Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what people have against Labour?

454 replies

TheSmallestOneWasMadeline · 01/10/2022 12:21

I have come across lots of people who, even while admitting that the Conservatives are far from ideal, seem to scrunch their nose up and say 'but, ew, Labour' when talking about politics.

I have to admit I dont understand what it is that people think is so terrible about them and nobody ever cares to elaborate! I always vote for them as I think their principles align pretty closely with my own even if I don't agree with absolutely e everything they stand for.

Could someone please explain what people think is so terrible about them that they would do a worse job at running the country than the Conservatives have done?

OP posts:
BirmaBrite · 01/10/2022 19:59

www.gov.uk/government/statistics/dwp-benefits-statistics-february-2021/dwp-benefits-statistics-february-2021

@Florenz a lot of people who are taking from the welfare budget are those who have earned a state pension, the rest is made up of people who are working, but are poorly paid, people who are looking for work and people who are unable to work due to disability or ill health of themselves or their dependents.Its all there on the link. Smile

x2boys · 01/10/2022 19:55

I think if Labour want to win the next general election, they need to say what their actual policies are stop whinging and moaning about Conservatives and rather then say how badly they are doing say what they will do better ,also they need to get people on there side rather then telling people who they dont agree with they are thick and stupid they need to be trying to get them to agree with their policies, I'm not sure keir Starmer is the the man for the job though he's rather insipid .

hattie43 · 01/10/2022 19:54

Polls

hattie43 · 01/10/2022 19:53

Whattaweapon · 01/10/2022 19:37

This thread is depressing. It's incredible how many people are actively defending the Tories after the absolute shitshow they've inflicted on the country.

Thank fuck it's not replicated in the real world, with the Tories now languishing at around 20% in the polls.

That's right now a snapshot in time , no government could successfully steer through what has been thrown on us globally . Give it time and things will be better and todays pills will be a distant memory . For most Tories they will not bring themselves to vote labour the party of the losers . There's an aspiration for some about voting Conservative that Labour just doesn't offer . Militant unions and hair shirts .

DuckBilledFattypus · 01/10/2022 19:52

Whattaweapon · 01/10/2022 19:44

Are you actually serious?

Tanking the economy and threatening pensions and mortgages isn't exactly a vote winner. Labour have had a double digit lead in the polls for months now, the disastrous mini budget just shot it into the stratosphere.

It's not a vote winner for some. But it was never going to be. And it depends on what the outcome of that is further down the road. Double digits for labour at the moment doesn't actually mean anything.

pattihews · 01/10/2022 19:52

typicalmner · 01/10/2022 18:48

We are arguing over which main party is worse for women’s safety… how bloody shit is this?

I live in Wales. We've had a Labour government here for more than 20 years. Here our First Minister and his government have proposed various initiatives to support 'the most marginalised in our community' (ie transpeople). The Welsh government has, for years, outsourced anything to do with LGB or TQ+ issue to Stonewall. Drakeford has refused, for years, to meet representatives of any women's organisation that doesn't support TWAW. Wales government has traditionally been fairly easy to approach a minister and arrange a meeting, but feminist groups and women's groups that with to question gender ideology have been denied any access.

A few weeks ago, at a public event, Drakeford said that one of his ministers would welcome contact from a coalition of women's rights groups. A polite letter, promising discretion, was sent. There has been no response several weeks down the line.

This isn't the Tories, this is Labour — Labour refusing to listen, let alone discuss what its people think.

TwoSheetstothewind56 · 01/10/2022 19:50

See my bus analogy

TwoSheetstothewind56 · 01/10/2022 19:49

Florenz · 01/10/2022 19:44

Labour normalised benefits. Can you imagine going back to the 20s and telling people that people who didn't work would be about as well-off as people who did work? Labour used to stand for the Right to Work. They used to organise marches and protests for it, for people's rights to have jobs so they could support themselves and their families. What happened to that?

People who don’t work do not get the same money as people who work. But food banks are ok then? Reduced tax for the super rich is ok then? Removing the cap on bankers bonuses is ok then? Because they had so much wealth, they gambled with the housing market and caused the housing crash. All is forgiven. You’ve done your time, here have stupid amounts of cash.

NoWordForFluffy · 01/10/2022 19:49

Whattaweapon · 01/10/2022 19:40

Indeed, but apparently Labour are the failures. 🙄

The public should be fucking furious.

I'm fucking furious with both the Tories for how they're wrecking the country, AND with Labour for failing to give me a viable option to vote for, all because of their ridiculous TWAW stance. I want to vote Labour, but can't. And I won't vote Tory (or LD, or Green).

jeaux90 · 01/10/2022 19:48

Because they have no idea what a woman is.

(An ex party member)
I left after Starmer said that stating that only women have a cervix is offensive

They can fuck right off

TwoSheetstothewind56 · 01/10/2022 19:45

I like the bus analogy of who to vote for.

If you’re getting a bus, you get the bus that gets closest to your destination. No bus is going to stop exactly where you want. And you might have to walk in the rain for a bit.

Vote for the party that is closest to your ideals and values.

I’m a freelancer that wants to make money and have a comfortable life. But I don’t begrudge paying taxes to help other people or support the NHS.

NoWordForFluffy · 01/10/2022 19:45

BirmaBrite · 01/10/2022 19:37

As bad as, if not worse than, Labour.

So that's the Conservatives, Labour and the Lib dems out if TWAW is the main thing you are going to vote on ? Who is left in England ? The Green party ?

Christ, no. Also captured.

I'm politically homeless; it's awful.

Challenger5 · 01/10/2022 19:45

A question:

How many £ per week extra do you think benefit claimants would get under a Labour Government.

I say this because I doubt the average increase would be more than £20- £25 per week.

Whattaweapon · 01/10/2022 19:44

DuckBilledFattypus · 01/10/2022 19:39

For now. But there's still some time to go. It's by no means a done deal that labour will be in next time.

Are you actually serious?

Tanking the economy and threatening pensions and mortgages isn't exactly a vote winner. Labour have had a double digit lead in the polls for months now, the disastrous mini budget just shot it into the stratosphere.

Florenz · 01/10/2022 19:44

TwoSheetstothewind56 · 01/10/2022 19:38

I’m with you here. The Tories have normalised food banks. Can you imagine going back to the 90s and explaining food banks.

Labour normalised benefits. Can you imagine going back to the 20s and telling people that people who didn't work would be about as well-off as people who did work? Labour used to stand for the Right to Work. They used to organise marches and protests for it, for people's rights to have jobs so they could support themselves and their families. What happened to that?

Whattaweapon · 01/10/2022 19:40

TwoSheetstothewind56 · 01/10/2022 19:38

I’m with you here. The Tories have normalised food banks. Can you imagine going back to the 90s and explaining food banks.

Indeed, but apparently Labour are the failures. 🙄

The public should be fucking furious.

sashagabadon · 01/10/2022 19:40

I doubt I will ever vote labour again. I just don’t think they are the party that represent me anymore. I hate identity politics as I think it is divisive and regressive and I also think Starmer gets a lot of big decisions wrong. I also don’t rate his back bench or many of his MP’s and would not like to see them in charge.
I think the country may be ready for a labour government however and accept that may be the case ( although I personally don’t think so)

DuckBilledFattypus · 01/10/2022 19:39

Whattaweapon · 01/10/2022 19:37

This thread is depressing. It's incredible how many people are actively defending the Tories after the absolute shitshow they've inflicted on the country.

Thank fuck it's not replicated in the real world, with the Tories now languishing at around 20% in the polls.

For now. But there's still some time to go. It's by no means a done deal that labour will be in next time.

TwoSheetstothewind56 · 01/10/2022 19:38

I’m with you here. The Tories have normalised food banks. Can you imagine going back to the 90s and explaining food banks.

NewspaperTaxis · 01/10/2022 19:38

The identity politics is poor politically from a ruthless pov. The Tories would not do that. There just aren't that many out there personally affected by trans issues so it can't sway an election. Really, they could all be thrown under a bus. The Tories do that with care home relatives, as appalling as what went on during Covid, the dead can't vote and if all the affected care home families voted Labour in protest - not a given - it just wouldn't sway an election under the first past the post system. Supporting trans issues winds up many and Labour falls foul of the whole anti-woke brigade, perhaps a bit needlessly.

If you grew up in a Labour-led local authority you may find out how corrupt it all is, esp in Rotherham, Rochdale, Greater Manchester, Oxford where grooming gangs ran rampant, ignored at best, instigated at worst by corrupt Labour-led local authorities and police. You would most likely vote anything else after that and I wouldn't blame them.
I live in Surrey and would never vote Conservative again given how the Tory-led Surrey County Council declared war on me after I shopped a dodgy care home to the local press, which also revealed they were hiring illegal immigrants at a time when Theresa May as Home Secretary was trying to deport them. Or after how Chris Grayling MP dealt with our complaint. But again, it's just one vote and I can be thrown under a bus, so to speak. Probably literally too, given whether the police would investigate!

Lastly, I think Labour have had the whiff of failure about them and some just like to side with the winners, like some football fans. I do think their identity is a bit strained and that Starmer doesn't seem too relaxed or natural. The Tories do seem like that largely because the strategy is, we're very happy and keen to make millions for us and our mates and we are doing it, it exudes success really. May failed to do that because she was a Remainer trying to sell Brexit.

Florenz · 01/10/2022 19:38

Labour need to return to their roots and forget about the crazy shit that has sidetracked them in the last couple of decades. If they concentrate on what working people earning less than the UK average salary want, and they would win every election fairly easily. When they start trying to divide people into minority groups, LGTBQ/Straight, BAME/White, Disabled/able-bodied, etc etc, they lose support.

Rainbowshit · 01/10/2022 19:37

They will not get my x until they respect my sex.

Humans cannot change sex and I will not vote for a party that is so ideologically captured that they cannot tell the truth. How can you make robust, fair effective laws if they are too shit scared to tell the truth.

TwoSheetstothewind56 · 01/10/2022 19:37

Except of course when Johnson said “Let the bodies pile high” during Covid.

BirmaBrite · 01/10/2022 19:37

As bad as, if not worse than, Labour.

So that's the Conservatives, Labour and the Lib dems out if TWAW is the main thing you are going to vote on ? Who is left in England ? The Green party ?

Whattaweapon · 01/10/2022 19:37

This thread is depressing. It's incredible how many people are actively defending the Tories after the absolute shitshow they've inflicted on the country.

Thank fuck it's not replicated in the real world, with the Tories now languishing at around 20% in the polls.

Swipe left for the next trending thread