Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone the parent of a child with asd and not seeking a diagnosis?

664 replies

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 13:37

Not looking for a bun fight. Just trying to sort out my thinking. Anyone with any of their own insight that they'd be willing to share?

OP posts:
TheCatWithGreenEyes · 03/10/2022 22:47

My eldest has a private diagnosis of ADHD with suspected autism. I didn't bother getting him assessed for ASD as at age 14 he didn't want to and refused medication and all the help offered at school.
He is now a soldier in the army. But the suspected autism nearly cost him his career. He was refused but luckily appealed and allowed to continue his application.
My youngest child is most definitely on the spectrum but I will not be seeking a diagnosis just in case he wants to work in the military.
My husband also most definitely has ASD undiagnosed and served 22 years and his ASD made him the soldier he was.

Mumofsend · 03/10/2022 22:17

My DD always blows my mind. Can memorise facts and theoretical information long a sponge. Can she put it into practice? Not at all. Can she grasp that a car park isn't a road but cars still move? Not at all. Can she reliably walk on a pavement and not randomly run into a road? No. Has she got any social awareness or skills? No, not even comparable to the 4 year olds in reception. Yet she can sit through a teaching input, memorise the content, complete the task well and then it's like poof, that info is gone.

It all absolutely fascinates me!

BlankTimes · 03/10/2022 21:51

I think a rough rule of thumb for people who don't understand autism could be don't assume that because the autistic person/person with autism you are discussing can easily do a certain task because you've seen them do a different task very capably.

The oft-repeated 'If you've met one person with autism, you've met one person with autism' holds true.

In the NT world, it's fairly safe to assume that if a person can do one task then they are very likely able to do several others that naturally follow on from the original one.

When someone is neurodiverse, that all goes out of the window and each individual has a set of strengths and weaknesses which show how autism, ADHD and all the other co-morbids and three letter acronym conditions affect them. Someone else with the same conditions can be affected very differently.

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 03/10/2022 21:39

Sorry meant to quote @Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow

I also see that other posters have already made my point better than I have!

eyeteevee · 03/10/2022 21:39

I didn’t say anything about taking anything away from someone, it’s not a competition, it’s about a way to understand someone’s situation quickly, albeit bluntly.

Nobody who is involved with mine or my children's care should be making quick, blunt decisions about our autism. Anybody else is irrelevant.

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 03/10/2022 21:37

There's no way to understand someones situation quickly with ASD (and why would you need to?) It's a complex condition, and every case is different. There is no quick and handy scale of severity.

My DD recently got some good GCSEs, has no toileting or personal care issues, is stylish and creative, looks 'normal' walking down the street and can hold an intelligent conversation. She made herself a healthy dinner tonight. Does that mean she's 'mild' or high functioning?

Nope. She has no self esteem, no friends, has diagnoses of depression, an eating disorder, anxiety, and OCD; she has medication to stop her being violent towards herself, others and objects, has no concept of time/timetables so can't get anywhere on time or without help. She is paranoid and suspicious of everyone. She can't interact with shop assistants/bus drivers etc. so can't go out alone. She sometimes has meltdowns in public and (deliberately) knocks things over. She was a school refuser for years. She sees a psychiatrist regularly. I could go on and on but you get my drift.

ParrotPoppy · 03/10/2022 21:32

@BlankTimes as always your post is excellent.

You can describe their needs as relevant to the situation. Just because someone is ‘high functioning’ (I hate that term) doesn’t mean they have low support needs. You can’t neatly fit people into boxes like that.

Can I ask how you would classify one of my DC? He wears pull ups/slips, needs round the clock care and has SM which means he is largely non-verbal. He is also academically very able. He is ‘high functioning’ using the true definition of the phrase, but can’t by anyone’s standards be considered to have low support needs - he has an EHCP, a social care package, HRC/HRM DLA, tier 4 CAMHS involvement.

BlankTimes · 03/10/2022 21:28

This has already been linked to upthread, but it's worth doing again to illustrate there's no 'scale of severity'
neuroclastic.com/its-a-spectrum-doesnt-mean-what-you-think/

I think this extract explains it very well.
"People who can speak aloud and have reasonable control over their motor processing are often called “high-functioning,” and yet these autistics often struggle with employment, relationships, and executive function.
My doctor recently referred to my autism is “mild.” I gently pointed to my psychologist’s report which stated that my executive dysfunction as being greater than 99th percentile.
“That means I am less functional than 99% of people. Does that seem mild to you?” I asked her.
But, you see, I can speak, and I can look people in the eyes, so they see my autism as “mild.” My autism affects those around me mildly but my autism does affect me severely.
There is no question that those who suffer from severe neuromotor difficulties are extremely disabled, and I am not in any way comparing myself to them.
In fact, I am specifically asking people to stop comparing me to them. It does them a disservice to assume that they have what I have, only worse.
It is this assumption that dehumanizes people like Ido Kedar and Carly Fleischmann. It is this assumption that leads to them and many like them being treated as unthinking, unfeeling, and unhearing. It is this assumption that drives them to beat their heads against the wall in frustration.
If they have what I have, but worse, then they must be so very autistic that they can’t function at all. They must have worse interpersonal skills, worse information processing, worse social awareness.
But that isn’t true at all."

Is anyone the parent of a child with asd and not seeking a diagnosis?
H1nger5442678 · 03/10/2022 21:25

Autism is not an illness
It's something you're born with. Signs of autism might be noticed when you're very young, or not until you're older. If you're autistic, you're autistic your whole life. Autism is not a medical condition with treatments or a "cure".
www.nhs.uk › ... › Autism

Ifyouknowyouknowyouknow · 03/10/2022 21:18

eyeteevee · 03/10/2022 21:06

@harrietm87

We don't have to distinguish. Autism affects people differently and n the same way as the majority of other conditions. Nobody labels COPD or arthritis in such a way, yet strangely people who suffer these conditions usually manage to access the support/help they need.

The competitive autism is bullshit.

Nobody is taking anything away from someone with very high needs by having lesser needs.

I didn’t say anything about taking anything away from someone, it’s not a competition, it’s about a way to understand someone’s situation quickly, albeit bluntly.

And btw plenty of other medical conditions exist on some kind of scale of “severity” or however you want to describe it.

H1nger5442678 · 03/10/2022 21:17

What ParrotPoppy said.

H1nger5442678 · 03/10/2022 21:16

Having kids and an education doesn’t make you have low support needs.

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 03/10/2022 21:09

eyeteevee · 03/10/2022 10:01

All three are happy. Healthy. Youngest doing well in pre school and oldest in their schools. So why bother getting assessed? You get assessed if they need support.

I'm thinking back to when my now 12 year old was in pre school. Doing well. Happy. Healthy. She is now an absolute wreck who barely leaves the house and no longer goes to school. I can't imagine how the past few years would have played out without the diagnosis being in place as soon as we were able to proceed with the assessment.

I think back over my own life experiences and having a firm diagnosis and understanding of myself would have saved me from so much hurt, trauma; rape... Being able to advocate for myself because I understand why I'm different regather than hiding away thinking I am weird has been life changing.

Waiting until support is needed is leaving it far too late.

So much this^

My DD was diagnosed at 8. She was well supported in primary even before this, but being diagnosed meant she got to a lovely school with specialist teaching for secondary* and when her mood and behaviour went seriously south at age 12 she was quickly supported by a psychiatrist from CAMHS as she was already seeing them.

Puberty is a notoriously difficult time for ASD youngsters, and if serious problems arise it may be difficult to get help when the waiting list is 18 months to 2 years long for CAMHS.

*even with a diagnosis it was a fight; so many parents chasing too few places for their DC. There were no undiagnosed children in the STF, even if, as a PP may claim, it shouldn't be necessary.

eyeteevee · 03/10/2022 21:06

@harrietm87

We don't have to distinguish. Autism affects people differently and n the same way as the majority of other conditions. Nobody labels COPD or arthritis in such a way, yet strangely people who suffer these conditions usually manage to access the support/help they need.

The competitive autism is bullshit.

Nobody is taking anything away from someone with very high needs by having lesser needs.

harrietm87 · 03/10/2022 21:01

Out of interest, how would the people saying there’s no such thing as mild autism distinguish between my cousin who is non-verbal, wears nappies and needs round the clock care, and my colleague diagnosed with Asperger’s as a teen who is married with kids having got a starred first at Cambridge?

Is “low support needs” acceptable?

ParrotPoppy · 03/10/2022 19:51

There is no such thing as mild autism. People have different presentations and different needs, but that doesn’t mean they are less or mild. “Persistent difficulties” that “limit and impair everyday functioning” aren’t mild. If their difficulties were mild they wouldn’t get a diagnosis.

H1nger5442678 · 03/10/2022 18:34

SteveHarringtonsChestHair

My dc were those children and my Dd not only masked her autism but stark learning difficulties to the extent she got into grammar school. It has been catastrophic I will never forgive her schools for being so spectacularly shite and having a nothing to see here attitude because she made their data look good. She is halfway through an EHCP and now has so many services supporting her.

There is no such thing as mild autism.Nobody knows anything about anybody’s day to day functioning. My daughter looked great but was dying inside and has been hospitalised multiple times.

Sirzy · 03/10/2022 18:33

It’s worrying how many people think waiting until things start going wrong to begin the diagnosis process is a good idea!

firef1y · 03/10/2022 18:11

SteveHarringtonsChestHair · 01/10/2022 14:00

Bollocks.

I work in a school and I see many children both with and without diagnoses. They are all supported through their own particular challenges and having a diagnosis doesn’t make them any more likely to actually come into school and stay there.

If they need one to one support or special adjustments made etc of course it would help, but if they are achieving well and are streets ahead of their peers, having taught themselves to read at nursery age and being “that kid” correcting the teacher at the age of 7, making them feel that there is something “wrong” with them isn’t always a positive thing.

I am that person, taught themselves to read at age 2, offered a private school scholarship at age 4 (not taken up). Miles ahead throughout primary school, passed 11+ with flying colours etc etc etc
But while my parents always knew there was something different about me (they'd never have said wrong with me even though I would), they never tried to get me a dx.
I struggled all the way through High school, was labeled "naughty" and "disruptive". Always knew I was different, was desperate to fit in, would have loved to be able to walk in to a full classroom and make friends like other people can.
The struggling has carried on throughout adulthood, looking back now I can see how incredibly vulnerable I was/am and how this led to me being in an abusive relationship. Pretty easy to isolate someone who doesn't do socialing anyway.
I finally got my ASD and ADHD dx 5 years ago at age 45. Yes I still have the same issues, but now I don't fight them.

containsnuts · 03/10/2022 18:10

There is no such thing as "mild autism".

It's "mild" in the sense that day-to-day functioning is effected less than for others with the same diagnosis. Think successful business person, married with children vs someone unable to talk, feed, toilet themselves.

MinervaTerrathorn · 03/10/2022 17:57

Miffee · 03/10/2022 14:13

@MinervaTerrathorn

I'm so sorry your experience was so difficult, thank you for your post that is exactly what I want my DC to feel like.

I think you've made the right decision to go with what your child wants to do. My younger sibling realised they were autistic in their teens but has never pursued diagnosis. Maybe my diagnosis meant that they knew sooner than they would have otherwise, then that would mean some good came of it.

RainingRubies · 03/10/2022 17:48

My reasons for that is because he’s high functioning and extremely mild, has amazing school support and I don’t feel he needs additional input or a label as for him it would change nothing

There is no such thing as "mild autism".

Being high functioning doesn't prevent that damage to mental health that constant masking does, particularly when you don't understand why you are having to do it.

A medical diagnosis is not a label.

And it's funny how not a single person I know who has a diagnosis believes it was detrimental to them. In fact, quite the opposite.

RainingRubies · 03/10/2022 17:42

making them feel that there is something “wrong” with them isn’t always a positive thing.

Why would being autistic imply there is something "wrong" with someone?

Shocking that somebody who says they work in a school has such ideas.

Miffee · 03/10/2022 14:13

@MinervaTerrathorn

I'm so sorry your experience was so difficult, thank you for your post that is exactly what I want my DC to feel like.

R0BYN · 03/10/2022 13:00

He got his diagnosis over the summer and it was such a relief to him. He finally understands why he doesn't always fit in and that it's okay. He doesn't need to mask as much anymore. (masking is very detrimental to their mental health). We could get accommodations made for him eg to leave his jumper off whilst in school, he can take sensory and movement breaks when he needs to. His SNA(TA in UK) will help any way they can

He has a diagnosis, not a label

ASD is not some shameful or embarrassing disorder, it's a different way of thinking

This.

Those of you with primary aged children who say that they suspect their child has ASD but they are not willing to get a diagnosis - please know this.

Its extremely likely that you child knows that they are different. If you are not willing to pursue help or an explanation for them, please know this:

There are many adults and adult led groups online who will be queuing up to give your child an alternative explanation for why they feel that they don’t fit it, which is that you “ assigned them the wrong gender”, they are trapped in the wrong body and the answer is to get powerful drugs and surgery to fix their faulty body.

They don’t need to talk to you about it - there are plenty adults online who will help them bypass normal safeguarding protocols.

Instead of being weird and geeky, they will hold out the prospect of being cool and exciting.

Instead of feeling unimportant and even invisible, they can be important and get special rights and privileges over other pupils .

Instead of being powerless they will be powerful. They get to tell the teachers and other adults what to say and do.

They can even punish the children who have ignored or bullied them by making allegations against them and they will be believed without question.

Instead of being left out and lonely, they will find “ their tribe “ and groups who will welcome then with open arms. They will be the most famous and well known pupil in their school. They will get praise or maybe even awards for being brave and authentic.

How seductive is that? Sign me up now please. So much better than tedious old fashioned autism 🥱🥱🥱