Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nurses taking Strike Action

456 replies

shmiz · 01/10/2022 08:45

AIBU to believe the public will be supportive of Nurses taking Strike Action ?
Nurses are being asked to vote YES to strike action by the biggest nurses union RCN
www.rcn.org.uk/Get-Involved/Campaign-with-us/Fair-Pay-for-Nursing/Latest-updates

OP posts:
usernamealreadytaken · 30/11/2022 10:04

walkingonsunshinekat · 30/11/2022 09:03

Why would any worker agree to work for £15 LESS than they can get elsewhere?
Do you think "goodwill" pays the mortgage?

OT and extra pay don't count toward pension contributions, well, at least they never have in any role i've done, its contracted hours only.

My own view is 7 day working has contributed to the staffing crisis, who wants to work a w/e so they can have tuesday and wed off? kids at school, partner at work, friends at work.

If you are on rota for overnight, weekend or bank holiday work it is normal hours so would be pensionable. We want a 24/7 service and that is part of normal hours, but pay is uplifted for any unsocial hours - the majority of lower grade nursing staff receive shift uplifts so fewer will be on the basic wage only.

Pjsandhotchoc · 30/11/2022 09:54

usernamealreadytaken · 30/11/2022 08:44

The nearly £17 an hour is the hourly wage for a salary of £32,934, and the "random" £27 is the £17 an hour with the Sunday shift uplift - like the random £42 an hour you quoted for "some shifts" - assuming these are the unsocial hours shifts.

If NHS staff worked on Sundays at £27 an hour instead of going to agencies to work for £42, they would be paid a decent wage and the NHS wouldn't have to cover staff with higher costing agency workers. There are posts on here from workers who deliberately work part time so that they can take up agency shifts to be paid more - it seems non-sensical because if they didn't work the agency shifts there would be more money to actually pay them a decent wage.

Nurses are humans; some nurses are absolute angels who care entirely about their work and patients, some are not - it's the same with any human.

Ok, thanks for your advice, that completely solves our problems. I’ll be sure to let every nurse on my ward know that if we just all work Sundays, there isn’t an issue!
I’m sure my ward manager will have no problem complying with this, as of course, she could put all 60 nurses on shift on a Sunday. Then we will all get our unsociable hours payments, hooray!
I don’t know why we haven’t thought of this before, silly nurses hey! Thanks again!

prescribingmum · 30/11/2022 09:19

usernamealreadytaken · 30/11/2022 08:58

Thanks for actually taking time to consider the content of my post instead of just jumping and assuming I'm some nurse-hater - I'm waiting for a suitable apprenticeship so that I can join the ranks.

I totally get what you say, but surely it would be a good starting point for a negotiation.

Do you not think these points haven’t been set out to the government? This isn’t something that has suddenly happened, a constant, ongoing decline has led us to a position where no one will fill a post so the pay on offer via agency goes up and up until someone finally takes it.

Unions have pointed this out to the government many times - they are choosing to ignore it because they don’t want a fully funded health service. They would prefer it collapses so they can say it wasn’t their fault.

NHS staff work many hours overtime for nothing on a daily basis; they work through their unpaid breaks and stay late for every shift they do. Working unsocial hours comes with the role and they take it. How much more goodwill do you expect towards the employers that refuse to pay them fairly? Why should they work for less and do it on a Sunday when they could be with their families?

walkingonsunshinekat · 30/11/2022 09:03

Why would any worker agree to work for £15 LESS than they can get elsewhere?
Do you think "goodwill" pays the mortgage?

OT and extra pay don't count toward pension contributions, well, at least they never have in any role i've done, its contracted hours only.

My own view is 7 day working has contributed to the staffing crisis, who wants to work a w/e so they can have tuesday and wed off? kids at school, partner at work, friends at work.

Lapland123 · 30/11/2022 08:59

Agency gets paid on top, as far as I know

so the money is there, being spent already. Could be used for pay restoration for all the HCP, to assist recruitment and retention to the permanent jobs. Improve patient care and outcomes.

but the government do not want better patient outcomes from the NHS, do they?

usernamealreadytaken · 30/11/2022 08:58

Lapland123 · 30/11/2022 08:54

usernamealreadytaken

in theory if no one took up the agency work, there would be more money to pay for the normal job.... but in practice, that money is not on offer to boost the permanent roles. Instead there’s pay erosion of 20% for nurses, 35% for consultants.
no one is offering pay restoration, we all will have to strike for it.

the money saved by not using agency staff is not on offer to the staff to boost their normal jobs.

Thanks for actually taking time to consider the content of my post instead of just jumping and assuming I'm some nurse-hater - I'm waiting for a suitable apprenticeship so that I can join the ranks.

I totally get what you say, but surely it would be a good starting point for a negotiation.

usernamealreadytaken · 30/11/2022 08:56

prescribingmum · 30/11/2022 08:37

Other thing public should know is that the agency themselves take at least 20% on top of the rate given to the staff member to do the shift. They’re the ones who are raking it in and getting full advantage of the dire staffing rates.

Goodness, so you mean nurses working a Sunday shift for an agency would get paid only slightly less if they did it direct for the NHS (but would get the pension conts), and actually they are working to line the pockets of agencies? Or do you mean the NHS pays £50 for the shift and the nurse "only" gets £42?

Lapland123 · 30/11/2022 08:54

usernamealreadytaken

in theory if no one took up the agency work, there would be more money to pay for the normal job.... but in practice, that money is not on offer to boost the permanent roles. Instead there’s pay erosion of 20% for nurses, 35% for consultants.
no one is offering pay restoration, we all will have to strike for it.

the money saved by not using agency staff is not on offer to the staff to boost their normal jobs.

usernamealreadytaken · 30/11/2022 08:44

TheLoupGarou · 29/11/2022 20:57

Sorry what?
I personally am 'bleeding the coffers dry' by occasionally working extra shifts, over and above my contracted hours in my permanent post, for a different trust?

Shifts that would otherwise be uncovered?

If I work for staff bank I get my own hourly rate - am not in England, so it is not "nearly £17" per hour and I don't know where you are randomly getting £27 from.

Gettaefuck

The nearly £17 an hour is the hourly wage for a salary of £32,934, and the "random" £27 is the £17 an hour with the Sunday shift uplift - like the random £42 an hour you quoted for "some shifts" - assuming these are the unsocial hours shifts.

If NHS staff worked on Sundays at £27 an hour instead of going to agencies to work for £42, they would be paid a decent wage and the NHS wouldn't have to cover staff with higher costing agency workers. There are posts on here from workers who deliberately work part time so that they can take up agency shifts to be paid more - it seems non-sensical because if they didn't work the agency shifts there would be more money to actually pay them a decent wage.

Nurses are humans; some nurses are absolute angels who care entirely about their work and patients, some are not - it's the same with any human.

prescribingmum · 30/11/2022 08:37

Other thing public should know is that the agency themselves take at least 20% on top of the rate given to the staff member to do the shift. They’re the ones who are raking it in and getting full advantage of the dire staffing rates.

Lapland123 · 30/11/2022 00:04

Prescribingmum is spot on
give the HCPs the pay rise they deserve and need, and there would be far less use of agency staff.
the money is already being spent on staffing the service, why not make it good enough for people to want to do permanent roles.

this could be sorted quickly and would lead to better patient care and outcomes. But the government don’t want that

prescribingmum · 29/11/2022 22:14

usernamealreadytaken · 29/11/2022 20:35

Surely as a top of band 5 earning nearly £17 an hr, you'd earn up to £27 an hr depending on the shift, for the same job. Perhaps if more nurses actually did their work for the NHS, then the NHS would have more money to pay them as they wouldn't be paying agency wages? You're literally bleeding the coffers dry rather than working for your own employer 😢

Bollocks. If the NHS paid a decent wage, they would be well staffed. As a result, there would be absolutely no need to offer the shift out to an agency and offer ever increasing amounts to fill the gap because no one considers it worthwhile for a measly £17/hr given the extent of stress and abuse they encounter.

The ONLY solution to the problem (if we don’t want a private healthcare system) is to offer fair pay for the job done. Market forces determine if a wage is worthwhile for the individuals and right now, they’re telling us it isn’t even close.

As @walkinginsunshinekat has pointed out, the governments aim is to privatise the system and do this by turning everyone against each other. They’re succeeding if this post is anything to go by.

TheLoupGarou · 29/11/2022 20:57

usernamealreadytaken · 29/11/2022 20:35

Surely as a top of band 5 earning nearly £17 an hr, you'd earn up to £27 an hr depending on the shift, for the same job. Perhaps if more nurses actually did their work for the NHS, then the NHS would have more money to pay them as they wouldn't be paying agency wages? You're literally bleeding the coffers dry rather than working for your own employer 😢

Sorry what?
I personally am 'bleeding the coffers dry' by occasionally working extra shifts, over and above my contracted hours in my permanent post, for a different trust?

Shifts that would otherwise be uncovered?

If I work for staff bank I get my own hourly rate - am not in England, so it is not "nearly £17" per hour and I don't know where you are randomly getting £27 from.

Gettaefuck

usernamealreadytaken · 29/11/2022 20:35

TheLoupGarou · 26/11/2022 22:09

I'm an ED nurse. At top of band 5 I earn about £16 per hour. As an agency nurse in ED I can earn up to £42 per hr depending on the shift, for the same job. Yes, when I need extra money I do agency work, outside my own trust. Who wouldn't?

Surely as a top of band 5 earning nearly £17 an hr, you'd earn up to £27 an hr depending on the shift, for the same job. Perhaps if more nurses actually did their work for the NHS, then the NHS would have more money to pay them as they wouldn't be paying agency wages? You're literally bleeding the coffers dry rather than working for your own employer 😢

MissyB1 · 29/11/2022 09:42

walkingonsunshinekat · 29/11/2022 08:47

My belief is they want a system where the NHS costs far far less, with the onus put on the population with health insurance & the charity, the state providing emergency care only, NHS moving into the private sector.

The model being dentistry, we are now putting up with very expensive ins/treatments and for those without, its DIY and/or AE/Emergency treatments.

The problem they have is the population don't want any of this, so its done little by little, keep the majority on side.

Can't be incompetence, the removal of the bursary was a well thought out action, as was offering 1% after the pandemic, deliberate insult.

@walkinginsunshinekat yep you hit the nail on the head, this is precisely the plan as far as I can see.

Lapland123 · 29/11/2022 08:52

walkingonsunshinekat

totally agree, it’s deliberate

walkingonsunshinekat · 29/11/2022 08:47

BlueWalnut · 29/11/2022 07:47

True but would be achieved by no staff? My brother in law had an operation privately (because he couldn’t wait in pain any longer) and the private hospital was also very short staffed, so not just the NHS. Are the tories Just incompetent or do they want to grind the population down until we are a bunch of grovelling serfs, who are grateful for any titbit tossed off their table?

My belief is they want a system where the NHS costs far far less, with the onus put on the population with health insurance & the charity, the state providing emergency care only, NHS moving into the private sector.

The model being dentistry, we are now putting up with very expensive ins/treatments and for those without, its DIY and/or AE/Emergency treatments.

The problem they have is the population don't want any of this, so its done little by little, keep the majority on side.

Can't be incompetence, the removal of the bursary was a well thought out action, as was offering 1% after the pandemic, deliberate insult.

BlueWalnut · 29/11/2022 07:47

walkingonsunshinekat · 28/11/2022 18:40

Govt wants no staff - its the only conclusion.

Low pay & remove the bursary.

Labour are missing an opening goal.

True but would be achieved by no staff? My brother in law had an operation privately (because he couldn’t wait in pain any longer) and the private hospital was also very short staffed, so not just the NHS. Are the tories Just incompetent or do they want to grind the population down until we are a bunch of grovelling serfs, who are grateful for any titbit tossed off their table?

DohaDragon · 28/11/2022 19:58

interviewing for 0923 intake at the minute and we have far fewer applicants than at this point in previous years

yes certainly looks like it’s a nationwide issue. And last year they’d dropped 8% nationally. So 40% this year on top of last year is bad.

Lapland123 · 28/11/2022 19:34

Government want no staff is the only conclusion😞

maliafawn · 28/11/2022 18:42

DohaDragon · 28/11/2022 16:58

Interestingly latest figures from this current ucas cycle is that nursing and midwifery applications are down 40% compared to this point last year (and previous years). I suspect a combination of deciding the wage is no longer worth it as it’s got effectively less over the last few years and people not being able to afford to train during a cost of living crisis.

Applications from mature students are disproportionately affected, dropped off a Cliff.

This is not going to help the nhs staffing crisis.

Im interviewing for 0923 intake at the minute and we have far fewer applicants than at this point in previous years

walkingonsunshinekat · 28/11/2022 18:40

Lapland123 · 28/11/2022 17:43

Interesting stats and not a surprise.
do people want no staff?

Govt wants no staff - its the only conclusion.

Low pay & remove the bursary.

Labour are missing an opening goal.

Lapland123 · 28/11/2022 17:43

Interesting stats and not a surprise.
do people want no staff?

DohaDragon · 28/11/2022 16:58

Interestingly latest figures from this current ucas cycle is that nursing and midwifery applications are down 40% compared to this point last year (and previous years). I suspect a combination of deciding the wage is no longer worth it as it’s got effectively less over the last few years and people not being able to afford to train during a cost of living crisis.

Applications from mature students are disproportionately affected, dropped off a Cliff.

This is not going to help the nhs staffing crisis.

TheLoupGarou · 26/11/2022 22:13

Bank and agency is taxed as a second job, so generally as basic rate - agency pays more so much more worth working

Swipe left for the next trending thread