Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bring back capital punishment?

235 replies

LittleMaroonRidingHood · 01/10/2022 13:03

This thread was prompted by the news item about a possible discovery of the remains of a victim of the 'Moors Murderers'.

Should Capital Punishment be re-instated for murder ?

YABU - The value of the offender's life should not be negated by the offender's crime.
YANBU - When someone sets out with intent to deprive someone of their life, then they automatically forfeit the right to get any older.

OP posts:
MotherofPearl · 01/10/2022 16:48

Very strongly opposed to capital punishment here.

Figgygal · 01/10/2022 16:48

Despite the costs involved in long term incarceration there is no place for the death penalty in a civilised society

Discovereads · 01/10/2022 16:46

DaphneSprucesPippasClack · 01/10/2022 16:45

There are corrupt police. As long as they are focused on solving crime numbers, the wrong people can and will be punished. For that reason alone. No. Never.

Make them live. But also some criminals deserve treatment and the chance to be better human beings. But they won't get that in our prison systems.

While corruption is a factor, there is also plain old human error.

DaphneSprucesPippasClack · 01/10/2022 16:45

Also, it's wrong and it doesn't work as a deterrent.

DaphneSprucesPippasClack · 01/10/2022 16:45

There are corrupt police. As long as they are focused on solving crime numbers, the wrong people can and will be punished. For that reason alone. No. Never.

Make them live. But also some criminals deserve treatment and the chance to be better human beings. But they won't get that in our prison systems.

girlfriend44 · 01/10/2022 16:45

TortugaRumCakeQueen · 01/10/2022 13:13

Yes, we should bring it back. We are spending Billions keeping people alive, that can never be reintroduced into society and who have committed unforgivable crimes. They don't pay tax, they don't contribute anything and they are deadly dangerous. Why are we keeping them alive? What for?

This, its a lot of money to keep them locked up they are a drain on society.
Money spent better elsewhere.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 01/10/2022 16:40

ThisIsNotThePostYourLookingFor · 01/10/2022 14:49

I would re-instate capital punishment if it was beyond doubt the person was guilty.

too many people take the life’s of others then themselves go on to live happy normal lives after a few years in jail.

You cite the cases of rehabilitation working as intended as your argument that rehabilitation doesn't work. A bold approach, but perfectly in keeping with the usual paucity of thinking that goes hand-in-hand with advocating capital punishment.

Tiny2018 · 01/10/2022 16:31

I heavily researched capital punishment during my degree years, and am most definitely against it. Ths concept is not only hypocritical by nature, but retributionist.

Albert Pierrepoont himself wrote in his memoirs that he did not believe it to be an effective deterrent. Considering the sheer amount of people he hanged as Britains most prolific executioner, I think we should leave it well alone. As an above poster commented, emotion should stay out of law.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 01/10/2022 16:21

Anyone who’s looked at this in any detail, and with any seriousness, thinks capital punishment is a bad idea.

Anyone else either hasn’t given it full consideration, or is a fool.

Vegay · 01/10/2022 16:15

When I think about this topic, I can't help thinking about it in a totally emotional way. Do I want these people who murder children, or anyone for that matter (in cold blood), to suffer? Yes. Would I want someone who killed one of my loved ones to die in the most horrific way? Absolutely!

There can't be emotion in law though. For this reason and the fact that innocent people have been convicted and killed, I oppose the death penalty. I do think a life sentence should mean for the rest of their life though.

MrsSchrute · 01/10/2022 16:15

Have you read Justice on Trial by Chris Daw KC?

He argues that, in order to make society safer and reduce recidivism, our prison system should be made more like Norway's. The focus there is that the vast majority of prisoners will be released one day, so their time in prison should be spent preparing them for that day. They say that that prisoner could one day be your neighbour.
Their philosophy is that being denied freedom of movement and choice but being imprisoned IS the punishment, and then environment in prison should be as much like normal life as possible.
Actually, he goes much further than that! But you get the idea. And it works.
There's a really good documentary on Netflix where a Norwegian prison warden goes to visit an American prison and visa versa - well worth a watch!

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 01/10/2022 16:05

No I am really against it. It doesn’t bring the murdered person back, it’s been shown not to act as a deterrent and there is a very real risk that an innocent person could end up being put to death by the state. Our current government seem right wing at the moment so I wouldn’t be at all surprised if this is something they try to reintroduce.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 01/10/2022 16:04

Albert Pierrepoint, the last hangman, wrote an autobiography, in which he said that he didn’t believe that the threat of the death penalty had prevented even one murder, ever.

Flapjacker48 · 01/10/2022 16:02

Also the people commenting they want prisons to be more like brutal concentrations camps, even ignoring the ethical issues, to run such as system would be hugely expensive in terms of staffing, have major issues of staff safety (which is a big enough issue now in prisons) and the sort of people attracted to work in such as system are exactly those who shouldn't be.

Textboxmm · 01/10/2022 16:00

Trying to stop people from murdering by committing murder is fucked up.
and it is used disproportionately against people of colour.
we’re better than that.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 01/10/2022 15:58

AnneLovesGilbert · 01/10/2022 14:31

I’d want to kill them myself.

That’s why grieving traumatised relatives don’t get to make laws or decide on punishments.

We decide what sort of society we want to live in. Murdering a murderer isn’t the mark of a civilised one.

Exactly.
There was an interesting case a while back. A guy randomly killed a couple of kids. The red-top newspapers launched into their usual 'bring back hanging' frenzy, a large part of which was the standard 'if it was your kid, you'd want the guy to swing' angle. And of course, as they always do, they tried to get the family to say as much, so that they could trumpet that the child's mum demands that we "string 'em up." Because, who's going to suggest that the victims' family don't have a really decisive say in this?

And then the family issued a statement saying that they were completely against capital punishment, and that they felt that, in the terms of their faith, they should seek to forgive.

There was a short stunned silence from the papers - and then they started to run articles suggesting that the family were unhinged by grief, they were religious nutcases, and no one should pay any attention to them, poor things.

Discovereads · 01/10/2022 15:58

VioletInsolence · 01/10/2022 15:52

Psychopathy isn’t a mental illness.

But it is a mental disorder.

CulturePigeon · 01/10/2022 15:56

I'm not a softie - I believe in consequences, but I am against capital punishment because:

There have been many recorded miscarriages of justice (Timothy Evans etc) and you can't bring people back from the dead. Still awful to serve a long sentence if you're innocent, but at least you can be freed and compensated financially.

Capital punishment makes us all killers, and I don't want to be one.

And less nobly...frankly, hanging IS too good for some people. I want them to sit in prison for a long time and think about what they've done. I would like Fred West to be sitting there, but he took the easy way out.

Also, I imagine that the police and psychologists would value the opportunity to question serious offenders further. I realise that psychopaths like Brady can find gratification in withholding information, but while they are alive it's always possible that more information might be obtained, or other murders they've committed may be able to be assigned to them (eg Levi Bellfield) and more bereaved families obtain some kind of peace.

Flapjacker48 · 01/10/2022 15:54

@PhillySub No, which is why the victims/families of victims don't decide punishments for offenders. The judge when sentencing will always consider victim impact statements as PART of his/her decision.

VioletInsolence · 01/10/2022 15:52

Isaidnoalready · 01/10/2022 13:27

How could we guarantee they were guilty?

What about the mentally ill?

Surely you need to be mentally ill to kill someone?

Ethically speaking is it ever right to kill a mentally ill person?

Psychopathy isn’t a mental illness.

Flapjacker48 · 01/10/2022 15:48

The only people who want the death penalty are uneducated idiots who think papers like the Daily Mail "tell it like it is" and that Priti Patel should be PM.

Flapjacker48 · 01/10/2022 15:44

No, don't be ridiculous.

Discovereads · 01/10/2022 15:41

RubyJam · 01/10/2022 15:21

Yes I’m absolutely fine with females being executed.

There are female murderers that are equally if not worse than men , not sure why you even asked this to be honest ? Do you believe in women being exempt ?

Just curious, as I do know some women who think when men murder children, they’re always evil but when women murder children they were always made to do it by a mental illness. As in always. No exceptions.

JOFFCV · 01/10/2022 15:41

RubyJam · 01/10/2022 15:21

Yes I’m absolutely fine with females being executed.

There are female murderers that are equally if not worse than men , not sure why you even asked this to be honest ? Do you believe in women being exempt ?

I didn't understand that comment either.

If I saw someone kill or abuse my child I would kill that person if I could.

Discovereads · 01/10/2022 15:40

BeanieTeen · 01/10/2022 15:24

That so an interesting point. What sort of mind do you need to have to want a job killing people?

I think mostly weirdos for sure. But I think there would also be those who would take the job because they believe in it being done properly if it has to be done, in as dignified as possible a way.

I read the biography of a professional hangman family. Three generations. And in it, it was clear they prided themselves on using the weight and height of the convict to calculate the exact length of rope and drop needed to deliver an instant painless death by breaking the neck. They’d also adjust this based on the actual piece of rope because back then the ropes were hemp which is a natural fibre and so every rope of of a slightly different thickness and had different tensile properties. They also recorded how to treat the prisoner during the execution. Using gentle tones of voice, body language. Having a hanky so they can wipe tears, give them moments to compose themselves.

Not all hangmen were like this though, there were many that were utter cold hearted hacks and many prisoners died very hard deaths with them in charge.