Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nurses taking Strike Action

456 replies

shmiz · 01/10/2022 08:45

AIBU to believe the public will be supportive of Nurses taking Strike Action ?
Nurses are being asked to vote YES to strike action by the biggest nurses union RCN
www.rcn.org.uk/Get-Involved/Campaign-with-us/Fair-Pay-for-Nursing/Latest-updates

OP posts:
TheLoupGarou · 26/11/2022 22:09

I'm an ED nurse. At top of band 5 I earn about £16 per hour. As an agency nurse in ED I can earn up to £42 per hr depending on the shift, for the same job. Yes, when I need extra money I do agency work, outside my own trust. Who wouldn't?

LionsandLambs · 26/11/2022 13:47

KnittedCardi · 26/11/2022 10:41

and spending less overall as not reliant on agency staff

I would love to find figures, I can't, on the actual cost per hour for NHS nurses v. agency nurses. Talking cost here, not salary. So once you add the pension, holiday pay, sick pay, employer NI, what is the difference between recruiting an agency nurse v. a directly employed nurse. I suspect the difference isn't huge. Might even be cheaper?

This is is just for interest though, as a directly employed NHS employed nurse would always be preferable for so many reasons.

Also can someone confirm whether directly employed NHS nurses also do agency work? No judgement, just interested as to why.

When I work Bank my take home pay is lower than my substantive wage. I just do it to help out my colleagues, there is no great benefit to me.

reesewithoutaspoon · 26/11/2022 12:11

A lot of nurses do agency or work extra on their own trust bank. most trusts offer the shift to bank staff first before putting it out to the agency if it cant be filled. So the nurses will usually register with the hospital bank and also a couple of external agencies if they are needing to work extra
The unit I worked on was so short-staffed that 8 of its beds were almost permanently closed and there would be on average 5 bank/agency staff per shift. (highly specialised and complex nursing so not easy to recruit)

KnittedCardi · 26/11/2022 10:41

and spending less overall as not reliant on agency staff

I would love to find figures, I can't, on the actual cost per hour for NHS nurses v. agency nurses. Talking cost here, not salary. So once you add the pension, holiday pay, sick pay, employer NI, what is the difference between recruiting an agency nurse v. a directly employed nurse. I suspect the difference isn't huge. Might even be cheaper?

This is is just for interest though, as a directly employed NHS employed nurse would always be preferable for so many reasons.

Also can someone confirm whether directly employed NHS nurses also do agency work? No judgement, just interested as to why.

Lapland123 · 26/11/2022 10:26

safe patient care is not happening right now! Anyone with any awareness ( so not Friedduck) knows that. If the strike is successful in its achievements, I assume the trusts are looking forward to retaining staff, recruiting new staff, and spending less overall as not reliant on agency staff. This will lead to better patient care, experience and outcomes.
Go, nurses!
hope the BMA could follow suit for doctors’ strike please, and all healthcare professionals!

Pjsandhotchoc · 26/11/2022 09:56

FriedDuck · 26/11/2022 09:09

Personally I think it’s grossly inappropriate for NHS trusts to be publicly supporting strike action that will harm patients. The trusts’ role is to deliver high quality patient care, not become pawns in a political game or be an activist group.

Personally it’s getting to the stage where I’d be saying to the unions- you’ve got until December 1 to accept the offer on the table or it’s a pay freeze for the next year. Plenty of other public services in need of the extra cash if NHS staff don’t want it.

The trusts’ role is to deliver high quality patient care.

They fail in that role every day that the wards remain understaffed.

prescribingmum · 26/11/2022 09:53

FriedDuck · 26/11/2022 09:09

Personally I think it’s grossly inappropriate for NHS trusts to be publicly supporting strike action that will harm patients. The trusts’ role is to deliver high quality patient care, not become pawns in a political game or be an activist group.

Personally it’s getting to the stage where I’d be saying to the unions- you’ve got until December 1 to accept the offer on the table or it’s a pay freeze for the next year. Plenty of other public services in need of the extra cash if NHS staff don’t want it.

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Your utter ignorance towards the situation is astounding. I can only imagine how awful someone like you must be to work for. Posters keep spelling it out to you and you continue to spout out useless suggestions that will only make the issue worse. You can’t apply private sector mentality to NHS staffing 🤦🏻‍♀️

To spell it out for people like @FriedDuck who seem to lack the very basics of the current situation: The government need nurses more than nurses need the work at the moment. Vacancies are at an all time high, ward staffing is the worst it’s been and payments on agency staff is soaring. Implementing ridiculous suggestions like this will mean more resign and increase the reliance on expensive agency staff/expensive recruitment campaigns abroad to try fill gaps. Neither option offer long term solutions and the problems continue.

Ultimately the NHS costs even more money and likely collapses in the not too distant future.

TheFarawayNearby · 26/11/2022 09:17

FriedDuck · 26/11/2022 09:09

Personally I think it’s grossly inappropriate for NHS trusts to be publicly supporting strike action that will harm patients. The trusts’ role is to deliver high quality patient care, not become pawns in a political game or be an activist group.

Personally it’s getting to the stage where I’d be saying to the unions- you’ve got until December 1 to accept the offer on the table or it’s a pay freeze for the next year. Plenty of other public services in need of the extra cash if NHS staff don’t want it.

I completely disagree with this - Trusts are supporting staff who are taking legally recognised strike action. It's too simplistic to say that any strikes will harm patients (and contingency plans will be put in place to prevent this); the current situation within the NHS is harming patients (and staff) every day.

FriedDuck · 26/11/2022 09:09

Personally I think it’s grossly inappropriate for NHS trusts to be publicly supporting strike action that will harm patients. The trusts’ role is to deliver high quality patient care, not become pawns in a political game or be an activist group.

Personally it’s getting to the stage where I’d be saying to the unions- you’ve got until December 1 to accept the offer on the table or it’s a pay freeze for the next year. Plenty of other public services in need of the extra cash if NHS staff don’t want it.

Lapland123 · 25/11/2022 22:44

It’s great to hear more trusts are supportive, and why wouldn’t they be? It’s the government that’s setting the pay bar so low the trusts are dealing with a nightmare for recruitment and retention

TheFarawayNearby · 25/11/2022 08:13

The Trust I work for seems to be being very supportive of the nurse's strike as well, and is communicating about ongoing contingency planning etc. I'm really impressed with how they're handling it.

LionsandLambs · 25/11/2022 08:05

Lapland123 · 25/11/2022 07:56

LionsandLambs

gosh that’s very upsetting.
ive heard my previous Trust has sent a very supportive email about it, to all staff, to support our striking nurses. I was really impressed. Detailing action to support and arrange for strike days.
im surprised and disappointed at your Trust. I mean, why would anyone want nurses to have pay erosion and poor work conditions ffs. If the HCP of this country are treated fairly, doesn’t that benefit everyone?

good luck with it- every doctor I know supports, as do all the AHP xxxxx

Thanks @Lapland123
Good to hear your Trust have been kinder about it.
I wasn’t surprised, ours flies it’s flag on being better than everywhere else so they will hate that their staff voted to proceed.

Lapland123 · 25/11/2022 07:56

LionsandLambs

gosh that’s very upsetting.
ive heard my previous Trust has sent a very supportive email about it, to all staff, to support our striking nurses. I was really impressed. Detailing action to support and arrange for strike days.
im surprised and disappointed at your Trust. I mean, why would anyone want nurses to have pay erosion and poor work conditions ffs. If the HCP of this country are treated fairly, doesn’t that benefit everyone?

good luck with it- every doctor I know supports, as do all the AHP xxxxx

LionsandLambs · 25/11/2022 07:47

Lapland123 · 25/11/2022 07:43

full support for this xxx
i wish BMA would get on and do something too
well done nurses for taking this stand

Yes. Quite an intimidatory email sent round by the hospital trust yesterday, lots of misinformation contradicting the unions guidance. Makes me even more cross. Got 2.6% increase this year which barely covered the NI increase. The government have messed with the pay structure so much that someone working at my pay grade is on less than the people we manage for 5 years after starting in post. Have had enough.

Lapland123 · 25/11/2022 07:43

full support for this xxx
i wish BMA would get on and do something too
well done nurses for taking this stand

LionsandLambs · 25/11/2022 07:33

Got our dates now. 15th and 20th December.

DohaDragon · 22/11/2022 07:27

I agree.

When I went into the nhs nearly 20 years ago the salary was comparatively better, the pension was much better (I'm not saying it's bad now but it was better), the staffing was better, you were able to give more care with less paperwork, there was less complex care (obviously it's good that treatments improve but it takes more time so needs more staff and we have less staff), patients have got sicker (before I guess they'd have died).

It's not the same job either from a pay or conditions point of view. I would not go into front line nhs work now. And have thankfully managed to escape a frontline nhs role now. But just being on the periphery is bad enough

Neanov · 22/11/2022 05:42

usernamealreadytaken · 20/11/2022 21:33

@Putonyourshoes why did you take a degree and go in to a field where you knew there was an absolute salary (unlike in the private sector where wages are somewhat negotiable) if you thought you were worth more than that salary? Did you do it specifically so that you could tell everyone you were worth more, and we'd all clap? I knew the salary when I took my job, it's a fairly responsible job with some autonomy but up until a few years ago when the public sector pay freeze was lifted I was working for a little over minimum wage - I knew that when I took the job but I enjoy my work and get on well with my colleagues, plus the public sector "perks" are worth it.

It's not just the money I think that's the least problem. It's the sheer volume of patients nurses have to look after and the work load is intense at times. It's long shifts so people easily get worn down. Other sectors you can move around more easily if you studied accountancy or IT is your background fir example.

Putonyourshoes · 20/11/2022 22:32

usernamealreadytaken · 20/11/2022 21:33

@Putonyourshoes why did you take a degree and go in to a field where you knew there was an absolute salary (unlike in the private sector where wages are somewhat negotiable) if you thought you were worth more than that salary? Did you do it specifically so that you could tell everyone you were worth more, and we'd all clap? I knew the salary when I took my job, it's a fairly responsible job with some autonomy but up until a few years ago when the public sector pay freeze was lifted I was working for a little over minimum wage - I knew that when I took the job but I enjoy my work and get on well with my colleagues, plus the public sector "perks" are worth it.

I wanted to be a nurse. I didn’t sign up to year on year real terms pay cuts all the while my workload and stress continues to increase and increase.

Do you not see the problem with what you’re saying? Our pay isn’t negotiable. I can’t decide I’m not happy and go elsewhere, unless I turn to agency. Why should I just put up with worsening working conditions and pay? Why do you think nurses should do that?
The options are quit or strike. I thought most would be pleased we’re wanting to strike instead of quit.

Alexandra2001 · 20/11/2022 22:25

usernamealreadytaken · 20/11/2022 21:33

@Putonyourshoes why did you take a degree and go in to a field where you knew there was an absolute salary (unlike in the private sector where wages are somewhat negotiable) if you thought you were worth more than that salary? Did you do it specifically so that you could tell everyone you were worth more, and we'd all clap? I knew the salary when I took my job, it's a fairly responsible job with some autonomy but up until a few years ago when the public sector pay freeze was lifted I was working for a little over minimum wage - I knew that when I took the job but I enjoy my work and get on well with my colleagues, plus the public sector "perks" are worth it.

My DD went into the NHS because she wants to help people, she knew the pay but what she didn't factor is the shear contempt people have for her... so she is quitting... to help people on the other side of the world.

Tory voters have no right to criticise them or the strike action they may take.

TomTraubertsBlues · 20/11/2022 22:20

usernamealreadytaken · 20/11/2022 21:33

@Putonyourshoes why did you take a degree and go in to a field where you knew there was an absolute salary (unlike in the private sector where wages are somewhat negotiable) if you thought you were worth more than that salary? Did you do it specifically so that you could tell everyone you were worth more, and we'd all clap? I knew the salary when I took my job, it's a fairly responsible job with some autonomy but up until a few years ago when the public sector pay freeze was lifted I was working for a little over minimum wage - I knew that when I took the job but I enjoy my work and get on well with my colleagues, plus the public sector "perks" are worth it.

Most people who are currently nurses entered the profession before austerity. Before a decade of real terms pay cuts.

They may well have thought the salary appropriate in 2007, but it has since been devalued.

usernamealreadytaken · 20/11/2022 21:33

@Putonyourshoes why did you take a degree and go in to a field where you knew there was an absolute salary (unlike in the private sector where wages are somewhat negotiable) if you thought you were worth more than that salary? Did you do it specifically so that you could tell everyone you were worth more, and we'd all clap? I knew the salary when I took my job, it's a fairly responsible job with some autonomy but up until a few years ago when the public sector pay freeze was lifted I was working for a little over minimum wage - I knew that when I took the job but I enjoy my work and get on well with my colleagues, plus the public sector "perks" are worth it.

Putonyourshoes · 20/11/2022 21:21

usernamealreadytaken · 20/11/2022 20:52

@Putonyourshoes

I didn’t deliberately round down. But now I think about, I think that’s actually fair that I did, considering the £480 a year I pay in parking and £120 in registration fees.

I pay for parking at my public sector job too. Shall I minimise my salary too? DH pays over 3x what you pay for parking, but nobody cries about those in the private sector.

You can make comparisons to private sector jobs all you like. I’m not crying about parking. What I often cry about is not being able to give the care to patients that they deserve because we are so short staffed.
If you genuinely believe, I as an intensive care nurse, often working the job of two people due to the staffing crisis, and working through my breaks and past the end of my shift, am only worth the £16.84 an hour I am being paid, then there is nothing more to argue.

usernamealreadytaken · 20/11/2022 20:52

@Putonyourshoes

I didn’t deliberately round down. But now I think about, I think that’s actually fair that I did, considering the £480 a year I pay in parking and £120 in registration fees.

I pay for parking at my public sector job too. Shall I minimise my salary too? DH pays over 3x what you pay for parking, but nobody cries about those in the private sector.

TabithaTittlemouse · 19/11/2022 10:14

@FriedDuck where did you get 35k? That’s middle of band 6 (in our trust band 6 don’t do nights and weekends so don’t get the incentive anyway). The pay is there for everyone to see if you care to look.

Swipe left for the next trending thread