Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bring back capital punishment?

235 replies

LittleMaroonRidingHood · 01/10/2022 13:03

This thread was prompted by the news item about a possible discovery of the remains of a victim of the 'Moors Murderers'.

Should Capital Punishment be re-instated for murder ?

YABU - The value of the offender's life should not be negated by the offender's crime.
YANBU - When someone sets out with intent to deprive someone of their life, then they automatically forfeit the right to get any older.

OP posts:
MsReid · 01/10/2022 18:04

No, because what if an innocent person was killed. I don’t think we have any right to take someone else’s life, regardless of what they’ve done.

WagathaChristieMystery · 01/10/2022 18:02

No! What about when there’s a miscarriage of justice, so an innocent person is convicted then killed?

I understand people’s strength of feeling for bringing back capital punishment, but I absolutely don’t agree with it.

I also think using capital punishment as a punishment makes us (the state) no better morally than the criminal receiving it, because we’re essentially giving them the same treatment as they dealt to their victim.

DorothyBinns · 01/10/2022 17:55

How can people opposed to the death penalty be forced to serve on juries where the death penalty was a realistic prospect following conviction? They couldn’t- you’d have murderers released simply because the jury would not convict. I would certainly not convict anyone myself, if I were on the jury.

The alternative would be to allow people to opt out of being on the jury for those trials, and that wouldn’t work either because we would then have juries composed of only those who are pro death penalty who are more right wing and more likely to convict, which means the conviction wouldn’t be safe. Having a self-selecting jury also undermines the point of a jury in the first place. So either unsafe convictions and innocent people executed, or an appeal straight away, with exactly the same problem the second time around.

You could have a panel of judges, but the problem remains - many wouldn’t do it, and the ones who would aren’t infallible.

gnilliwdog · 01/10/2022 17:44

Discovereads · 01/10/2022 15:00

Oh yes, this worked put so well what with transporting criminals to the Americas, Australia and New Zealand. Fob off our problems on the unsuspecting populations of other countries. A penal colony is still colonialism….

Are there any uninhabited islands north of Scotland? We would have to secure it and tag prisoners. But we could leave them there with some equipment to attempt self sufficiency and keep it under remote surveillance. I don't think they would need guards or any kind of services, perhaps just a basic supplies delivery every 6 months. It would need to be single sex because obviously you don't want children there. I don't know if any medical care would be needed either, though possibly they could set up their own hospital if they have some doctors amongst them. Leave them to it in exile basically.

ghostyslovesheets · 01/10/2022 17:44

I can't say I feel any remorse when you hear about certain criminals being raped in prison

that's some fucking paradox right there - rapists should all die - except the ones who rape people I don;t like - then they are heros!

junipermarten · 01/10/2022 17:40

Absolutely not.

I have never and never will agree with the death penalty.

How the fuck can you punish someone for taking a life by doing the same thing to them?! It's all manners of fucked up. NO human should make that decision for another human.

They should lose their freedom and have to live with that because of what they've done, not have it snuffed out for it all to be over. I'm an atheist so don't subscribe to them paying for it once they die.

jeffbezoz · 01/10/2022 17:32

No. What does that say about the society we live in? Are we that desensitised to violence that we'd be ok with that? I think we have been desensitised due to violence in TV and film..

Crankley · 01/10/2022 17:32

No, it's abhorrent and has no place in a civilised country.

Suetwo · 01/10/2022 17:29

No. But life should 100% mean life. You die in prison. People like Hindley should be kept in minimal comfort - just the basics to keep them alive. And if such a person wants to end their own life, because they can't see the point of going on, we should provide them with the pills to do so.

Snugglemonkey · 01/10/2022 17:26

XSnoe · 01/10/2022 13:45

You think someone who tortures a child murderer is on the same level as the one who tortured/raped/killed an innocent child?

Absolutely. It doesn't matter who the victim is, the torture is a heinous crime either way.

Snugglemonkey · 01/10/2022 17:24

Melodiax · 01/10/2022 13:28

I simply made the point that some sentences are a joke & it's naive to think all murderers will "suffer"

You replied to me saying "death is the easy way out". You realise when I was talking about suffering, I was talking about torture? Not prison sentences. I can't say I feel any remorse when you hear about certain criminals being raped in prison.

You have the same attitude toward your fellow humans as the perpetrators!

anderosonnmj · 01/10/2022 17:23

Didn't the moores murders take place before capital punishment was abolished? Or thereabouts? If so, it wasn't much of a deterrent.

SoupDragon · 01/10/2022 17:19

LittleMaroonRidingHood · 01/10/2022 16:52

@SoupDragon
Are you planning to come back and comment on your own thread @LittleMaroonRidingHood

No.

nice.

VladmirsPoutine · 01/10/2022 17:15

No. The type of people who are in full support of it almost always know their 'type' wouldn't be at risk of any systemic failures. Similarly to how I'm thankful our police force aren't routinely armed - because I know the odds of me or my relatives being shot for merely looking suspicious would go through the roof. And in anycase death is the easy way out.

girlfriend44 · 01/10/2022 17:13

Quveas · 01/10/2022 16:55

I won't vote because neither of your statements are correct. It is not about whether one persons life is worth more than another persons. The death sentence deters nobody; and the majority of murders are committed either by people who are ill, or in the heat of stupidity / anger - very few are planned and thought out or intentional. If they were, there wouldn't be as many murders.

For those who ask why we keep them alive, we do so because (a) we are a civilised country (supposedly, although I do sometimes wonder about that), (b) if killing people is wrong then it is as wrong for us to do it in the name of justice as it was for them to kill, and (c) because we still get things wrong and it is bloody hard to raise someone from the dead or say sorry when justice screws up and convicts the wrong person - if you execute even one wrong person that is one too many.

Dna has come om along way and there are cameras everywhere.
The trouble about not putting ppl to death is that the problem arises when they want to come out. There's appeals etc and nobody knows what to do.
Some people are let out and commit crime again which shows how badly scummy some people are. They don't fear prison.
Parole boards get in in the neck etc, people out outraged.
At least if your not going to hang people then keep them inside forever.
Then there's no appeals and no worries anymore.
Nowadays it's not uncommon for people to only serve 12 years for murder. It's a pisstake.

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 01/10/2022 17:07

Give the state the power to decide if you live or die? Not a chance.

LetHimHaveIt · 01/10/2022 17:05

Kiszko

Sirius3030 · 01/10/2022 17:05

Ihatethenewlook · 01/10/2022 13:09

Same. I’d be pretty happy to do some torturing.

You would actually be happy to torture someone?

You are sick.

Discovereads · 01/10/2022 17:01

Quveas · 01/10/2022 16:57

And prejudice!

Yes. Too many ways to end up convicting an innocent.

Quveas · 01/10/2022 16:57

Discovereads · 01/10/2022 16:46

While corruption is a factor, there is also plain old human error.

And prejudice!

LetHimHaveIt · 01/10/2022 16:57

The case of Stefan Kisxko is the single most compelling reason for never bringing back the death penalty. But it's really only drivelling idiots who clamour for the death penalty, anyway.

Quveas · 01/10/2022 16:55

I won't vote because neither of your statements are correct. It is not about whether one persons life is worth more than another persons. The death sentence deters nobody; and the majority of murders are committed either by people who are ill, or in the heat of stupidity / anger - very few are planned and thought out or intentional. If they were, there wouldn't be as many murders.

For those who ask why we keep them alive, we do so because (a) we are a civilised country (supposedly, although I do sometimes wonder about that), (b) if killing people is wrong then it is as wrong for us to do it in the name of justice as it was for them to kill, and (c) because we still get things wrong and it is bloody hard to raise someone from the dead or say sorry when justice screws up and convicts the wrong person - if you execute even one wrong person that is one too many.

Cherrysherbet · 01/10/2022 16:55

Too many mistakes are made in our justice system.
I wouldn’t want to live in that type of society.

Two wrongs don’t make a right.

LittleMaroonRidingHood · 01/10/2022 16:52

@SoupDragon
Are you planning to come back and comment on your own thread @LittleMaroonRidingHood

No.

OP posts:
ghostyslovesheets · 01/10/2022 16:51

I hate the hyperbole around 'what if YOUR child was raped' - I was that child - knowing my abuser would be killed if I spoke up would have silenced me forever - I couldn't have lived with that - and I was the 'victim' not my parents.

If you know the penalty for rape is death by the way - why would you risk leaving a witness? So murder would likely increase.

No one has the right to kill another human being - including the state

aside from that - it doesn't bloody work - look at countries that have the death penalty - are you suggesting they have no violent crime?

and it's cost MORE than locking someone up for life.

Agree about the Norwegian model btw