Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bring back capital punishment?

235 replies

LittleMaroonRidingHood · 01/10/2022 13:03

This thread was prompted by the news item about a possible discovery of the remains of a victim of the 'Moors Murderers'.

Should Capital Punishment be re-instated for murder ?

YABU - The value of the offender's life should not be negated by the offender's crime.
YANBU - When someone sets out with intent to deprive someone of their life, then they automatically forfeit the right to get any older.

OP posts:
Fifthtimelucky · 01/10/2022 15:38

No. And no torture either. I'm horrified that people would be suggesting that.

I think I would support any change that would allow criminals to opt for the death sentence in some circumstances - eg if they had been sentenced to life imprisonment and knew they had no realistic prospect of release.

RhannionKPSS · 01/10/2022 15:37

If the moors murderers had been hanged , then the body of Pauline Reade would not have been found so for that reason alone , it was better they were not hanged. At least Pauline’s family were finally able to give her a decent burial. Let’s hope that Keith’s family are able to do the same at last.

UnderCoverFieldAgent · 01/10/2022 15:34

Absolutely not. Even if only 1 person in 10k was executed incorrectly then that’s 1 person too many. For that reason only, that’s why we shouldn’t have the death penalty. I think that life without parole is under-used in this country though. To me, that would be a fate worse than death anyway.

Discovereads · 01/10/2022 15:34

RhannionKPSS · 01/10/2022 15:29

No it didn’t, it had been abolished just before they were caught. They would have been hanged if they had been on trial the year before.

The point was that the death penalty was in force for their crimes while they were committing them…ergo it did not deter them.

Incrediblebuttrue · 01/10/2022 15:31

No. Apart from the fact it's not a deterrent, every country that has it, will have at some time executed innocent people. I don't want to live somewhere where this is considered ok.

RhannionKPSS · 01/10/2022 15:29

ThisIsNotAFlyingToy · 01/10/2022 14:00

Capital punishment still existed in the UK when Brady and Hindley were murdering. So the deterrent argument is bollocks.

And for every other reason, it's a no.

No it didn’t, it had been abolished just before they were caught. They would have been hanged if they had been on trial the year before.

DamnUserName21 · 01/10/2022 15:26

I feel there are people around the world that commit (or sanction) so many atrocities that they do not deserve to live.
I wonder if Hitler would have been executed-I like to think so.
Saddam was.
On a smaller atrocity scale, yes, I'd be pro-death penalty providing the evidence was irrefutable and the death penalty sentence was not chosen by a jury (who are influenced by the media) but rather an impartial board of professionals. What a job! Can't see it happening though.

BeanieTeen · 01/10/2022 15:24

That so an interesting point. What sort of mind do you need to have to want a job killing people?

I think mostly weirdos for sure. But I think there would also be those who would take the job because they believe in it being done properly if it has to be done, in as dignified as possible a way.

BeanieTeen · 01/10/2022 15:22

I think there are definitely people who deserve to die for their crimes. But that does not mean I believe in capital punishment. The two don’t go hand in hand. There being power in the law and justice system to take someone’s life is too risky in my opinion. There’s always room for error - and just one person convicted and put to death unfairly is too many.

RubyJam · 01/10/2022 15:21

Discovereads · 01/10/2022 15:07

You realise that this would mean quite a few women being executed?

Yes I’m absolutely fine with females being executed.

There are female murderers that are equally if not worse than men , not sure why you even asked this to be honest ? Do you believe in women being exempt ?

SoupDragon · 01/10/2022 15:17

Are you planning to come back and comment on your own thread @LittleMaroonRidingHood ?

balalake · 01/10/2022 15:15

I think sometimes there would be jury members who would refuse to convict someone, if they thought they were sending them to their death. Just as much as innocent people being hung because of the wish to convict someone.

SoupDragon · 01/10/2022 15:15

The people who applied for that job would either have serious issues of their own to make them want to do that or they would be desperate, neither of which makes it an acceptable position for them to be in.

That so an interesting point. What sort of mind do you need to have to want a job killing people?

AuntSalli · 01/10/2022 15:15

The problem with the current prison system is it quite a lot of people have a better life in that and they would outside Shannon Matthews mother Springs immediately to mind she was given skills that she is able to now take out into society very good living with she was just a complete waste of space. Now you could say present is done its job it’s rehabilitated her.
But when a life sentence doesn’t mean life and when 16-year-olds can spend 10 years in prison receiving better nutrition access to teams access to education discipline in forced on them. Ava Whites killer springs to mind. I would imagine at some point he’s proud parents will be sat at his graduation what about AVA‘s parents ?
There needs to be a balance.

FriedasCarLoad · 01/10/2022 15:10

In principle I agree with the death penalty.

In practice I think that the risk of innocent people being killed and of it being applied unequally are too high, so I wouldn't vote for it.

Blanketpolicy · 01/10/2022 15:10

No, I would not want someones job to be killing another person against their will, regardless of what they have done. The people who applied for that job would either have serious issues of their own to make them want to do that or they would be desperate, neither of which makes it an acceptable position for them to be in.

AirFryerNinja · 01/10/2022 15:09

No, because that would put me on the same level as the murderer. Taking a life.
Personally I would lock them away in a small concrete cell with absolutely no access whatsoever to the outside world, including visits and letters.
Then they have the rest of their miserable lives to think about how they got there.
A bit like the max security prison in Colorado.

RosieRooster83 · 01/10/2022 15:07

I don't think it should be reinstated because no one has the right to take another persons life, no matter what they have done. They aren't really paying for their crime when they are dead.

Discovereads · 01/10/2022 15:07

RubyJam · 01/10/2022 15:05

I’d support capital punishment, especially for the depraved disgusting child killers recently , that have tortured and starved children.
In this day and age with DNA testing I think guilty verdicts would be more accurate than ever.

I hate to read about these child killers getting short sentences, life is very rarely life in this country , thats the problem.

You realise that this would mean quite a few women being executed?

RubyJam · 01/10/2022 15:05

I’d support capital punishment, especially for the depraved disgusting child killers recently , that have tortured and starved children.
In this day and age with DNA testing I think guilty verdicts would be more accurate than ever.

I hate to read about these child killers getting short sentences, life is very rarely life in this country , thats the problem.

Sparklesocks · 01/10/2022 15:02

No.
And you sometimes get cases where new evidence comes to light and someone is exonerated and released after being found guilty. As awful as it is that they’ve lost years of their life in a cell for a great injustice, it would be worse if they were put to death and the wrong could never be righted.

Discovereads · 01/10/2022 15:00

Ouchh · 01/10/2022 13:58

I think if an offender is 100% proven to have committed numerous horrific offences (i.e: rape, murder, torture, crimes involving children) and it isn't possible to rehabilitate them, then we should offer them the choice between execution and being banished to a prison colony. The prison colony would be a single-sex island and you'd work and live like you might anywhere else, just no internet or link to the outside world. Offenders would work, helping to make it a financially self-sustaining colony. That way they can live, and the only risk they'd pose is to each other, and they maybe wouldn't cost the taxpayer so much either

Oh yes, this worked put so well what with transporting criminals to the Americas, Australia and New Zealand. Fob off our problems on the unsuspecting populations of other countries. A penal colony is still colonialism….

clarepetal · 01/10/2022 15:00

Two wrongs don't make a right. And what if the wrong person was convicted?

FurAndFeathers · 01/10/2022 14:50

PhillySub · 01/10/2022 14:26

Interesting subject. So if your baby/child is raped/abused you are happy for the offender just to be removed from the streets?

So your premise is that the justice system is there to make victim’s families ‘happy’?

that isn’t what it’s there for, and I’m not entirely sure that being happy after such awful experiences as you describe is an achievable goal.

the justice system is there to safeguard the public and ensure correct application of the law.

it’s not a ‘revenge system’ or an ‘emotional support system’ or a ‘retribution system’

ThisIsNotThePostYourLookingFor · 01/10/2022 14:49

I would re-instate capital punishment if it was beyond doubt the person was guilty.

too many people take the life’s of others then themselves go on to live happy normal lives after a few years in jail.