Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone the parent of a child with asd and not seeking a diagnosis?

664 replies

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 13:37

Not looking for a bun fight. Just trying to sort out my thinking. Anyone with any of their own insight that they'd be willing to share?

OP posts:
LilyPAnderson · 03/10/2022 01:17

I can see why some of the people at the social group have been brought up to think it's fine to ruin the evening for everybody else, if some of their parents are the types from here who follow me onto other MN forums and poke their nose into what I'm saying to try to bully me. I bet their kids have had every excuse made for them to act antisocial, as the parents do it. I guess all online forums are at risk of people like that with no life or intelligence.

NCFT0922 · 03/10/2022 00:07

@HelloDoggy the masking (not displaying certain behaviours in front of others) which you state he does at school already, aged 10, is very damaging long term.

My son doesn’t have a label. He has a diagnosis. He doesn’t have meds; you cant medicate the ASD out of someone. My son doesn’t have limits; I would actually say I think he probably has more opportunities than many other children which he is very lucky for, but we and others can make adaptations/considerations in advance so that things are manageable for him.

I am not for a second doubting you don’t love your son, and we all want the best for our children, I just find it sad when some parents are so defiantly against a diagnosis and believe it can only be a negative. My experience hasn’t been negative at all.

HelloDoggy · 02/10/2022 23:35

NCFT0922 · 02/10/2022 23:15

@HelloDoggy but those aspects of your son, the ones that may make him experience difficulty with things, do you have no interest at all in seeking support to help him manage those things better?
None of us want our children to suffer in anyway. I’m really struggling to understand why you wouldn’t want to make things easier for him?

I do want to make things easier for him. I love him.

I do want to support him to manage better in the areas he struggles in. Of course I do. I do agree it is helpful to offer him strategies to manage and cope.

I just don't agree that labelling him will help him. I don't agree medication is the best thing for him.

If he has lots of energy to burn, he's learning that swimming calms him. He finds peace in swimming. He loves it. It keeps him even and content. So he's already found a helpful strategy for his energy.

He stims and he finds that a helpful way to calm excitement and manage over tiredness. He's learnt not to do it in school so he doesn't get picked on. He's managing appropriately.

He can't detect when he's too hot or cold and so wears inappropriate clothes at school. So we are working together on startegies to manage that.

The list could go on. We are developing strategies together. I don't see the need for a label. We all have to manage and adapt to things all the time. I'm impulsive and have to learn ways not to speak non stop.or blurt things out in meetings for example! Life is about learning is it not? All children have to learn ways to manage in this complex world.

I'm happy with the way I'm raising my DS. And I equally think it's fine if other parents would manage a similar child differently, by following the diagnosis route. We are all different. We all do things differently..but I love my son as much as you or anyone else may love thier child.

I don't want to limit him by making him think he will never be able to do X or Y because he has a 'disorder". I don't want him to think there is anything wrong with the way he does stuff or sees stuff. I want him to know his way of seeing and being in the world is equally valid to other people's.

NCFT0922 · 02/10/2022 23:15

@HelloDoggy but those aspects of your son, the ones that may make him experience difficulty with things, do you have no interest at all in seeking support to help him manage those things better?
None of us want our children to suffer in anyway. I’m really struggling to understand why you wouldn’t want to make things easier for him?

HelloDoggy · 02/10/2022 23:13

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 23:04

The spectrum isn’t a linear spectrum with mild at one end and severe at the other. People with autism have differing needs but not on a continuum from mild to severe.

When people say ‘mild autism’ they typically mean the person’s autism affects others mildly, it doesn’t mean it affects the individual mildly. In order to be diagnosed one must have “persistent difficulties” that “limit and impair everyday functioning”, if someone’s difficulties were “mild” they wouldn’t get a diagnosis.

All ‘high functioning’ means is there isn’t a co-morbid learning disability and IQ is above 70. The problem is many people use it to mean something it’s not.

This and this are articles that explain it better than I can.

Thanks Parrot, that looks interesting and helpful, I'll give it a read.

HelloDoggy · 02/10/2022 23:12

NCFT0922 · 02/10/2022 23:04

@HelloDoggy your child was assessed; they would either get a diagnosis of ASD or not. They would not be told if they were high functioning, “mild” or anything like that. Of course, as a child’s parent, those assumptions may be made. But it is no longer part of the diagnostic assessment.

Your views on a diagnosis purely being a label and somewhat of a glass ceiling is offensive, yes.

The spectrum of Autism is not mild - severe.

I'm sorry you findy way of seeing the world as offensive. It's not meant to be. We just have different ways of understanding people's 'symptoms'. To me, my son's 'symptoms' are just aspects of him that I don't want to label. They are what makes him him. To you they are evidence of a disorder that you do want to label. That's fine and I get that. I'm sorry I don't see the world in the same way as you. But we are all different. I'm sorry my way of seeing the world offends you. But I can't change my way of seeing things just to make you happy.

I have found some of the comments on here helpful and they've made me think, but I don't really understand the purpose of comments which are just basically attacking me.

NCFT0922 · 02/10/2022 23:05

@ParrotPoppy thank you, you’ve articulated it much better than me.

NCFT0922 · 02/10/2022 23:04

@HelloDoggy your child was assessed; they would either get a diagnosis of ASD or not. They would not be told if they were high functioning, “mild” or anything like that. Of course, as a child’s parent, those assumptions may be made. But it is no longer part of the diagnostic assessment.

Your views on a diagnosis purely being a label and somewhat of a glass ceiling is offensive, yes.

The spectrum of Autism is not mild - severe.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 23:04

The spectrum isn’t a linear spectrum with mild at one end and severe at the other. People with autism have differing needs but not on a continuum from mild to severe.

When people say ‘mild autism’ they typically mean the person’s autism affects others mildly, it doesn’t mean it affects the individual mildly. In order to be diagnosed one must have “persistent difficulties” that “limit and impair everyday functioning”, if someone’s difficulties were “mild” they wouldn’t get a diagnosis.

All ‘high functioning’ means is there isn’t a co-morbid learning disability and IQ is above 70. The problem is many people use it to mean something it’s not.

This and this are articles that explain it better than I can.

HelloDoggy · 02/10/2022 22:52

NCFT0922 · 02/10/2022 22:46

@HelloDoggy you’re quoting out of date materials and your ignorance of the spectrum is shocking.

I am not ignorant. I may not know as much as you, but I do know a bit. The terminology has changed and most people now refer to autistic spectrum condition / autistic spectrum disorders, where once there was a differentiation between Asperger's and autism. What used to be termed Asperger's is now considered a milder form of autism spectrum condition, at one end of the autistic spectrum. If my son was to be diagnosed, I expect this is the end of the spectrum he would fall on. He does not have a more severe form of autism. He is high functioning. I'm sorry I didn't say it in whatever way you were hoping I would say it, but I hoped you would understand what I meant by mild.

I'm sorry I seem to have really offended you somehow. It's a shame we can't all just have different perspective which we each respect. Not sure why some people have to be so nasty to others on here.

NCFT0922 · 02/10/2022 22:46

@HelloDoggy you’re quoting out of date materials and your ignorance of the spectrum is shocking.

HelloDoggy · 02/10/2022 22:36

NCFT0922 · 02/10/2022 12:14

@HelloDoggy no; if your son had a diagnosis it would not be “v.mild” as they don’t diagnosis it as mild or severe 🙄 honestly, some people. And they wonder why some children end up fucked up.

"The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th Edition (DSM-5), conceptualizes autism as a spectrum, in which people with low support needs are considered to be “mildly” autistic and those with high support needs as “severe.” Mild autism is also sometimes referred to as high-functioning autism"

HelloDoggy · 02/10/2022 22:27

Daftasabroom · 02/10/2022 12:33

@HelloDoggy I'm an ex-professional sports-person lately diagnosed with ADHD, not getting your son diagnosed is storing up a whole world of hurt, addiction, and pain. The very same neurological differences that drive someone to be better than everyone else, to hyper-focus, to push through very damaging pain, can destroy them.

Your attitude will destroy your son.

Daftasabroom - thanks for sharing that. How would a label have helped you? Do you think you would have taken meds? What problems did you experience and is there a way, other than getting a label, that your parents could have supported you so you could have avoided pain and addiction?

HelloDoggy · 02/10/2022 22:24

gowestlifeispeacefulthere · 02/10/2022 13:12

Your son is 10. Every part of his life is scaffolded right now. If he does indeed have ASD and ADHD things will get more and more challenging as he gets older and more independent. There's a huge difference between primary and secondary in terms of planning, organisation etc. Then college, uni, work. Sport is not going to get him through all that.
I speak as someone who was diagnosed with ADHD in my 40s. I spent my whole adult life not understanding why I couldn't function in the way that others could. I'm intelligent, I'm interested, I look completely "normal". I can pinpoint when things started to feel tricky, towards the end of my A Levels, but I pulled it back. I almost gave up at university but I dragged myself through and wore myself out. I have a professional career, but my mental health is shot because I have to run at 100mph to keep up with everyone else who just goes at a sedate 30mph and gets everything done.
I have only managed to reach the level I'm now at because I finally have a diagnosis so am protected under the EA and have reasonable adjustments (and a very understanding manager). But I have in no way met my potential, both professionally or personally, because for most of my life I've been swimming in mud.
Medication can by life changing for ADHD.
Do you want to deny your son all this? For what reason? It's just down right cruel.

It sounds like it's been a difficult path for you gowestlife, and I'm sorry you has to endure that.

I'm not keen on managing symptoms with medication, especially for children. So, I'm not sure in what other ways a label would help. I was planning to help him identify where he finds things a struggle and support him to find ways to manage those struggles. I'm not sure how that would be different if his struggles had a label and what advantage there would be to the label.

HelloDoggy · 02/10/2022 22:12

NCFT0922 · 02/10/2022 12:18

@Sirzy agree. As though no child with ASD/ADHD could possibly be lovely, have friends or enjoy sport.

i can’t work out if @HelloDoggy is goady or just really thick. Maybe both, the 2 often go hand in hand. God help her son!

That's not very nice! The OP asked if anyone has a child who may have ASC and isn't seeking a diagnosis. I'm that parent and have just explained my reasoning. I'm entitled to my opinion. I'm neither thick nor goady.

'God help her son' - that's a pretty goady and unpleasant thing to say. I love my son and am trying my best to bring him up the way I feel is best for him. Other people are also doing the same, just differently. No need for the hostility.

HelloDoggy · 02/10/2022 22:08

Sirzy · 02/10/2022 12:16

“He’s actually a lovely boy”

do you realise how insulting things like that are (and let’s not go onto your well educated over diagnosis comments) being autistic doesn’t mean someone isn’t lovely you know!

I'm sorry, I didn't mean it how you perceived it. I was just stating he's a lovely boy. Which he is. With or without a diagnosis. What I was trying to say is that I appreciate him as he is and don't feel it would be helpful for him to have a diagnosis. That's just my view as a parent.

HelloDoggy · 02/10/2022 22:06

NCFT0922 · 02/10/2022 12:14

@HelloDoggy no; if your son had a diagnosis it would not be “v.mild” as they don’t diagnosis it as mild or severe 🙄 honestly, some people. And they wonder why some children end up fucked up.

You sound nice

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 21:29

gowestlifeispeacefulthere · 02/10/2022 21:21

You've only quoted part of my sentence there. My occupational health report most definitely states that I have a disability that comes under the protection of the EA.
The problem is the issues caused by ND conditions can appear to be due to laziness, poor organisational skills etc. I've left roles before because I simply couldn't manage them, I couldn't keep up. I had no idea why, so I couldn't ask for help. Or any help I was offered didn't address the core issues. For example, there is a key part of my role in my current position that involves a huge amount of multitasking. I cannot do it. No matter of training or strategies will support me to do it, I could try but I'd do it poorly and it would be incredibly stressful. I am able to demonstrate through an explanation of my disability why I cannot do it. So instead I do an alternative task that is as meaningful.
I can absolutely tell you from experience that a diagnosis goes a long long way to helping you access support.

I know I have only quoted part of your sentence. The other part of your sentence was and have reasonable adjustments (and a very understanding manager) which wasn’t relevant to the point I was making which is why I didn’t quote it all. It makes it sound like you are only protected because of the diagnosis, which isn’t the case, hence why I posted.

gowestlifeispeacefulthere · 02/10/2022 21:21

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 19:01

I have only managed to reach the level I'm now at because I finally have a diagnosis so am protected under the EA

You don’t need a diagnosis to be covered under the Equality Act.

You've only quoted part of my sentence there. My occupational health report most definitely states that I have a disability that comes under the protection of the EA.
The problem is the issues caused by ND conditions can appear to be due to laziness, poor organisational skills etc. I've left roles before because I simply couldn't manage them, I couldn't keep up. I had no idea why, so I couldn't ask for help. Or any help I was offered didn't address the core issues. For example, there is a key part of my role in my current position that involves a huge amount of multitasking. I cannot do it. No matter of training or strategies will support me to do it, I could try but I'd do it poorly and it would be incredibly stressful. I am able to demonstrate through an explanation of my disability why I cannot do it. So instead I do an alternative task that is as meaningful.
I can absolutely tell you from experience that a diagnosis goes a long long way to helping you access support.

MinervaTerrathorn · 02/10/2022 20:40

@ParrotPoppy
Thanks for the advice. It's difficult as I don't see any health professionals, I've only ever asked for help when desperate, no health issues. There will be nothing on paper unless my masking didn't work and something was picked up on. Just now not coping too well.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 20:11

Equalbutdifferent · 02/10/2022 20:04

With the best will in the world, CAB are not going to be able to help the poster prove she has an impairment.

CAB themselves won’t be able to prove the impairment, but the poster will be able to discuss her specific circumstances with them and they may be able to suggest what she can use as evidence to prove an impairment. They advised an acquaintance of mine on how to prove to work they needed reasonable adjustments due to a physical impairment. I have provided several examples of evidence she could use, but without knowing the specific circumstances and the specific impairment it’s impossible to say exactly what will work for her so going to someone she could explain her circumstances in more detail to could help.

Equalbutdifferent · 02/10/2022 20:04

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 18:59

You don’t have to prove the diagnosis, so don’t necessarily need a HCP to believe you have a diagnosis without paperwork to prove it. (Although it’s worth asking your GP if they would accept you have a diagnosis without the paperwork as you won’t know if you don’t ask.) You only need to prove the impairment(s), which must be present in order to meet the criteria for diagnosis. How you could prove the impairments depends on what the impairment is and you/your specific circumstances. It might be worth speaking to somewhere like citizens advice to advice specific to your situation.

With the best will in the world, CAB are not going to be able to help the poster prove she has an impairment.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 19:01

I have only managed to reach the level I'm now at because I finally have a diagnosis so am protected under the EA

You don’t need a diagnosis to be covered under the Equality Act.

ParrotPoppy · 02/10/2022 18:59

MinervaTerrathorn · 02/10/2022 14:58

Thanks, I just don't understand how I prove it? If I've never told any health care professional will the first one I tell believe me.

You don’t have to prove the diagnosis, so don’t necessarily need a HCP to believe you have a diagnosis without paperwork to prove it. (Although it’s worth asking your GP if they would accept you have a diagnosis without the paperwork as you won’t know if you don’t ask.) You only need to prove the impairment(s), which must be present in order to meet the criteria for diagnosis. How you could prove the impairments depends on what the impairment is and you/your specific circumstances. It might be worth speaking to somewhere like citizens advice to advice specific to your situation.

BogRollBOGOF · 02/10/2022 18:38

I'm glad DS has his diagnosis. He's of the "high function" type that copes and masks, and most people wouldn't "see" it. But that is a cost on his emotions and energy. At 11, he's managed so far, but as he develops and society's expectations of him change at different rates he may need additional support and that diagnosis is a stepping stone for getting it. It took 15m from referral to diagnosis and fortunately it was a phase where no trauma was created. If he suddenly struggles in the teen years, the stakes of damage during 2 year waits for diagnosis are high.

I've taught or worked with kids that are displaying textbook neurodiverse difficulties/ behaviours without diagnosis, and parents that at best are not interested in that route and it obstructs being able to support appropriately. It can mean things like following standard behaviour policy rather than a more appropriate reasonable adaption that would defuse an issue.

DS would stand out anyway. His dyslexia and dyspraxia diagnoses protect him from labels like "careless" or "lazy". If he makes a social faux-pas, it's better to be "autistic" and have someone explain the nuance of the situation and ways to manage it differently, rather than being "rude".

Neurodiversity often runs in families. It can be culturally normal through the family which can cause huge blindspots in wanting to see the issue and seek diagnosis. DH doesn't "see" DS's neurodiversity in the same way that I do. To some extent he sees a repeat of his brothers and other relations... a nephew is diagnosed too...

As a physical health comparison, it's better to know you have high blood pressure and manage it, maybe through lifestyle, maybe through medication than to ignore the signs and suddenly have to deal with an accute health situation.

Swipe left for the next trending thread