Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone the parent of a child with asd and not seeking a diagnosis?

664 replies

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 13:37

Not looking for a bun fight. Just trying to sort out my thinking. Anyone with any of their own insight that they'd be willing to share?

OP posts:
eyeteevee · 03/10/2022 12:58

Genuine question to those who don't want their child 'labelled' because they are doing well in school

What do you think would happen to your child if they were labelled (diagnosed)?

Winecrispschocolatecats · 03/10/2022 12:45

We had this dilemma with DS. Although showing a number of ASD traits, he was doing well in primary school, with great reports and lots of friends. We were keen not to have him 'labelled' for the sake of it. However, a friend of ours with an older ASD child strongly recommended we start the process of obtaining a diagnosis and I'm so glad he persuaded us!

Our DS had always been a model pupil in school, but came home exhausted each day and had increasingly violent meltdowns over the slightest thing. Looking back, we've now realised that the effort he was making to 'mask' his ASD was taking all his strength. Once we finally got a diagnosis (about 18 months) and he got the support and accommodations at school that he needed, he's been so much happier and more relaxed. It really has been worth every single form and assessment and therapy session and chase-up calls.

MinervaTerrathorn · 03/10/2022 12:34

Miffee · 03/10/2022 11:05

But an autistic child grows up to be an autistic adult and doing that without any support or understanding of why things can be so confusing and difficult, in both mine and Ds's experience is just awful and very very damaging

I see what you are saying but you can still discuss with your child. I spoke to my child about it first when they were 12. They said it made sense to them when they looked into it but were largely disinterested. We've discussed it multiple time over the years, they basically accept that they are autistic but don't want a diagnosis.

That said I realise that my DC had a very specific set of circumstances that meant we were incredibly lucky.

I wish I'd been able to discuss it like this but been able to pursue a diagnosis if or when I was ready to.

gowestlifeispeacefulthere · 03/10/2022 12:00

@Lovelyricepudding getting a diagnosis of autism doesn't mean that you are forced to become part of the Autistic Community online!
I have huge issues with the community. There are always bun fights on MN posts about autism when someone who is active in that demands that they are seen to be right as theirs is the authentic experience. Ands then there's the whole trans issue which is another can of worms.

gowestlifeispeacefulthere · 03/10/2022 11:54

Chipsahoy · 03/10/2022 09:53

My eldest two are text book adhd. Maybe one higher on spectrum also. Smallest I notice autistic traits. We have autism and adhd in the family. All three are happy. Healthy. Youngest doing well in pre school and oldest in their schools. So why bother getting assessed? You get assessed if they need support. Mine have had some issues but we have managed and they have sorted ways to deal on their own. I don’t believe having an assessment will help mine at all.

Please read my post from earlier in the thread. If your kids are "text book" ADHD life will get hard at some point, be it secondary school, college or beyond.
Medication can be absolutely life changing.

Take it from someone with lived experience, denying them a diagnosis therefore an understanding of self, and support, is not helping them. At all.

Miffee · 03/10/2022 11:05

But an autistic child grows up to be an autistic adult and doing that without any support or understanding of why things can be so confusing and difficult, in both mine and Ds's experience is just awful and very very damaging

I see what you are saying but you can still discuss with your child. I spoke to my child about it first when they were 12. They said it made sense to them when they looked into it but were largely disinterested. We've discussed it multiple time over the years, they basically accept that they are autistic but don't want a diagnosis.

That said I realise that my DC had a very specific set of circumstances that meant we were incredibly lucky.

Punxsutawney · 03/10/2022 10:47

I got my autsim diagnosis three months ago and I absolutely welcome it, but being undiagnosed for 47 years means that I'm unfortunately dropping off that cliff at the moment and it's awful. I can only imagine how different things could have been had my difficulties been recognised sooner.

I also have a Ds that was diagnosed at 15 and 3 years later he needs specialist education.

A child may look like they are coping, you may not want what you call a 'label' ( it is not). But an autistic child grows up to be an autistic adult and doing that without any support or understanding of why things can be so confusing and difficult, in both mine and Ds's experience is just awful and very very damaging.

Beefstew · 03/10/2022 10:45

I stuck my head in the sand for twelve years delaying an ASD diagnosis. I was negligent and should have known better as my older two kids are autistic, my third was social, very popular, managing well with a few flags that I tried to manage myself . But I'm not a professional! When secondary school and puberty came into play his differences were highlighted.
Yes he was sociable but immature and inappropriate at times, his moodiness stemmed from masking all day at school, his school jumper irritates him, the noise of hundreds of students as they move around the school overwhelm him. The smells in the air, I could go on and on.
He got his diagnosis over the summer and it was such a relief to him. He finally understands why he doesn't always fit in and that it's okay. He doesn't need to mask as much anymore. (masking is very detrimental to their mental health). We could get accommodations made for him eg to leave his jumper off whilst in school, he can take sensory and movement breaks when he needs to. His SNA(TA in UK) will help any way they can.
He has a diagnosis, not a label.
ASD is not some shameful or embarrassing disorder, it's a different way of thinking.

MinervaTerrathorn · 03/10/2022 10:30

listen to actual autistic people who are able to verbally tell you what its like, not one of them will tell you they are not glad of their diagnosis in the end.
I was not glad of my diagnosis as I was years away from being ready to accept it. My mental health dropped off a cliff following my diagnosis and my teenage years are a blur. I wish I had had the positive experience many others have mentioned of an adult diagnosis.

Theillustratedmummy · 03/10/2022 10:17

@Chipsahoy, OP and all the others who say your dc are doing ok in school, are happy and your dealing with it yourself so don't need a diagnosis, please consider my post.

I'm not claiming to know your dc or your family but remember autism is a communication disability. You dc may be struggling internally but be unable to fully and accurately communicate their needs and their pain. If you had asked me as a child if I was happy I'd have said yes, my parents thought I was doing OK, a bit quirky but in general a happy girl. Inside I was absolutely dying, I was scared, I felt like an alien, so different, life was utterly overwhelming. I couldn't find the words or the way to communication this despite trying. I'm an articulate person but I didn't have the knowledge or ability to do so. No one would know. It was hell on earth. I wanted to die. I tried in secret to pluck up the courage to end my life multiple times from age 11. My parents still to this day don't know this. You may not know how much your dc are really struggling. My diagnosis has been life changing.
When I heard those words as an adult I cried through grief and sadness for my childhood self and I actually feel angry that my parents didn't do something. I find them selfish and I don't think I can ever forgive them.
You might think your dc are OK. They may well be, but they may also be so trapped inside themselves they don't know how the fuck to get out. Do not let them down.

I fought and fought for my dc diagnosis because its who they are, they are not labeled as odd or quirky and because it means we know what support might help. I will do everything in my power to protect their mental health and that is the right way.

listen to actual autistic people who are able to verbally tell you what its like, not one of them will tell you they are not glad of their diagnosis in the end.

Also stands for adhd which I have too.

Mumofsend · 03/10/2022 10:04

I learnt the hard way with my DD not to wait until they are in urgent need of support to really push for it. It took us 18 months to reverse the damage.

eyeteevee · 03/10/2022 10:01

All three are happy. Healthy. Youngest doing well in pre school and oldest in their schools. So why bother getting assessed? You get assessed if they need support.

I'm thinking back to when my now 12 year old was in pre school. Doing well. Happy. Healthy. She is now an absolute wreck who barely leaves the house and no longer goes to school. I can't imagine how the past few years would have played out without the diagnosis being in place as soon as we were able to proceed with the assessment.

I think back over my own life experiences and having a firm diagnosis and understanding of myself would have saved me from so much hurt, trauma; rape... Being able to advocate for myself because I understand why I'm different regather than hiding away thinking I am weird has been life changing.

Waiting until support is needed is leaving it far too late.

Chipsahoy · 03/10/2022 09:53

My eldest two are text book adhd. Maybe one higher on spectrum also. Smallest I notice autistic traits. We have autism and adhd in the family. All three are happy. Healthy. Youngest doing well in pre school and oldest in their schools. So why bother getting assessed? You get assessed if they need support. Mine have had some issues but we have managed and they have sorted ways to deal on their own. I don’t believe having an assessment will help mine at all.

MummyJ12 · 03/10/2022 09:51

I can only share my experience, I’m not here to judge. You’ll do what you feel is best.
My DS is getting assessed next week. He’s 15 and I feel terrible that I’ve let him get to that age before he’ll be (most certainly) diagnosed.
I never suspected ASC, but knew there was something that I wasn’t picking up on. DS has always struggled socially and in hindsight I have been an idiot not to know sooner. Primary school didn’t flag, and Covid hit as soon as he got to high school pretty much. It was only then, when he began with mental health issues of anxiety and low mood. He was referred to CAMHS when he became suicidal.
CAMHS have helped hugely with this and they asked us to consider ASC.
18 months down the line, he is now on anti depressants which have helped the anxiety and low mood but his autistic traits are very apparent. High school and puberty have absolutely had an impact. They describe him as high functioning. He still however, needs a lot of support. Exit passes for school etc.
His high school tried to put me off going for a diagnosis, they actually asked “why I’d want to give him that label”!! They have been less than supportive.
I’ll be glad to have the diagnosis, so we can help him as much as we can. It’s not what I’d hoped for, I see him struggling on a daily basis. It’s definitely getting worse and not better.
With the wait time for assessment (CAMHS) being on average 2.5 years, it may be worth getting the ball rolling on this and seeing how they get on. I wish I’d have woken up to it earlier, my DS may not have had the issues with his anxiety and now severe depression that he has if I had have had support for him sooner. In my case though, I wasn’t thinking along the lines of ASC until very recently, now when I have done some research, it seems so obvious and I’m left feeling that I’ve failed him.

eyeteevee · 03/10/2022 09:49

'Identity' never seems to about the individual but about identifying into a group.

It doesn't have to though. The sense of identity I both got from my diagnosis and taught my children is that you do not have to fit into any group. I wish I had known as a child navigating my way through school that it was ok just to spend time on my own.

The Autistic Community online group never allows individual identity - you have to accept the groups strictures.

You don't have to join these groups though. I have been in a few over the years and the reason I'm not now is because there is an expectation of agreement. Nobody has to be part of that.

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 03/10/2022 09:30

The Autistic Community online group never allows individual identity

Perhaps but I wasn't just refering to online communities. A local charity has some fab groups for young autistic people near me and from what I see there are lovely friendships.

beachcitygirl · 03/10/2022 09:21

Your child will be labelled.
You get to choose wether that is autistic or weird.

HoHoHowMuch · 03/10/2022 09:11

When I was growing up, neurodiversity wasn't something people knew much about I guess. I had heard of dyslexia, but that's about it. I first heard of dyspraxia after I had finished school and it was like reading an autobiography. The flood of emotion as I understood that all the things I had thought were wrong and broken about me were actually a neurological thing and there were others like me. My family weren't supportive of pursuing a diagnosis and as a young adult I didn't really know how to.

I have spent a lot of time trying to fake it. Don't let on that I can't follow multiple instructions, covering up my lack of attention to detail, don't know left from right, am always spilling things or walking in to things. The amount of energy I have spent on masking has been utterly exhausting and got harder with age.

With no diagnosis, I feel like an absolute fraud telling people I have dyspraxia, as I have no proof that it is true. I can't get a diagnosis now unless I spend nigh on a grand kn a private one, money I don't have to spare. School and work would have been made easier by knowing, instead of being told I was useless. I have joined a dyspraxia group to be with others who understand and that does make a difference. I don't consider a diagnosis would have been a label, it would have been an understanding of why life was different for me. I am still sad now that I don't have the ability to get one. I suspect that one of my child is neurodiverse and am absolute pursuing a diagnosis. I can only see that it will help them in life.

Lovelyricepudding · 03/10/2022 09:03

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 03/10/2022 08:32

It's not about a label either it's about a sense of identity. Your son might feel he always has to make with his friends but if he was with other autistics he could be his authentic self. We all like to feel we belong.

Authentic self or another crowd requiring a different kind of masking? 'Identity' never seems to about the individual but about identifying into a group. The Autistic Community online group never allows individual identity - you have to accept the groups strictures. Of course to be welcome into such a group when you have previously felt isolated and apart, can seem very lovely. But it is not about 'authentic self' it is about the group - as a lot of autistic friends found to their cost.

EndlessTea · 03/10/2022 08:34

I was in denial for a while with DD but she started having meltdowns every day after school because of the stress of holding it all in. I was scared she wouldn’t be able to handle mainstream education. We got the diagnosis when she was 10 and I am so glad we did, because it helps so much. She is much less frustrated with herself, more accepting. If someone tells her she is rude or something, she can explain that she is autistic and this really helps her with friendships - she does a lot of research into it and there’s quite a few online communities and YouTubers (I do need to keep a fairly close eye on that those, because there are quite a few unhealthy ‘self-diagnose terrible mental health’ content creators around), so she is less confused about why she is different from other kids - she even has a sense of identity around it. All my fears that she’d be stigmatised were unfounded. She’s doing so well. I’d always go for a diagnosis-at whatever age- it takes the pressure off and brings peace.

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 03/10/2022 08:32

It's not about a label either it's about a sense of identity. Your son might feel he always has to make with his friends but if he was with other autistics he could be his authentic self. We all like to feel we belong.

alltheevennumbers · 03/10/2022 08:14

I completely get why you don't want to see your child as being in a state of 'deficit' as the assessment processes inevitability come at it from this standpoint. Working with professionals, beyond that point is, however, a really good means to achieve a richer understanding of one's child and how to enable them to thrive.

The 'opportunity cost' of not getting a diagnosis needs weighing up really carefully especially, as PPs have said, in respect of adolescence and mental health. Once in secondary school your influence wanes rapidly and your child will be navigating difficult social relationships that you will not be able to mediate.

I think lots of us come from a place of acceptance and don't like the idea of medication etc. But just on ADHD, meds top-up chemicals responsible for overly slow brain processing, which can transform someone's ability to participate in a classroom, which in turn can help lifelong self-esteem.

HelloDoggy · 03/10/2022 07:49

H1nger5442678 · 03/10/2022 06:05

HelloDoggy

I think you’ve got a steep learning curve ahead of you. I did all that with my dc and it has been catastrophic in the teenage years. Severe mental health issues. Masking is damaging and exhausting. Not understanding why you are struggling adds on even damage. You can’t micro manage the teenage years or mental health and actually and when they get to 17 you are pushed out legally and naturally anyway.

Define high functioning. My dc are intelligent, selectively educated and fit in socially in many ways. It has taken a massive toll and both have had catastrophic mental health problems. Not having/ understanding diagnosis has exacerbated the struggle hugely. Not understanding why or being given the tools is a huge handicap in recovery.

Interested to hear how you’ll handle issues. If professionals recommend diagnosis I don’t think any parent shuck be allowed to refuse.Professionals if they suspect autism would treat as if it’s there anyway as it will impact how treatment is carried out. I take it you’d refuse that too which means he wouldn’t get treatment tailored to his needs. If you didn’t refuse you are simply trying to hide his disability by refusing a diagnosis which is wrong and hypocritical.

There is no 'treatment" for ADHD or autism. It's about managing and adapting and using strategies. I don't see why a diagnosis helps with that. To be honest, improbably meet the criteria for ADHD myself. Can't see how it would help me to get that label. I'm happy as I am.

H1nger5442678 · 03/10/2022 06:05

HelloDoggy

I think you’ve got a steep learning curve ahead of you. I did all that with my dc and it has been catastrophic in the teenage years. Severe mental health issues. Masking is damaging and exhausting. Not understanding why you are struggling adds on even damage. You can’t micro manage the teenage years or mental health and actually and when they get to 17 you are pushed out legally and naturally anyway.

Define high functioning. My dc are intelligent, selectively educated and fit in socially in many ways. It has taken a massive toll and both have had catastrophic mental health problems. Not having/ understanding diagnosis has exacerbated the struggle hugely. Not understanding why or being given the tools is a huge handicap in recovery.

Interested to hear how you’ll handle issues. If professionals recommend diagnosis I don’t think any parent shuck be allowed to refuse.Professionals if they suspect autism would treat as if it’s there anyway as it will impact how treatment is carried out. I take it you’d refuse that too which means he wouldn’t get treatment tailored to his needs. If you didn’t refuse you are simply trying to hide his disability by refusing a diagnosis which is wrong and hypocritical.

BryceQuinlanTheFirst · 03/10/2022 04:45

@HelloDoggy

I'm curious whether you spend any time chatting with autistic or adhd adults? The fb groups I'm in are full of adults who feel they were let down by parents who didn't support diagnosis paths. Even in a professional networking group I'm in, 5 women recently have sought out adhd diagnoses and they talk about feeling hugely liberated and relieved.

Swipe left for the next trending thread