Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone the parent of a child with asd and not seeking a diagnosis?

664 replies

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 13:37

Not looking for a bun fight. Just trying to sort out my thinking. Anyone with any of their own insight that they'd be willing to share?

OP posts:
Mumofsend · 02/10/2022 11:53

LilyPAnderson · 02/10/2022 11:40

I'm curious why you're so much more keen on them attending mainstream schools? Most people on the autism spectrum had an awful time in school from being 'different'. It takes a lot of effort to fake social skills and trying to be cool, and that effort would be put to better use at concentrating on the education.
I think you're probably more likely to become an autistic genius like Elon Musk, Guy Martin etc, if you can avoid mainstream social pressures and concentrate on your special interests.
If I could have my time again, providing you could take the same exams as mainstream schools, I wouldn't have chosen a mainstream school.
Maybe others would though, but that's my personal opinion.

Because every school specialist and mainstream are vastly different.

My DD has a wonderful year group, she doesn't have the ability to fake social skills so doesn't really feel that pressure as her awareness isn't there to even notice. Her class are so accepting towards her and she's fully embraced for who she is.

Her specialist options were:

Behavioural school where quite a lot happen to have autism but it isn't an autism school. She would have been not only the only girl in her class but the only other girls were 4 years above her. The behaviour in the school is understandably challenging and she didn't manage to cope with one child in her year (who is now at that school) let alone her whole class finding things difficult. She isn't a behavioural child.

Moderate Learning disabilities school, she has a specific learning difficulty but is very capable academically. Her class would be 3-4 years behind her.

The autism twin schools are predominantly non-verbal. She wouldn't have peers similar to her. Also non-academic.

She will move to specialist for secondary but there are more options available. For now, where she is is absolutely the best thing for her.

Sirzy · 02/10/2022 11:50

LilyPAnderson · 02/10/2022 11:40

I'm curious why you're so much more keen on them attending mainstream schools? Most people on the autism spectrum had an awful time in school from being 'different'. It takes a lot of effort to fake social skills and trying to be cool, and that effort would be put to better use at concentrating on the education.
I think you're probably more likely to become an autistic genius like Elon Musk, Guy Martin etc, if you can avoid mainstream social pressures and concentrate on your special interests.
If I could have my time again, providing you could take the same exams as mainstream schools, I wouldn't have chosen a mainstream school.
Maybe others would though, but that's my personal opinion.

With ds i wasn’t dead set on mainstream. I was dead set on the best setting to meet his needs. The specialist provisions locally couldn’t have met his specific needs in the same way his mainstream school (with full 1-1 and a good support package do). This was the only school that was a feesible option for him. It that was to fail I would be pushing for an EOTAS package for him.

that’s not to say the other schools I visited weren’t fantastic they just weren’t right for him.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 11:48

@LilyPAnderson In DS’s case it’s because MS is best for him. I’m not just saying that, it is the opinion of every professional involved. He is happy there, thriving, he doesn’t have to fake social skills or try to be cool - DS would be aghast at either of the last 2. I’m not for mainstream at all costs - my other DS with an EHCP doesn’t attend MS because it isn’t best for him, but it is for the DS attending MS.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 11:45

MinervaTerrathorn · 02/10/2022 11:25

I rarely see my GP, I was signed off for stress/depression for a couple of weeks over the phone two years ago, and a referral for anorexia then a assessment (no treatment) by ED services the year before that. MH stuff when I was regularly seeing anyone was 18+ years ago.

You could make an appointment to discuss the matter. When you were signed off did you discuss/mention any of the difficulties causing the stress/depression and, as they often are, were they related in any way to the impairments stemming from autism? Was your autism diagnosis &/or the impairments mentioned at all in the AN referral/assessment? Often they are due to the higher incidence of AN in the autistic population. You could ask work for a OH referral.

LilyPAnderson · 02/10/2022 11:40

I'm curious why you're so much more keen on them attending mainstream schools? Most people on the autism spectrum had an awful time in school from being 'different'. It takes a lot of effort to fake social skills and trying to be cool, and that effort would be put to better use at concentrating on the education.
I think you're probably more likely to become an autistic genius like Elon Musk, Guy Martin etc, if you can avoid mainstream social pressures and concentrate on your special interests.
If I could have my time again, providing you could take the same exams as mainstream schools, I wouldn't have chosen a mainstream school.
Maybe others would though, but that's my personal opinion.

LilyPAnderson · 02/10/2022 11:29

I noticed in the social group that males and females present very different. The males are usually more obvious, and more likely to not realise they're hassling others in their approach. Many of the females seem to realise they don't act normal and become nervous in social situations, so sometimes just seem shy.
You would hardly guess many of the females are ASD until you get to know them, as many females talk, dress and act 'normal'. However, once you get to know them and find out what has happened to them, you find out how much they have been taken advantage of. I would say most of the females have been sexually assaulted from not seeing the dangers or intentions of dangerous men, or even been taken advantage of by bossy female friends who realise they're desperate for a friend. Even though you would never guess they're on the spectrum, they're still at risk.

MinervaTerrathorn · 02/10/2022 11:25

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 10:57

You could speak to the GP, and also ask for a referral to occupational health. Other possibilities to prove the impairment(s) rather than the diagnosis could include things like email exchanges or GP/other HCP notes (e.g. from appointments about other things or your MH difficulties - for example DS1’s recent immunology and allergy clinic letter comments on his communication and interaction difficulties) or assessment reports as part of other things (e.g. those who apply for a blue badge and are assessed by an OT as part of the process could use that assessment report). It’s difficult to know what evidence would be available to you without knowing a lot more about you and your circumstances.

I rarely see my GP, I was signed off for stress/depression for a couple of weeks over the phone two years ago, and a referral for anorexia then a assessment (no treatment) by ED services the year before that. MH stuff when I was regularly seeing anyone was 18+ years ago.

alltheevennumbers · 02/10/2022 11:14

So agreement here at least that the stress and mental, financial and practical burdens involved in trying to get basic legal minimum adherence to our disabled children rights is pushing families into mental health crises.

When we think about the 'success' of our nation, lots to reflect on here in terms of how it's most vulnerable children and their families are treated.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 02/10/2022 11:13

My cousin won't with her DS who has just started Y7. She's convinced he has it, as are most of the family but I think she's scared of the small chance not getting a diagnosis as it would reflect badly on his previous behaviour. He attended a small village school up to Y6 and caused significant disruption and damage to classrooms. I agree with others - if your child needs any kind of additional help that a diagnosis would bring then you're harming them by not getting it. Even if it's just extra time in exams or pastoral support.

Daftasabroom · 02/10/2022 11:06

@coodawoodashooda

We attended National Autistic Society parenting courses. It's more of a slightly different way of thinking and parenting.Tips include (and there are hundreds of these):

Don't worry about eye contact, sensory processing issues mean they may not be able to look at you and listen to what your saying at the same time.

Buy the same clothes all the time. Is it really a big deal if he only ever wears white socks? We bought school uniforms a year early and left them in his wardrobe to get used to them. Think Geoff Goldblum in the Fly.

The school let him sit in headmasters office and read an encyclopedia if he was having a playtime meltdown. Did you know slugs have shells?

Allowing and helping him to stim in non conspicuous ways (he spins a pen round his fingers, quite impressive to watch TBH!).

He had a huge collection of soft toys that he took to bed, it got to the stage where the collection got bigger and so did he. There wasn't enough room for all of them so we had to devise a rota!

We got lots of help transitioning from primary to secondary to college to uni.

The big big thing is "choose your battles". Is not being able to dispose of something you have given a name (stoney the stone) a big deal? Not really compared to learning how to cross a road. (This goes for all kids, but doubly for ASC).

The tough times have been tough but the bits in-between have been incredible. The GCSE English grade 5 meant more than all his 9s put together.

Tumbleweed101 · 02/10/2022 11:03

It depends if they can manage the education system without a diagnosis. If they have an area they significantly struggle in then it would be kinder to go through assessment and get them the support they need.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 02/10/2022 10:58

I have adhd, diagnosed as an adult. I don't blame my parents for not getting me diagnosed as a child. I don't think they realised, and as I'm also pretty sure that my mum has undiagnosed adhd herself, she had normalised so many of the behaviors that should have alerted her to it.

I think for a parent who has identified that some kind of neurodiversity is a possibility, it's negligent not to pursue a diagnosis. It's cruel to deny them that opportunity to understand why they are how they are and to access support when they need it. I honestly don't understand why any parent would do that to their own child, unless they are so prejudiced against neurodiversity that they would consider it somehow something to be ashamed of.

Ultimately, it's your child, OP, and you get to decide how to handle this decision. What you don't get to decide is how your child will evaluate that decision when they are old enough to do so. They may find it difficult to forgive.

balloonsballoonsballons · 02/10/2022 10:58

@coodawoodashooda you said this in an earlier post;

"I think I can get him all of this professional understanding without the label."

How do you think you could?

I also asked you why you think your DC has ASD but you haven't replied. What are the signs / symptoms / behaviours?

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 10:57

MinervaTerrathorn · 02/10/2022 10:46

Sorry not keeping track of names. I replied to your previous post. I left school 22 years ago, I only have my grades, no reports, not that I remember anything being mentioned in my reports. I have never had support or mentioned the diagnosis to any GP. I had some mental health difficulties in my teens/early twenties but I completely rejected the diagnosis until I was 25 so didn't mention it. Apparently they would have only had to keep my childhood records until my 25th birthday and I don't remember who diagnosed me.

You could speak to the GP, and also ask for a referral to occupational health. Other possibilities to prove the impairment(s) rather than the diagnosis could include things like email exchanges or GP/other HCP notes (e.g. from appointments about other things or your MH difficulties - for example DS1’s recent immunology and allergy clinic letter comments on his communication and interaction difficulties) or assessment reports as part of other things (e.g. those who apply for a blue badge and are assessed by an OT as part of the process could use that assessment report). It’s difficult to know what evidence would be available to you without knowing a lot more about you and your circumstances.

FellowClassicsMum · 02/10/2022 10:50

I have only read the first page but parents who refuse to proceed with the diagnosis process are selfish IMO (as a parent of an autistic child and also likely autistic myself). The acceptance of themself that my child has and the ability to advocate for their own needs is mind blowing - I contrast that with my own teenage years where I regularly contemplated suicide as I could not understand why I was such a failure at being human. If your child was diabetic would you not label them and provide insulin in case it ‘led to low expectations’ or if they needed glasses would you refuse to have their eyes tested as they should just try harder to be able to see properly. That might sound ridiculous but it’s about enabling them to have their needs met - for every person on here who says that the school will meet the child’s need without one (ignoring that you don’t stay in school for ever), I can show you a parent whose child is not getting their needs met AND they have an official diagnosis. It has undoubtedly made my child’s relationship with their teachers easier at Secondary school!

MinervaTerrathorn · 02/10/2022 10:46

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 10:31

Do you know how you get evidence? I have a diagnosis but no evidence of it. Can I just tell my GP about it?

I have quoted my last reply in case you missed it. Some GPs would be willing to add an oversees autism diagnosis following an appointment where you discuss it, others may not, but you don’t necessarily need to prove the diagnosis, just the impairment(s). And you can do that in other ways - occupational health, school reports/IEPs, emails… - it depends on what the impairment is and your specific circumstances.

Sorry not keeping track of names. I replied to your previous post. I left school 22 years ago, I only have my grades, no reports, not that I remember anything being mentioned in my reports. I have never had support or mentioned the diagnosis to any GP. I had some mental health difficulties in my teens/early twenties but I completely rejected the diagnosis until I was 25 so didn't mention it. Apparently they would have only had to keep my childhood records until my 25th birthday and I don't remember who diagnosed me.

NightIbble · 02/10/2022 10:43

My just 5 year old DS has recently been diagnosed ASD we started the process at his 2 year review. He has an Educational Care Plan in place which the diagnosis helped with and has just started mainstream school with a little bit of help in place as that is all he currently needs.
However if that changes at any time, which it often does especially with the onset of hormones etc... we will be well placed to react and help rather than try and start the diagnosis process when he is struggling as it takes years to get through in some areas. I would say to get it done as early as poss so it is there if you need it!

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 10:31

ParrotPoppy · 01/10/2022 18:50

Yes, if you can prove the impairment in other ways e.g. via occupational health or did you mention it when you registered with a GP in the UK? It’s difficult to say exactly what evidence without knowing the exact situation and you/your history. Do you know who assessed you? If so, you could see if they still hold the records.

Do you know how you get evidence? I have a diagnosis but no evidence of it. Can I just tell my GP about it?

I have quoted my last reply in case you missed it. Some GPs would be willing to add an oversees autism diagnosis following an appointment where you discuss it, others may not, but you don’t necessarily need to prove the diagnosis, just the impairment(s). And you can do that in other ways - occupational health, school reports/IEPs, emails… - it depends on what the impairment is and your specific circumstances.

Mumofsend · 02/10/2022 10:27

Sirzy · 02/10/2022 10:18

The system is ultimately very flawed which means too many children fall through the net.

for a child to get their needs met it sadly relies on them having parents who are able to navigate the complex systems and fight against the poor advice and illegal practises. That’s not a dig at the parents who aren’t able to do that because it shouldn’t need parents to do it. The systems should be in place to have an easy to navigate set up whereby no child is left behind.

i was lucky I had a primary school who where willing to fight alongside me to get the right support for DS and the mainstream secondary now so the same. No specialist setting locally could meet his needs the way the mainstream with support package can.

the best support for parents is often other parents who have been through the same battles and can point you in the right direction

Working with school against the LA definitely made a huge difference here. Our LA did try and portray the school as just not wanting my child and trying to get rid of them at one point. I know the school staff well enough to know every single person who has supported by DD has given her the upmost care.

Our LA released a generic document stating schools should be doing xxx for your child at SEN support level. The provisions listed equated to thousands of ££ and was entirely written to place blame on schools for not providing these provisions. When you get digging, the practices are awful and the only people who are harmed are those children.

MinervaTerrathorn · 02/10/2022 10:25

@ParrotPoppy
Neither did I say you could walk into work and ask for reasonable adjustments without any evidence, quite the opposite in fact, but that evidence doesn’t need to be a diagnosis.
Do you know how you get evidence? I have a diagnosis but no evidence of it. Can I just tell my GP about it?

coodawoodashooda · 02/10/2022 10:24

Daftasabroom · 02/10/2022 10:24

@coodawoodashooda my 20yo son is autistic. I was really reluctant to seek a diagnosis as I didn't want him "labelled". I was wrong and seeking a diagnosis was the best thing we ever did. It opened doors to support and coping strategies that would otherwise have been closed to us.

Thank you. Can you give me any examples? Please.

OP posts:
Daftasabroom · 02/10/2022 10:24

@coodawoodashooda my 20yo son is autistic. I was really reluctant to seek a diagnosis as I didn't want him "labelled". I was wrong and seeking a diagnosis was the best thing we ever did. It opened doors to support and coping strategies that would otherwise have been closed to us.

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 02/10/2022 10:23

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 10:18

LAs like to say a lot of things that aren’t correct. They often try to have their own unlawful policies. This is why parents need to know what should happen, because if they don’t and listen to the LA the LA will often give incorrect information. I agree it’s not easy and the waits for tribunal are only going in one direction, but that doesn’t mean parents shouldn’t enforce DC’s rights.

This is true. Unfortunately, you would expect as a parent that professionals will give you the correct advice and act in the best interests of your child. It is a huge shock to realise that this is not the case. Parents who trust the professionals aren't at fault, the professionals are! And of course the waits for tribunal aren't a reason not to fight, but it can feel like a never ending battle, and disheartening is not a strong enough word to describe the feelings of parents in this situation.

Mumofsend · 02/10/2022 10:22

alltheevennumbers · 02/10/2022 10:08

^Exactly this.

ParrotPoppy and Mumofsend - you do seem to be suggesting that parental deficits in articulating a child's needs are the reason needs aren't being met by schools?

In my experience, locally, it doesn't matter how skilled or knowledgeable an advocate for your child you are, or how well you understand equality legislation, in the current climate you still get gaslit as to the extent of their needs, and screwed over when it comes to support. That's just where we are.

And ultimately, unless you can afford to 'lawyer-up', you have no real means of enforcement.

You are quite right the law is based on functional capacity and not diagnosis, but in practice, it's even harder without a diagnosis.

Not always but it tends to go hand in hand. Absolutely no fault of the parents and it absolutely should not be the case but LAs certainly rely on parents not knowing to get away with murder.

Schools tend to then be stuck in the middle and shafted. I have a huge amount of sympathy and respect for the schools. I go into them as part of a project I'm involved in and I think I've come across maybe 2 out of 16/17 where the attitude towards SEN just stank versus the majority who do want the best for all their children.

I certainly didn't lawyer up, I couldn't afford to. I did pay around £130 for the ipsea training levels 1-3. Sorting her EHCP and placement was brutal and the gaslighting nearly sent me crazy.They are so good at making you question it I can fully appreciate it is much easier in theory than reality. I'm not exaggerating when I say I very nearly had a complete MH breakdown. It reached a point I tipped from upset at how my 5 year old was being treated to just angry which is probably what got us through! I found everything I stated I had to specifically highlight the relevant part in law, I was told I misunderstood or was wrong otherwise.

I now run a local EHCP group and it's much easier helping other parents than doing it for my own children. I help other parents as much as I physically can so I see it day in and day out. But yes, we absolutely do need to shout from the roof tops what SHOULD happen.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 10:18

FishFingerSandwiches4Tea · 02/10/2022 10:15

Yes, perhaps this is correct. We didn't enforce mainstream as it wasn't the correct environment for our child, so we're obviously very pleased with the outcome. I did consider myself to be very clued upbthough and accepted that the additional funding the LA quoted was correct. It is very difficult to find out all the information that you need, as I'm sure you well know. The other thing (which I suspect you will also be all too familiar with) is that fighting for your child's rights often results in tribunal, which in my area is an 8/9 month wait. To get to this point your child will already have not had their needs met for at least several months, if not years. Meanwhile they fall further and further behind. We fortunately did not have to take it that far, although it was close.

LAs like to say a lot of things that aren’t correct. They often try to have their own unlawful policies. This is why parents need to know what should happen, because if they don’t and listen to the LA the LA will often give incorrect information. I agree it’s not easy and the waits for tribunal are only going in one direction, but that doesn’t mean parents shouldn’t enforce DC’s rights.