 13:37

Not looking for a bun fight. Just trying to sort out my thinking. Anyone with any of their own insight that they'd be willing to share?

OP posts:
Sirzy · 02/10/2022 10:18

The system is ultimately very flawed which means too many children fall through the net.

for a child to get their needs met it sadly relies on them having parents who are able to navigate the complex systems and fight against the poor advice and illegal practises. That’s not a dig at the parents who aren’t able to do that because it shouldn’t need parents to do it. The systems should be in place to have an easy to navigate set up whereby no child is left behind.

i was lucky I had a primary school who where willing to fight alongside me to get the right support for DS and the mainstream secondary now so the same. No specialist setting locally could meet his needs the way the mainstream with support package can.

the best support for parents is often other parents who have been through the same battles and can point you in the right direction

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 10:15

alltheevennumbers · 02/10/2022 10:08

^Exactly this.

ParrotPoppy and Mumofsend - you do seem to be suggesting that parental deficits in articulating a child's needs are the reason needs aren't being met by schools?

In my experience, locally, it doesn't matter how skilled or knowledgeable an advocate for your child you are, or how well you understand equality legislation, in the current climate you still get gaslit as to the extent of their needs, and screwed over when it comes to support. That's just where we are.

And ultimately, unless you can afford to 'lawyer-up', you have no real means of enforcement.

You are quite right the law is based on functional capacity and not diagnosis, but in practice, it's even harder without a diagnosis.

It shouldn’t be that way, but sadly DC whose parents know the system and can advocate for their child get better support than parents, who for whatever reason, can’t or don’t. And there are numerous reasons parents can’t or don’t challenge and advocate for their DC - their own additional needs, EAL, MH difficulties, family circumstances, lack of knowledge (again not a criticism, but if parents were informed from the beginning what should happen they would find it easier to go through the system and challenge and advocate). That isn’t a criticism of the parents, they should be supported to.

Many parents have to appeal but securing the support is possible in every LA. You don’t have to lawyer up to secure a detailed, specified and quantified EHCP. You can go to SENDIST without and win. Both my DC have excellent EHCPs without us hiring a lawyer. It has meant a lot of work on our behalf but it is possible. There are also charities that can help and some are eligible for legal aid.

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 02/10/2022 10:15

Mumofsend · 02/10/2022 10:07

What I suspect happened is LA told the mainstream schools they won't go any more funding than their maximum, those schools have said they can't meet needs. Parents didn't wish to enforce the right for mainstream (which is perfectly reasonable) and the LA shot themselves in the foot. I had to make it clear to the LA I was enforcing the right to mainstream whilst school enforced they couldn't meet needs without the correct funding. It did take us working together.

Yes, perhaps this is correct. We didn't enforce mainstream as it wasn't the correct environment for our child, so we're obviously very pleased with the outcome. I did consider myself to be very clued upbthough and accepted that the additional funding the LA quoted was correct. It is very difficult to find out all the information that you need, as I'm sure you well know. The other thing (which I suspect you will also be all too familiar with) is that fighting for your child's rights often results in tribunal, which in my area is an 8/9 month wait. To get to this point your child will already have not had their needs met for at least several months, if not years. Meanwhile they fall further and further behind. We fortunately did not have to take it that far, although it was close.

msannabella · 02/10/2022 10:13

My BIL has obvious autistic tendencies and in fact even to outsiders is quite severe. My MIL refused to even listen to anyone when they suggested autism in a case of burying her head in the sand. The result now is a 42 year old man that still loves at home with no job or friends, who has no real quality of life. I think how differently things may have gone for him if she'd got him diagnosed and he got the support. On the other hand, my son is suspected ASD and we are pushing to get diagnoses etc so he can get all support needed in future.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 10:09

Mumofsend · 02/10/2022 10:01

Sounds like our scenario, the amount of people who tried to say her EHCP couldn't be provided in mainstream. It absolutely could, with the correct funding. She is now a thriving, happy little girl.

The specialist options were less able to meet all of her needs, some could meet her autism needs but not her educational ones, others could meet her educational needs but not her social ones. Placing an anxious autistic child with no behavioural issues in a behavioural school would have been fairly disastrous too.

All children should be able to thrive and I fully support the advocating of making sure every parent knows what SHOULD happen so they can also advocate for their children. Nothing will change whilst too many parents are unaware of law vs what LAs and schools spout.

Your last paragraph puts it much better than I have. Parents should be supported to challenge schools and LAs, rather than accept unlawful practices and policies. They can’t challenge what they don’t know should be happening.

Specialist wouldn’t be right for DS either. He needs mainstream with the correct support.

alltheevennumbers · 02/10/2022 10:08

HenryPlease · 02/10/2022 09:27

There is a vast gulf between what should and does happen.

Yes, parents have the right to and should challenge schools and local authorities when their child’s needs aren’t being met.

The reality is that many parents: don’t have the knowledge or information to do that; or don’t have the energy or time in as they have other children, full time jobs etc; aren’t educated, articulate, confident in challenging authorities; English isn’t their first language etc etc.

I’m not talking out of my area, here. I’m SLT in a school. I also have a child with autism.
I’ve seen this from all sides, and it’s a system that isn’t fair and a lot of the time isn’t legal.

Schools, LAs, allied professional all know this. There is just very little anyone can do about it.

I had to lawyer up and raise merry hell to get my child the support he needed. Even then , it was very far from adequate. Without a diagnosis I would have had fuck all chance of getting what I did get, no matter what the law says.

^Exactly this.

ParrotPoppy and Mumofsend - you do seem to be suggesting that parental deficits in articulating a child's needs are the reason needs aren't being met by schools?

In my experience, locally, it doesn't matter how skilled or knowledgeable an advocate for your child you are, or how well you understand equality legislation, in the current climate you still get gaslit as to the extent of their needs, and screwed over when it comes to support. That's just where we are.

And ultimately, unless you can afford to 'lawyer-up', you have no real means of enforcement.

You are quite right the law is based on functional capacity and not diagnosis, but in practice, it's even harder without a diagnosis.

Mumofsend · 02/10/2022 10:07

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 02/10/2022 10:03

It obviously depends on area as that was the maximum that the LA said could be allocated and they're now funding an independent specialist school at £80k per year 🤷‍♀️. I'm sure they would have saved themselves £50k a year if that was an option.

What I suspect happened is LA told the mainstream schools they won't go any more funding than their maximum, those schools have said they can't meet needs. Parents didn't wish to enforce the right for mainstream (which is perfectly reasonable) and the LA shot themselves in the foot. I had to make it clear to the LA I was enforcing the right to mainstream whilst school enforced they couldn't meet needs without the correct funding. It did take us working together.

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 02/10/2022 10:03

Mumofsend · 02/10/2022 09:50

My DD in mainstream is funded just over 30k for her EHCP provision precisely because I knew what should be happening and how to enforce it.

She does amazingly in mainstream because I knew this too. The LA hate that her mainstream placement costs more than their maintained specialists but not my DD's problem.

It obviously depends on area as that was the maximum that the LA said could be allocated and they're now funding an independent specialist school at £80k per year 🤷‍♀️. I'm sure they would have saved themselves £50k a year if that was an option.

Mumofsend · 02/10/2022 10:01

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 09:55

This is like DS. He is in a mainstream secondary with a fully funded EHCP worth more than £30k. It includes full time 1:1 including break and lunchtime and therapies many incorrectly say you can’t secure for pupils in MS. He wouldn’t have it if I didn’t know what should happen, how to enforce it and advocate for him.

Sounds like our scenario, the amount of people who tried to say her EHCP couldn't be provided in mainstream. It absolutely could, with the correct funding. She is now a thriving, happy little girl.

The specialist options were less able to meet all of her needs, some could meet her autism needs but not her educational ones, others could meet her educational needs but not her social ones. Placing an anxious autistic child with no behavioural issues in a behavioural school would have been fairly disastrous too.

All children should be able to thrive and I fully support the advocating of making sure every parent knows what SHOULD happen so they can also advocate for their children. Nothing will change whilst too many parents are unaware of law vs what LAs and schools spout.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 09:55

Mumofsend · 02/10/2022 09:50

My DD in mainstream is funded just over 30k for her EHCP provision precisely because I knew what should be happening and how to enforce it.

She does amazingly in mainstream because I knew this too. The LA hate that her mainstream placement costs more than their maintained specialists but not my DD's problem.

This is like DS. He is in a mainstream secondary with a fully funded EHCP worth more than £30k. It includes full time 1:1 including break and lunchtime and therapies many incorrectly say you can’t secure for pupils in MS. He wouldn’t have it if I didn’t know what should happen, how to enforce it and advocate for him.

Mumofsend · 02/10/2022 09:50

My DD in mainstream is funded just over 30k for her EHCP provision precisely because I knew what should be happening and how to enforce it.

She does amazingly in mainstream because I knew this too. The LA hate that her mainstream placement costs more than their maintained specialists but not my DD's problem.

Sirzy · 02/10/2022 09:45

The highest banding of extra funding with an ehcp isn’t £6k, Ds is in mainstream with full 1-1 and the funding from his plan is considerably more than that (not enough to fully cover the 1-1 but add in the nominal 6k schools are expected to have then it would) - don’t get me wrong it took a lot of fighting to get that all in place and I am not disputing the system is rubbish and lets down way to many young people.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 09:39

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 02/10/2022 09:36

^ This.

Posters can bang on all they like about the law, but the reality is that there is NO FUNDING. My child's previous mainstream headteacher has been told there is no additional funding and no additional special school places. Every child is expected to remain in mainstream. People have no idea about the reality of SEND provision. The latest teacher pay rises that schools have been told must come out of existing budgets are also having a huge impact. The highest band of ehcp funding is an additional £6k. How far do you think this goes on funding an additional TA? It's an awful situation, at least in England. I thank my lucky stars that my child's specialist placement was agreed last year.

In that situation parents need to appeal to SENDIST where SS placements are often ‘won’ and EHCPs can be fully funded. Then if the provision isn’t provided they can enforce the EHCP.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 09:36

eyeteevee · 02/10/2022 09:31

@Haffiana

Thank you for recognising what that poster has been doing. Even when I said I felt I was being talked over and invalidated they came back to tell me they were not doing that - which actually proved they were doing exactly that.

I had to step away from that interaction because no matter what I said it was rubbished in favour of 'the law' - the law is all good and well but realistically people have to fight hard for support even WITH a diagnosis, we all know jack shit is happening for those without.

Laughable that someone thinks I could walk into work and ask for adjustments with absolutely no evidence of needing them. This is why I don't work by the way, because I did not have the understanding or support that I so desperately needed. The law Hmm

I absolutely wasn’t invalidating you. Correcting your insistence you needed a diagnosis for protection under the equality act isn’t talking over you or invalidating you.

Neither did I say you could walk into work and ask for reasonable adjustments without any evidence, quite the opposite in fact, but that evidence doesn’t need to be a diagnosis.

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 02/10/2022 09:36

HenryPlease · 02/10/2022 08:51

Schools do break the law, every day. I’ve worked in mainstream secondary education for 20 years. Things have never been worse. There is not enough funding. There are woefully inadequate resources. The school I work in currently has to fight to get the EP in once or twice a year to see a handful of children.

EHCP applications are routinely turned down. In my borough, without a diagnosis, a child will not get one. It’s that simple. There are too many children WITH diagnoses fighting for one for the LA to be bothered to consider giving that money to those without.

Even for the children who get an EHCP, getting adequate funding attached and good quality expert advice written into it is very, very hard.

Then you have to look at how mainstream schools actually use the funding that comes attached to an EHCP. A lot of schools (I would say the majority of secondary schools) use the individual child’s funding to fund TA support that they then spread thinly among children without an EHCP, often without a diagnosis, but with significant needs.

Is this morally wrong? Is it illegal? Yes.
But this is the reality of mainstream SEND provision in England, at least.

In my experience, only children with vocal, educated parents who fight tooth and nail to get a diagnosis, get an EHCP and hold the LA and school to account at every annual review get the support they need and are entitled to.

It’s a bleak picture.

^ This.

Posters can bang on all they like about the law, but the reality is that there is NO FUNDING. My child's previous mainstream headteacher has been told there is no additional funding and no additional special school places. Every child is expected to remain in mainstream. People have no idea about the reality of SEND provision. The latest teacher pay rises that schools have been told must come out of existing budgets are also having a huge impact. The highest band of ehcp funding is an additional £6k. How far do you think this goes on funding an additional TA? It's an awful situation, at least in England. I thank my lucky stars that my child's specialist placement was agreed last year.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 09:34

The reality is that many parents: don’t have the knowledge or information to do that; or don’t have the energy or time in as they have other children, full time jobs etc; aren’t educated, articulate, confident in challenging authorities; English isn’t their first language etc etc.

I agree, DC whose parents who know the system and can advocate for them get better support. Which is why it is important parents know what should be happening because if they don’t know what should happen it makes the situation even harder. All parents should be supported to challenge schools and LAs. There is help out there parents can access for help, e.g. there are charities that can help (including by funding independent assessments or providing a caseworker), there are many groups within the ‘SEN community’ that can support, many parents don’t realise they may be eligible for Legal Aid… Assessments such as Ed psych/SALT/OT can all evidence needs without a diagnosis.

eyeteevee · 02/10/2022 09:31

@Haffiana

Thank you for recognising what that poster has been doing. Even when I said I felt I was being talked over and invalidated they came back to tell me they were not doing that - which actually proved they were doing exactly that.

I had to step away from that interaction because no matter what I said it was rubbished in favour of 'the law' - the law is all good and well but realistically people have to fight hard for support even WITH a diagnosis, we all know jack shit is happening for those without.

Laughable that someone thinks I could walk into work and ask for adjustments with absolutely no evidence of needing them. This is why I don't work by the way, because I did not have the understanding or support that I so desperately needed. The law Hmm

HenryPlease · 02/10/2022 09:28

Area = ARSE 🤪

HenryPlease · 02/10/2022 09:27

There is a vast gulf between what should and does happen.

Yes, parents have the right to and should challenge schools and local authorities when their child’s needs aren’t being met.

The reality is that many parents: don’t have the knowledge or information to do that; or don’t have the energy or time in as they have other children, full time jobs etc; aren’t educated, articulate, confident in challenging authorities; English isn’t their first language etc etc.

I’m not talking out of my area, here. I’m SLT in a school. I also have a child with autism.
I’ve seen this from all sides, and it’s a system that isn’t fair and a lot of the time isn’t legal.

Schools, LAs, allied professional all know this. There is just very little anyone can do about it.

I had to lawyer up and raise merry hell to get my child the support he needed. Even then , it was very far from adequate. Without a diagnosis I would have had fuck all chance of getting what I did get, no matter what the law says.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 09:23

Haffiana · 02/10/2022 09:16

@ParrotPoppy It isn't very helpful that you keep posting what should be happening to support children. We can all regurgitate the internet about what should be happening.

You have already posted over the actual experiences of a few PPs on here.

Do you understand that you are constantly dismissing and invalidating people's actual personal experiences of what happened to them? Do you understand that your "shoulds" have no relevance when someone is desperate and is needing to be heard?

How do you know I don’t have “actual experiences”? You don’t. In fact I do. I am autistic and have autistic DC with EHCPs.

I am not dismissing or invalidating anyone. Pointing out they are wrong to think a diagnosis is necessary to be covered by the Equality Act or for support in schools is not dismissing or invalidating them. It is pointing out the law.

Yes, it is helpful to post what should happen because if one doesn’t know what should happen how on earth is one supposed to enforce your/DC’s rights and advocate for yourself/them. If I knew at the start everything I do now about what should happen our ‘journey’ through ‘the system’ would have been much easier and less work.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 02/10/2022 09:21

You're assuming only parents push for a diagnosis when usually the DC has a lot of problems that leads into medical investigation and eventually leads to a diagnosis.

I had no idea my DD was on the spectrum. I thought she had an awful attention span and naturally clumsy with no planning skills like me.

Age 6 after 2 year in school they realised she was masking and not learning she has never acted out or being destructive, she is so good, now 14 a introverted quiet teenager.

DS OTOH cried with sensory issues from birth all day and everyday to the point where I wanted to die.

If he wasn't crying he was groaning and had a severe unhealthy attachment to me, he was put out of childcare at 10 months, my Dsis agreed to mind him she couldn't cope after 7 months I had to leave my job.

This continued to aggressive, stereotypical autistic behaviours, he is very antisocial and I fear he has a personality disorder not only autistic.

Morph22010 · 02/10/2022 09:20

We waited until diagnosis to apply for an ehcp as school told me Ds wouldn’t get one without diagnosis and I didn’t know any better at the time. Then when we did apply after diagnosis we still got refused as the la said it was a new diagnosis and they wanted to give time to see if things magically improved now he had a diagnosis. He did eventually get an ehcp but by the time we got it things had got too bad and he still didn’t manage in mainstream. Now doing well in a specialist asd school.

Haffiana · 02/10/2022 09:16

@ParrotPoppy It isn't very helpful that you keep posting what should be happening to support children. We can all regurgitate the internet about what should be happening.

You have already posted over the actual experiences of a few PPs on here.

Do you understand that you are constantly dismissing and invalidating people's actual personal experiences of what happened to them? Do you understand that your "shoulds" have no relevance when someone is desperate and is needing to be heard?

Mumofsend · 02/10/2022 09:11

And both my DC had their EHCPs pre-diagnosis. DD received her EHCP January of reception year, her diagnosis came about 6 months later. DS was given the GDD label at 3 and his EHCP just after he turned 4 ready for school. EHCPs are needs based.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 09:09

Notplayingball · 02/10/2022 08:53

My child struggles to stay focused, and is very impulsive. Apparently "just about managing" is fine for him. They say they address his needs, they are assessed regularly like all other pupils.

Without a diagnosis, I don't see how the situation for him will change.

So, enforce his right to support then, you don’t just have to accept it. A diagnosis doesn’t change his needs and schools must make their best endeavours to meet a pupil’s SEN - diagnosis or no diagnosis. Parents can also get an EHCNA when schools could do more but won’t. Schools often try the “managing/coping/fine” line, but parents can challenge it. You can get an EHCP when the school think the pupil is managing/fine/OK, when in reality they aren’t.