Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The good old Mumsnet Council housing debate

141 replies

QuandaleDingle · 30/09/2022 22:14

You know all you people who demand that council tenants have their long tenancies taken off them and have their rents increase ??

Why don't you INSTEAD demand that the government makes shitty insecure private renting better ? And becomes more affordable and secure.
Or even better than that, build more council homes so anyone who wants or needs one can have one.

Rather stick the boot in on council tenants out of some sort of spite and ...jealousy ? I also think snobbery comes into it

It's a race to the bottom for some peeps🤦‍♀️ I'm not a council tenant btw but I have been.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
cawfeee · 02/10/2022 12:41

And no, we shouldn’t have enough council houses for everyone. How is that a good idea and how logistically and economically would that work
Social housing should be available for anyone that wants it, the people that want it are those on lower incomes and those living in insecure shitty private housing. People that can afford to buy their own properties do not want to live in social housing.
That's why when given the option to buy their council houses many people did.
The idea that if you were to create more social homes, suddenly every 'shit hot' lawyer and doctor in town will be selling up to move in one and therefore unsustainable is laughable.

longleggitybeastie · 02/10/2022 11:51

What would happen if buy to lets were only given if rent chargable was no more than the local housing allowance?

Probably still an awful lot of mortgages paid for by the public purse through housing benefit, which sits really uncomfortably with me (I don't blame others for doing it, it's legal and we're all just trying to survive at the end of the day!).

MrsSkylerWhite · 02/10/2022 09:52

Realityloom · Yesterday 17:29
@MrsSkylerWhite hahah you said where is the money going for SH?? Lots of houses have been up 30 plus years. They don't do their repairs BUT they still get the rent and the SERVICE charges. Yet a lot of repairs are not done, cheaply done or not done at all and the houses are a run down shit hole. Why is is this!“

I think you’re confusing me with someone else?
I agree with you.

Valeriekat · 02/10/2022 07:36

Lolliepoppie · 01/10/2022 09:39

I can just imagine the doctors (on their drs salaries) jostling for position in the queue to live in a council house slap bang next to their surgeries.
Utopia indeed! 🙄

In mu Dad's school in the 70s and 80s several teachers lived on the quite rough council estate.

Valeriekat · 02/10/2022 07:34

This is a global problem now. So many new big houses being built in rural areas without infrastructure.

So much property being bought to rent for big profits by big money interests (pension funds etc) pricing ordinary people out of the market.

It will take a big paradigm shift to solve this problem and currently neither political party has a plan
We do need council property to be built but no one wants to live in a high rise which would be the most efficient way of houses lots of people. It works in Singapore though.

Maybe we should look at the HDB model in Singapore.

giggly · 02/10/2022 01:44

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 01/10/2022 10:08

The vitriol spouted about LA & HA tenants living in homes where they are not bursting at the seams stem from the high private rental prices.

I pay £400pcm on my 3 bed council home (built in the 70's). When we moved in (2016) our neighbour opposite was paying 500pcm private rent for a mirror image of our home but with a much better interior and kitchen. They moved out and the current occupiers are paying £750pcm.

A smaller 3 bed mid terrace home at the end or our cul-de-sac fully refurbished is paying £950pcm.

There were 14 3 bed council houses built in my cul-de-sac in the 1970's. 4 of them are still council. 2 familes bought their council house in the 80's and still live there. 5 are now private rentals charging double the council rates and the remaining have been sold on.

And this is the problem with private landlords/ businesses charging absolutely what they want and people having g no other options but to pay. Fair rent law needs to be implemented at local levels to stop all this nonsense. There was a previous post that asked how landlords are supposed to pay for repairs if there is rent caps which would reduce their profits, easy answer there is to sell. Absolutely no sympathy from me for private landlords

StarbucksSmarterSister · 02/10/2022 01:32

I can just imagine the doctors (on their drs salaries) jostling for position in the queue to live in a council house slap bang next to their surgeries.

It's a long time ago now but my granny's doctor lived across the road from her (his surgery was in his large house). On a council estate. He didn't own the house, it came with the job.

HighlandPony · 02/10/2022 00:32

witchesbubblebath · 02/10/2022 00:23

I've said for a long time that there needs to be a cap on how many properties a landlord can own and a cap on rent charges. I can't see it happening but I wish it would happen.
I'm saying that as a person on disability benefits that has hugely struggled in the past finding affordable housing.

Yes!! This. And no air b&bs in pressured areas

witchesbubblebath · 02/10/2022 00:23

I've said for a long time that there needs to be a cap on how many properties a landlord can own and a cap on rent charges. I can't see it happening but I wish it would happen.
I'm saying that as a person on disability benefits that has hugely struggled in the past finding affordable housing.

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 02/10/2022 00:00

When I was private renting when I was single before I had my child, private renting was literally a casino bet. There were sooooooo many people for every single property that the letting agent would collect up all the application forms and the Landlord would pick the best applicant. So despite the fact that I had more than sufficient income, that I had proof that I'd never missed a rent payment in 21 years of private renting, that I had pristine references and a guarantor if required - I NEVER got chosen as the Landlord always^^ chose the couple who were the wealthiest. At one point I was viewing 1-4 properties per day(!) and got refused for every single one.
This is what is wrong with the private renting market. Unless you're the Doctor & Dentist who are minted but not planning to buy for whatever reason, then they'll you've no chance! Private landlords who don't use agents always have a pre-existing list of people wanting somewhere so they never need to advertise. The only way I eventually found somewhere (after 19 months of quite literally daily viewings), it was only because 2 months prior I'd resorted to offering a year's rent in advance!!! (Even then some landlords still didn't choose me as others did the same! It's absolute pure madness

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 01/10/2022 23:46

romany4 · 30/09/2022 22:32

I'm in a HA house. My rent goes up every single year without fail.
And don't even ask about trying to get a repair done ...they are still saying minimum 3 months because Covid!

Goes up? I've been in my HA new build for 3 years and my rent has only ever gone down! It was £550 until 3 months ago when it went down to £470. It really shouldn't be going up

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 01/10/2022 23:44

AlwaysGinPlease · 30/09/2022 22:28

Jealous? Unlikely.

And do the snobbery begins

Sarasandman · 01/10/2022 23:42

Quincythequince · 01/10/2022 09:40

A GP doesn’t need subsidised housing.

Not everyone needs to be subsidised!

Why suggest subsidising people who don’t need it, but would take advantage of it anyway.

It isn't subsidised. It's rented.

Sarasandman · 01/10/2022 23:42

Lolliepoppie · 01/10/2022 09:39

I can just imagine the doctors (on their drs salaries) jostling for position in the queue to live in a council house slap bang next to their surgeries.
Utopia indeed! 🙄

This is normal in London. Plenty of academics, teachers, NHS staff, politicians, artists, you name it in social housing, as was the original aim.

Sarasandman · 01/10/2022 23:38

Quincythequince · 01/10/2022 09:10

Where is all the money coming from the build all these houses. And maintain them?

Why do so many people in this country expect other people to subsidise and indeed pay for them. Why?

As others have pointed out: it isn't subsidised. Tenants pay rents. These rents are lower than private rentals because private landlords make higher profits. The rents from council tenants used to be used by the council, but we're later redirected to central government. Social housing tenants' rents are used for the greater good of society rather than to subsidise private landlords' lifestyles.

And, even were it not so, why wouldn't you want to subsidise/ support your fellow creatures?

Realityloom · 01/10/2022 17:29

@MrsSkylerWhite hahah you said where is the money going for SH?? Lots of houses have been up 30 plus years. They don't do their repairs BUT they still get the rent and the SERVICE charges. Yet a lot of repairs are not done, cheaply done or not done at all and the houses are a run down shit hole. Why is is this!

ChilliBandit · 01/10/2022 17:03

SOCIAL HOUSING IS NOT SUBSIDISED BY THE GOVERNMENT. The vast majority of councils no longer keep their own housing stock, it’s passed over to Social Housing Associations who are not for profit or mutual societies. They take out commercial multi million pound loans to cover building. These are paid back through shared ownership, right to buy and rents.

Also to the landlords, you pay 40% on profits not income. Why should you get more tax breaks to pay off the capital on your assets? No one else does.

HighlandPony · 01/10/2022 16:00

MrsSkylerWhite · 01/10/2022 12:17

Quincythequince · Today 09:10

Where is all the money coming from the build all these houses. And maintain them?

Why do so many people in this country expect other people to subsidise and indeed pay for them. Why?“

the system was screwed when the Conservative Govt. that devised right to buy purloined the receipts and prevented LAs from ploughing them back into social housing.

Maybe because they subsidise them in other ways that aren’t monetary. Let’s face it if it wasn’t for folk like home carers or nursing home staff or childminders and nursery staff how many folk in better paid positions would be fucked and forced to quit work to look after their kids or elderly relatives? But do these people get paid fairly for allowing people to live and not have to do it? No. So they need top up benefits or subsidised housing because they do the job the families either can or don’t want to

Porcupineintherough · 01/10/2022 13:12

@5128gap but you couldn't, not really. You'd need to add on money for insurance and running repairs at the very least. Wouldn't be as much as the rental cost but far more than just the mortgage. And that's without big long term costs like new heating systems, replacing double glazing, new roof etc

One of the things that shocked me most about moving from rented to home ownership is how many on-costs there are.

5128gap · 01/10/2022 12:23

vivainsomnia · 01/10/2022 11:34

If the government invested in providing more social housing there would be less people looking to rent privately and that would bring the private rents down too
No. This would lead to exactly what is happening now. Landlords would sell, and those who can't afford to buy would have even less options. The government doesn't want this. They want the tax put upon landlords which caused so many to sell because there is little or no profits to be made for many and led to the current shortage.

No, its not exactly what's happening now. A very important part is missing. The part where we build more SH. If we had sufficient SH it wouldn't matter in the least if landlords sold, because fewer people would require the private sector.

5128gap · 01/10/2022 12:19

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 01/10/2022 12:09

A landlord has to pay tax on the rental income, so the net rental income has to be sufficient to cover the mortgage and potentially any voids. At 20% tax £600pm would barely cover the mortgage let alone any void periods. If the landlord is on 40% tax then the rent needs to be higher just to meet the mortgage.

You can't compare the cost of the mortgage against gross income, it has to be against net. (note to Central Gov't)

I'm not comparing the rent charged against the landlords mortgage. I'm comparing the cost of the rent to the tenant against the cost to that same tenant if they were paying a mortgage to live in the property.
You could buy and live in the same house you're renting for £850m at a cost of £450m, and own it at the end. However, because of the high rent, people can't save the deposit.

MrsSkylerWhite · 01/10/2022 12:17

Quincythequince · Today 09:10

Where is all the money coming from the build all these houses. And maintain them?

Why do so many people in this country expect other people to subsidise and indeed pay for them. Why?“

the system was screwed when the Conservative Govt. that devised right to buy purloined the receipts and prevented LAs from ploughing them back into social housing.

Laughingravy · 01/10/2022 12:17

One capital city is regularly voted a great place to live and 2/3 of its citizens live in social housing. Average cost to rent is 25% of household income, the rent is set to cover costs plus maintenance and not by some specious 'market'. Low paid households get extra subsidies and so key workers can afford to live in the city and near their place of work. The city owns some 200,000 homes and subsidies a further 200,000 owned by housing associations. They invest in new homes as the population grows rather than paying housing benefits to the private sector. In this city social housing is for all, not just the poorest.

This is what we should be striving for but instead we have had successive governments where the profit motive trumps everything...

Oh yes and that city is Vienna. And it isn't the only city to take such an enlightened view on housing. Bilbao, Rotterdam and Singapore have similar schemes. 80% of Singapore's population live in social housing on 99 year leases. (Info taken from Chapter 2 of Go Big by Ed Miliband.)

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 01/10/2022 12:09

5128gap · 01/10/2022 11:26

I completely agree that if there was more affordable social housing it would have a positive effect in pushing down extortionate private rents. Maybe even to the point landlords would sell up and there would be more options for first time buyers, pushing house prices down too. As far as I can see that would be an entirely positive outcome.
As for rent and mortgage, where I live you can still buy a modest 3 bed house for £130k, on a 25 year mortgage, around £450m. The LHA figure for a 3 bed property if £600m. Only the landlords who are prepared to take tenants on benefits charge as 'little' as this. Most charge at least £850. So, while multiple times the cost of a mortgage was an exaggeration, its still significantly more.

A landlord has to pay tax on the rental income, so the net rental income has to be sufficient to cover the mortgage and potentially any voids. At 20% tax £600pm would barely cover the mortgage let alone any void periods. If the landlord is on 40% tax then the rent needs to be higher just to meet the mortgage.

You can't compare the cost of the mortgage against gross income, it has to be against net. (note to Central Gov't)

StarCourt · 01/10/2022 12:07

I'm in a SO 2 bed flat with DD13 and DDog. After splitting with XH 10 yrs ago there wasn't enough equity for a deposit on a new place and even though I've always worked FT I couldn't afford a mortgage. so I had to
Private rent at a much higher rate than a mortgage which meant I had no shot at saving either. When I hit 55 last year I took a private pension lump sum to buy a share in a SO property. So I now pay significantly lower rent to a HA and have no mortgage but also no pension.