Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Looks like a junior doctors strike is coming. Reasonable or unreasonable?

206 replies

Erica56 · 30/09/2022 21:14

www.bma.org.uk/pay-and-contracts/pay/junior-doctors-pay-scales/fair-pay-for-junior-doctors-in-england

OP posts:
RitesOfSaussage · 01/10/2022 11:19

thebabessavedme · 01/10/2022 11:00

I have spent most of the last 24hours in an assement ward with my elderly mother - NOTHING would induce me to work in any part of the NHS, I cannot describe the chaos (this is after I was told I was looking at a 6 hour wait for an ambulance for dm who was collapsed on a car park floor) I have had to change my DMs incontinance knickers, wash her, make her comfy etc, the staff were like blue arsed flies they were so busy, the beds were not cooling down from one patient to the next the turn over was so quick. Yet despite everything, everyone who treated my dm was professional, kind, caring and respectful. I would like to thank all the staff because frankly I think I would have stood in the middle of the ward and cried if I was being asked to work like this. Please do what you feel you must to improve conditions, not only for junior doctors but all staff, this cannot go on, this is just a snapshot of one old lady's care, if that includes striking then so be it!

👏excellent post. I'm sorry about your mum's situation. Thanks

avocadotofu · 01/10/2022 11:19

They are paid a pittance, so they are definitely not being unreasonable!

CanaryShoulderedThorn · 01/10/2022 11:14

My husband teaches A level chemistry, previously he had many children in his class go on to study medicine, now no one aspires to.

I personally know 2 medics who have given up practicing due to stress, one is now a yoga teacher and the other opened a coffee shop.

Who can blame them.

noblegiraffe · 01/10/2022 11:06

missbipolar · 01/10/2022 10:50

How does this work in practice? Like if there's zero Jr doctors then surely this puts patients and risk? Especially given the current nursing situation as well?

Patients are already at risk.

Not striking won't improve that. Trying to emotionally blackmail the people who are holding public services together on a shoestring by suggesting that they are the ones endangering patients by having working conditions so poor that they are forced to take action is not on, IMO.

The government are responsible for the terrible conditions. If terrible conditions lead to strike action which further endangers patients then that is doubly their fault.

thebabessavedme · 01/10/2022 11:00

I have spent most of the last 24hours in an assement ward with my elderly mother - NOTHING would induce me to work in any part of the NHS, I cannot describe the chaos (this is after I was told I was looking at a 6 hour wait for an ambulance for dm who was collapsed on a car park floor) I have had to change my DMs incontinance knickers, wash her, make her comfy etc, the staff were like blue arsed flies they were so busy, the beds were not cooling down from one patient to the next the turn over was so quick. Yet despite everything, everyone who treated my dm was professional, kind, caring and respectful. I would like to thank all the staff because frankly I think I would have stood in the middle of the ward and cried if I was being asked to work like this. Please do what you feel you must to improve conditions, not only for junior doctors but all staff, this cannot go on, this is just a snapshot of one old lady's care, if that includes striking then so be it!

Shinyhappyperson22 · 01/10/2022 10:58

I work in the NHS and support anyone that voted/votes to strike. It is shit and has just got worse and worse. Less staff, more workloads, huge waits, extra shifts. It is already UNSAFE for patients. I’m always on at my dad to take his meds and be careful etc because I would not want him in a hospital right now.

There is always money for other things like high pay tax cuts but not for public services which are all now run into the ground. Enough. We’ve had years of this shit and it just gets worse.

TabithaTittlemouse · 01/10/2022 10:54

Northernlurker · 30/09/2022 21:34

Well I work in the nhs and I don't think it's reasonable. Yes they are underpaid but if they aren't at work people are going to die. This is not 6 years ago, we can't absorb this safely. It's a total nightmare.

As a nurse I am completely behind the junior doctors.
We have had so maybe junior doctors close to breaking, questioning why they chose this role and not being able to see a way out. Some are already completely broken. They can’t continue as they are.

TheNinny · 01/10/2022 10:51

Nurses, admin, porters and domestics are balloted soon as well. Likely will be a yes so brace yourselves. Totally justified though 👍

missbipolar · 01/10/2022 10:50

How does this work in practice? Like if there's zero Jr doctors then surely this puts patients and risk? Especially given the current nursing situation as well?

Ireolu · 01/10/2022 10:48

My husband is a consultant and is happy for them to strike. He and his senior colleagues are willing to cover on the day that those who wish to strike won't be at work. I am also a clinician and we fully support a junior doctors strike.

RitesOfSaussage · 01/10/2022 10:46

Apparently the Toris don't mind increasing their own wages.

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11259343/Council-free-school-meals-expenses.html

Local Tori councillors reject extra £660,000 for free school meals… minutes before approving pay boost to their OWN allowances because 'we're all affected by cost-of-living' crisis.

'It doesn't matter if you live in a cottage or a manor house, we're all affected by cost-of-living increases,' said millionaire Tory cabinet member Cllr Steve Dixon.'

How about NHS staff Cllr Steve Dixon?

One word to sum these politicians up: corrupt!

RedKitchen · 01/10/2022 10:45

Northernlurker · 30/09/2022 21:34

Well I work in the nhs and I don't think it's reasonable. Yes they are underpaid but if they aren't at work people are going to die. This is not 6 years ago, we can't absorb this safely. It's a total nightmare.

Isn’t that the point? That being underpaid and undervalued and given a fucking tea bag means people are leaving for Australia/Canada etc. That the whole clap for the NHS was deemed that people should work for free as people will die, people aren’t charities.

The U.K. is given as an example in Europe of what happens when you underfund. No waiting times other countries A&E’s.

You know doctors seriously share the £60k adverts to be a train driver??

TheHoover · 01/10/2022 10:41

Yes for sure.
The pay deal was struck under the old government and I would have said a strike was maybe 50/50. But this disastrous shit show and their hell bent desire to bring the country to economic ruin whilst leaving a handful of uber-rich sorted for millennia have swung it to a 90% possibility.

newyearsresolurion · 01/10/2022 10:15

Nurses next

BelleMarionette · 01/10/2022 09:51

I just wanted to come back to say thank you for the support here. It didn't appear to be the case during the previous strikes.

To my colleagues having difficulties, hugs, and I hope you are getting the support you need, if not please pm me. I think the majority of us have been there. I have had PTSD as a result of working on the covid wards.

Bunnyfuller · 01/10/2022 09:45

I hope everyone strikes. The wealthy are exploiting all of us average people and it needs to stop.

How uncapping bankers bonuses at the same time as looking to cut benefits is seen as an acceptable path, well, if you voted Tory I hope you’re happy. I wish you knew how few police officers there are on shift sometimes. Crime is going through the roof, and there aren’t the resources to combat it.

OldManEmu · 01/10/2022 09:44

the80sweregreat · 01/10/2022 09:38

It's the inequality that gets to me
That someone such as Zoe ball ( just an example ) can have a salary of nearly half a mil as a presenter yet she couldn't save lives or put out a fire or nurse someone after a operation or do any of the things we need. I'm sure she's lovely and maybe gives to charity and her money does trickle down the economy in other ways , but some salaries are eye watering in comparison to the ones people earn doing things we actually need to function as a society.
I'm not having a go about her, but just making the comparison to more normal jobs.
I know it's not always a fair world and is what it is, but makes me realize how poor I am to someone like her in the media who earn the mega bucks.

Yep. It's the whole horrible false narrative we have in this country that the more you earn, the harder you've worked for it. If that were the case, Dr's, nurses, firefighters, teachers, armed forces, RNLI etc etc should all be millionaires.

It's the nasty party's lies that spout rubbish about the politics of envy instead of actually sorting societies ills.

paintitallover · 01/10/2022 09:43

Completely reasonable and understandable.

Toohardtofindaproperusername · 01/10/2022 09:43

What's your question really about. Everyone has the right to strike, no one takes it lightly and if you had any idea of working in the NHS right now...
What's your point of view?

floorida · 01/10/2022 09:41

And you could argue if the industry attracts billions why shouldn't those in it get a cut?

floorida · 01/10/2022 09:40

Tbf to Zoe Ball, singers, footballers etc if no one was interested, didn't tune in they wouldn't get paid.

RitesOfSaussage · 01/10/2022 09:39

How can we support junior doctors' and teachers' strikes? is there anything tangible ordinary people can do? Other than writing letters to the MP?

the80sweregreat · 01/10/2022 09:38

It's the inequality that gets to me
That someone such as Zoe ball ( just an example ) can have a salary of nearly half a mil as a presenter yet she couldn't save lives or put out a fire or nurse someone after a operation or do any of the things we need. I'm sure she's lovely and maybe gives to charity and her money does trickle down the economy in other ways , but some salaries are eye watering in comparison to the ones people earn doing things we actually need to function as a society.
I'm not having a go about her, but just making the comparison to more normal jobs.
I know it's not always a fair world and is what it is, but makes me realize how poor I am to someone like her in the media who earn the mega bucks.

JDocNC · 01/10/2022 09:35

To the poster saying that her friend had two weeks off between rotations, I’m sure she’ll have been using her AL. That is not standard at all.
What is much more likely is you’ll be rota’d on call in different hospitals miles apart whilst still being expected to attend induction. I’m not the only one who has finished a night shift in hospital A, driven an hour to hospital B, sat through a morning of useless induction (no computer log ins etc but a nice lecture on how to be more resilient or how not to set the ward microwave on fire), driven home for a couple of hours sleep then driven back to hospital B for another night shift in a specialty I’ve never worked in before and have had no specialist induction or teaching.

We have no say over our jobs geographically. I know colleagues who live away from their families in the week (at their own personal cost, we pay for hospital accommodation etc) because they’ve been allocated jobs two + hours away from home and you can’t uproot your spouse and children every year at the whims of the deanery. I know people who have moved only to be told a month before starting (when they’ve already signed a lease, husband got a new job, kids in new schools etc) that there had been a mistake and they now had to work in an entirely new location. My training scheme has decided that I need to go to a different hospital for 6 months. I currently walk to work. This new hospital is an hour and a half on public transport. We had to sell my car as we couldn’t afford to run both and my partner works a busy on call rota at a hospital an hour away. I’ll be expected to suck it up and pay for this like I pay for my indemnity insurance, my exams, my portfolio, my college membership, my GMC fees. All in all my partner and I have spent thousands this year just to be allowed to work. We have no choice in this, you don’t pay you can’t work.

The NHS is a monopoly employer. It can only run by exploiting its staff.

I’ve been in some very dark places during my career. I used to fantasise every day about how I could harm myself so I didn’t have to go back in. I’d stand by the kettle every day picking up the courage to pour the hot water over my hand in the hopes I’d get a morning off. I wouldn’t look before crossing roads in the hopes somebody would run me over.

I’ve carried three bleeps because there weren’t enough doctors. I’ve been bullied by seniors. I’ve done 12 hour shifts without eating or taking a break. I’ve been the only doctor for over 200 patients. I’ve been verbally and physically abused by patients and their relatives. I’ve had leave cancelled with one days notice. I’ve been bullied into working extra on calls (including the night before my grandma’s funeral). I’ve been consistently underpaid or worked locum shifts that then don’t get paid for 6+ months. I’ve had colleagues denied leave to go to their own wedding despite giving a years notice. I’ve worked 12+ hour shifts with a two hour round commute and then had to squeeze in some revision for my upcoming £600 exam which I have to pass in order to progress. I’ve had colleagues move across the country for a new job only to be told in an email at 4.30pm on a Friday that there’s been a mix up and they’re actually in a different hospital (never might that they’d moved house, kids had moved schools etc).
I’ve been so ill on shift that my observations were worse than some of the patients I was admitting but if I went home there was literally nobody else.
I’ve watched consultants I admire get stretched more and more thinly until they stop. And despite all this it’s not good enough. I’m not good enough. There is nothing more demoralising than running yourself into the ground mentally and physically only to spend every patient encounter apologising for this shit care you’re providing.

Conditions would be awful regardless of what we were paid but the terrible working situation combined with the (comparatively) low wage (or at least a wage that has never caught up with inflation) means that it’s becoming even less tolerable to stay. This means more are leaving (the profession, the country) which makes the whole situation worse.

The only way this makes sense is that the government are deliberately running it into the ground to make it easier to privatise.

I’m leaving. I can’t do it anymore. At times I still love it, I’ve been so privileged to be involved in some of the most impactful moments of peoples lives. When you have a good five minutes it’s the best job in the world. But I can’t remember when I last had a good five minutes. And I don’t want to be one of those doctor suicide stories.

ShadowoftheFall · 01/10/2022 09:09

Agree with @BadPaintDay

Swipe left for the next trending thread