Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bring back capital punishment?

235 replies

LittleMaroonRidingHood · 01/10/2022 13:03

This thread was prompted by the news item about a possible discovery of the remains of a victim of the 'Moors Murderers'.

Should Capital Punishment be re-instated for murder ?

YABU - The value of the offender's life should not be negated by the offender's crime.
YANBU - When someone sets out with intent to deprive someone of their life, then they automatically forfeit the right to get any older.

OP posts:
Anon778833 · 01/10/2022 14:00

I like the way that your OP assumes to know what everyone thinks one way or the other 🙄

Its not about ‘the value of the offenders life’. Certainly in my case. I don’t want to live in a country where the state kills people, thanks. Justice shouldn’t be about revenge.

And there are miscarriages of justice sometimes.

HenBob · 01/10/2022 13:59

You need to do far more research on capital punishment. It's not a deterrent, it's more expensive, it's systemically racist, a large proportion of people on death row are found to be innocent of their crimes. Not the way forward, we aren't barbarians.

LizzieSiddal · 01/10/2022 13:58

Have you looked at America recently? It doesn’t work as a deter any so no, the state should not do this.

Ouchh · 01/10/2022 13:58

I think if an offender is 100% proven to have committed numerous horrific offences (i.e: rape, murder, torture, crimes involving children) and it isn't possible to rehabilitate them, then we should offer them the choice between execution and being banished to a prison colony. The prison colony would be a single-sex island and you'd work and live like you might anywhere else, just no internet or link to the outside world. Offenders would work, helping to make it a financially self-sustaining colony. That way they can live, and the only risk they'd pose is to each other, and they maybe wouldn't cost the taxpayer so much either

MarshaBradyo · 01/10/2022 13:56

Podgedodge · 01/10/2022 13:52

Really? You’d be happy to do some torturing?
Think about that for a minute.

What would that make you?

Agree
Torture is a terrible idea too

Suedomin · 01/10/2022 13:56

Murder is wrong, whether the state does it or an individual does.
Capital punishment isn't justice it's revenge.
We already seem to be going back in time with food banks and blaming people for being poor. if we bring back capital punishment it really will feel as though we are back in Victorian times.

ReneBumsWombats · 01/10/2022 13:56

Ihatethenewlook · 01/10/2022 13:09

Same. I’d be pretty happy to do some torturing.

Lots of people would. They just need a way for it to be acceptable.

MarshaBradyo · 01/10/2022 13:55

No as awful as really bad things can be I wouldn’t go to that

Pemba · 01/10/2022 13:55

No because it's state sanctioned murder and there's always the possibility of mistakes, person turns out to be innocent. That is horrible.
Plus it's uncivilised, and not an effective detterent - look at Texas, highest rate of executions but also the highest number of homicides I've heard. Or something like that.

I do believe there should be more whole life tariffs though, which seem to be the exception in the UK.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 01/10/2022 13:54

SavingsThreads · 01/10/2022 13:51

No. And anyone who supports the death penalty or torture (as the person above), would you be willing to do it yourselves? To inflict the pain and hear the screams?

This is a good point. I read something a while ago from a Dr in America who had be present at several deaths of people on death row. It was a burden and he regretted it.

Very going point. We are authorising individual to kill or burdening multiple people by employing them to be involved. I can imagine any healthy person being able to do that without it affecting them.

ilovesooty · 01/10/2022 13:53

TortugaRumCakeQueen · 01/10/2022 13:13

Yes, we should bring it back. We are spending Billions keeping people alive, that can never be reintroduced into society and who have committed unforgivable crimes. They don't pay tax, they don't contribute anything and they are deadly dangerous. Why are we keeping them alive? What for?

Do you know how expensive the death penalty and the appeals process is in the US?

Podgedodge · 01/10/2022 13:52

Ihatethenewlook · 01/10/2022 13:09

Same. I’d be pretty happy to do some torturing.

Really? You’d be happy to do some torturing?
Think about that for a minute.

What would that make you?

SavingsThreads · 01/10/2022 13:51

No. And anyone who supports the death penalty or torture (as the person above), would you be willing to do it yourselves? To inflict the pain and hear the screams?

Eeiliethya · 01/10/2022 13:51

No I don't think it should.

Admittedly though when seeing some recent cases of horrendous child abuse that results in death I would like to see the fuckers responsible die. And slow.

Ouchh · 01/10/2022 13:51

It depends what they've done. If they are proven to serially offend with no remorse (and can thus never be safely released into the public) then I do think it should be an option. If an offender is redeemable, then by all means we should rehabilitate them. But if they commit horrific crimes and can't be rehabilitated, then I don't see why the taxpayer should spend thousands to millions of pounds over the offender's lifetime paying for them to be locked away.

ReeDeeHee · 01/10/2022 13:50

Melodiax · 01/10/2022 13:47

A system that tries to focus on "rehab" rather than punishment. If they are in for life, they should be suffering in that time.

The justice system is no longer built around "punishment" or making people suffer. You might be surprised if you look up the reoffender rates in places like Norway where the focus is heavily on rehabilitating people back to society compared to here.
If we take away human rights from those we consider "beneath" them, we open the door for those rights to be taken away from us at some future date.

Melodiax · 01/10/2022 13:49

LadyKenya · 01/10/2022 13:48

I think that neither has the right to hurt another person like that regardless as to what they have done. That is what the justice system is there for, is it not.

You said "how does that make you any better?"

They might both be in the wrong, but the one who tortured and killed someone innocent is worse than the one hurting them in revenge

Echobelly · 01/10/2022 13:48

Terrible idea. I don't think it works at all, as it seems to me most murders fall into two categories:

  • Killer is mentally unwell/has serious personality disorder and so won't be put off by death penalty
  • Killer commits act in a moment of red mist and if they could turn back time and make a choice of course they would not do it, so if the fact they were about to kill another human being didn't stop them in the moment, neither would the thought they could face the death penalty.
LadyKenya · 01/10/2022 13:48

XSnoe · 01/10/2022 13:45

You think someone who tortures a child murderer is on the same level as the one who tortured/raped/killed an innocent child?

I think that neither has the right to hurt another person like that regardless as to what they have done. That is what the justice system is there for, is it not.

Sirzy · 01/10/2022 13:47

XSnoe · 01/10/2022 13:45

You think someone who tortures a child murderer is on the same level as the one who tortured/raped/killed an innocent child?

But where do you draw the line? Is there really any line between good murder and bad murder? If we put the power to end someone’s life into someone else’s hand what does that make them?

Melodiax · 01/10/2022 13:47

Sirzy · 01/10/2022 13:45

Which is why we have a judicial system rather than a system whereby the emotions of the relatives decide on things.

A system that tries to focus on "rehab" rather than punishment. If they are in for life, they should be suffering in that time.

GucciBear · 01/10/2022 13:46

I was always for capital punishment until I had a long talk with my dear father when he said the problem with it is that if someone is discovered to be innocent at a later date, you cannot bring them back!

ReeDeeHee · 01/10/2022 13:46

Absolutely not.
The people who decide what is and what is not a crime should not have the power to allow capital punishment. It's that simple to me.
All well and good when it's "only" the scum of society but it can easily become a slippery slope to murdering dissidents in the wrong hands/wrong government. Better to have an absolute red line that the state can not kill anybody.

XSnoe · 01/10/2022 13:45

LadyKenya · 01/10/2022 13:43

Eh, how does that make you any better than the offender?

You think someone who tortures a child murderer is on the same level as the one who tortured/raped/killed an innocent child?

Sirzy · 01/10/2022 13:45

XSnoe · 01/10/2022 13:42

Most people are rational and do not seek out murder as vengeance.

I guess I'm irrational then, because if someone raped my child, I'd want them at least dead, at best alive and suffering.

Which is why we have a judicial system rather than a system whereby the emotions of the relatives decide on things.

Swipe left for the next trending thread