Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is anyone the parent of a child with asd and not seeking a diagnosis?

664 replies

coodawoodashooda · 01/10/2022 13:37

Not looking for a bun fight. Just trying to sort out my thinking. Anyone with any of their own insight that they'd be willing to share?

OP posts:
alltheevennumbers · 04/10/2022 09:03

HCPs are now seeing anxiety as absolutely central to the social experience of autism in young people, and viewing other features of autism (rigidity, controlling behaviour etc) as strategies for managing that anxiety.

Lovelyricepudding · 04/10/2022 09:02

Autistic traits may be different, but we all meet the criteria for diagnosis

And those criteria change and broaden. None of the criteria are black and white, they all involve arbitrary cut offs along a spectrum. 'We are all a little bit autistic' is condemned and yet everyone sits somewhere on those spectrums and non-autistic people sit below the arbitrary cut off for some (but not necessarily) all of them. Perhaps diagnosis needs to be done on the basis of brain imagery? Yet even there studies often create a false dichotomy by only comparing autistic brains with 'neurotypical' brains - not others with other neuro diversities.

eyeteevee · 04/10/2022 09:02

Also, the 'who I am' thing?

The diagnosis gave me peace and understanding that the past 40+ years were not my fault. They have given me the ability to advocate for myself in certain situations where I would have previously given up. I have non verbal episodes still but I understand I'm not a freak who just can't think of what to say. I have realised my vulnerability, all those times of thinking people liked me, men were interested in me, just for it to end badly. I have been in I don't k on how many toxic situations that I only recently was able to reframe and fully understand. Going forward I am aware of this and very cautious around new people who show such obvious red flags. I had no idea before. I used alcohol as a crutch for a good 20 years, managed to get sober as I could place to reason and the damage. I no longer feel that I need or should be doing things and I work on a basis of what suits me. This is a power I did not have prior to my diagnosis and it had been absolutely life changing.

eyeteevee · 04/10/2022 08:52

But what does “who you are” mean? Every human being is different with strengths and weaknesses. If every single person with autism is different such that it’s impossible to generalise or even use more specific terms then what understanding do you get from the term?

Autistic traits may be different, but we all meet the criteria for diagnosis which is little to do with the common traits most people attach to autism.

Lovelyricepudding · 04/10/2022 08:52

OCD, anxiety, depression are comorbidities and not part of autism. Yet several posters are saying my/my child''s autism is not mild because ocd/anxiety/depression. If you put this together with 'autism is not an illness/no cure' then the logic is to leave these individuals with untreated mental illnesses.

Why is autism 'not low support needs because ocd/anxiety/depression/suicidality' but 'those support needs are due to learning disability so don't count'?

TheFreaksShallInheritTheEarth · 04/10/2022 08:38

harrietm87 · 04/10/2022 00:35

No one “needs” to distinguish. It’s not about competition or validation, it’s about the meaning of words. Your analogies are inapposite.

If autism covers such a broad range of attributes that it’s literally impossible to make any generalisations then I wonder why it is also essential for autistic people to know they are autistic. What does autism mean if it tells you nothing at all about the person with autism?

Why is diagnosis essential if really autism is just an umbrella term of a collection of attributes that varies massively from person to person? The support needed by any individual should be determined by the attributes whether they are diagnosed with something or not.

...if it tells you nothing at all about the person with autism?

A diagnosis of autism tells you that someone has a congenital neurological difference. It tells that person that the reason they're struggling is because their wiring is different to others', not because they are stupid or socially inept. It is important that this is recognised, as it is a lifelong difference.

It tells their teachers that the reason for their screaming, not following instructions, or other 'bad' behaviour is not naughtiness. It tells me and my daughter that her OCD is lifelong, not a problem that can disappear with therapy.

The support needed by any individual should be determined by the attributes whether they are diagnosed with something or not

Two young children may both be crying in assembly and reluctant to go to school generally, but the support needed could be very different: one has has a difficult start to life and is shy; the other is autistic. The help that is needed for each will be different and may involve different agencies. The first may get better within a short while with a little understanding and increasing maturity; the second's difficulties will be lifelong and require different accommodations. It's not just the symptoms, it's the cause of the symptoms that's important, which is how a diagnosis helps.

It would be great if there were 4 or 5 different types of autism, easily identifiable and diagnosible, with symptoms that are easy to anticipate and mitigate so that adjustments could easily be put in place, but it is far more complex and varied than that, unfortunately.

ohanami · 04/10/2022 08:32

@HelloDoggy my daughter has recently been diagnosed with ASD. She's nearly 9 and she's always been the model student at school. Speaks when she's spoken to, likes to get things right, always a peacemaker when there are arguments between friends. School didn't see any of her traits, and senior teachers questioned the point of pushing for a diagnosis, "because she's doing fine".

You talk about the strategies you're working on to help your son manage, but sometimes that isn't enough. This summer, an apparently harmless incident at school tipped DD into a period of severe anxiety. We spent a night in the safe room at A&E because she was trying to kill herself. She started refusing school. She stopped sleeping. I've spent the last 4 months dealing with the fallout of a throwaway comment in the playground.

Because she hadn't been diagnosed when this started, the only help I could access was a referral to a parenting course. Can you imagine how that feels when you're trying to stop your child deliberately causing herself severe harm?

You can't second guess what it's going to take for your make-do coping strategies to fall apart, and what the consequences could be.

I'd also suggest you have a think about whether it's really appropriate to teach your son not to stim "in case he's picked on". The pressure of always trying to conform is huge, and detracts from learning. The way I explain it to dd is that it's like trying to swim and pick up bricks from the bottom of the pool at the same time. She can still swim a length, but if she has to keep stopping to pick up the bricks she's going to get tired sooner and won't swim as far. Trying not to stim is the equivalent of constantly stopping for bricks. Now that she has a diagnosis she's starting to allow herself to do it, and her work is more accurate as a result. She feels better about herself too. Now it's just a thing she sometimes needs to do, not something she has to hide. Always hiding who you are, even with the people you're closest to, makes her really lonely.

harrietm87 · 04/10/2022 08:30

Sirzy · 04/10/2022 08:04

But it’s also very hard to undo the damage from not having had the support and understanding of who you are.

But what does “who you are” mean? Every human being is different with strengths and weaknesses. If every single person with autism is different such that it’s impossible to generalise or even use more specific terms then what understanding do you get from the term?

(I don’t actually agree with this btw but it’s the logical conclusion of what some posters on this thread are saying).

eyeteevee · 04/10/2022 08:07

This is where my reticence to push forward comes in. An adolescent can seek a diagnosis but not undo one.

Why would anyone be undoing a diagnosis?

Sirzy · 04/10/2022 08:04

But it’s also very hard to undo the damage from not having had the support and understanding of who you are.

coodawoodashooda · 04/10/2022 08:01

harrietm87 · 04/10/2022 00:35

No one “needs” to distinguish. It’s not about competition or validation, it’s about the meaning of words. Your analogies are inapposite.

If autism covers such a broad range of attributes that it’s literally impossible to make any generalisations then I wonder why it is also essential for autistic people to know they are autistic. What does autism mean if it tells you nothing at all about the person with autism?

Why is diagnosis essential if really autism is just an umbrella term of a collection of attributes that varies massively from person to person? The support needed by any individual should be determined by the attributes whether they are diagnosed with something or not.

This is where my reticence to push forward comes in. An adolescent can seek a diagnosis but not undo one.

OP posts:
eyeteevee · 04/10/2022 07:45

Nobody labels COPD or arthritis in such a way

Of course they do. COPD even has stages and arthritis is often classed as mild, moderate severe.

My mistake. I used those as examples as my Dad has COPD and my DH has osteoarthritis - neither of them has been categorised so I wrongly assumed that was normal. Apologies.

containsnuts · 04/10/2022 07:18

"There must be a very valid reason why the military will not accept those diagnosed with ASC otherwise they would be open to discrimination under the Equality Act surely?"

Presumably it's because it's not always possible to make adjustments to accommodate someone's needs. Those in the military need to be physically and mentally robust and be able to adapt to all kids of extreme situations. Lots of people are deemed unsuitable for the military.

Miffee · 04/10/2022 06:35

Nobody labels COPD or arthritis in such a way

Of course they do. COPD even has stages and arthritis is often classed as mild, moderate severe.

And of course there is reason to distinguish between somebody who is unable to speak or use the toilet and somebody who is independent.

harrietm87 · 04/10/2022 00:35

NCFT0922 · 03/10/2022 23:30

@harrietm87 why do people need to distinguish?

Do people with eating disorders also have to validate themselves using this ridiculous “my condition is worse than yours” shit? How would you describe a person who makes themselves sick once a day compared to someone who makes themselves sick 15 times a day? Mildly bulimic? Low level bulimic? High functioning bulimic?

Is the employed, home owning married father who has attempted suicide once this year “low level suicidal” compared to the homeless, unemployed, single man who has attempted suicide 6 times this year? Is low level suicidal acceptable ?

No one “needs” to distinguish. It’s not about competition or validation, it’s about the meaning of words. Your analogies are inapposite.

If autism covers such a broad range of attributes that it’s literally impossible to make any generalisations then I wonder why it is also essential for autistic people to know they are autistic. What does autism mean if it tells you nothing at all about the person with autism?

Why is diagnosis essential if really autism is just an umbrella term of a collection of attributes that varies massively from person to person? The support needed by any individual should be determined by the attributes whether they are diagnosed with something or not.

PlinkyPlonk1 · 04/10/2022 00:05

I know if two kids who have subsequently been diagnosed with Autism who had parents reluctant to be assessed for fear of a 'label'.

It's really bitten them on the bum because they are hurtling towards the end of their secondary education and have been refused help because if no diagnosis. The SENCOs are having to prioritise the kids who were diagnosed.

The support they've had us minimal. By the time they get an EHCP in their hand, they'll have left school as it's taking approximately 2 years to get an EHCP now unless you're one of the lucky ones who gets no resistance from the LA.

One of those kids really ought to be in a MLD school but no EHCP so is stuck in a mainstream being badly bullied. I first met this child 10 years ago and my first instinct was "this child is different". Other kids spot it and see them as weird. At least if the child is assessed they can understand their differences better.

Treebranch · 03/10/2022 23:47

cansu · 01/10/2022 19:52

Have two with asd both diagnosed. My partner is not diagnosed and it has had a massive impact on him. As a teacher I see many undiagnosed kids. I think it is very sad to see these kids struggle through school. The diagnosis could allow them a smoother path through the system.

Of it's so obvious, why does there have to be an official diagnosis to make adjustments?

TheCatWithGreenEyes · 03/10/2022 23:45

MummyJ12 · 03/10/2022 22:59

I’m just wondering what your thoughts are on the hypothetical higher risk of PTSD following military deployments, considering that there are studies that indicate co-morbidity with ASC and PTSD TheCatWithGreenEyes?
There must be a very valid reason why the military will not accept those diagnosed with ASC otherwise they would be open to discrimination under the Equality Act surely?

I didn't know about the risks of ASD and PTSD but my husband was severely injured and does suffer from complex PTSD.
I don't think there should be a blanket ban on ASD for military service but I think each individual should be looked at.
My husband ASD traits made him who he was. He recognises the traits in many of his colleagues and believes they helped not hindered military service.

Nn9011 · 03/10/2022 23:36

My mum didn't get one of my siblings tested because she didn't want them labelled and it was one of the things I think she'll forever regret.
As a result my sibling didn't get the support they needed to be able to thrive in school and dropped out without barely a qualification. They find it difficult to hold down a job and are struggling to understand themselves.
As someone who is waiting for an ADHD diagnosis and has spent the year speaking to adult women being diagnosed with ASD/ADHD as adulta I can tell you that it is cruel to not get the diagnosis that your child deserves. If you thought they were dyslexic or blind would you deny them the support? Yes a label can be used, but 9 times out of 10 it is helpful from school right through to getting help and support in the workplace.
If you truly think they may be autistic please listen to the people from the neurodivergent community who are telling you that label matters, even if a small minority want to be unfair because of it. It matters on every level and if you chose to not get them the support then you are being selfish, I'm sorry but it's true.

NCFT0922 · 03/10/2022 23:30

@harrietm87 why do people need to distinguish?

Do people with eating disorders also have to validate themselves using this ridiculous “my condition is worse than yours” shit? How would you describe a person who makes themselves sick once a day compared to someone who makes themselves sick 15 times a day? Mildly bulimic? Low level bulimic? High functioning bulimic?

Is the employed, home owning married father who has attempted suicide once this year “low level suicidal” compared to the homeless, unemployed, single man who has attempted suicide 6 times this year? Is low level suicidal acceptable ?

Sickoffamilydrama · 03/10/2022 23:15

In one way I understand why the military would exclude people with autism. I recall seeing a study that found that over 50% of high functioning teenagers and 20% of adults with high functioning autism exhibited aggressive behavior.

It would make sense to not take on people with more aggressive tendencies but then it does not seem unfair to the 80% that don't.

I've often thought the military and police should do some kind of psychometric testing to weed out the aggressive and power hungry people.

Daftasabroom · 03/10/2022 23:12

BlankTimes · 03/10/2022 21:51

I think a rough rule of thumb for people who don't understand autism could be don't assume that because the autistic person/person with autism you are discussing can easily do a certain task because you've seen them do a different task very capably.

The oft-repeated 'If you've met one person with autism, you've met one person with autism' holds true.

In the NT world, it's fairly safe to assume that if a person can do one task then they are very likely able to do several others that naturally follow on from the original one.

When someone is neurodiverse, that all goes out of the window and each individual has a set of strengths and weaknesses which show how autism, ADHD and all the other co-morbids and three letter acronym conditions affect them. Someone else with the same conditions can be affected very differently.

I've posted before that it isn't so much things individual kids can do as the things they struggle with that defines the impact of ASC on their each of their lives.

ParrotPoppy · 03/10/2022 23:02

For the Navy autism isn’t an automatic barrier, each case is judged individually.

MummyJ12 · 03/10/2022 22:59

I’m just wondering what your thoughts are on the hypothetical higher risk of PTSD following military deployments, considering that there are studies that indicate co-morbidity with ASC and PTSD TheCatWithGreenEyes?
There must be a very valid reason why the military will not accept those diagnosed with ASC otherwise they would be open to discrimination under the Equality Act surely?

NameChange30 · 03/10/2022 22:52

I had no idea people diagnosed with autism are not allowed to join the army; how is that not illegal discrimination?!

Selfishly I wouldn't want my DC to join the army (no disrespect to people in the military, just not my preference for my children) but of course if that's what my DC wanted to do I would support them and wouldn't want them to have unfair barriers.

It won't stop me pursuing a diagnosis though and that's mainly because I think it will help my DC's mental health in the short, medium and long term to have a diagnosis and to have solid evidence to argue for support.