Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable here?

115 replies

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 07:39

I am A or B- I don't want to say which do it doesn't skew answers. I've not included salaries as a stealth boast - just for context in terms of level of post.

A - senior manager in a business support function line managed by B. Started £75k role in late January- job is approx 1.5 hour commute each way from A's home. Notice in first year is 1 month, after that it's 3 months. Enjoying the job, excellent feedback and has consistently fed back how committed they are to role/organisation. Resigned on Friday for a new role closer to home - about 25 minutes- on a little bit more money. Has given 1 month notice including a week of which they are in a precooked holiday. A says they didn't aim to mislead - but the job came up and they went for it. Feels that B has taken the resignation personally.

B - A's line manager - senior senior manager. Really pleased with A's work. Received resignation on Friday. Upset, disappointed and a bit pissed off that A has been lying about commitment to role as would have taken another candidate on if it had been known they would leave so soon after joining. Has offered A payrise and flexible working to stay but A still wants to go. Has fed back to A that the move is career limiting due to changing sectors and that they do feel personally let down.

Who is unreasonable here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 13:15

Herejustforthisone · 01/10/2022 12:50

I’m wondering if B is why there have been quite such a high turnover in A’s role.

Not really,

1- left because didn't want to return to work on site (that's fair enough and our business is mostly on site so wfh is limited). Had been in post around 2 years.

2- left on capability grounds after 6 months

3- interim for 6 months covering before I joined.

OP posts:
Herejustforthisone · 01/10/2022 12:50

I’m wondering if B is why there have been quite such a high turnover in A’s role.

billy1966 · 01/10/2022 12:23

declutteringmymind · 01/10/2022 11:38

While B is being unreasonable, A needs not to give a shit but say something like 'It's a shame that you can't understand why I have taken this role, and I hope it's not a reflection of what I thought was an excellent working relationship. Of course, if there was anything that you could have done to make me stay, then I would have come to you first, but this role meets needs for me that this company cannot. I am determined to part in good terms on my part, and will do what I can to make the handover process as smooth as possible'

Then don't look back!

This.

If the OP has worded hard and done a fair days work for her pay, she owes her boss/ company nothing more than that.

She is only in the place 5 minutes.

B needs to figure out why she can't retain staff and try harder.

That is on B.

declutteringmymind · 01/10/2022 11:40

Just read your update. Tbh I'd be a bit miffed if I was B and I wasn't given the opportunity to offer you flexi working. Especially now that you've said that you would have taken it. Hope it doesn't bite you on the bum.

declutteringmymind · 01/10/2022 11:38

While B is being unreasonable, A needs not to give a shit but say something like 'It's a shame that you can't understand why I have taken this role, and I hope it's not a reflection of what I thought was an excellent working relationship. Of course, if there was anything that you could have done to make me stay, then I would have come to you first, but this role meets needs for me that this company cannot. I am determined to part in good terms on my part, and will do what I can to make the handover process as smooth as possible'

Then don't look back!

BirdinaHedge · 01/10/2022 11:34

But I do think A might have been clearer about priorities around the commute etc.

Hearthnhome · 01/10/2022 11:34

BadNomad · 01/10/2022 11:30

No, it's when you think someone else's actions or words are about you. What B is doing is thinking selfishly.

And I don’t think there’s a problem with that.

A is thinking selfishly
so is B.

BirdinaHedge · 01/10/2022 11:31

Neither is unreasonable.

A is sensible to take the new job; B is justified in being pissed off, for reasons given.

BadNomad · 01/10/2022 11:30

marcopront · 01/10/2022 11:00

Isn't the definition of taking it personally, only thinking about them self.

No, it's when you think someone else's actions or words are about you. What B is doing is thinking selfishly.

SerenaTee · 01/10/2022 11:21

It was pretty obvious you were A! Obviously not unreasonable to take a new job that suits you better but also not unreasonable for B to feel disappointment at having to recruit another person to the role so soon again.

TimeforZeroes · 01/10/2022 11:21

A did what we’d all do. B could’ve countered with a higher wage offer but A would still be totally reasonable to go.

EL8888 · 01/10/2022 11:17

B. They also need to grow up a bit. It’s nothing personal after all, it’s just work

Cw112 · 01/10/2022 11:15

You're loyal to a job so long as you work there not to the death! Employees are always entitled to look for better opportunities, further their career or better their work life balance. Its not unreasonable for B to encourage A to stay since they're happy with their work and A is not unreasonable to leave given it sounds like a great opportunity for them . I don't think anyone is being overly unreasonable in this scenario.

billy1966 · 01/10/2022 11:14

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 09:51

So would I have if I hadn't been offered £82k much closer to my house saving me at least £300 a month on tip in fuel and early morning childcare

Its a no brainer.

Also from the point of view of emergencies with your children.

Congratulations and good luck.

TheHoover · 01/10/2022 11:03

It was blindingly obvious you were A

marcopront · 01/10/2022 11:00

BadNomad · 01/10/2022 09:29

B isn't taking it personally - B doesn't actually give a shit about A. B is just thinking of themselves and how annoying it will be to have to go through the process of recruiting and training another person again. That's life.

Isn't the definition of taking it personally, only thinking about them self.

RhubarbFairy · 01/10/2022 10:51

Congratulations on the new job.

DH also works 25 miles from home. Since WFH full-time, he and everyone else have refused to go back to the old way, even though management are pushing for it. On a clear run (mainly motorways) it's 20 minutes. But some days it can be over an hour each way due to the pinch points you mentioned. When the DC were small he might not see them some days as he had to be out early and back late just to avoid the pinch points and also be able to park. The balance is much better now.

At the same time I also worked 25 miles (non mororways). Took me a minimum of an hour and cost me a fortune in fuel and breakfast club. Changed to one 10 minutes away a month before lockdown. Life changing.

KeepYaHeadUp · 01/10/2022 10:24

Congratulations on the new job, OP!

KeepYaHeadUp · 01/10/2022 10:23

B is BA. A doesn't owe an employer, or line manager, anything.

Brigante9 · 01/10/2022 10:10

B is U to think that A was lying about their commitment. It’s just a job, not a vocation.

IncompleteSenten · 01/10/2022 10:01

If you are the 4th person in 3 years to quit then B is doing something very wrong.

The role needs to be more attractive.

LadyWithLapdog · 01/10/2022 09:59

OP, the flexi working sounds good on paper but can you imagine having to log on from home for another 2 hours? Not when you have a better offer. Good luck!

IncompleteSenten · 01/10/2022 09:58

Neither of them.
A is doing what is right for them which is fine. It's a job.

B is pissed off that they now have to recruit again. Fair enough. It's a hassle.

If you really really need someone to be in the wrong then I'd say B for taking it personally and thinking A owes them anything.

bossorworker1 · 01/10/2022 09:56

pandy2 · 01/10/2022 09:53

But doesn't flexible working mean wfh so the commute is no longer such an issue?

No, I was offered 1 day from home and to change my hours to 10-4 in the office +2 hours at home each day so I could avoid rush hour. To be fair, I would have taken them up on it if I didn't have an offer in hand.

OP posts:
pandy2 · 01/10/2022 09:53

But doesn't flexible working mean wfh so the commute is no longer such an issue?

Swipe left for the next trending thread