Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nurses taking Strike Action

456 replies

shmiz · 01/10/2022 08:45

AIBU to believe the public will be supportive of Nurses taking Strike Action ?
Nurses are being asked to vote YES to strike action by the biggest nurses union RCN
www.rcn.org.uk/Get-Involved/Campaign-with-us/Fair-Pay-for-Nursing/Latest-updates

OP posts:
maiafawnly · 06/10/2022 15:33

@Signeduptosimplyreplytothis

Whilst I can see the sentiment that's doesn't solve anything. When you have 2 nurses on a 28 bed emergency surgery ward with half needing 2/3 turns, everyone on IVs with at least 25% needing a new cannula on a given day, everyone needing pain relief, everyone needing regular obs everyone needing daily bloods, 7 or 8 different consultants you u have to chase for reviews, discharge letters, take home medications, people needing packages of care, physio/OH/salt input, people needing district nurse referrals or follow up appointments etc etc etc. Nurses not being able to take a break cos they can't leave one nurse on the ward, nurses staying an hour + late to complete care plans as they haven't had chance to sit and write about 14 patients during their shift. Then getting home at 9pm and having to be back on shift raring to go at 6.45am the next day for handover of 14 patients again. People buying their own walking sticks is going to have zero effect.

MissyB1 · 06/10/2022 15:25

Arewerelated · 06/10/2022 14:56

My DH is a nurse and supports anything but the strike, he's sure that some of his patients will die or be neglected if he doesn't go in.
I feel for him as it will be difficult to go in if his colleagues are not, but I'm proud of him for sticking to his guns.

Patients are having their needs neglected day in day out because of lack of staff. Your Dh needs to acknowledge that, and realise that in order to attract staff, and therefore make hospitals safer, the job needs to be more attractive.
Demanding better pay in order to staff hospitals better is one way of being an advocate for patients. Because patients deserve well staffed hospitals with content and motivated nurses.

Signeduptosimplyreplytothis · 06/10/2022 15:23

I'm really opposed to strike action in general. I find it counterproductive and ultimately can lead to a loss of jobs in some instances, or worse in this instance a potential for loss of life and limb.

What strikes me from these posts is that the issue isn't pay its working conditions that are the problem. The endemic bullying (and I've witnessed it as a patient before), the lack of respect for breaks, the chronic staff shortages, the increase in work load due to the challenges and changes that have come through modern medicine. I'm not sure what strike action can do to resolve bullying.

i think what might help is if the public expect and use LESS of our health and social care services. Yes we pay for them. Yes they are free at the point of use. But we as the public could help by attending our appointments on time, practicing self care, looking out for family and neighbours, buying bits of kit like walking sticks and those seats you get on the toilet or handles for our bathroom walls. Free up the time so those who most need it get the care they require.

maiafawnly · 06/10/2022 15:15

Just to point out many many nurses have left the Nhs to go agency nursing. Every ward I have been to as student and bank ha has had agency nurses on shift almost every night. Hospitals pay the agency, who in turn pay their staff £35-60 an hour depending on shift times and experience. Way more than NHS employees earn at the same banding. If they paid their staff more, not agency levels but more overall, ultimately they would save money and retain staff. They would have nurses on wards consistently who know the patients and areas instead of agency coming into a speciality they may not have experience of and whilst they are able to do basic nursing tasks, it leaves more work for permanent staff having to also pick up the work the agency staff are not skilled in.

prescribingmum · 06/10/2022 15:14

Arewerelated · 06/10/2022 14:56

My DH is a nurse and supports anything but the strike, he's sure that some of his patients will die or be neglected if he doesn't go in.
I feel for him as it will be difficult to go in if his colleagues are not, but I'm proud of him for sticking to his guns.

What happens to his patients when he goes home to sleep? On his days off? On bank holidays he doesn't work? He is aware that a nursing strike means that there is a service equivalent to BH continuing on strike day and everyone doesn't just leave the patients to their own devices?!

An honourable as he maybe, he has a very shortsighted view. He is not there 24/7 propping up the service and nor will he be there forever. If nurses join forces and act on behalf of the whole workforce, it will help address the underlying issues with staff retention which will have a much bigger effect on the service as a whole

shmiz · 06/10/2022 15:09

Arewerelated · 06/10/2022 14:56

My DH is a nurse and supports anything but the strike, he's sure that some of his patients will die or be neglected if he doesn't go in.
I feel for him as it will be difficult to go in if his colleagues are not, but I'm proud of him for sticking to his guns.

He sounds honourable and a decent nurse
but when he’s burnt out / retired and gone
who is coming up behind him ????

i think he’s being short sighted
strike is about addressing long term pay / staff issues

he should strike to protect patients / nhs

OP posts:
Arewerelated · 06/10/2022 14:56

My DH is a nurse and supports anything but the strike, he's sure that some of his patients will die or be neglected if he doesn't go in.
I feel for him as it will be difficult to go in if his colleagues are not, but I'm proud of him for sticking to his guns.

TooBigForMyBoots · 06/10/2022 14:48

I support the nurses.
No employer should have to give out Food Bank vouchers, but that was happening before Covid. It must be even worse now.

I would like my nurses to be fed well, rested well and renumerated well so they can focus on the really important job they do.

shmiz · 06/10/2022 14:45

@Onceuponatimeinalandfaraway yes

we have a food bank opened for our hospital staff -
breaks my heart that it’s come to that

OP posts:
TrussSucks · 06/10/2022 14:23

Those of you saying the pay isn't that bad are missing the point. For the same or better pay you can get a job in a supermarket which means better work life balance, less stress etc so it makes nursing even less attractive. I work with 2 Trusts and they have 25% vacancy rates for nursing at the mo. No one wants the jobs.

Onceuponatimeinalandfaraway · 06/10/2022 14:21

Isn’t it one in four hospitals in England have opened food banks specifically for their staff to use?

can’t believe some of the comments in here against nurses wanting a pay rise. Hope you enjoy paying for your healthcare when the nhs collapses as the lack of nurses and doctors currently increases and more leave in their droves.

prescribingmum · 06/10/2022 14:10

Alexandra2001 · 06/10/2022 13:39

Strange argument, when in every other walk of life, remuneration is always given as a reason to attract (by the tory govt) and retain staff - most recently with Banker Bonuses and the cut in the 45% rate.

Nurses getting a 10% pay rise, just means the status quo, so more staff leave = worse working conditions, so a 5% above inflation is reasonable.

Of course had we not left the EU, we'd still have all those EU nurses who left.

In addition to these points, everyone seems to have forgotten that nurses had experienced a real terms pay cut over 10% before the pandemic even happened. All those years of pay freezes have played a part, then add on recent double digit inflation. If they got the 15% they are striking for, they will still be worse off compared to early 2000s in real terms

Alexandra2001 · 06/10/2022 13:39

BigWoollyJumpers · 06/10/2022 10:19

I don't support the strike when they are asking for 15%, it's ridiculous.

Those who have been interviewed have always highlighted the overwork, and lack of nursing staff, both huge issues I agree. However, neither of those is down to pay. Most of the grievances are down to other issues. Equally important, and mostly down to the lack of staff. I think it is simplistic to say though, that more pay will lead to staff retention. I suspect if they get a good pay rise, many will go part-time, to mitigate the stress of work. More pay also means there is less to go round for new hires, so it is a vicious circle.

A point many are missing too, is though it is more expensive to hire agency nurses on an hourly rate, it is still less expensive than having an employee. The NHS saves money as they don't have to pay holiday pay, or sick pay, or National Insurance or pension payments. Another catch 22.

Strange argument, when in every other walk of life, remuneration is always given as a reason to attract (by the tory govt) and retain staff - most recently with Banker Bonuses and the cut in the 45% rate.

Nurses getting a 10% pay rise, just means the status quo, so more staff leave = worse working conditions, so a 5% above inflation is reasonable.

Of course had we not left the EU, we'd still have all those EU nurses who left.

NicolaSixSix · 06/10/2022 13:35

SleeplessInEngland · 06/10/2022 09:38

"Things are shit in the private sector therefore they should be shit everywhere" isn't the convincing argument you think it is.

@SleeplessInEngland this

yet you see the race to the bottom argument so often you wonder what kind of mad max situation we’d be in if it was allowed to run all the way to it’s conclusion.

all those who are saying here that nurses shouldn’t strike because they are personally not getting a pay rise or because the starting salary for nurses is amazing, etc - I bet they complain when they can’t get appointments, or there’s no social care to support elderly loved ones, and so on, yet when they get to the ballot box they vote tory anyways, because they believe the “hard work pays” trope and earn £160k and like not being taxed an extra 5% on those £10k.

is thinking that hard?

traintraveller · 06/10/2022 13:08

Coldilox · 06/10/2022 12:03

I’m married to a nurse but she is not RCN, she’s in Unison. She hasn’t heard anything about a ballot, does anybody know if they are planning a ballot for nurses?

Unison is also balloting members re strike action.

MerlinsButler · 06/10/2022 13:04

@funtycucker
I'm completely behind nurses taking strike action and back their right for better pay and improved working conditions but I'm sorry, having to pay for your parking is not something that should even be brought into it. Many people have to pay for parking at work. What about retail workers in town/city centres who are more often than not on minimum wage?

Re paying for parking. The issue is that not only are they working long and anti-social shifts but are having to pay to park at their place of work where often public transport isn't available at the times they need it. Nurses and doctors parking shouldn't be something that private companies can make money from. If I worked late in my office role - my company paid for a taxi home (if after midnight). Why should nurses have to pay over the odds just to work long shifts.

MerlinsButler · 06/10/2022 13:00

I'm not in the medical profession and can hands down say I couldn't do a nurse's role. I've witnessed the grief they put up with daily whilst in A&E. I've also watched them sit with my elderly grandparents as they died. And taking the time to clean them up afterwards so we could sit with them a while. I've only ever had excellent treatment myself from caring and very overworked nurses.

I absolutely think they should strike. Not only for more money but also to bring back nursing bursaries. The workload caused by lack of staff is directly related to the poor pay and conditions. Improve those - you have more chance of filling the vacancies and the working conditions become better for everyone.

It's easy to stand on a doorstep and clap like trained seals. If the general public truly care about the NHS and nursing staff then we should support the strike. It is the only way they will get better working conditions.

Overthebow · 06/10/2022 12:50

funtycucker · 06/10/2022 12:45

I'm completely behind nurses taking strike action and back their right for better pay and improved working conditions but I'm sorry, having to pay for your parking is not something that should even be brought into it. Many people have to pay for parking at work. What about retail workers in town/city centres who are more often than not on minimum wage?

Agree, and paying for own study and student loans shouldn’t either, that’s the same for all graduates, lots not starting on £27k.

Student nurses having to do a lot of shift work during their degrees is a separate matter, this should be paid. Perhaps the apprentice rate would be appropriate for this.

PearlclutchersInc · 06/10/2022 12:48

Nurses have my support, having been on the receiving end lately. If they weren't so understaffed and overworked I might not but the majority do more than pull their weight.

Mummyme87 · 06/10/2022 12:46

RCM (midwives) also about to vote for strike. I will be voting yes

funtycucker · 06/10/2022 12:45

Nightnurse123 · 06/10/2022 10:39

We have to make life and death decisions in really stressful circumstances. We have to constantly study in our own time to keep up to date for the safety of our patients. Many of us work shifts so finding childcare is even more difficult than if we worked regular 9-5 jobs.

I pay for my own car parking, registration fees and union/indemnity insurance. We often have to pay for own study. I am lucky that I am not newly qualified but those nurses on £27k will have to pay their student loans back for years and years.

I'm completely behind nurses taking strike action and back their right for better pay and improved working conditions but I'm sorry, having to pay for your parking is not something that should even be brought into it. Many people have to pay for parking at work. What about retail workers in town/city centres who are more often than not on minimum wage?

Overthebow · 06/10/2022 12:44

I’m really conflicted on this. Nurses pay is pretty good and the pension is excellent, but it’s such a hard job and the working conditions sound awful. I think they should absolutely get a pay rise that matches inflation, but I don’t support the RCN asking for way above inflation rise. Especially at the moment when cost of living is affecting everyone and most are getting way below inflation or no pay rise. I would more support them asking for 10% plus better working conditions.

Redlocks28 · 06/10/2022 12:36

Totally support nurses and doctors striking. I hope people will be supportive of the teachers strikes, as well.

QueenJaineApproximately · 06/10/2022 12:34

NicolaSixSix · 06/10/2022 11:39

I can’t believe I have to say this twice in as many days.

when was the last time you:
put a dead person in a body bag
dealt with people at their most vulnerable
saw someone die
had to deal with safeguarding issues such as family members abusing the patient (physical, sexual, emotional abuse)
had to deal with people terrified of losing their loved ones/their pain as they lose loved ones
had to hold the possibility, hundreds of times a week, of making a simple mistake in your job that could kill someone (eg drawing decilitres of a medication when it should be millilitres, assessing something as not needing immediate attention but being wrong)

and on, and on, and on

Not to mention work related ill health or injury. eg communicable diseases , musculoskeletal issues or risk of contracting hepatitis b, HIV or hepatitis C if you sustain a needle stick injury from a contaminated source.

shmiz · 06/10/2022 12:30

Coldilox · 06/10/2022 12:03

I’m married to a nurse but she is not RCN, she’s in Unison. She hasn’t heard anything about a ballot, does anybody know if they are planning a ballot for nurses?

Not aware of unison balloting for strike
this is specifically RCN
the largest nursing union in UK

OP posts: