Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what is happening in my DS school?

88 replies

Mrssalvatore123 · 30/09/2022 20:13

I have a 5 year old son. He was born at the end of August so even though he has just turned 5 he is in year 1. Lots of his class mates are turning 6 so he is the youngest by nearly a year to a lot of them.

School keep asking us in for meetings as they suspect he has ADHD. The reasons given are that in school he is easily distracted, quite tactile with staff and fidgets a lot. He is apparently behind the rest of the class with his phonics. Apparently he struggles to build relationships with adults and other children

At home there is no evidence of this. He pays attention in his extra curricular activities, he is mostly well behaved, he can write short sentences and reads his school books at home well. He loves doing “homework” tasks and telling us what he has learnt at school. He has a group of 5 or 6 good school friends and is regularly invited on play dates which he behaves well at.

School say his behaviour is good but he has all the signs of ADHD and we must get him assessed.

After the school first had us attend a meeting we were worried and took him to the doctor who said they could see no signs of ADHD. He was just young in the school year and nothing to worry about! They also said the school have a route to follow for assessment and this is not the way.

We had a call last week and had to attend another meeting with the teacher today. They stressed we must push harder with the doctor to start assessment for ADHD. We asked for examples and were told again that he needs extra encouragement to pay attention and that he fidget in class and is behind in phonics.

He has just turned 5.

I don’t want to be the parent who dismisses things but I’m at a loss. Do I keep pushing for an assessment? If he had ADHD would we see signs at home or in his other activities? My gut is that he is just little and if he had been born 2 weeks later he would be in reception.

AIBU to think the school could be wrong here?

OP posts:
HarryPotterIsAfraidOfTheDark · 01/10/2022 04:29

He sounds like a typical 5 year old. He’s younger than my 5 year old who hasn’t even started school yet (we start school older here). There’s no way he’d be sitting through a grade one lesson. Is there no option for him to repeat reception? Otherwise can your Doctor write a letter pushing it back on the school.

BananaSplitX · 01/10/2022 04:11

Omg. The school is clearly wrong and spending time in the wrong area. Your little boy is a year younger than most of his classmates. In most (if not all) European countries 5 year olds are in nursery and not school. This country puts kids into education so early and our poor kids are simply not ready. I also have a late July boy. He’s in year 2. Someone said on this tread they should be reading stage 5 phonics in year 1. My son is doing this now in year 2. Because he simply wasn’t ready in year 1. The school have no concern with him. They say he’s very young, he’ll catch up when his brain is ready. Nothing to worry about. For reference I am European. I could not write my name when I was 5. I was at nursery. I started school at 6, and was doing 1+1 at that age. I have 2 degrees. I feel
sorry for our little kids who should be playing with toys and run around, rather than be stuck in a classroom forcing their little brains to do things they are simply not meant to be doing at this age. Please push the school back. They are making your life difficult for no reason. And enjoy your little boy. He sounds amazing.

RainbowCrayons · 01/10/2022 03:43

Sorry, when you say school are pushing this, who has spoken to you? Is it just the teacher? Has the head of Early Years (if the school has one) or head teacher spoken to you? Because it is strange the SENDCO isnt involved. I would wonder how much is actually coming from the school and how much is just this teacher. I can understand to some extent. Expectations are set for the average child and the teacher is probably getting questioned and is under pressure to get all children to that level or above when it isn't reasonable especially for the summer horns. If school are telling the teacher that a diagnosis isn't appropriate yet I wonder if they are trying to get you to get one by the back door to get the leadership team off their back particularly if they aren't a confident teacher or are very new to it and not used to standing up to leadership.

Happyhappyday · 01/10/2022 03:24

Kids who are youngest in year are diagnosed with learning difficulties at a much higher rate than their peers and this persists throughout school. I’d tell school to piss off, dr does not agree with their assessment at all. They have experience with kids but ARE NOT medical professionals. If you don’t feel like they are being supportive, I would consider moving schools.

WalkthisWayUK · 01/10/2022 02:55

Stand your ground, you do not need to push on your side. What they need to do is accommodate him and you don’t need a diagnosis for that. He is not going to be magically ‘solved’ outside of school. School need to come up with a plan - keep pushing for that. Whether it’s an official Senco EHCP or just ‘a sensible plan’.

I’d ask to meet with the school and outline what the problems are - and how THEY are going to cope. Help them by looking at what you think would help e.g. less epectation that he will sit still, more movement breaks, able to fidget if he wants (there are things to try like fidget toys and chairs that you can move around or rock in) - lots of chances to move around.

Testingprof · 01/10/2022 02:39

cunningartificer · 30/09/2022 22:42

Summer born children can lag up to university age, there are lots of studies about this, but in school they're often not recognised. As a senior leader it's now one of the things I insist teachers identify in our school, along with left handedness (so they sit them on the left hand side of paired desks for example). When DD was little her teacher told me she thought she was dyslexic as she was so behind compared to her brother, who was in the school year above but September born when she was late August. I had kept his books so showed her a comparison of their writing at the exactly equivalent chronological age and next thing she was diagnosed as gifted 😂

You do realise you can be both dyslexic and gifted?

@Mrssalvatore123 as pp have said bat it back to the school. The senco should be the first contact for this type of thing. I also have a summer born boy and for us it has always been the social aspect that has lagged behind and that is still noticeable.

FatMog · 01/10/2022 01:55

Sorry Y2 not Y1.

FatMog · 01/10/2022 01:54

Not the point OP, but I think we put children in formal schooling waaay too early.

Your boy is a good lad, he behaves at home, he concentrates, and he listens. He fidgets at school and is behind in his phonics at school. He's a whole year younger than some of his friends. I think he's just not ready for school. I hope in Y1 he just gets it and catches up. Try not to worry.

ElectedOnThursday · 01/10/2022 00:15

Honestly I could weep. A school that assesses children by what are perceived to be deficits is something that belongs back in the 50s.

I would want to take him out. Your child is absolutely allowed to be exactly who he is and it is the school’s duty to meet him where he is at, not to burden him with ridiculous expectations.

L1ttledrummergirl · 01/10/2022 00:11

My ds1 is a July birthday and in the early years of primary we were constantly told that he was immature compared to his classmates.

I remember asking one teacher if they expected a newborn baby to to the same things as a 10 month old, and if not, why such a big expectation that they will be on a par after only a few years.

If the school want your ds tested when you don't feel there is an issue then they need to arrange it, it's not like gps are overrun with issues that can't be dealt with by another agency.

ThunderstomsAreComing · 30/09/2022 23:59

Mrssalvatore123 · 30/09/2022 20:13

I have a 5 year old son. He was born at the end of August so even though he has just turned 5 he is in year 1. Lots of his class mates are turning 6 so he is the youngest by nearly a year to a lot of them.

School keep asking us in for meetings as they suspect he has ADHD. The reasons given are that in school he is easily distracted, quite tactile with staff and fidgets a lot. He is apparently behind the rest of the class with his phonics. Apparently he struggles to build relationships with adults and other children

At home there is no evidence of this. He pays attention in his extra curricular activities, he is mostly well behaved, he can write short sentences and reads his school books at home well. He loves doing “homework” tasks and telling us what he has learnt at school. He has a group of 5 or 6 good school friends and is regularly invited on play dates which he behaves well at.

School say his behaviour is good but he has all the signs of ADHD and we must get him assessed.

After the school first had us attend a meeting we were worried and took him to the doctor who said they could see no signs of ADHD. He was just young in the school year and nothing to worry about! They also said the school have a route to follow for assessment and this is not the way.

We had a call last week and had to attend another meeting with the teacher today. They stressed we must push harder with the doctor to start assessment for ADHD. We asked for examples and were told again that he needs extra encouragement to pay attention and that he fidget in class and is behind in phonics.

He has just turned 5.

I don’t want to be the parent who dismisses things but I’m at a loss. Do I keep pushing for an assessment? If he had ADHD would we see signs at home or in his other activities? My gut is that he is just little and if he had been born 2 weeks later he would be in reception.

AIBU to think the school could be wrong here?

my DD was the youngest in her year - I was called in to be told that she was "below average" academically and they wanted to give her extra coaching. She was very bright, but shy. The teacher was a surprised when I responded to the "below average" remark with "well someone has to be, that's how averages work". I declined the extra teaching and she gradually caught up with the rest of the year group as she matured.

She got excellent A levels, a 2:1 degree and is doing well in her career.

Teachers don't always get it right. I was a teacher and worked with some right idiots who were wedded to attainment charts and talked about getting their class to all get "above average" results. I taught maths, it gave me the rage.

Forgetaboutme · 30/09/2022 23:47

I remember my sons first parents night was horrible when he was only 4. His teacher said he was fidgety, had language issues, sensory issues, wasn't settled, not writing well enough (at 4!!). I was so upset after it. He was also one of the youngest in the year.

We were so worried because the head teacher wanted to talk to us about referring him for further checks. He got referred for speech and language intervention but he got on fine there and was meeting all criteria for his age. Referral after referral with a big delay eventually because of covid. Anyway, now he is 9, dismissed from speech and language, no concerns after his referral to the paediatrician and getting on well in school.

Obviously not every kid is the same but I definitely think younger kids can stand out, especially boys. I wish I had deferred him because I genuinely think he would have been fine if he had one more year to mature. A lot of worry over nothing for us.

MargaretThursday · 30/09/2022 23:42

Really, I'd ask the school to refer you and see where it goes.

It's normal for them to display different behaviour at home with 1-2-1 than in a classroom environment, with or without ADHD.

My experience is that they're reluctant to refer to summer boys because they assume they'll grow out of it.
I had a ds similar to your ds. I was told he'd grow out of it again and again. He was finally diagnosed aged 13yo, when I'd been querying since preschool. I wish I'd pushed harder.
By getting the diagnosis it means that methods of help have been opened up. But more importantly it means that he knows he isn't just a "naughty boy", but he does genuinely find things more difficult. It has made a huge difference to his self-esteem.

He is far more likely to not be diagnosed when he needs to be than the other way round.

When I requested ds was referred for ADHD, they initially assessed him and said they didn't think he had ADHD, but they did want to take ASD further. After they'd diagnosed ASD, they then decided to revisit ADHD and decided he did have that after all. For both they said he was borderline but just over the criteria.

The doctor will not be a specialist in either, so I would ask the school to refer rather than you going through the GP.

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 30/09/2022 23:28

I was born on August 30th and have ADHD (I also suspect Aspergers/whatever the new name is for that now).
Being the youngest in the year was extremely difficult. Even though I was academically well in line with others (and in English, always way ahead of everyone else for some bizarre reason), I was however, socially very far behind.

My parents were given the option to keep me in year 6 for another year, rather than allow me to go to high school a few days after turning 11, however they chose not to.
Well, what a mistake that was! I cried through the entirety of year 7. I was not at all ready and was utterly bloody terrified.
It hugely affected my emotional well-being and personal growth at such an important time in a young person's development.

Whilst all the others were making connections with people they would likely have a bond with for life, I was sat crying, desperately wishing I could go back to the school I loved, understood & felt comfortable in and had learnt so much from.

I do see why my parents didn't keep me back a year though. As I said above, I wasn't behind academically so it would've been a year of repeating work I'd already done to a more than satisfactory level.
However, in that year of repeating work, I also would've grown & matured at a similar level to those around me, which would've instilled the confidence I would've needed to tackle year 7 head on, just like everyone else . My entire education would almost certainly have gone entirely more successfully (and as such quite possibly, my entire start in adult life), but oh well!

Anyway, I digress. I realise this is a few years on from your little one's stage. However I felt I'd share my perspective as a Neurodiverse summer born!

One thing is for certain, a school they feel happy & comfortable in, is quite literally fundamental. Flowers

sevencontinents · 30/09/2022 23:02

Like some other posters, I work in SEN and it is true that traits need to be seen across two settings for a diagnosis to be made. I also agree that just turned 5 is way too young to be diagnosed as some of the behaviours can be developmentally appropriate. I think it is really poor practice if a school is trying to push a parent into pursuing a diagnosis and it goes against the SEN Code of Practice, which says that parental voice should be at the centre of provision. Yes, the school should be telling you if your child is struggling but they should be working WITH you to support him, not forcing their medicalised perspective onto you when you are clearly saying that you do not see these traits at home.

You might be interested to google 'the adhd map of America'. It is interesting because it implies that ADHD is currently overdiagnosed.

GG1986 · 30/09/2022 22:45

I agree with what others have said, if school are concerned then they need to get their school senco lead to do their own assessment in the classroom and go from there. If the senco lead agrees then they can make the referral, not the doctor! You will then be sent forms to fill in, as will the teacher and then a paediatrician appointment will be made.

cunningartificer · 30/09/2022 22:42

Summer born children can lag up to university age, there are lots of studies about this, but in school they're often not recognised. As a senior leader it's now one of the things I insist teachers identify in our school, along with left handedness (so they sit them on the left hand side of paired desks for example). When DD was little her teacher told me she thought she was dyslexic as she was so behind compared to her brother, who was in the school year above but September born when she was late August. I had kept his books so showed her a comparison of their writing at the exactly equivalent chronological age and next thing she was diagnosed as gifted 😂

Blahdeebla · 30/09/2022 22:32

This sounds really odd to me (eyfs teacher), as a PP has said they can't diagnose unless it's seen across settings. I would ask the school about their transition, they should still be having access to free flow, short carpet sessions etc. Did the early years team see anything ? Did he achieve any Early Learning Goals ?

Dibbydoos · 30/09/2022 22:21

My son was seen by a speech therapist at age 3 because he was obviously mega bright but his speech wasn't always clear. They said its a boy thing.

He was diagnosed ASD 9 years later.

Sometimes early signs are there, sometimes it is just they need to catch up.

The school is being a bit aggressive imo - maybe because a diagnosis means more money for the school. Keep reading abd observing him, you will see ADHD behaviour if it's there.

Good luck.

Anothermother3 · 30/09/2022 22:17

I think you sound sensible and well informed. Most places don’t want to assess before 6 anyway because it’s not unusual for there to be some attention and concentration limitations for children before then it’s developmentally appropriate. If there is no evidence of pervasive inattention, hyperactivity and impulsivity across contexts then it sounds premature. I have adhd and I have ensured my middle child is on the assessment pathway as to me it’s obvious she has adhd. I started pushing at 6 because I know it’s a lengthy process. I just watched and waited until she was older as I know what I’m looking at both personally and professionally. Summer born children are so little they should be playing. Is he at a school that pushes test results?

Oojamaflipp · 30/09/2022 22:15

My son has ADHD and the pediatrician told us that they won't diagnose until at least 7, as until then a lot of children exhibit those traits (inattentiveness, hyperactivity etc). But by 7, most kids have grown out of it. There's no way a doctor would diagnose ADHD in a child who's just turned 5.

Stick to your guns - if the school believe there's a problem, then the senco should be involved, they should not be trying to pass the buck back to you to tell you to get him diagnosed. If there's no improvement in 2 years, by all means go down that route, but until then I would absolutely tell them no doctor will refer you at this age.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 30/09/2022 22:12

This is a thread where I'd really like to offer a nugget of hope.

Both of my children are now adults but I , until last year, worked with children with SEN , for around 20 years.

When my daughter was newly in sixth form ( at a Grammar School I might add , but we live in Kent where Grammar Schools are part of the system) she came home one day and announced that her form tutor remarked that more than three quarters of her form were summer born.

Just saying.

And , as I'd been a Sen HLTA for so many years, being summer born really doesn't make much difference above Year 2.

underneaththeash · 30/09/2022 22:04

I would start a child that young on adhd meds. Put him in the year below is he’s struggling .
adhd meds delay puberty and growth in boys. If he’s really struggling in a few years yes. But putting him back a year is surely better.

my daughter has inattentive adhd / we have not medicated her yet, but may well in the future.
we have several friends who have medicated adhd children. But not at age 5.

HelloDoggy · 30/09/2022 21:56

Can you move schools OP?

Personally I think you are doing great and sound a good mum. If it was ADHD it would show in other areas. It sounds like he's just young for the year and school don't know what they r doing.

Don't push for an assessment. What would it achieve?

CoastalWave · 30/09/2022 21:56

He could have ADHD or he may just be immature in comparison to his peers (understandable)

Honestly. It's probably just that he's young. But I would also bear in mind that teachers see lots of children your child's age. You only see your own child and their immediate friends (and birds of a feather flock together)

I teach a child whose parents are in complete denial about their child having additional needs. School have put the child on a learning programme and they still don't believe she's in need of support.