Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable here?

115 replies

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 07:39

I am A or B- I don't want to say which do it doesn't skew answers. I've not included salaries as a stealth boast - just for context in terms of level of post.

A - senior manager in a business support function line managed by B. Started £75k role in late January- job is approx 1.5 hour commute each way from A's home. Notice in first year is 1 month, after that it's 3 months. Enjoying the job, excellent feedback and has consistently fed back how committed they are to role/organisation. Resigned on Friday for a new role closer to home - about 25 minutes- on a little bit more money. Has given 1 month notice including a week of which they are in a precooked holiday. A says they didn't aim to mislead - but the job came up and they went for it. Feels that B has taken the resignation personally.

B - A's line manager - senior senior manager. Really pleased with A's work. Received resignation on Friday. Upset, disappointed and a bit pissed off that A has been lying about commitment to role as would have taken another candidate on if it had been known they would leave so soon after joining. Has offered A payrise and flexible working to stay but A still wants to go. Has fed back to A that the move is career limiting due to changing sectors and that they do feel personally let down.

Who is unreasonable here?

OP posts:
properdoughnut · 01/10/2022 08:47

Tbh if B can't handle it they should probably be looking for a new job too

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 01/10/2022 08:43

Managers in general need to let go of "feeling let down"
Just grow the fuck up
And I say that as a Manager.

olympicsrock · 01/10/2022 08:31

Both are a bit unreasonable.
A should not have taken a job so far form home without discussing flexible working at the outset. They have been less than truthful about their committment to the job

B should have offered flexible working and better pay earlier to ensure the job was competitive. Understandably frustrated to have to recruit again.

DisforDarkChocolate · 01/10/2022 08:29

B, the update make no difference.

You can be totally committed, and then just come across an advert for a job that makes you want to leave.

I suspect the reason people keep leaving has something to do with B's attitude. Flexibility isn't their strong point. Making people constantly reaffirm their commitment is ridiculous.

RhubarbFairy · 01/10/2022 08:29

You were obviously B from the outset. Your description of B is much more emotive, and your follow up confirmed it.

B is overstepping. Yes it's irritating to have to start the recruitment process, but A is perfectly entitled to leave for whatever reason, whenever they choose. It's not a jail sentence.

B is being manipulative with comments about career progression. This attitude is most likely the reason that no-one stays for long.

Good luck to A. They're well shot of what sounds like a horrendous commute to an environment that is toxic the moment you don't toe the line.

ZenNudist · 01/10/2022 08:28

Neither are unreasonable. I do think A is fairly unprofessional for jumping ship so soon but in the end the company is better off without people like that. You need trustworthy committed staff.

B should not take it personally. It's really hard to hire the right staff. Sometimes people leave sooner than you want. It such a ballache doing the hiring and getting someone up to speed. It's limiting to your plans because I don't doubt that A has taken time to get used to the job and having put in all that leg work B will have to start again. There's also the recruitment cost if they paid an external recruiter. You don't get that back if they leave sooner.

That's why it's frowned upon to move jobs frequently. If I see someone has moved after a short time I make sure they have good reason and as a one off I might allow it for the right candidate but I do view people like that as a flight risk.

Whowhatwherewhenwhynow · 01/10/2022 08:28

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 08:03

Sorry, I'm going add - because I forgot, not a drop feed!

A is the fourth person in this role in 3 years. Was asked multiple times through recruitment process and after about commitment and the need for stability in the team.

So if they’ve had 4 people leave the role over 3 years they obviously need to look at why. Either they need to offer better money, more befits or adapt the job someone wants to stay in it. They need to look at themselves if multiple people are leaving the same role.

Rosehugger · 01/10/2022 08:24

The manager is being unreasonable. Recruiting can be a pain in the arse but businesses also get rid of employees at the drop of a hat at times, no-one is indispensable. So no employee should put loyalty to an employer over a better choice for their finances or quality of life, or both, because an employer would not hesitate to make redundancies if they had to.

Idontevenknow · 01/10/2022 08:24

You're obviously B and I don't think either of you are unreasonable. It is the nature of business. Very similiar happened to my OH last year- he went to a new role with every intention of staying long-term and then was asked (he was not looking) to work elsewhere much closer to home and for better pay/conditions. It has changed our home life for the positive immeasurably and he would have been mad to say no. He felt guilty but ultimately had to do what was best for him and his family.

However you have every right to feel the way you feel and its completely understandable. Its not personal. You've offered more, A has declined. Move on gracefully and start looking for someone else.

girlmom21 · 01/10/2022 08:23

B is unreasonable. If there's more money or flexible working available it should be offered to the candidate when they're offered the job - maybe they'll get more loyal employees if working conditions are better.

alloutoflunchideas · 01/10/2022 08:23

Sounds like it’s a shit company to work for or B is a shit person to work for if turnover is so high tbh

but it’s business doesn’t matter how committed someone is initially peoples lives and priorities change

decayingmatter · 01/10/2022 08:22

Makes zero difference.

b should try working in social care management. She’d pass out*

Haha, yes. 9 months would be the longest standing member of staff sometimes.

SirChenjins · 01/10/2022 08:22

MiddleParking · 01/10/2022 08:20

It’s so incredibly self-important to post like this. Yes you’re being unreasonable, whichever one you are. Also describing a bitchy, mean comment as something one ‘fed back’ doesn’t magically make it less bitchy or mean.

We’ll that’s one way of getting your YABU in 😂

YellowTreeHouse · 01/10/2022 08:21

You’re B. You need to stop taking business so personally and fix what is making everyone leave rather than putting it on them.

MiddleParking · 01/10/2022 08:20

It’s so incredibly self-important to post like this. Yes you’re being unreasonable, whichever one you are. Also describing a bitchy, mean comment as something one ‘fed back’ doesn’t magically make it less bitchy or mean.

properdoughnut · 01/10/2022 08:18

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 08:03

Sorry, I'm going add - because I forgot, not a drop feed!

A is the fourth person in this role in 3 years. Was asked multiple times through recruitment process and after about commitment and the need for stability in the team.

Why would they tell A that? Did A ask?

Anyway that should be telling B something is up with the job and they aren't matching their competitors offer. Or they don't like working for B.

Hercisback · 01/10/2022 08:18

B clearly (which is obviously you).

You need to consider why people are leaving so quickly. There is a common denominator.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 01/10/2022 08:17

Anyone is entitled to resign from a job at any point, for any reason, it's the nature of it surely. A is not unreasonable for opting for a shorter commmute, or a salary increase. B is not unreasonable for being a little fed up of recruiting.

Perhaps B needs to think about why they've recruited so many times and why people aren't staying?

Ponoka7 · 01/10/2022 08:17

"A is the fourth person in this role in 3 years."

I agree that flexible working and better pay needs to be considered as standard. There's a reason why people are leaving.

Hearthnhome · 01/10/2022 08:14

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 08:03

Sorry, I'm going add - because I forgot, not a drop feed!

A is the fourth person in this role in 3 years. Was asked multiple times through recruitment process and after about commitment and the need for stability in the team.

Doesn’t impact peoples feelings around it. A was telling the truth when they said they were committed. Things change/

Stoll don’t think B is wrong thoughts

Though B and the company need to look at what the issue is and why they can’t get stability.

knittingaddict · 01/10/2022 08:14

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 08:03

Sorry, I'm going add - because I forgot, not a drop feed!

A is the fourth person in this role in 3 years. Was asked multiple times through recruitment process and after about commitment and the need for stability in the team.

So you're B then.

dontputitthere · 01/10/2022 08:13

It's understandable for B to be disappointed. But to feel A was 'lying' and telling them it's a shit career move is a tad OTT.

It's a job. Life happens. You don't sign over your life and soul loyalty when you a join a company.

gretr · 01/10/2022 08:13

Nobody is unreasonable, but the company might want to rethink the job as the turnover rate is high which says more about the company than the individual.

KeepingKeepingOn · 01/10/2022 08:13

I think you’re B and I think you’ve overstepped if you’ve told A you feel personally let down 😬 even if you do (and I can understand why), A hasn’t done anything personal to you. You don’t necessarily know what’s happening in her home life that means that extra 2 hours back a day could be a godsend. Employees have to look after themselves, as businesses (not people) will always look after the business first - that’s just the way it is 🤷‍♀️

NoSquirrels · 01/10/2022 08:11

No one is unreasonable.

A is entitled to resign.
B is entitled to feel annoyed about it.