Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bring back capital punishment?

235 replies

LittleMaroonRidingHood · 01/10/2022 13:03

This thread was prompted by the news item about a possible discovery of the remains of a victim of the 'Moors Murderers'.

Should Capital Punishment be re-instated for murder ?

YABU - The value of the offender's life should not be negated by the offender's crime.
YANBU - When someone sets out with intent to deprive someone of their life, then they automatically forfeit the right to get any older.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ReneBumsWombats · 02/10/2022 16:22

SomeSquirrelsAreBlack · 02/10/2022 15:10

I entirely disagree with the death penalty, as it is cruel an irreversible, however public humiliation for fly tippers and shop lifters, certainly.

Maybe bring back the stocks, though obviously no throwing of rotten fruit. Also bring back penal treadmill in prisons for violent offenders.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penal_treadmill

If all that happened to you in the stocks was being hit with tomatoes, you were very lucky indeed.

SomeSquirrelsAreBlack · 02/10/2022 15:13

Victims could pop up to the prison and watch whilst their mobile phones are being charged by "prisoner power".

SomeSquirrelsAreBlack · 02/10/2022 15:10

I entirely disagree with the death penalty, as it is cruel an irreversible, however public humiliation for fly tippers and shop lifters, certainly.

Maybe bring back the stocks, though obviously no throwing of rotten fruit. Also bring back penal treadmill in prisons for violent offenders.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penal_treadmill

CentaureaCyanus · 02/10/2022 14:38

I don’t support the death penalty. It has no place in a civilised society.

This expresses my view exactly. YABU.

CoralBells · 02/10/2022 14:24

No. Think of all the wrongful convictions.
www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/uk/2009/mar/18/miscarriages-justice-history

girlfriend44 · 02/10/2022 14:19

bloodyplanes · 01/10/2022 20:55

Me to! I honestly couldn't care less what happens to them, imo they forfeited any human rights they have when they took away those of another human being 🤷‍♀️

Me neither but sadly they are allowed to claim compensation if they get attacked.
Incase anyone dosent know Ian Huntley claimed money for this.

It's crazy, what does he expect when he did what he did, that people are going to be falling over him wanting to be his friend.
Waste of oxygen.

RueValens · 02/10/2022 14:10

There was a man who ruined my family and made our lives hell for years. As a child, I used to fantasise about how I would torture him, if I could. So while emotionally, I feel like some people certaintly deserve all the pain and suffering, and I genuinely do think I could really hurt some people and enjoy seeing their pain, I think it's a good thing we don't allow it. Prison doesn't punish strongly enough though. I don't think the goal should be rehabilitation for many people.

LakieLady · 02/10/2022 09:44

AlsoknownasOther · 01/10/2022 13:09

Sorry we executed you and then discovered you were innocent.

This.

It's bad enough that some people spend years in prison after being wrongfully convicted, but at least they get released and some financial compensation. Imagine if the Birmingham 6 etc had been executed?

And killing people is just wrong, unless it's in self-defence, so the state shouldn't be doing it.

waterlego · 02/10/2022 09:39

It’s always really unsettling in these discussions to see the relish with which a few individuals talk about how much they would enjoy torturing certain criminals.

I think there’s a difference between not caring very much how those criminals get treated once they’re in prison and actively wanting to torture them yourself. If you’re capable of torturing someone, there is something wrong with you, no matter what your motives are, or how despicable your victim is.

No to the death penalty for all the reasons already discussed. Completely archaic and pointless.

Puppers · 02/10/2022 00:55

I don’t support the death penalty. It has no place in a civilised society.

This isn’t because I give a single fuck about child rapists and murderers. It’s not because I think they deserve better or can be rehabilitated. It’s for a multitude of reasons such as:

No state should have the power to end a human life in this context.

Wrongful convictions happen.

In some cases it endangers victims (I.e. punishing rape with execution incentivises rapists to kill their victims in order to eliminate the key witness, since they have already crossed the capital punishment threshold).

It sends the message to citizens that life is cheap.

I would rather see a radical overhaul of the justice system. There are thousands of people in prison who don’t belong there. Almost all non-violent criminals could be dealt with by alternative means. This would free up resources to actually meaningfully attempt to rehabilitate those who can be rehabilitated and to hand down whole-of-life tariffs to all of those who deserve them, which should be absolutely every child killer, and probably most murderers. I’d welcome whole life tariffs for child rapists if it could be proven that this did not increase the murder rate.

Laughingravy · 02/10/2022 00:32

In theory I don't have a problem with the state taking the life of a murderer in certain circumstances. But where do you draw that line? Of that I'm not sure. It would perhaps help if we had the US system with degrees of murder and manslaughter?

But in practice there are cases where innocent citizens are gaoled and it's no deterrent. So on balance it's a no but I don't see it as barbaric if it is instant and painless. As for a PP thinking that executing the perpetrator would be upsetting for the victims family I simply don't see that at all.

I do wonder how it costs less to keep a Rose West or Ian Huntley incarcerated for decades than execute them. Is it that there can be any number of costly appeals that drag the process out? In the US it does seem cruel to have someone on death row for years and years before executing them. Not to mention in some states they will treat mental illness to a point where they can carry out the death sentence.

More generally I don't go all DM usually but I have no problem with building more gaols - though the spending should to be matched by funding programmes to help prisoners rehabilitate. There's a small percentage of the population who are persistently criminal and I don't have a problem having a cell for each and everyone. You only need to watch a few fly on the wall cop programmes to see when it comes to justice our system isn't working.

ddl1 · 02/10/2022 00:00

No. It turns all citizens into murderers by proxy; there is too much risk of convicting the innocent; and it does not even act as an effective deterrent, especially not for the terrorists and psychopaths who would most seem to deserve it. Also, it could increase murderers' motivation to kill potential witnesses as well as the original victims.

AffIt · 01/10/2022 23:26

Absolutely not.

Murder of any kind is wrong, but state-sanctioned murder is the worst of the lot.

eastegg · 01/10/2022 23:23

girlfriend44 · 01/10/2022 20:56

Dna has improved since then.
Everywhere has cameras now.

And in 50 years time or so people may look back and say ‘of course things are better now, we don’t make the same mistakes we made in 2022’. The whole point of mistakes is you don’t know you’re making them. You think all convictions are watertight because of DNA and cameras? Good grief, have a think.

Porcupineintherough · 01/10/2022 23:17

Melodiax · 01/10/2022 13:05

Honestly I wouldn't give a fuck if some people were tortured, if they've definitely commited the crime, such as raping children. Yeah, were better than that, but I would still love to see child abusers suffer.

Im pretty sure if you torture them enough, people will confess to pretty much anything. Be great for the clear up rate, for sure.

Vegay · 01/10/2022 23:01

@KrisAkabusi don't be so obtuse and dramatic. The vast majority of individuals on this thread, including myself, are against the death penalty. Going by votes, around 130 people are in favour and 520 aren't. It is a very emotive topic. Some of those people voting in favour may have been subjected to, or loved someone that was subjected to the most heinous of crimes - it doesn't make them a sociopath. It makes them human. Whilst I oppose it, I can understand why people, especially those who have experienced things I can't even begin to understand, may be in favour of it.

Fml1980 · 01/10/2022 22:33

Nope definitely not, like the saying goes an eye for an eye and the world turns blind.

Look up George Stinney its a really sad case, and why the death sentence never should happen.

I do think some prisoners are given to much of an easy life though and jail as it formally Is isn't really isn't a deterrent

StoneofDestiny · 01/10/2022 22:25

Absolutely not, it's barbaric. Capital Punishment is not a deterrent, indeed it's likely to bring about more deaths as criminals kill arresting officers and witnesses. Even DNA hasn't given us absolute certainty over guilt, and mistaken prosecutions remain a risk.
Imprisonment without parole is a huge punishment - some with such sentences take their own lives rather than serve that time e.g. Harold Shipman, Fred West.

LetHimHaveIt · 01/10/2022 22:22

Oh God. Here comes the 'But DNA!' lot.

It's absolutely not infallible and is of limited utility given that murders are seldom committed by strangers.

There was no DNA testing when Kiszko was convicted of Lesley Molseed's murder. But it was possible at that time to have a fifteen second glance under a microscope and determine that he was sterile and therefore not her rapist and therefore not her murderer. But no fucker bothered to do that.

ReeDeeHee · 01/10/2022 22:22

There are some interesting stats here:
innocenceproject.org/dna-exonerations-in-the-united-states/

KrisAkabusi · 01/10/2022 22:11

I don't know if this thread has brought all the sociopaths out, or whether a lot of Mumsnet members are sociopathic. But it's really depressing how many people on here are in favour of torture and murder.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 01/10/2022 22:03

girlfriend44 · 01/10/2022 21:50

They can do.

Even DNA is not infallible. Nobody knows how common chimerism is. Some individuals have more than one DNA profile depending which organs are involved. Women can retain small amounts of male DNA from having sons.
DNA Chimera

Pilipalapal · 01/10/2022 21:57

I am absolutely sympathetic to the emotional reaction where you want those who have committed heinous crimes to be killed or tortured. I sometimes feel it myself.

But, for all the reasons previously given by PPs, capital punishment is unacceptable and has no place in this day and age.

girlfriend44 · 01/10/2022 21:50

ghostyslovesheets · 01/10/2022 21:01

DNA and CCTV don't prove guilt though!

They can do.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 01/10/2022 21:33

Apart from the unacceptable risk of a miscarriage of justice, the abolition of the death penalty is a statement about the society we want to be.
I don't want to live in a society that has barely moved on from the Code of Hammurabi - you would hope we'd learnt something in the last couple of millennia. State sponsored murder is still murder. It is the intentional killing of another not in self-defence, not in an accident but in a deliberate pre-mediated act. I do not want to live in a society that implements killing as a social tool.

I wonder how many people calling for the death penalty would be prepared to administer it themselves or even watch it being administered. How many people , when faced by the choice as a member of a jury, would come to a verdict that meant someone would die. I don't think I could do any of the above so I wouldn't expect it of anyone else.

Swipe left for the next trending thread