Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The good old Mumsnet Council housing debate

141 replies

QuandaleDingle · 30/09/2022 22:14

You know all you people who demand that council tenants have their long tenancies taken off them and have their rents increase ??

Why don't you INSTEAD demand that the government makes shitty insecure private renting better ? And becomes more affordable and secure.
Or even better than that, build more council homes so anyone who wants or needs one can have one.

Rather stick the boot in on council tenants out of some sort of spite and ...jealousy ? I also think snobbery comes into it

It's a race to the bottom for some peeps🤦‍♀️ I'm not a council tenant btw but I have been.

OP posts:
HighlandPony · 01/10/2022 11:49

Threadkillacilla · 01/10/2022 08:56

I used to hate RTB with a passion but you can't argue with the impact it has on social mobility. Even the discounts are funded from the rental income. I do despise the hoarding of the proceeds by central, the income from RTB should be kept by local gov and used to build replacement property.

Not even social mobility but to be able to stay put. When you’ve got five generations in the village and you’re living in a house that could be taken away. A was to ensure that my kids have a place to stay if they want to stay in the village they grew up in. I’m in Scotland so we don’t have the bedroom tax but there’s other things your house can be taken for and getting older was my fear. My families roots are in the villages for near 300 years. The deal when I bought mine was you had to offer it back to the council before you could sell it on the open market because it was a pressurised area

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 01/10/2022 11:45

LuffleGro · 01/10/2022 10:25

And water? And energy?

Landlords are providing a service at a price people are prepared to pay. If they weren't prepared to pay then the landlord wouldn't get tenants. One of the driving forces behind high rents is the shortage of supply. The less property is available the more rents will go up. Drive the private landlords away (as has been done with changes to tax rules) and there will be less rental property available and the prices will inevitably go up. It is not private landlords' responsibility to provide affordable housing any more than it is a supermarket's responsibility to provide affordable food. I don't see people raging at Tesco for daring to make a profit.

That may be for some landlords. But you cannot deny that a high proportion of landlords see Landlord Dave across the road renting his house out for £100 more than them per month but reckon their house is nicer so they raise the rent they charge by £150 per month. They don't need the money from the increase but if they can increase it because people are desperate enough to pay it why not?

vivainsomnia · 01/10/2022 11:34

If the government invested in providing more social housing there would be less people looking to rent privately and that would bring the private rents down too
No. This would lead to exactly what is happening now. Landlords would sell, and those who can't afford to buy would have even less options. The government doesn't want this. They want the tax put upon landlords which caused so many to sell because there is little or no profits to be made for many and led to the current shortage.

5128gap · 01/10/2022 11:30

Oh, and let's not forget the particularly lucrative exploitation that is the HMO.

5128gap · 01/10/2022 11:26

LuffleGro · 01/10/2022 11:05

But what is driving up the prices is (lack of) availability of property to rent. If there were more places to rent than people looking to rent the prices would go down because the landlords would be competing for tenants. At the moment the pressure is upwards because there aren't enough rental properties available for the people that need them.

If the government invested in providing more social housing there would be less people looking to rent privately and that would bring the private rents down too. That way the people who get social housing win because they have affordable rents and the private renters win because those rents fall as well.

I'm not sure where in the country you can rent houses out for multiple times the mortgage cost? The rule for buy-to-let mortgages is that the rent should cover 125% of the mortgage payments so that you can cover the costs of maintenance and void periods. Around here you'd be very lucky to get much more than that.

I completely agree that if there was more affordable social housing it would have a positive effect in pushing down extortionate private rents. Maybe even to the point landlords would sell up and there would be more options for first time buyers, pushing house prices down too. As far as I can see that would be an entirely positive outcome.
As for rent and mortgage, where I live you can still buy a modest 3 bed house for £130k, on a 25 year mortgage, around £450m. The LHA figure for a 3 bed property if £600m. Only the landlords who are prepared to take tenants on benefits charge as 'little' as this. Most charge at least £850. So, while multiple times the cost of a mortgage was an exaggeration, its still significantly more.

vivainsomnia · 01/10/2022 11:17

Yet so many people pay private landlords profits instead, so many welfare benefits are given to private landlords
It amazes me how many people can be so judgemental whilst totally lacking knowledge.

I, like many landlords, pay 40% of my rental income to the government. The rest goes into paying the interests on the mortgage, the numerous fees, repairs, insurance etc... I make about £1k a year profit if that. I pay the mortgage through my day to day job so I hope it is paid by the time I retire.

That's why the government doesn't want to totally avoid private renting. They get much more income back from it then from any social rental without all the problems dealing with tenants.

Grapewrath · 01/10/2022 11:17

I’m so privileged to live in council housing
My home is right in the coast and is council because it used to house the grounds men council workers years ago. I have cheap rent and my next door neighbour bought their house for 400k. I feel extremely lucky.
The snobbery and nastiness on places like mumsnet is unreal and unusually down to jealously tbh.
i do get it, council housing is really cheap so I understand why people are envious, but the bitterness is unreal

LuffleGro · 01/10/2022 11:05

5128gap · 01/10/2022 10:39

People can only be considered 'prepared to pay' for things that are optional. It simply doesn't apply to essentials, does it? If a loaf of bread went up to £5, people wouldn't be buying it because they were prepared to pay it, but because otherwise they couldn't eat.
Private landlords are taking cheap properties off the housing market, often charging their tenants multiple times the mortgage cost had the tenant been able to buy it instead, trapping people in the rental market because they can't afford to save due to artificially inflated rent, and creating the conditions they need to profit from other people. Which yes, of course, is how business works, but it's a very damaging business, that should never have been allowed to thrive to the extent it has.

But what is driving up the prices is (lack of) availability of property to rent. If there were more places to rent than people looking to rent the prices would go down because the landlords would be competing for tenants. At the moment the pressure is upwards because there aren't enough rental properties available for the people that need them.

If the government invested in providing more social housing there would be less people looking to rent privately and that would bring the private rents down too. That way the people who get social housing win because they have affordable rents and the private renters win because those rents fall as well.

I'm not sure where in the country you can rent houses out for multiple times the mortgage cost? The rule for buy-to-let mortgages is that the rent should cover 125% of the mortgage payments so that you can cover the costs of maintenance and void periods. Around here you'd be very lucky to get much more than that.

5128gap · 01/10/2022 10:39

LuffleGro · 01/10/2022 10:25

And water? And energy?

Landlords are providing a service at a price people are prepared to pay. If they weren't prepared to pay then the landlord wouldn't get tenants. One of the driving forces behind high rents is the shortage of supply. The less property is available the more rents will go up. Drive the private landlords away (as has been done with changes to tax rules) and there will be less rental property available and the prices will inevitably go up. It is not private landlords' responsibility to provide affordable housing any more than it is a supermarket's responsibility to provide affordable food. I don't see people raging at Tesco for daring to make a profit.

People can only be considered 'prepared to pay' for things that are optional. It simply doesn't apply to essentials, does it? If a loaf of bread went up to £5, people wouldn't be buying it because they were prepared to pay it, but because otherwise they couldn't eat.
Private landlords are taking cheap properties off the housing market, often charging their tenants multiple times the mortgage cost had the tenant been able to buy it instead, trapping people in the rental market because they can't afford to save due to artificially inflated rent, and creating the conditions they need to profit from other people. Which yes, of course, is how business works, but it's a very damaging business, that should never have been allowed to thrive to the extent it has.

Mangolist · 01/10/2022 10:34

Screamifyouwanttogofast · 30/09/2022 22:23

Jeez, spot the nimby. It’s hardly Hong Kong here!

Where I live - booming, but worst for economic inequality in the country - there are at least four massive new private housing estates being pout up at any one time. Plenty of room if there is money to be made

luckylavender · 01/10/2022 10:31

userxx · 30/09/2022 22:20

Or even better than that, build more council homes so anyone who wants or needs one can have one.

Because the UK is massive 🙄

There's plenty of room actually

Newrumpus · 01/10/2022 10:28

berksandbeyond · 01/10/2022 09:41

@Newrumpus Libraries are great. I'm confused with how you think using a library and living in a council house are comparable but okay? 😐

council housing and council libraries are both run by councils.

ChilliBandit · 01/10/2022 10:28

High private rents are primarily driven by high mortgages due to lack of supply due to buy to lets. A self fulfilling prophecy.

Newrumpus · 01/10/2022 10:27

Quincythequince · 01/10/2022 09:43

Private landlords needs more regulation, no question.

But the alternate to a poor private housing isn’t council housing for all.

There is something in between.

There doesn’t need to be council housing for all. There can be council housing for all that want it.

LuffleGro · 01/10/2022 10:25

Porcupineintherough · 01/10/2022 09:22

Really? And do you feel the same about food?

And water? And energy?

Landlords are providing a service at a price people are prepared to pay. If they weren't prepared to pay then the landlord wouldn't get tenants. One of the driving forces behind high rents is the shortage of supply. The less property is available the more rents will go up. Drive the private landlords away (as has been done with changes to tax rules) and there will be less rental property available and the prices will inevitably go up. It is not private landlords' responsibility to provide affordable housing any more than it is a supermarket's responsibility to provide affordable food. I don't see people raging at Tesco for daring to make a profit.

ChilliBandit · 01/10/2022 10:21

LuffleGro · 01/10/2022 10:18

It's subsidised because the capital investment comes from the government. If the rent had to cover the cost of building/buying the property as well as running and maintaining the property then the rents would be higher.

www.gov.uk/government/news/86-billion-for-affordable-homes-to-give-boost-onto-housing-ladder

FWIW I think we should be investing far more into social housing and it should be much more widely available to those who need it. The number of people waiting to be housed adequately is a disgrace. But it is subsidised (as it should be).

That amount is to build all homes, only 1/4 of homes in the scheme will be for social rent. The amount from that total actually allocated to social housing will be minuscule. The last time I did the accounts for a social housing association (about 4 yrs ago) the government grant was about £3,000 per new house. I wouldn’t call that a subsidy. Private developers get more than that to boost their profits through help to buy.

LuffleGro · 01/10/2022 10:18

badgermushrooms · 01/10/2022 09:20

Can those of you confidently alleging that social housing is subsidised please for the love of God go and look up the concept of a housing revenue account.

It's subsidised because the capital investment comes from the government. If the rent had to cover the cost of building/buying the property as well as running and maintaining the property then the rents would be higher.

www.gov.uk/government/news/86-billion-for-affordable-homes-to-give-boost-onto-housing-ladder

FWIW I think we should be investing far more into social housing and it should be much more widely available to those who need it. The number of people waiting to be housed adequately is a disgrace. But it is subsidised (as it should be).

Threadkillacilla · 01/10/2022 10:17

Quincythequince · 01/10/2022 10:07

Ok, so we don’t actually disagree with housing for those who need it.

I’ve said that that’s a priority.

That wasn’t the basis of your position though.

I know, that's why I said my utopia would be the old principles.
As for affordability though you surely must see that not building is a false economy. The money spent on emergency housing and topping up private rents would be better spent on social housing and infrastructure instead of vehicles for profit in the private sector.
years of labouring to the private sector mean we will have to pay double whilst we build but the current system isn't sustainable.

ChilliBandit · 01/10/2022 10:11

Private rents due to inflated house prices or greed have really skewed people’s perception of what is a reasonable rent, therefore social rent looks subsidised but it’s not.

ChilliBandit · 01/10/2022 10:09

Quincythequince · 01/10/2022 08:59

WWhy so we need to build enough council houses for anyone who wants or needs one?

Where the hell is this money coming from?

And of course it’s subsided. What on earth is the PP who said that they weren’t, talking about.

It is not subsidised. Housing associations take on commercial loans to build housing due to the lack of government funding, they fund themselves via selling homes they build under shared ownership and rents received and they do make a surplus. They work on economies of scale. If you are talking about people who receive housing benefit, not all housing association tenants receive that and it’s a separate issue. Don’t make claims you know nothing about.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 01/10/2022 10:08

The vitriol spouted about LA & HA tenants living in homes where they are not bursting at the seams stem from the high private rental prices.

I pay £400pcm on my 3 bed council home (built in the 70's). When we moved in (2016) our neighbour opposite was paying 500pcm private rent for a mirror image of our home but with a much better interior and kitchen. They moved out and the current occupiers are paying £750pcm.

A smaller 3 bed mid terrace home at the end or our cul-de-sac fully refurbished is paying £950pcm.

There were 14 3 bed council houses built in my cul-de-sac in the 1970's. 4 of them are still council. 2 familes bought their council house in the 80's and still live there. 5 are now private rentals charging double the council rates and the remaining have been sold on.

Quincythequince · 01/10/2022 10:07

Threadkillacilla · 01/10/2022 10:04

Sure it wouldn't be a priority for now We should just look to solve the crisis and build enough to get people housed who need it and people who are stuck in bnbs.
the money we save in emergency housing costs can then go to the social project.

Ok, so we don’t actually disagree with housing for those who need it.

I’ve said that that’s a priority.

That wasn’t the basis of your position though.

5128gap · 01/10/2022 10:07

People need to stop seeing local authority owned housing as a benefit for the deserving poor, and a stop gap until they can do the 'right thing' sort themselves out and buy their own home.
This was never the principle behind it. The idea was to provide an option for affordable housing that people could choose to take up if they couldn't afford, or DIDN'T WANT to buy.
Too many people drunk the kool Aid and now believe home ownership is both desirable and the default, and if you don't own property you must endeavour to change that at the earliest opportunity.
And where has that led us? To a severe shortage of affordable homes; to people unable to move out of the family home until years after they want to; to social housing estates stigmatised, neglected and deprived as limited housing must be disproportionately allocated to vulnerable people, with little mix of demographic; to a disproportionate number of tenants on benefits, so yes, unable to pay rent (hence the oft referred to subsidies); to an exploitative private rental sector where by to let landlords push cheaper properties further from the reaches of people who would like to buy, and do many other issues to numerous to list.
Of course it's possible to build more social housing. The decision not to is entirely political because keeping SH as a scarce resource supports a certain political ideology.

Threadkillacilla · 01/10/2022 10:04

Sure it wouldn't be a priority for now We should just look to solve the crisis and build enough to get people housed who need it and people who are stuck in bnbs.
the money we save in emergency housing costs can then go to the social project.

Quincythequince · 01/10/2022 10:04

But let’s also talk about the lack of schools, GPS and general infrastructure in many places too.

Gotta build all of these too if building new homes as well, and we are already short in those areas too.

Where is the money coming from?

More schools, GPS and other basic components of infrastructure are needed before council houses for all.