Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what people have against Labour?

454 replies

TheSmallestOneWasMadeline · 01/10/2022 12:21

I have come across lots of people who, even while admitting that the Conservatives are far from ideal, seem to scrunch their nose up and say 'but, ew, Labour' when talking about politics.

I have to admit I dont understand what it is that people think is so terrible about them and nobody ever cares to elaborate! I always vote for them as I think their principles align pretty closely with my own even if I don't agree with absolutely e everything they stand for.

Could someone please explain what people think is so terrible about them that they would do a worse job at running the country than the Conservatives have done?

OP posts:
TomPinch · 02/10/2022 21:50

DuckBilledFattypus · 02/10/2022 20:33

When Corbyn was in charge of the Labour Party the same sort of people ran amok. Some of them were the very same people, just much older.

Were they the same people though tompinch? Or were they deliberately tarred with the same brush in order to bring down Corbyn?

Do you think what I described them as doing in the 70s (and the 80s for that matter) was a smear?

Instantnoodles · 02/10/2022 21:39

walkingonsunshinekat · 02/10/2022 18:53

Your very vocal on here, so perhaps you can tell me what is Labours stance/policy on self ID and compare it to the Tory policy on self ID ?

Their 2019 manifesto committed the LP to reforming the Gender Recognition Act and replacing 'gender assignment' with 'gender identity'.

In summer 2021 KS told Pink News that, "we’re committed to updating the GRA to introduce self-declaration for trans people.”

Around the same time he was asked whether it is transphobic to say that only women have a cervix and replied, "Well, it is something that shouldn't be said. It is not right"

Various shadow front benchers have
insulted concerned gender critical women. Rights hoarding 'dinosaurs' (Lammy).

This, coincidentally from today, is good background:

www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/oct/02/if-labour-is-truly-the-party-of-equality-it-wouldnt-shut-down-the-trans-debate

The Tories: avoidable harm to women and girls has occurred on their watch. They set wheels in motion towards self ID in around 2018 but since appear to have read the room and stepped back. This thread is about Labour so I'll leave it there.

TheHoover · 02/10/2022 21:27

Duckbill
I’m weird? They are hellbent on destroying all workers’ rights.
But it’s fine to vote for them because they seem to know what a woman is.

Pilipalapal · 02/10/2022 21:26

Now that’s identity politics.

Pilipalapal · 02/10/2022 21:24

Re. the NMW issue, wages are only really part of the factor when it comes to measuring prosperity.

Under the last Labour government, there was a consistent and considerable drop in poverty rates in the UK. While there was an uptick due to the global financial crisis of 07/08, poverty levels remained lower than they were before Labour came into power.

However, poverty rates have been consistently increasing again, under successive Tory governments. They don’t exactly look like improving soon, either.

DuckBilledFattypus · 02/10/2022 21:24

TheHoover · 02/10/2022 21:17

I’m going to watch with interest how the ‘erosion of women’s rights’ brigade reacts when maternity rights are destroyed under Truss and her bunch of expletives.

Weird. No one has said the Tories have been good with this stuff. But labour would make the situation worse. But watch with interest if it rocks your boat. I take it you're not female and you don't have daughter's. Because if you are/ do then that's really weird.

TheHoover · 02/10/2022 21:17

I’m going to watch with interest how the ‘erosion of women’s rights’ brigade reacts when maternity rights are destroyed under Truss and her bunch of expletives.

Pilipalapal · 02/10/2022 21:13

Florenz · 02/10/2022 20:59

It doesn't matter what the minimum wage is. What matters is what percentage of jobs pay only minimum wage.

The proportion of low paying jobs does matter, but claiming that the actual wage paid to those workers doesn’t matter is absurd.

BirmaBrite · 02/10/2022 21:06

It doesn't matter what the minimum wage is. What matters is what percentage of jobs pay only minimum wage.

It kind of does matter ?

Pilipalapal · 02/10/2022 21:05

Sorry I should leave a source. It’s the table at #3 - www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwork/earningsandworkinghours/bulletins/lowandhighpayuk/2019

Pilipalapal · 02/10/2022 21:04

Florenz · 02/10/2022 20:48

There were more people working for low wages in 2010 than there were in 1997. The minimum wage IS a low wage.

I can’t find any statistics that support your claim. The ONS tracks the proportion of workers in low wage jobs. There was a (small) drop in the proportion of hourly-rate, low paid workers between 1997 and 2010, whereas the proportion of salaried, low paid workers stayed almost constant. Not bad that given that the introduction of the NMW, lower-earners were earning more than they had previously.

(Tbf, you did say the number of workers as proposed to the proportion; I can’t find specific figures for that, but it there were a greater number of lower wage workers in 2010, that must be because of growth in the number of workers, given that the proportion of low earners either remained unchanged or dropped marginally).

Florenz · 02/10/2022 20:59

It doesn't matter what the minimum wage is. What matters is what percentage of jobs pay only minimum wage.

BirmaBrite · 02/10/2022 20:55

@Florenz Oh God don't even think about mentioning increasing the minimum wage, that will result in the End of days, entire businesses will go bust, mass unemployment, Bank holidays being cancelled, raw sewage running through the streets, rats as big as cats, er some other really bad stuff ....

Florenz · 02/10/2022 20:48

There were more people working for low wages in 2010 than there were in 1997. The minimum wage IS a low wage.

Pilipalapal · 02/10/2022 20:43

Labour laid the foundations for the economic problems this country has today. By creating a low wage economy and subsidizing employers through paying welfare to low paid workers. Result is that our economy is less automated and has lower productivity. Tories have never managed to get off this drug.
Can you explain how Labour created a low wage economy?

I’m not old enough to remember pre-Thatcher, so the only Lab government I can remember is the one that introduced the minimum wage and led a big drive to get more younger people into higher education.

Whattaweapon · 02/10/2022 20:42

MangyInseam · 02/10/2022 19:49

And lots of people who are ethnic minorities do think this kind of attitude is racist, and dangerous. Very similar to the way the Democrats in the US treat race issues.

Interesting that you just skim over the issues that poster raised.

How can you defend the Rwanda policy and the comments made by Boris, and accuse others of being racist?

Seems you want to call out racism only when it suits you.

VestaTilley · 02/10/2022 20:38

They have a real blind spot about women. Their attitude to gender ideology and self-ID actively endangers women. They’re also quite racist in their own way, see Rupa Huq.

They’re quite cowardly when it comes to inconvenient truths, like benefit fraud and Asian grooming gangs, and their swallowing of identity politics is chilling.

DuckBilledFattypus · 02/10/2022 20:33

When Corbyn was in charge of the Labour Party the same sort of people ran amok. Some of them were the very same people, just much older.

Were they the same people though tompinch? Or were they deliberately tarred with the same brush in order to bring down Corbyn?

BirmaBrite · 02/10/2022 20:32

(4) it’s not just about the results, it’s the whole package and Keir’s education will have given him advantages that Liz’s didn’t. Let’s face it, she isn’t the best public speaker…but public speaking wasn’t high in the agenda in Leeds comprehensive schools back in the 80’s!

And yet he gets slagged off for having no charisma ! Public speaking might not have been high on the agenda in Leeds comprehensive schools back in the 80's but she then went on to Oxford, worked in high positions in a number of big companies and has been in the Government in one way or another for 12 years. It's a bit 'the dog ate my homework' territory !

DuckBilledFattypus · 02/10/2022 20:30

Some years back I read a book called 'Seasons in the Sun'. It was a history of the UK from 74 to 79

Thanks tompinch. That sounds interesting. I'll have a look for it.

BirmaBrite · 02/10/2022 20:22

@MangyInseam You might want to consider that the fact that being a Euroskeptic is no longer acceptable in Labour may relate to that change. At best it is extremely paternalistic for all of these people to claim they know better where the interests of the w/c lie.

Isn't being a Eurosceptic in any party a bit of a moot point now, given we have left the EU ? Pretty sure Boris got Brexit done and all that ?

I am going to go out on a limb and say that I believe that the best interests of the w/c probably won't be served by this particular incarnation of Conservative government. You might not agree with me, but me saying that doesn't mean I am being paternalistic, more pragmatic.

sst1234 · 02/10/2022 20:22

Lidlcustardtart · 02/10/2022 19:37

This post is offensive and just really unintelligent - the left are racist? Rwanda policy anyone? Boris Johnson's 'letterboxes'? Not racist?

Areas with large % of ethnic minority voters in general vote labour. Are you implying they vote against their own interests?

Have you called 101 yet? To report it.

Acheyknees · 02/10/2022 20:20

Two reasons why I don't like Labour:
1.They have tied themselves up in knots deciding what a woman is.

  1. No discernable talent on the front bench
Florenz · 02/10/2022 20:18

Why don't Labour listen to what people are saying? Why are they so adamant that they are right and the people that don't vote for them (or vote for them while holding their noses) are wrong?

Lozzybear · 02/10/2022 20:14

@BirmaBrite well (1) they didn’t read the same subject so it’s not a direct comparison - Keir read law which has always been one of the most difficult subjects to secure a university place; (2) Leeds university has an outstanding law faculty with very high entry requirements; (3)Keir went to Oxford for post-graduate studies; (4) it’s not just about the results, it’s the whole package and Keir’s education will have given him advantages that Liz’s didn’t. Let’s face it, she isn’t the best public speaker…but public speaking wasn’t high in the agenda in Leeds comprehensive schools back in the 80’s!