Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable here?

115 replies

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 07:39

I am A or B- I don't want to say which do it doesn't skew answers. I've not included salaries as a stealth boast - just for context in terms of level of post.

A - senior manager in a business support function line managed by B. Started £75k role in late January- job is approx 1.5 hour commute each way from A's home. Notice in first year is 1 month, after that it's 3 months. Enjoying the job, excellent feedback and has consistently fed back how committed they are to role/organisation. Resigned on Friday for a new role closer to home - about 25 minutes- on a little bit more money. Has given 1 month notice including a week of which they are in a precooked holiday. A says they didn't aim to mislead - but the job came up and they went for it. Feels that B has taken the resignation personally.

B - A's line manager - senior senior manager. Really pleased with A's work. Received resignation on Friday. Upset, disappointed and a bit pissed off that A has been lying about commitment to role as would have taken another candidate on if it had been known they would leave so soon after joining. Has offered A payrise and flexible working to stay but A still wants to go. Has fed back to A that the move is career limiting due to changing sectors and that they do feel personally let down.

Who is unreasonable here?

OP posts:
bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 09:51

glitterfarts · 01/10/2022 08:55

For 75k I'll do it. And stay more than a year.

So would I have if I hadn't been offered £82k much closer to my house saving me at least £300 a month on tip in fuel and early morning childcare

OP posts:
Sewwhatmrmagpie · 01/10/2022 09:44

B is unreasonable, and should be thinking more about why they haven't been able to retain anyone in the role for more than 10 mins. It's a job, you aren't an indentured slave and you are free to move around if you find it doesn't suit.

Last year I moved from a job after 4 months, they were so awful to me that I started looking after 2 weeks in the role. Their reaction confirmed I did the right thing.

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 01/10/2022 09:39

B is being unreasonable.

A has done nothing wrong. They have worked well and acted professionally. They had no way to predict whether thiscother opportunity would come off, and if it hadn't they would have continued working well and happily in this job. The fact that B wouldn't have appointed them if they had known A was looking elsewhere too is proof that A dif the right thing, as if the other opportunity hadn't come off they would be unemployed. A iscthe only one responsible for looking out for A's best interests and they have done so without breaking contract or being unprofessional.

Readaboutyourself · 01/10/2022 09:34

Ewarty · 01/10/2022 07:51

Neither are being unreasonable and the feelings are entirely understandable on both sides - it's just one of those things.

Yep and irrelevant anyway. A will leave and B will rehire upset or not.

girlmom21 · 01/10/2022 09:32

pandy2 · 01/10/2022 09:30

Why not stay then given you could have extra money and flexible working and not have the inconvenience of a new job?

Because of the commute

pandy2 · 01/10/2022 09:30

Why not stay then given you could have extra money and flexible working and not have the inconvenience of a new job?

BadNomad · 01/10/2022 09:29

B isn't taking it personally - B doesn't actually give a shit about A. B is just thinking of themselves and how annoying it will be to have to go through the process of recruiting and training another person again. That's life.

LadyWithLapdog · 01/10/2022 09:25

Unless it was truly disastrous for my career, as B warns. Lots of factors in play.

LadyWithLapdog · 01/10/2022 09:24

properdoughnut · 01/10/2022 09:21

Even if you could get 80k working nearer home?

Well no, of course I’d take the money and the shorter commute! 💰

properdoughnut · 01/10/2022 09:21

LadyWithLapdog · 01/10/2022 08:59

😂 me too

Even if you could get 80k working nearer home?

LadyWithLapdog · 01/10/2022 09:19

Ah, 24 miles isn’t that far. I can see why you hadn’t realised it would take so long. I did that distance as well for a couple of years. It was taking me about 45 minutes (a combo of city, motorway and country driving).

SunnySusan83 · 01/10/2022 09:16

I think B is being unreasonable in taking it all so personally. Lots of companies are having to offer excellent packages in order to recruit in certain industries and I think there's a lot of previously content people having their heads turned. It is all business as so many others have pointed out.

worriedatthistime · 01/10/2022 09:15

B , A owes B nothing its jobs and not personal

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 09:13

LadyWithLapdog · 01/10/2022 08:58

OP, I said B was unreasonable. However, just how could you not have predicted the commuting time? How far is it in miles? Sounds like at least 50 miles? That’s a long way from home. I did that too, as I had no choice, but it was killing me and I too moved asap.

24 miles. I've never travelled that way before so had no idea the pinch points would be that bad.

OP posts:
Calphurnia88 · 01/10/2022 09:09

NoSquirrels · 01/10/2022 08:11

No one is unreasonable.

A is entitled to resign.
B is entitled to feel annoyed about it.

This.

Although B doesn't change A, so B needs to accept that this is business and move on (and reflect on why this is the 4th person in this role in 3 years).

billy1966 · 01/10/2022 09:05

Neither are unreasonable.

However B is a little naive in thinking that someone doing a 90 minute commute won't ALWAYS keep an eye out for a job that doesn't involve that length of time.

Commuting is wasted time.

I did an hours commute for a year (for a work assignment) and I remember registering the difference in my energy levels when I returned to a 10 minute walk to my original office. I was only 25 at the time!

My husbands company (Pharma) are having huge difficulty getting people back into the office.

Several long term, highly valued staff, have flat out said 1 day a week for meetings only, or they walk.
It has been accepted.
They are no longer prepared to do the commute.

B needs to look at their recruiting package and include flexible working terms to help retain staff.

A has nothing to feel guilty about IMO.

Congratulations on loosing that commute, it will be life enhancing.

YellowTreeHouse · 01/10/2022 09:04

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 08:52

To be fair I started in January when a lot of people were still WFH so the journey was 45 minutes which is feasible. The traffic situation has massively changed and it's adding at least another 45 minutes on which I would never have predicted

You couldn’t possibly have predicted that most people were stopping WFH and that traffic would increase? 🤨

LadyWithLapdog · 01/10/2022 08:59

glitterfarts · 01/10/2022 08:55

For 75k I'll do it. And stay more than a year.

😂 me too

LadyWithLapdog · 01/10/2022 08:58

OP, I said B was unreasonable. However, just how could you not have predicted the commuting time? How far is it in miles? Sounds like at least 50 miles? That’s a long way from home. I did that too, as I had no choice, but it was killing me and I too moved asap.

glitterfarts · 01/10/2022 08:55

For 75k I'll do it. And stay more than a year.

NippyWoowoo · 01/10/2022 08:54

SirChenjins · 01/10/2022 07:49

I’m guessing you’re A?!

It's obvious, these posts are so tiresome. Lots of detail for A, it's clearly A? 😂

YABU for this post OP, HTH

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 08:52

olympicsrock · 01/10/2022 08:31

Both are a bit unreasonable.
A should not have taken a job so far form home without discussing flexible working at the outset. They have been less than truthful about their committment to the job

B should have offered flexible working and better pay earlier to ensure the job was competitive. Understandably frustrated to have to recruit again.

To be fair I started in January when a lot of people were still WFH so the journey was 45 minutes which is feasible. The traffic situation has massively changed and it's adding at least another 45 minutes on which I would never have predicted

OP posts:
Jalepenojello · 01/10/2022 08:51

B is being unreasonable

properdoughnut · 01/10/2022 08:49

Well as A stop giving a crap what B thinks.

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 08:47

Testina · 01/10/2022 07:50

Neither, they’re just opinions.
It’s tiresome that you - whether you’re A or B - think posters are incapable of answering without this “won’t say who I am” nonsense. It’s as bad as a reverse 🙄

Thank you everyone for your comments. I'm actually A.

However, I absolutely disagree with this ^^ the whole tone of the replies changed once people seems to think I was B. I'm a regular poster so I know that's how AIBU works sometimes hence I wanted to see which side people picked when they didn't know which one was the OP.

OP posts: