Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Looks like a junior doctors strike is coming. Reasonable or unreasonable?

206 replies

Erica56 · 30/09/2022 21:14

www.bma.org.uk/pay-and-contracts/pay/junior-doctors-pay-scales/fair-pay-for-junior-doctors-in-england

OP posts:
floorida · 01/10/2022 09:02

@Foxinmygarden thank you for answering.

There seems to be a massive issue across society where younger people have seen pay not go anywhere, conditions not so favourable & life costing more. At uni I worked in a saturday job & got more the NMW today & that was decades ok. How on earth can it be fixed?

Theimpossiblegirl · 01/10/2022 09:01

I was just coming back to this thread to say that I hope people are seeing the support. It's refreshing. The media is not on our side.

I'm an exhausted primary teacher too. I've worked until 11 every night this week to free up a bit of time this weekend as it's my dds birthday tomorrow. I was really proud that I've 'only' got to do a few hours in the evening on Sunday.

nameychangey6 · 01/10/2022 08:54

Junior doctor here. Really touched to see so much support.

I haven't gone into training after my foundation years. Currently, I'm limping along with enough locums to keep myself skilled but I'm not sure I'll stay. I feel a complete shell of who I was when I started medical school. So many of my colleagues have left medicine or gone abroad. The ones who have stayed all feel like I do.

Working as a junior doctor is a death by 1000 cuts. It's changing department every 4-6 months (and, within each placement, sometimes changing ward/team weekly!), it's always being new and expected to fit in and know what to do, it's a hideous bullying culture, it's anti whistleblowing, it's hours of eLearning in your own time, it's thousands of pounds in fees/exams / equipment/moving house / travel / parking, it's long long hours, it's trying to do the job of 3 people safely knowing that no one will have your back if something goes wrong, it's bearing the brunt of permanent colleagues' (and patients') frustration as you are an easy target, it's being rotaed to work your own wedding, it's coming to work to be sent home as you're needed for a night shift that night instead (and it's being very frowned upon to actually have your own life and plans outside work), it's getting home and studying for more exams, it's having to uproot your family and never being able to settle, it's sitting on a bin in meetings because there are no chairs, it's sharing one computer with 2 other doctors and 6 nurses even though you all need it to do any of your jobs, it's 14 hour shifts with nothing to eat and no time to go to the loo, it's IT never working, it's being expected to come in 30 minutes early and leave 1 hour late and being too scared to exception report, it's being completely beholden to your awful rota and job because you need your seniors to sign you off as competent and write you references, it's 80+ hour weeks (silly 17 year old me didn't realise the 48 hour working week was averaged out!), it's emotional battering with no space or time to debrief, it's watching your senior colleague's cry quietly in their offices and realising it doesn't get better, it's patients telling you you don't care when really you can't sleep for thinking about them but you don't have the resources to make things better for them and you're just fire fighting, it's watching all of your friends out-earn you, it's feeling isolated because none of your friends want to hear about your job - you're definitely lying about your pay and hours. And ultimately, it's not safe. I can't remember the last time I worked on a fully staffed rota. Mistakes happen, and things get missed - a lot flies under the radar as it gets sorted out in the end, but patient care suffers. I didn't go into training for that.

PS. To the lovely nurses on this thread, I have your back too. The NHS is sadly home to some bullies who shout very loud. But it's also full of lots of kind people. I'll always remember my first weekend (and second ever shift) - I cried in the store room whilst one nurse hugged me and then helped me plan my jobs out. When I got back to the doctor's room, another nurse had left me a pile of biscuits. I was so flustered I didn't even realise it was her first ever shift! Their kindness meant so much to me and I hope they knew that.

Foxinmygarden · 01/10/2022 08:49

floorida · 01/10/2022 08:37

What has happened to doctors t&cs over the years? I have a couple of family friends who were/are consultants & they are all extremely comfortable.

As a consultant I take home a fairly decent wage. It's the junior doctors who are struggling. Their pay simply hasn't increased in line with the cost of living and other professions. A junior doctor posted her payslip on twitter last week. I am not joking when I say that I took home exactly the same as a first year doctor in 2001. Admittedly part of this was due to the pay banding I received for antisocial hours, but it's still not right.

At the other end, many colleagues are retiring early or reducing hours because of the pension tax situation. I know people who have received 5 figure tax bills.

RitesOfSaussage · 01/10/2022 08:41

The more teachers, doctors, nurses and other professionals feel like this the more the very fabric of our society erodes.

RitesOfSaussage · 01/10/2022 08:41

sydenhamhiller · 01/10/2022 07:46

DC1 has just started at med school last week and his father and I (non medics but have medic friends) both tried to dissuade him.

Look at XXX who works in pharmaceuticals/ research/ the City. The hours they work, the bonuses. Think how aunt YYY and Uncle ZZZ’s stories (the hours, the under staffing, the mismanagement).

And that is terrible. Working in healthcare is amazing. We should have been encouraging it. But as my 16 year old rather histrionically said to dc1 ‘you’ll never make it to my wedding as a doctor’. (No wedding imminent!)

I am a primary teacher, and found that I cried 4 times on Monday. Cried nearly every day last week. Thought perhaps my age, dc1 starting at uni, me losing what marbles are left etc etc. Then at a well being staff meeting (my well being would have been enhanced being able to get my marking done), 4 other colleagues I spoke to had been crying at work that week. And they are just the ones I spoke to.

I know we are not being blown up abroad, and not as stressful as A&E, I tell myself that a lot when I feel desperate. But surely this is not right…

If anyone else in any other sector feels like this, I fully support their right to strike. And it is not a race to the bottom: agreeing that their terms and conditions are not right does not mean that others are not worse.

Thanks

I know we are not being blown up abroad, and not as stressful as A&E, I tell myself that a lot when I feel desperate. But surely this is not right…

The more teachers, doctors, nurses and other professionals feel like this there the very fabric of our society erodes. Your suffering is not an isolated case, it's how things now are for many people. Impossible targets, meaningless 'wellbeing' interventions 🤐instead of tackling and reforming what doesn't work. Each and everyone of us who is finding our professional lives increasingly stressful and impossible are a symptom of this country's failures.

I support teachers' strikes too.

floorida · 01/10/2022 08:37

What has happened to doctors t&cs over the years? I have a couple of family friends who were/are consultants & they are all extremely comfortable.

RitesOfSaussage · 01/10/2022 08:36

Medicine is no longer an attractive career to many, because of the pay compared to other professions. We need to turn this around. We need motivated and intelligent doctors.

Absolutely!

TheHoover · 01/10/2022 08:27

Reasonable. They only got 2% in the last pay rise. Consultants and very senior managers by comparison got 4%.
Senior managers and clinicians got 1-2% (this includes the highest qualified and most experienced non-medical clinicians in the workforce ie nurse consultants, consultant pharmacists, senior matrons etc). BTW if anyone wants to say senior managers in the NHS don’t work hard, I am ready for a fist fight with you right now.

MissyB1 · 01/10/2022 08:23

Foxinmygarden · 01/10/2022 08:09

As a hospital consultant, I fully support them. Many foundation year doctors today take home less pay than I did as a house officer 20 years ago.

Medicine is no longer an attractive career to many, because of the pay compared to other professions. We need to turn this around. We need motivated and intelligent doctors.

Consultants will be striking next because of the pensions fiasco.

@Foxinmygarden
Yrs my dh is a consultant and he will totally support his juniors striking, as he did last time.
And don’t get me started on the pension thing….. 🤦‍♀️😡

And all members of mumsnet need to know this Government are now planning more austerity measures to pay for those tax cuts. Your already badly damaged public services are about to get even worse.

Cosycover · 01/10/2022 08:17

Long overdue I'd say.

GreenGreenArse · 01/10/2022 08:16

Agreeing with all of you. The Tories seem to be trying to kill off the NHS by underfunding it.

Foxinmygarden · 01/10/2022 08:09

As a hospital consultant, I fully support them. Many foundation year doctors today take home less pay than I did as a house officer 20 years ago.

Medicine is no longer an attractive career to many, because of the pay compared to other professions. We need to turn this around. We need motivated and intelligent doctors.

Consultants will be striking next because of the pensions fiasco.

Youaremysunshine14 · 01/10/2022 08:00

Absolutely reasonable. Truss' ally Simon Clarke, the so-called Levelling Up secretary, has given an interview to The Times overnight basically saying another age of austerity is coming because they plan to cut public spending again to pay off Govt debts – which, let's not forget, have accumulated even higher by them refusing to levy a windfall tax on the energy firms. Our public services are on their knees already and that is their solution to prop up tax cuts to higher earners. I hope every public sector worker from junior doctors to teachers to bin men to librarians goes on strike now. I will support every single one of them.

lobsterkiller · 01/10/2022 07:52

Of course they're reasonable. Striking happens when you have run out of options. I'm currently involved in an industrial dispute too. Its bloody awful, not where I want to be, but I'm damned if I'm/we going to be walked all over anymore.

sydenhamhiller · 01/10/2022 07:46

DC1 has just started at med school last week and his father and I (non medics but have medic friends) both tried to dissuade him.

Look at XXX who works in pharmaceuticals/ research/ the City. The hours they work, the bonuses. Think how aunt YYY and Uncle ZZZ’s stories (the hours, the under staffing, the mismanagement).

And that is terrible. Working in healthcare is amazing. We should have been encouraging it. But as my 16 year old rather histrionically said to dc1 ‘you’ll never make it to my wedding as a doctor’. (No wedding imminent!)

I am a primary teacher, and found that I cried 4 times on Monday. Cried nearly every day last week. Thought perhaps my age, dc1 starting at uni, me losing what marbles are left etc etc. Then at a well being staff meeting (my well being would have been enhanced being able to get my marking done), 4 other colleagues I spoke to had been crying at work that week. And they are just the ones I spoke to.

I know we are not being blown up abroad, and not as stressful as A&E, I tell myself that a lot when I feel desperate. But surely this is not right…

If anyone else in any other sector feels like this, I fully support their right to strike. And it is not a race to the bottom: agreeing that their terms and conditions are not right does not mean that others are not worse.

walkingonsunshinekat · 01/10/2022 07:44

Northernlurker · 30/09/2022 21:34

Well I work in the nhs and I don't think it's reasonable. Yes they are underpaid but if they aren't at work people are going to die. This is not 6 years ago, we can't absorb this safely. It's a total nightmare.

But people are dying right now waiting for treatment or even an ambulance and if nothing is done, more junior Doctors will leave, along with all the other nhs staff required.

Then there will be even more chaos in healthcare.

Any additional deaths are on the Tories, just as the current ones are, Truss borrowed 67billion to fund tax cuts, including removing £21billion in funding for the NHS via the reversal in NI rises.

Anyway, no health service union is saying they wont staff emergency care in any strike action.

holidayelbow · 01/10/2022 07:36

@RainbowCat26 seem to be is key here. Any Job can look overworked and underpaid and there is a very effective campaign to get everyone to believe this of junior doctors. I don't know if it really is tbr universal truth

lannistunut · 01/10/2022 07:32

RainbowCat26 · 01/10/2022 07:28

accidentally selected unreasonable 🤦‍♀️ But I think it’s reasonable. They seem to be vastly underpaid and overworked.

Not that it matters but you can switch your vote

RainbowCat26 · 01/10/2022 07:28

accidentally selected unreasonable 🤦‍♀️ But I think it’s reasonable. They seem to be vastly underpaid and overworked.

RitesOfSaussage · 01/10/2022 07:22

We support this.

Ds is looking seriously into studying medicine to become a doctor. Is there any way he can support striking Junior Doctors? We live near London.

Spudina · 01/10/2022 07:15

Totally reasonable. I worked through the last junior Drs strike and we managed. The Consultants did all the ward rounds, decision making, test ordering etc supported by nurses. A lot of nurses undertake the extended roles historically undertaken by Junior Drs anyway. We can make it work for a couple of days. I fully support them, and I know our team of Drs will fully support the nurses when we walk out.

holidayelbow · 01/10/2022 07:08

I am going against the grain here but I don't agree with the strike.

My friend is a junior doctor. Did her F1 and F2 full time. She has two full weeks holiday in between each rotation. Whilst she was busy - she did regular hours and had time off.

She is now part time and sometimes becuase of how it works can go a whole wee k without working, and then she sometimes picks up locum shifts and gets £££££ for it.

Young lads in Afghanistan got blown up on 18k year. No one seemed to be bothered about those super low paid roles.

Zuve · 01/10/2022 06:58

Maybe they will, the NHS is in crisis. We must all value it more

KvotheTheBloodless · 01/10/2022 06:56

It's absolutely reasonable to strike, I fully support them. They are underpaid, massively overworked and have extremely poor working conditions. They have to pay for their own insurance and training, it costs thousands every year. So many leave for Aus or NZ now, where the pay is lots better and there's actually a work-life balance for doctors.