Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bring back capital punishment?

235 replies

LittleMaroonRidingHood · 01/10/2022 13:03

This thread was prompted by the news item about a possible discovery of the remains of a victim of the 'Moors Murderers'.

Should Capital Punishment be re-instated for murder ?

YABU - The value of the offender's life should not be negated by the offender's crime.
YANBU - When someone sets out with intent to deprive someone of their life, then they automatically forfeit the right to get any older.

OP posts:
Raquelos · 01/10/2022 21:10

Well I suppose it depends on how much faith you have in the system to find the right people guilty every time.

So that's a hard no from me on that basis

LetMeSpeak · 01/10/2022 21:09

Is DNA and other evidence being used is so useful then surely we wouldn’t even have trials. We also know that it wouldn’t be fairly implemented.

Redlighting · 01/10/2022 21:07

No, I don't think anyone ever has the 'right' to take a life. I would definitely like to see more 'whole life tariffs' for utterly horrific crimes like this one. I think it's a worse punishment, knowing you'll spend the rest of your days in a prison.

LimpBiskit · 01/10/2022 21:04

No for several reasons including it is pure retribution, doesn't allow for rehabilitation, judgements are sometimes wrong........

LetMeSpeak · 01/10/2022 21:04

How would it be done? Do you know how expensive capital punishment actually is these days? Just let them rot in confinement.

ghostyslovesheets · 01/10/2022 21:01

DNA and CCTV don't prove guilt though!

Anon778833 · 01/10/2022 20:59

eastegg · 01/10/2022 20:37

Timothy Evans.

Derek Bentley.

Stefan Kiszko.

The first 2 are examples of people who were executed and by the state’s own admission definitely should not have been. The 3rd is an example, of which there are loads, of someone wrongfully convicted for a murder which was later proved to have been committed by someone else, where they served a very long time before their successful appeal due to new evidence or suchlike. In other words, they would have been wrongfully executed in the meantime.

What happened to Derek Bentley is heartbreaking. He had a mental age of 11. And the murder of a police officer was pinned on him because the one who pulled the trigger was too young for the death penalty. Absolutely sick.

girlfriend44 · 01/10/2022 20:56

eastegg · 01/10/2022 20:37

Timothy Evans.

Derek Bentley.

Stefan Kiszko.

The first 2 are examples of people who were executed and by the state’s own admission definitely should not have been. The 3rd is an example, of which there are loads, of someone wrongfully convicted for a murder which was later proved to have been committed by someone else, where they served a very long time before their successful appeal due to new evidence or suchlike. In other words, they would have been wrongfully executed in the meantime.

Dna has improved since then.
Everywhere has cameras now.

Anon778833 · 01/10/2022 20:56

eastegg · 01/10/2022 20:47

These are excellent points, and remind us of one of the reasons abolition came about. Juries were reluctant to convict, which of course brings about terrible injustice in itself.

Yes. I imagine that’s why Casey Anthony walked free.

bloodyplanes · 01/10/2022 20:55

Melodiax · 01/10/2022 13:05

Honestly I wouldn't give a fuck if some people were tortured, if they've definitely commited the crime, such as raping children. Yeah, were better than that, but I would still love to see child abusers suffer.

Me to! I honestly couldn't care less what happens to them, imo they forfeited any human rights they have when they took away those of another human being 🤷‍♀️

eastegg · 01/10/2022 20:47

DorothyBinns · 01/10/2022 17:55

How can people opposed to the death penalty be forced to serve on juries where the death penalty was a realistic prospect following conviction? They couldn’t- you’d have murderers released simply because the jury would not convict. I would certainly not convict anyone myself, if I were on the jury.

The alternative would be to allow people to opt out of being on the jury for those trials, and that wouldn’t work either because we would then have juries composed of only those who are pro death penalty who are more right wing and more likely to convict, which means the conviction wouldn’t be safe. Having a self-selecting jury also undermines the point of a jury in the first place. So either unsafe convictions and innocent people executed, or an appeal straight away, with exactly the same problem the second time around.

You could have a panel of judges, but the problem remains - many wouldn’t do it, and the ones who would aren’t infallible.

These are excellent points, and remind us of one of the reasons abolition came about. Juries were reluctant to convict, which of course brings about terrible injustice in itself.

eastegg · 01/10/2022 20:37

Timothy Evans.

Derek Bentley.

Stefan Kiszko.

The first 2 are examples of people who were executed and by the state’s own admission definitely should not have been. The 3rd is an example, of which there are loads, of someone wrongfully convicted for a murder which was later proved to have been committed by someone else, where they served a very long time before their successful appeal due to new evidence or suchlike. In other words, they would have been wrongfully executed in the meantime.

gatehouseoffleet · 01/10/2022 20:10

No, you can't do it for all the reasons given on this thread.

I do wish the law hadn't changed before the Moors Murderers though. There are some crimes which are so heinous that you would want the perpetrators to swing and they really should have done. Also Robert Black. And of course Wayne Couzens.

Sentencing law needs a massive overhaul. Non-violent criminals need to be kept out of prison except in a few cases where a short sentence needs to be used to send a message, eg contempt of court. But violent criminals (including arsonists and causing death by dangerous driving) need to stay locked up for longer so they can't endanger people again.

XenoBitch · 01/10/2022 20:10

No. Even now, people get wrongly convicted. Even if all the evidence was watertight, murdering someone in the name of justice is nothing but some sort of revenge.

BoxcarMilly · 01/10/2022 20:02

@WrinklesShminkles"My inkling that you're Liz Truss looking for electorate-distractors is looking stronger"

😜

Arbesque · 01/10/2022 20:02

Taking a life is wrong. And innocent people wrong convicted will end up bring killed. What use is a post humous pardon?

I do think sentences should be much much longer for some crimes and repeated rapes or murders should mean permanent removal from society.

WrinklesShminkles · 01/10/2022 19:59

LittleMaroonRidingHood · 01/10/2022 16:52

@SoupDragon
Are you planning to come back and comment on your own thread @LittleMaroonRidingHood

No.

My inkling that you're Liz Truss looking for electorate-distractors is looking stronger.

Lauram82 · 01/10/2022 19:33

Surely we’ve evolved from this idea? Too many innocent people murdered by the state because ‘we got it wrong’, no growth of mindset from the public (an eye for an eye-seriously biblical!). Current sentences seriously need an overhaul but nope we should never go back to capital punishment.

AutumnCrow · 01/10/2022 19:24

I'm not voting on your 'poll' because just one of the reasons I'm against capital punishment is the proven possibility of false convictions for murder on what would be capital crimes.

babybythesea · 01/10/2022 19:23

Kumri · 01/10/2022 13:39

I’d love to see capital punishment for rapists, ir people liek that guy who kicked his girlfriend in the stomach until she lost their baby because he didn’t want to pay child support, but the problem is that when we had capital punishment, it was also used against innocent people who’d been found guilty by a flawed process eg racist police just arresting the newrest black man. You can’t apologise and free someone after they’ve been executed.

There are also women in prison right now for ‘murder’ of their physically abusive husbands, who the women killed to protect their children. I think those women are heroines, but a legal system with capital punishment would have executed them.

I’m sorry if this has been said and I’ve missed it but…

One possible outcome of the death penalty for rape is that rather than rape someone and let them go, a rapist actually becomes more likely to murder and try to hide the body. Because if you get caught then you are going to die either way, so what’s the best way to avoid this? Don’t get caught - dispose of the evidence. I’m sure I read somewhere (no idea where but I’m sure I haven’t invented this theory) that where you have the death penalty it doesn’t stop a predator raping. What it does do is mean his victim is less likely to escape with her life.

EfficientDynamics · 01/10/2022 19:19

No, just give them a "life" sentence and then let them out in a few years for good behaviour so they can commit more crimes

FindingMeno · 01/10/2022 19:05

I would be fine with reintroducing the death penalty.

ArcaneWireless · 01/10/2022 18:58

It is barbaric. But then so is killing someone who has done nothing more than walk home after a night out. And a crime to me that was horrific and yet wasn’t screamed about countrywide.

Very recently, in a sleepy place not far away from me, a woman chose to walk home. And the only horror that we know for sure (although you can guess the motive) is that to cover up his crime, he set her on fire.

I pray she was already dead but the answer to that is yet to be told.

The accused is young and will no doubt be released while he has still more than half his life ahead of him.

That to me is abhorrent.

If a life sentence is passed then it should absolutely mean life. People who commit crimes like this have no place in society.

GlassDeli · 01/10/2022 18:46

Systematically killing people is going to make everyone's hearts harder. That isn't a good thing.

GlassDeli · 01/10/2022 18:43

No. We should not stoop to that level. That isn't the sort of people or country we're supposed to be. And it's barbaric.