Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bring back capital punishment?

235 replies

LittleMaroonRidingHood · 01/10/2022 13:03

This thread was prompted by the news item about a possible discovery of the remains of a victim of the 'Moors Murderers'.

Should Capital Punishment be re-instated for murder ?

YABU - The value of the offender's life should not be negated by the offender's crime.
YANBU - When someone sets out with intent to deprive someone of their life, then they automatically forfeit the right to get any older.

OP posts:
No499 · 01/10/2022 14:46

I used to be pro-capital punishment until my DH was murdered. Whilst processing his death and navigating the court system I realized it's not black and white. It's taken a long time but I have chosen to forgive my DH killer. They now sit in prison on a life sentence.

FurAndFeathers · 01/10/2022 14:46

TortugaRumCakeQueen · 01/10/2022 13:13

Yes, we should bring it back. We are spending Billions keeping people alive, that can never be reintroduced into society and who have committed unforgivable crimes. They don't pay tax, they don't contribute anything and they are deadly dangerous. Why are we keeping them alive? What for?

You know that trying to properly administer death penalty cases costs significantly more right?

Discovereads · 01/10/2022 14:45

Never.
Too many innocents end up executed when there is a death penalty. Our history is littered with them.

anotherdayanotherpathlesstravelled · 01/10/2022 14:43

Absolutely support capital punishment for any crimes involving the rape and/or death of a child like all those child killers sentenced in the last year

In fact I'd quite happily press the button myself

Our prison system isn't enough of a deterrent and our sentencing laws are weak

Mommabear20 · 01/10/2022 14:38

Absolutely not!
I do strongly believe we need to make prison less comfy for those incarcerated (tv privileges etc) and make them work to pay their debt to society, but killing them, is less of a punishment for them, but does cause upset and trauma for yet another family. So imagine, 1 person murders 2 people, and is sent to prison, you have 2 grieving families, you kill that murderer, you have 3. How is that an improvement?

ReeDeeHee · 01/10/2022 14:32

PhillySub · 01/10/2022 14:26

Interesting subject. So if your baby/child is raped/abused you are happy for the offender just to be removed from the streets?

I don't think "Happy" would be the right word.
Of course it's all hypothetical, nobody can know (and I really hope nobody ever finds out) how they would react in that situation. I'd want to kill them, of course, but in my logical, hypothetical mind right now I'd understand that I'd then also be in prison and away from my child who needs me to support them.

AnneLovesGilbert · 01/10/2022 14:31

PhillySub · 01/10/2022 14:26

Interesting subject. So if your baby/child is raped/abused you are happy for the offender just to be removed from the streets?

I’d want to kill them myself.

That’s why grieving traumatised relatives don’t get to make laws or decide on punishments.

We decide what sort of society we want to live in. Murdering a murderer isn’t the mark of a civilised one.

Lonelycrab · 01/10/2022 14:31

No.

The people of this country don’t want it. But that, coupled with the fact America does it makes it quite likely the current govt will try and push for it.

roarfeckingroarr · 01/10/2022 14:28

Never

PhillySub · 01/10/2022 14:26

Interesting subject. So if your baby/child is raped/abused you are happy for the offender just to be removed from the streets?

SuperCamp · 01/10/2022 14:26

Executing people is not civilised.

If we execute murderers we are being reactionary and allowing our moral standards to be influenced by those whose moral standards are the very lowest. It demeans us.

Murderers kill, a civilised society does not.

ReeDeeHee · 01/10/2022 14:23

See, I don't understand why the murder of someone in the emergency services is more outrageous than any other murder, and why that would be more worthy of the DP than any other, if someone supports that.

OneTC · 01/10/2022 14:13

Death to the emergency services!?

Seems a bit much

hattie43 · 01/10/2022 14:11

Life should mean life and hard labour . Having said that for child murderers , emergency services and serial killers then I'd support the death penalty. Some people are too heinous to expect mercy or rehabilitation.

Crocky · 01/10/2022 14:08

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

MrsTumblebee · 01/10/2022 14:07

No. Because it’s barbaric.
No. Because one innocent person executed in error is one too many.
No. Because no one should live their life knowing a loved one is to be executed.

No. Because no one should ever see the day their loved one is to be executed.

tranquiltortoise · 01/10/2022 14:07

Ouchh · 01/10/2022 13:58

I think if an offender is 100% proven to have committed numerous horrific offences (i.e: rape, murder, torture, crimes involving children) and it isn't possible to rehabilitate them, then we should offer them the choice between execution and being banished to a prison colony. The prison colony would be a single-sex island and you'd work and live like you might anywhere else, just no internet or link to the outside world. Offenders would work, helping to make it a financially self-sustaining colony. That way they can live, and the only risk they'd pose is to each other, and they maybe wouldn't cost the taxpayer so much either

  1. How do you 100% prove it?
  2. At what point does it become 'numerous horrific offences' - two times? three? four? Who decides and what is 'horrific' enough?
  3. Once you have this in place how do you ensure you prevent a slippery slope whereby sometimes it is not 100% proven, in a few years' time, once we are used to the death penalty being a thing and standards start to slide (as inevitably happens)?
  4. If you're giving the option of 'prison colony' why do you also need execution to be in there - people would not choose it over this option.
  5. Why is it single sex? So we need two islands?
  6. Who is overseeing this (you say 'the only risk they pose is to each other' but presumably somebody is there to enforce some kind of order?)
  7. Where is this magical island going to be?

Sorry but I think this is a little flawed.

MrsSkylerWhite · 01/10/2022 14:05

No because one wrong guilty verdict is one too many.

OneTC · 01/10/2022 14:04

XSnoe · 01/10/2022 13:45

You think someone who tortures a child murderer is on the same level as the one who tortured/raped/killed an innocent child?

Yeah pretty much. I'd say it's indicative there's something seriously wrong with them

ReneBumsWombats · 01/10/2022 14:04

Vote should have just been a straight yes or no.

Anon778833 · 01/10/2022 14:04

Eeiliethya · 01/10/2022 13:51

No I don't think it should.

Admittedly though when seeing some recent cases of horrendous child abuse that results in death I would like to see the fuckers responsible die. And slow.

Its understandable to feel that way. I think most normal people do, but that doesn’t mean we’d be happy to torture people. Some of the replies here concern me 😬

HairyMothballs · 01/10/2022 14:04

YANBU

LadyKenya · 01/10/2022 14:03

HenBob · 01/10/2022 13:59

You need to do far more research on capital punishment. It's not a deterrent, it's more expensive, it's systemically racist, a large proportion of people on death row are found to be innocent of their crimes. Not the way forward, we aren't barbarians.

I agree.

Believeitornot · 01/10/2022 14:03

floorida · 01/10/2022 13:17

@Believeitornot where did I say there wouldn't be miscarriages of justice or that it's a deterrent?

I’m making the point that those are reasons for not having capital punishment. It’s a stupid idea @floorida

ThisIsNotAFlyingToy · 01/10/2022 14:00

Capital punishment still existed in the UK when Brady and Hindley were murdering. So the deterrent argument is bollocks.

And for every other reason, it's a no.