Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Looks like a junior doctors strike is coming. Reasonable or unreasonable?

206 replies

Erica56 · 30/09/2022 21:14

www.bma.org.uk/pay-and-contracts/pay/junior-doctors-pay-scales/fair-pay-for-junior-doctors-in-england

OP posts:
Spudina · 01/10/2022 18:14

@TheNinny apologies.

TheNinny · 01/10/2022 17:48

@Spudina I think you meant to tag someone else? My post never mentioned junior doctors and I know exactly what they are, and they have my full support 🤔

Theredjellybean · 01/10/2022 16:51

Doctors do not take an oath.. Its a well loved mumsnet myth.
We do not stand up at graduation and swear the hipocratic oath... Sorry to disappoint you.
We are bound by the GMC guidance that is called Good Medical practice.

whereisthejasmine · 01/10/2022 16:41

Completely reasonable and actually overdue

Alexandra2001 · 01/10/2022 16:36

the majority of issues faced by healthcare staff currently are due to low staffing which takes years to solve, not sure how a strike will fix this

Higher pay will help with retainment and recruitment, i hope my DD strikes.

it is morally wrong to strike as a healthcare provider. Doctors specifically take an oath to 'do no harm', and I can confidently say that harm will be done in their absence

Thats on the Govt, why blame Doctors only?

the burden on other staff (nurses, nurse practitioners, secretaries, advanced clinical practitioners etc.) in their absence will be unimaginable

with so many staff leaving, thats happening already

medical students on placement will have their education severely disrupted

With no one to mentor them, they'll get sub standard training anyway.

They deserve better pay and working conditions but I do not believe that a strike is the best way to achieve this

err how? they've exhausted ALL other methods, as have ALL healthcare staff and still the Govt runs down the NHS.

e.g £5bn given to 45% tax payers (wont even notice) would give junior dr's a huge pay rise... political choices.

Pengwinn · 01/10/2022 16:32

strawberrysea · 01/10/2022 16:23

Completely unreasonable. I'm a nurse and wouldn't strike for the below reasons:

  1. the majority of issues faced by healthcare staff currently are due to low staffing which takes years to solve, not sure how a strike will fix this
  2. it is morally wrong to strike as a healthcare provider. Doctors specifically take an oath to 'do no harm', and I can confidently say that harm will be done in their absence
  3. the burden on other staff (nurses, nurse practitioners, secretaries, advanced clinical practitioners etc.) in their absence will be unimaginable
  4. medical students on placement will have their education severely disrupted

They deserve better pay and working conditions but I do not believe that a strike is the best way to achieve this.

  1. Because nothing is being done to address it at the moment. A bursary for a few thousand for some healthcare students, big whoop.
  1. It isn't morally wrong to strike, that's emotional blackmail to stop people fighting for their worth. Harm is being done to patients from the haemoraghing of staff as you'll well know as a nurse. This ideology is what has eroded pay and conditions to this point.
  1. That's the point, at some point someone has to step in and listen. All JDs I know would support strikes from nurses and other healthcare staff so to expect support for theirs isn't wild.
  1. Its already disrupted due to short staffing, savage conditions and government short cuts taking their opportunities.
Spudina · 01/10/2022 16:32

@strawberrysea I’m willing to be burdened for a couple of days if it means my colleagues get what they need and stay in the profession. I think of my worst shifts. The ones where everything went to hell and the only thing you could say was that all your patients are still breathing after your 13 hours. The ones where you didn’t feel you had time to have to eat or have bathroom breaks. What made those days slightly better was that the team supported each other and we genuinely were “all in it together”. We are nothing without each other. Support your colleagues if you want to keep them.

Scatterbrainbox · 01/10/2022 16:31

Completely reasonable.

Pengwinn · 01/10/2022 16:27

Young lads in Afghanistan got blown up on 18k year. No one seemed to be bothered about those super low paid roles

The military isn't really comparable. Free or heavily reduced accommodation, deployment enhancements, GYHP, quick progression in relation to the qualifications required for entry, soldiers out of trade training and on deployment wouldn't have been on 18k actual pay even if their base pay was.

I support junior doctors.

StJeanDeVence · 01/10/2022 16:27

What's your solution then, @strawberrysea ?

As an ex-midwife who still works closely with the NHS, I fully support the strikes.

strawberrysea · 01/10/2022 16:23

Completely unreasonable. I'm a nurse and wouldn't strike for the below reasons:

  1. the majority of issues faced by healthcare staff currently are due to low staffing which takes years to solve, not sure how a strike will fix this
  2. it is morally wrong to strike as a healthcare provider. Doctors specifically take an oath to 'do no harm', and I can confidently say that harm will be done in their absence
  3. the burden on other staff (nurses, nurse practitioners, secretaries, advanced clinical practitioners etc.) in their absence will be unimaginable
  4. medical students on placement will have their education severely disrupted

They deserve better pay and working conditions but I do not believe that a strike is the best way to achieve this.

Jojojojojowhat · 01/10/2022 16:15

Completely in support. It doesn’t need to get to the point of actually striking if the government give in and pay them fairly. But even if it does actually come to striking, the nhs coped in 2016 when this happened before.

Spudina · 01/10/2022 15:56

@TheNinny
“Junior Drs”includes all house office grades and Registrars. What happens is that the Consultants cover the wards and do rounds, usually performed by Registars. They will be supported by Nurses, Advanced Practitioners and other allied health professionals. As I said in another post a lot of historically Drs jobs (such as taking bloods, cannulating, inserting central lines, performing blood gases, taking biopsies, doing internal cameras) are now also performed by nurses and practitioners. We will pull together and make this safe. Or at least as safe as it is under current circumstances. Sending solidarity to my medical colleagues. We’ve got you.

paintitallover · 01/10/2022 15:00

When junior doctors go part time, it's mostly because part time is a full time job in most peoples judgement. They are the only people who suffer, because it takes them longer to climb the medical ladder. Nobody pays for junior doctors training on the long road to consultancy or specialist training , and they take exams for this all the time (and in their own time). The government are appalling and will lose them in droves unless they pay more.

RitesOfSaussage · 01/10/2022 14:29

The working conditions and pay are inhumane.

And a disgrace for a so called civilised country.

MrsSkylerWhite · 01/10/2022 14:04

holidayelbow · Today 07:08
I am going against the grain here but I don't agree with the strike.

My friend is a junior doctor. Did her F1 and F2 full time. She has two full weeks holiday in between each rotation. Whilst she was busy - she did regular hours and had time off.

She is now part time and sometimes becuase of how it works can go a whole wee k without working, and then she sometimes picks up locum shifts and gets £££££ for it.

Young lads in Afghanistan got blown up on 18k year. No one seemed to be bothered about those super low paid roles.“

I think anyone doubting how pressured the life of a junior doctor is ought to read/watch the TV adaptation of “This is Going To Hurt”, written by a junior doctor.

Gratefulbadger · 01/10/2022 14:01

In addition: pension been attacked twice and now essentially a tax-trap. Constant abuse in the media (daily mail). Having to move every 4-6 months during training. Being called a ‘junior doctor’ until your late 30s.

pennyfairweather · 01/10/2022 13:42

holidayelbow · 01/10/2022 07:08

I am going against the grain here but I don't agree with the strike.

My friend is a junior doctor. Did her F1 and F2 full time. She has two full weeks holiday in between each rotation. Whilst she was busy - she did regular hours and had time off.

She is now part time and sometimes becuase of how it works can go a whole wee k without working, and then she sometimes picks up locum shifts and gets £££££ for it.

Young lads in Afghanistan got blown up on 18k year. No one seemed to be bothered about those super low paid roles.

This seems to be an anomaly amongst all the posts from medics on here.

I absolutely support the strikes.

1FootInTheRave · 01/10/2022 12:55

I fully support my collegues in striking.

The working conditions and pay are inhumane.

howshouldibehave · 01/10/2022 12:55

Good to see so much support for the strikes. I hope people are as supportive with other sectors, eg teachers.

Gratefulbadger · 01/10/2022 12:54

5-6 years of uni, often >80k of debt with +6% interest, expensive GMC fees, indemnity fees, parking fees (if you can get a permit). Constant anxiety of being sued/imprisoned/GMC investigated (high suicide rate). Fear of harming/killing someone whilst trying to do your best in a completely broken system. Poor pay compared to friends of a similar / often worse academic standard. 30% pay cut over the past 10 years. I think it’d be highly unreasonable to not strike.

DOI lots of medic friends and family

MrsSkylerWhite · 01/10/2022 12:33

2pinkginsplease · Yesterday 21:38
Totally support them, having just had a relative in hospital very unwell these doctors and junior doctors work their arses off. Junior doctors are over worked and underpaid and unless something is done the NHS are going to have a huge shortage of doctors to treat patients. This needs sorted to encourage more people into this profession“

hope you’re relative is doing well now.

so torn on this. My husband would have died in 2017 without the NHS intervention.

would you support action if your relative needed to go in and couldn’t because of strike action?

CrustyFlake · 01/10/2022 12:27

I fully support the strike, and I think that paramedics and nurses should strike too.

beachcitygirl · 01/10/2022 12:23

Very reasonable. I support them fully & in fact I support any trade union voting for strike this winter.

People working full time should not have to

a) rely on benefits
b) suffer fuel or food poverty
C) get into debt

I predict a winter of discontent & general strike

Artemi · 01/10/2022 12:03

I want to say a huge thank you to the messages of support, it's really touched me.

I categorically support my nurse colleagues and other public sector workers striking. We need to stand together.

When I started work, I was so tired after shifts that I would worry that I would crash the car.
Then I started wishing I would crash so I didn't have to go to work.

My best friend and colleague took her own life. Everyone knows someone.

I have PTSD from being repeatedly awoken in the middle of the night (48 hour shift) to desperately try and fail to save someone. Now I barely sleep at all,even when not on call.

I cry before work almost every day.

The NHS has broken me.