Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The good old Mumsnet Council housing debate

141 replies

QuandaleDingle · 30/09/2022 22:14

You know all you people who demand that council tenants have their long tenancies taken off them and have their rents increase ??

Why don't you INSTEAD demand that the government makes shitty insecure private renting better ? And becomes more affordable and secure.
Or even better than that, build more council homes so anyone who wants or needs one can have one.

Rather stick the boot in on council tenants out of some sort of spite and ...jealousy ? I also think snobbery comes into it

It's a race to the bottom for some peeps🤦‍♀️ I'm not a council tenant btw but I have been.

OP posts:
Quincythequince · 01/10/2022 09:57

£100k to build (borrowed from central)

Yes, for one house, sure.

I get the basic maths.

But we are talking about building potentially millions of homes, so now let’s do the maths.

Doesn’t seem so great now does it.

Look at that level of borrowing….to build houses for many that don’t need it?

Where is the justification. There is none.

Threadkillacilla · 01/10/2022 09:54

@Quincythequince social I've covered.
economic.
(Local authority, HA work a bit different)
Simplified a council house works like this,
£100k to build (borrowed from central)
First 10 years income repays the loan, house is new/warranty so repairs covered.
after that rental is repair, maintenance, tenants levy other social incentive and infrastructure plus a small capped profit.
it pays for itself.

TraceyGerbil · 01/10/2022 09:54

My cousins grew up on a small council estate in North London. Nice area, leafy, parks. Their road was 3 and 4 bed semis and there was a big grassy “roundabout” at the end of the cul de sac where the kids used to play out. The houses had good sized gardens and it was a great place to grow up, and a great community. These houses are now largely inhabited by one or two old people, who can’t cope with the gardens, and it feels rundown and unkempt. These were fabulous family homes and surely should be again, with the old people encouraged to move and families brought in.

Fuwari · 01/10/2022 09:51

The big problem is 2 bed vs 3+ bed. I’m in London and have seen people with one child get housed relatively quickly, usually 12-18 months. The problem comes when they have more DC and end up waiting years (if they ever get it at all) for a bigger place. Then you get into the ethical arguments. Should they have had more children than they could accommodate? Should an older person be turfed out to then accommodate them? Is having more than one child a “luxury” that only the better off can afford?

Yes there are cases where women are say fleeing DV with maybe more than one child, but they actually get priority. I know because I was in this situation myself. If you’re in a refuge you place highly on the waiting list because the refuge space is needed for others.

As for high earners in council accommodation. That’s rare. My earnings are ok. Professional role but frontline public sector so the pay isn’t huge! Yes, because my rent is relatively low, I have a reasonable amount of disposable income but not enough to rent privately. But it seems there is a view that people in SH shouldn’t have any disposable income at all. Why is that?

Quincythequince · 01/10/2022 09:49

Was meant to say KK and co appear to have …

Quincythequince · 01/10/2022 09:48

5128gap · 01/10/2022 09:46

Where is the money cominv from? Thats almost amusing this week. Suffice to say, its not going to cost £65 billion is it?

That doesn’t really answer the question.

We are in dire financial straits, and all and Co appear to have made things worse.

Doesn’t change the situation as it is now though does it.

Why should anyone who wants it, get a council house?

What is the social and economic justification for this?

5128gap · 01/10/2022 09:46

Quincythequince · 01/10/2022 08:59

WWhy so we need to build enough council houses for anyone who wants or needs one?

Where the hell is this money coming from?

And of course it’s subsided. What on earth is the PP who said that they weren’t, talking about.

Where is the money cominv from? Thats almost amusing this week. Suffice to say, its not going to cost £65 billion is it?

Porcupineintherough · 01/10/2022 09:46

@GeorgeorRuth so you don't think that quality, location or extent should come into it? So a 5 bedroom house set in an acre of grounds with stables or a penthouse flat in Central London with access to pool and gym should be capped as the same price as a 2 bed flat in Hackney?

Not everyone who rents does so because they can't get a council house.

Threadkillacilla · 01/10/2022 09:45

People like GP s used to live locally and if the surgery was in a SH estate they lived in SH. There was plenty then and they did often have owned homes elsewhere but if you look at older hospitals they tend to be beside estates that provided SH for nurses and doctors. It fosters investment in communities and would be ideal if there were no shortages.

GeorgeorRuth · 01/10/2022 09:45

berksandbeyond · 01/10/2022 09:32

Why on earth would someone be jealous?

I don't agree with council housing or benefits except in the most extreme circumstances. It's a lifestyle choice for far too many people who moan about their crap life but are unwilling to do anything themselves to change it.

Did the pandemic teach nothing. The most valuable people then were the ones on shitty pay doing jobs the more affluent don't/ won't do. Presumably you are happy to pay the cleaner, shop worker, carer, etc 3 times the current going rate, so they don't need benefit to pay someone else's mortgage on their investment property.

inheritanceshiteagain · 01/10/2022 09:44

The rule where one person or a couple can remain in a 3 bed house because their family have grown up and left needs to be better enforced. I know a single man in a 3 bed house because his father died and no one else lived there. Crazy.

Quincythequince · 01/10/2022 09:43

Newrumpus · 01/10/2022 09:25

Where I live there is housing being built at unprecedented rates so there is clearly plenty of money for this.

Properties which are rented pay for their own maintenance.

I don’t think that private landlords and mass builders consider that other people are paying for or subsiding them, it is just the way the economy works. We are all reliant on each other.

Private landlords needs more regulation, no question.

But the alternate to a poor private housing isn’t council housing for all.

There is something in between.

retractablerule · 01/10/2022 09:43

I live in a new build HA property in a very nice, sought after town. My rent is sensible and much lower than comparable private rented. I get repairs done relatively easily although it's mainly sorting out new build snags as it's so new.
There is a lot of jealousy in the area from people who never applied for a house here. They assumed they wouldn't get one and people have moved from quite long distances to be here. There was a local link priority for applications. There are single people and couples in 2 bedroom properties.
I work in a senior professional health role and have a good wage but following a messy divorce I was never going to be able to buy my own place.
I feel privileged to have a beautiful house with a garden that is secure for me and my children. My previous private rental was poorly maintained and was owned by a local businessman who holds an enormous portfolio in the town and doesn't treat any tenants well.
There should be more estates like ours, more opportunities for quality homes and secure tenancies. The vast majority of people who live here work and the ones that don't are SAHM's with a working partner, disabled or retired.
I proudly tell people I live in a council house.

berksandbeyond · 01/10/2022 09:41

@Newrumpus Libraries are great. I'm confused with how you think using a library and living in a council house are comparable but okay? 😐

Quincythequince · 01/10/2022 09:40

Threadkillacilla · 01/10/2022 09:23

As to why should they because the society we live in benefits us all. Despite not needing SH myself I benefit because we have less homelessness, poorer children are housed accordingly, disabled people are housed and to prevent ghettos and poverty stricken areas we need a mix of people. RTB and big windfalls have queered the pitch imo, I think we need to go back to the old principles so that there is enough SH so that the GP can have a council house beside his surgery and the headmistress has one beside the school.
I'm going for utopia here but the true benefits of SH have been muddied deliberately.

A GP doesn’t need subsidised housing.

Not everyone needs to be subsidised!

Why suggest subsidising people who don’t need it, but would take advantage of it anyway.

Lolliepoppie · 01/10/2022 09:39

Threadkillacilla · 01/10/2022 09:23

As to why should they because the society we live in benefits us all. Despite not needing SH myself I benefit because we have less homelessness, poorer children are housed accordingly, disabled people are housed and to prevent ghettos and poverty stricken areas we need a mix of people. RTB and big windfalls have queered the pitch imo, I think we need to go back to the old principles so that there is enough SH so that the GP can have a council house beside his surgery and the headmistress has one beside the school.
I'm going for utopia here but the true benefits of SH have been muddied deliberately.

I can just imagine the doctors (on their drs salaries) jostling for position in the queue to live in a council house slap bang next to their surgeries.
Utopia indeed! 🙄

Threadkillacilla · 01/10/2022 09:38

Porcupineintherough · 01/10/2022 09:30

@Threadkillacilla but you are OK with someone going to a restaurant if they don't want to restrict themselves to what's available on their estate? So if they'd rather rent than live in whatever housing the state deems suitable, why can't they?

One thing is saying that there should be adequate social housing available. Another is insisting people live in it.

No I dont, I don't think people should be forced to live in SH at all. I think it should be an available option of someone does want it.

GeorgeorRuth · 01/10/2022 09:37

I have always thought that private rents should be capped to the same as local authority level.

I would vote for a party that pledges a large scale council house building programme.

In this day and age, secure homes should be a right not a privilege. A privilege which for some provokes jealousy and hostility as it is now only available for those further down the social scale.

Newrumpus · 01/10/2022 09:35

berksandbeyond · 01/10/2022 09:32

Why on earth would someone be jealous?

I don't agree with council housing or benefits except in the most extreme circumstances. It's a lifestyle choice for far too many people who moan about their crap life but are unwilling to do anything themselves to change it.

Do you agree with public libraries or do you think they should only be used by the most desperate too? Is there any need for local authorities at all in your view?

berksandbeyond · 01/10/2022 09:32

Why on earth would someone be jealous?

I don't agree with council housing or benefits except in the most extreme circumstances. It's a lifestyle choice for far too many people who moan about their crap life but are unwilling to do anything themselves to change it.

Porcupineintherough · 01/10/2022 09:30

@Threadkillacilla but you are OK with someone going to a restaurant if they don't want to restrict themselves to what's available on their estate? So if they'd rather rent than live in whatever housing the state deems suitable, why can't they?

One thing is saying that there should be adequate social housing available. Another is insisting people live in it.

Threadkillacilla · 01/10/2022 09:26

Quincythequince · 01/10/2022 09:17

There is no argument that housing shouldn’t be an investment sector at all.

If I can afford to by a house, not rely on anyone to subsidise my costs, why not?

You want communism then?

Socialism not communism yes.

Threadkillacilla · 01/10/2022 09:25

Porcupineintherough · 01/10/2022 09:22

Really? And do you feel the same about food?

Access to food as a basic human right? Yep. We should be allowed to grow or buy food and if there is no way to do that society (benefits) should be available.

Newrumpus · 01/10/2022 09:25

Quincythequince · 01/10/2022 09:10

Where is all the money coming from the build all these houses. And maintain them?

Why do so many people in this country expect other people to subsidise and indeed pay for them. Why?

Where I live there is housing being built at unprecedented rates so there is clearly plenty of money for this.

Properties which are rented pay for their own maintenance.

I don’t think that private landlords and mass builders consider that other people are paying for or subsiding them, it is just the way the economy works. We are all reliant on each other.

Threadkillacilla · 01/10/2022 09:23

Quincythequince · 01/10/2022 09:15

Shelter is a basic human right yes,
I also agree with the principle of council housing and helping those who need it.

Means tested though.

And no, not everyone who wants one should get one. Why should they?

As to why should they because the society we live in benefits us all. Despite not needing SH myself I benefit because we have less homelessness, poorer children are housed accordingly, disabled people are housed and to prevent ghettos and poverty stricken areas we need a mix of people. RTB and big windfalls have queered the pitch imo, I think we need to go back to the old principles so that there is enough SH so that the GP can have a council house beside his surgery and the headmistress has one beside the school.
I'm going for utopia here but the true benefits of SH have been muddied deliberately.