Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable here?

115 replies

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 07:39

I am A or B- I don't want to say which do it doesn't skew answers. I've not included salaries as a stealth boast - just for context in terms of level of post.

A - senior manager in a business support function line managed by B. Started £75k role in late January- job is approx 1.5 hour commute each way from A's home. Notice in first year is 1 month, after that it's 3 months. Enjoying the job, excellent feedback and has consistently fed back how committed they are to role/organisation. Resigned on Friday for a new role closer to home - about 25 minutes- on a little bit more money. Has given 1 month notice including a week of which they are in a precooked holiday. A says they didn't aim to mislead - but the job came up and they went for it. Feels that B has taken the resignation personally.

B - A's line manager - senior senior manager. Really pleased with A's work. Received resignation on Friday. Upset, disappointed and a bit pissed off that A has been lying about commitment to role as would have taken another candidate on if it had been known they would leave so soon after joining. Has offered A payrise and flexible working to stay but A still wants to go. Has fed back to A that the move is career limiting due to changing sectors and that they do feel personally let down.

Who is unreasonable here?

OP posts:
gettingolderandgrumpier · 01/10/2022 08:11

Why is anyone unreasonable people change / circumstances change . How can anyone possibly foresee anything and say you would recruit someone else , absolute absurd comment. Not unreasonable to be annoyed but unreasonable to think that people stay in jobs and that if they get another opportunity you take it personally.

FelicityFlops · 01/10/2022 08:10

4th person in the role in 3 years, hmm that sounds as if the company is not that great to work for or B is not spot on when engaging staff.
However, neither of them is being unreasonable. A saw an opportunity and took it, B is being unprofessional by taking this resignation personally, but should definitely do a lessons learned exercise prior to recruiting "C".
I do think it is unreasonable to expect people to commute for 3 hours every day (or even 1.5 hours).
Maximum commute for me is 30 minutes each way, by car, which is sufficient time in the morning to gear myself up, listen to the radio and do something more physical than sitting in front of a screen und enough time after work to unwind in peace. Neither of these things are possible on public transport.

hauntedvagina · 01/10/2022 08:09

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 08:03

Sorry, I'm going add - because I forgot, not a drop feed!

A is the fourth person in this role in 3 years. Was asked multiple times through recruitment process and after about commitment and the need for stability in the team.

Neither is unreasonable. It's business. People leave, and people get frustrated when people leave.

B should be looking at the role of A more in depth to question why people are leaving it so quickly.

Worriedaboutethics · 01/10/2022 08:08

@bossorworker1

100% B.

they could have done more a lot for if A going would be such a loss.

BoopBoopBoDiddley · 01/10/2022 08:07

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 08:03

Sorry, I'm going add - because I forgot, not a drop feed!

A is the fourth person in this role in 3 years. Was asked multiple times through recruitment process and after about commitment and the need for stability in the team.

So, you are B then. Obviously B, because you now say this is the 4th person in the role. If you are getting through this many people, something must be wrong somewhere

HandbagAtDawn · 01/10/2022 08:07

A got a better offer. B needs to make sure their offer is just as attractive. If A's role has seen four people come and go in quick succession, then B is the common denominator and should be looking into that a bit more.

SirChenjins · 01/10/2022 08:06

The moment most companies have a restructure, relocation or merger etc then they almost always show they have absolutely no loyalty to any individual employees, no matter how good at their role or dedicated

Absolutely agree

thirstyformore · 01/10/2022 08:06

B. If the business was restructuring and needed to make A redundant the business would do it in a shot. It's business. A has to make decisions based on what's right for them.

Darbs76 · 01/10/2022 08:06

B. It’s a job not a relationship. People can resign at anytime and it doesn’t mean she wasn’t committed to the job at the time, but a better offer has come up. You can’t take resignations from staff personally.

Lindy2 · 01/10/2022 08:05

The moment most companies have a restructure, relocation or merger etc then they almost always show they have absolutely no loyalty to any individual employees, no matter how good at their role or dedicated.

If your location, role, face no longer fits you're out without a second glance.

A needs to do what's right for them. 3 hours of commuting a day is a lot do their quality of life will most likely improve with being closer to work.

B is unreasonable to be treating this as anything other than business. It's not personal. It's understandable that B feels fed up having to recruit and train again but that's how business works.

StrawberryPot · 01/10/2022 08:05

B is unreasonable to take it personally.

B is also a bit daft to think anyone is going to want to spend 3 hours a day commuting on a long term basis and not jump at the chance to get a more local job.

Devilishpyjamas · 01/10/2022 08:05

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 08:03

Sorry, I'm going add - because I forgot, not a drop feed!

A is the fourth person in this role in 3 years. Was asked multiple times through recruitment process and after about commitment and the need for stability in the team.

Makes zero difference.

b should try working in social care management. She’d pass out.

BoopBoopBoDiddley · 01/10/2022 08:03

B. Business is business's. I don't blame A for wanting a job that's closer to home

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 08:03

Sorry, I'm going add - because I forgot, not a drop feed!

A is the fourth person in this role in 3 years. Was asked multiple times through recruitment process and after about commitment and the need for stability in the team.

OP posts:
MysteriesOfTheOrganism · 01/10/2022 08:03

Nobody is being unreasonable. A is entitled to look after their personal best interests. B is understandably disappointed and a bit cheesed off. But it's just life.

Wiaa · 01/10/2022 08:02

B

LadyWithLapdog · 01/10/2022 08:01

Oh, and congratulations if you’re A. It sounds like you’ve got a good job on more money and closer to home.

LadyWithLapdog · 01/10/2022 08:00

B - it’s business. They can learn from it next time they recruit.

Hearthnhome · 01/10/2022 07:57

No one is unreasonable. A is doing what’s best for them

B feels they invested time and energy into A because A gave the impression they wouldn’t be looking elsewhere.

No one lied. It just worked out differently. I don’t see the issue with a manger expressing their disappointment.

pimlicoanna · 01/10/2022 07:57

No one's unreasonable

properdoughnut · 01/10/2022 07:56

Devilishpyjamas · 01/10/2022 07:55

B. Clearly. No-one owns an employee. It’s irritating when someone moves shortly after joining, but not personal (& if it is, so what?)

I agree and It's also not uncommon surely? The first few months are the probabtion period for a reason.

Midnights · 01/10/2022 07:56

B is unreasonable - has unreasonable expectations of A! A was committed to the job, whilst they were doing it - however they're allowed to move on for new opportunities. A has given the required notice and done nothing wrong.

B needs to realise that loyalty should be to yourself before a company (and feeling personally let down is ott) - the company wouldn't be feeling any loyalty towards A if they needed to make cuts / restructure etc. A is replaceable.

Devilishpyjamas · 01/10/2022 07:55

B. Clearly. No-one owns an employee. It’s irritating when someone moves shortly after joining, but not personal (& if it is, so what?)

SeasonFinale · 01/10/2022 07:55

B is.

YellowTreeHouse · 01/10/2022 07:54

B is unreasonable. This isn’t personal, it’s business. A didn’t lie, their circumstances changed.