Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder what is happening in my DS school?

88 replies

Mrssalvatore123 · 30/09/2022 20:13

I have a 5 year old son. He was born at the end of August so even though he has just turned 5 he is in year 1. Lots of his class mates are turning 6 so he is the youngest by nearly a year to a lot of them.

School keep asking us in for meetings as they suspect he has ADHD. The reasons given are that in school he is easily distracted, quite tactile with staff and fidgets a lot. He is apparently behind the rest of the class with his phonics. Apparently he struggles to build relationships with adults and other children

At home there is no evidence of this. He pays attention in his extra curricular activities, he is mostly well behaved, he can write short sentences and reads his school books at home well. He loves doing “homework” tasks and telling us what he has learnt at school. He has a group of 5 or 6 good school friends and is regularly invited on play dates which he behaves well at.

School say his behaviour is good but he has all the signs of ADHD and we must get him assessed.

After the school first had us attend a meeting we were worried and took him to the doctor who said they could see no signs of ADHD. He was just young in the school year and nothing to worry about! They also said the school have a route to follow for assessment and this is not the way.

We had a call last week and had to attend another meeting with the teacher today. They stressed we must push harder with the doctor to start assessment for ADHD. We asked for examples and were told again that he needs extra encouragement to pay attention and that he fidget in class and is behind in phonics.

He has just turned 5.

I don’t want to be the parent who dismisses things but I’m at a loss. Do I keep pushing for an assessment? If he had ADHD would we see signs at home or in his other activities? My gut is that he is just little and if he had been born 2 weeks later he would be in reception.

AIBU to think the school could be wrong here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
makinganavalon · 02/10/2022 12:23

@TwoProngedFork
Sure it's revisionist History podcast, this episode called outliers, revisited.
My husband got me to listen to it as we are both born in late August and our DD is late July, but turns out things are different in Scotland so my lo will be 5 when she starts school, not just turned 4 as we were in England.

TheRubyRedshoes · 02/10/2022 10:13

@Rinoachicken

Excellent post.

Unfortunately teachers have little training in Sen needs so wouldn't know what the child is presenting.
Then senco are often just co ordinator s waiting for someone else to diagnose and tell them what to do.

TwoProngedFork · 02/10/2022 07:32

makinganavalon · 30/09/2022 20:22

I've just listened to a really interesting podcast about how huge the gap between the youngest in a year and the oldest in a year can be especially as they are younger.
It must be really hard for your little one.
I was the youngest in my year born at the end of August and this was always taken into account at my primary school- me and those others born in June, July and August were given special attention& accomodation because of our age- i.e not expected to write at the same point as they older ones.
Baffles me that this is not done in all schools? It's so obvious the difference between a five and six year old is huge!!
I would push the school to be helping him (and the others his age) more and giving them a break because they are so little.

@makinganavalon please do you mind sharing the name of the podcast. I'd really like to listen to it.

BridetoBee · 01/10/2022 14:30

@Mrssalvatore123 if you follow this link, www.nurseryresources.org/pdfs/EH7_Profile%20Exemplification_INSIDES_B&W.pdf the ELG exemplification this has lots of examples of what each area should look like for a child who is at the expected level of the end of Reception. It’s for the old curriculum but the exemplification for the new curriculum isn’t as clear unfortunately!

Melodiax · 01/10/2022 14:26

In her class of course

Isaidnoalready · 01/10/2022 14:26

Mrssalvatore123 · 30/09/2022 20:52

isle the school said there is no need to involve senco at this stage. I have to push the doctor. It’s very confusing

Nope tell them the Dr disagrees with your observation if YOU feel there is an issue YOU need to get him assessed at YOUR school

It costs them money to call someone in for assessment my secondary school paid out about £600 for an assessment and the child was off with covid that day

Melodiax · 01/10/2022 14:25

I dunno, kids birthdays are spread evenly throughout the year

You might have only one or two children born in July/August out of a whole year though, then maybe one in September, a few in October etc. They aren't evenly spread in the way that you might have equal birthdays in every month. My DD was the only one with a birthday in her month at her last school.

Andrea87 · 01/10/2022 14:21

Hi , being a summer born child may take a few years to catch up with older children, this is not uncommon.
He seems to be comfortable with cvc words dog , cat etc and high frequency words from phase 2, which is a good sign that he is blending correctly.
Phase 3 (normally also taught in reception) is much trickier as you have digraphs and trigraphs and need to realise which 2 or 3 letters make one sound. This can be a big step up from 1 letter = 1 sound.
Also different graphemes can make the same sounds or one grapheme can make different sounds.
English unfortunately is one of the most difficult languages to read and write due to the evolution of English spelling.
I make phonics games for teachers , home educators and parents who would like to give extra support. I don’t know how to get these to you though. I assume I can’t share my website on here.
Can I message you directly or is this not allowed? I don’t know if this is possible on here, but if we can message directly I can send you some helpful games for free.

Any way there are lots of ways you can help at home in fun ways and drip feeding reading and spelling into everyday activities is really useful.
He will get there. Wishing you all the best.

Rinoachicken · 01/10/2022 12:59

PDAmomma · 01/10/2022 12:25

Not sure whether all schools have the same route for assessment but where I am (Greater Manchester area), the GP doesn’t have any involvement in an ADHD diagnosis. The school are supposed to refer to the pathway themselves (which usually entails a classroom observation before they’ll even accept a referral) then you go on the never ending waiting list for assessment. In our area they won’t accept any referrals for children under 6 (and in year 2) as so many at 4-5 display adhd type symptoms which can just be normal behaviour. I also baffled as to why the SENCO isn’t involved - the SENCO should be leading on this. The process could differ depending where you live but I thought it was similar everywhere. Someone else also pointed out the ‘symptoms’ have to be present in more than one setting ie school AND home. So if you didn’t identify symptoms yourself he wouldn’t even be accepted onto the pathway. I think school are jumping the gun here massively x

This is the route for most of not all areas.

The main reason being, GPs have no idea how you child is doing at school, what they are doing or not doing. They don’t know your child at all. In order to justify the referral they would need to speak to the school to get that information.

So it was decided to cut out the middle man and have school refer directly. Makes far more sense.

Rinoachicken · 01/10/2022 12:56

I wouldn’t be prepared to waste any more of my GPs time until they can be bothered to get their own SENCO involved.

If the teacher has identified areas of need, the SENCO is the FIRST STEP, not rushing to try and get a diagnosis!

The SENCO would then observe, put plans in place where needed, the make adaptations where needed. That may be all it needs.

They should then see how the extra support goes for a while, reassess regularly. Call in an Educational Psychologist if required. If extra support on top of what they are already doing is felt to be needed, the school can apply for an EHCP to secure additional funding.

At this point (at least a year from now) it would be more evident if there were a need for a referral for diagnosis. In which case the SENCO is the one to refer to CAHMS for assessment, not your GP.

This is not something your GP can help with. They are not in contact with the your school, they don’t know you child at all, on what basis are they referring? Heresay? No. It’s done through the school that knows the child. Because they need to provide evidence of what they are seeing to support the need for an assessment.

If the teacher won’t even involve the SENCO then that to me says that this is a problem with this particular teacher. Speak to the SENCO directly yourself. They should be meeting his needs now regardless or any pending referral or not.

I think it’s a waste of everyone’s time and your emotions worrying about a referral for a diagnosis at this point.

You can just imagine it - GP makes a referral to CAMHS, CAMHS send questionnaires to the school and home, SENCO gets them and is like ‘who? I’ve never even been asked to look at this kid, no one has mentioned any problems to me, we’re not doing anything different with this child’. Parents fill out there forms and say no concerns here either!’ CAMHS will say bye! Come back when you actually have a problem!

The teacher is being beyond ridiculous.

PDAmomma · 01/10/2022 12:25

Not sure whether all schools have the same route for assessment but where I am (Greater Manchester area), the GP doesn’t have any involvement in an ADHD diagnosis. The school are supposed to refer to the pathway themselves (which usually entails a classroom observation before they’ll even accept a referral) then you go on the never ending waiting list for assessment. In our area they won’t accept any referrals for children under 6 (and in year 2) as so many at 4-5 display adhd type symptoms which can just be normal behaviour. I also baffled as to why the SENCO isn’t involved - the SENCO should be leading on this. The process could differ depending where you live but I thought it was similar everywhere. Someone else also pointed out the ‘symptoms’ have to be present in more than one setting ie school AND home. So if you didn’t identify symptoms yourself he wouldn’t even be accepted onto the pathway. I think school are jumping the gun here massively x

mamabear715 · 01/10/2022 11:59

Not RTFT but my Feb born DS showed ASD signs at school. I thought they were totally wrong at first! They were right, I was wrong.

Mrssalvatore123 · 01/10/2022 11:53

Thank you all so much for your replies. I really appreciate the support. To be clear I am 100% going to work with the school. It is a lovely school and both children are very happy there. I have requested another doctors appointment, but I find the route confusing and also the fact that we as parents, extended family and other care providers/ activity staff have not mentioned anything.

He can spell short words like cat, dog, and, the, etc. He write neatly in short sentences such as “the cat and dog go” he is comfortably reading phase 2 but he does still blend some words out loud rather than in his head but that is progressing week. To me that seemed about normal for a year 1 starter and certainly one who has just turned 5. I wish I could be a fly on the wall and see what actually happens in the classroom.

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 01/10/2022 11:03

Needafriend5 · 01/10/2022 10:19

I've been through this with my son who's 11. It has been hell I won't lie. Started in year 1 teachers saying the same thing to me as they have to you. We were quite shocked as he'd never shown any issues at home.
We agreed for the school to proceed and he was assessed. He was also observed in school by an educational psychologist. That lady said she saw nothing to indicate adhd/asd.
He was discharged by cahms and we have reams of paperwork saying no evidence of adhd/asd.
Over the years through school, we have realised its just the classroom environment he doesn't like. He does get distracted. He is never ever naughty. He has always done his work and performed well in his sats.
He has just started high school and I cannot believe the difference already. This is because he has many teachers each day and many different classes. It has solved all the problems he had a primary, and I knew it would.
Was all going well until yesterday when he brought home some paperwork from the high-school, a classroom plan for him. On which it listed his issues and that he had a diagnosis of adhd! They've told me all of this has come from the primary school. I am absolutely furious!
My advice is to stay strong, advocate for your child,

That means they've been tailoring their approach to teaching him as having the needs of somebody with ADHD, not that everything is magically fixed/all the fault of the previous school and he doesn't have it, though?

If, as it sounds, you don't want them to take it into account, you'll be expecting them to remove all adaptations/consideration and he'll likely experience a lot of difficulties as he goes through secondary - wouldn't you prefer it if he had access arrangements for exams, for example?

mrsnjw · 01/10/2022 11:01

Ahh sorry just seen he has just moved into year one. That's a massive shift for him from reception(where it is all play based). Lots more sitting at tables, writing in books and more importantly less time outside to burn off all that extra energy. Support the school to make a referral if that's what they feel is the right thing to do. If there is nothing to find they will find nothing, it's likely to be an expectation /! Age thing x

mrsnjw · 01/10/2022 10:55

They should absolutely be involving the senco. That's pretty odd not to. There is a massive difference between children born in sept and august. However, a teacher would be able to observe that's it more than age related early on. Get the senco involved. I'm teach N, R and year 1 x

TheRubyRedshoes · 01/10/2022 10:49

You said he can spell well etc?

TheRubyRedshoes · 01/10/2022 10:46

Op I'm confused by his reading ability?

T

Needafriend5 · 01/10/2022 10:19

I've been through this with my son who's 11. It has been hell I won't lie. Started in year 1 teachers saying the same thing to me as they have to you. We were quite shocked as he'd never shown any issues at home.
We agreed for the school to proceed and he was assessed. He was also observed in school by an educational psychologist. That lady said she saw nothing to indicate adhd/asd.
He was discharged by cahms and we have reams of paperwork saying no evidence of adhd/asd.
Over the years through school, we have realised its just the classroom environment he doesn't like. He does get distracted. He is never ever naughty. He has always done his work and performed well in his sats.
He has just started high school and I cannot believe the difference already. This is because he has many teachers each day and many different classes. It has solved all the problems he had a primary, and I knew it would.
Was all going well until yesterday when he brought home some paperwork from the high-school, a classroom plan for him. On which it listed his issues and that he had a diagnosis of adhd! They've told me all of this has come from the primary school. I am absolutely furious!
My advice is to stay strong, advocate for your child,

LynetteScavo · 01/10/2022 08:30

Ask the school to have him observed and assessed. If your GP isn't willing to refer your DS for an assessment you've met a brick wall there (unless you keep going back time after time and you centrally find a GP to agree). For now the choice is school refer or you go private.

I had a wobbly, fidgety, very chatty DD. She could sit still if asked, but she never stayed focussed on what was being taught. She just didn't learn to read or write, but was utterly charming and very teacher she had adored her. She left primary school barely able to read and write, and with a diagnosis of dyslexia. It wasn't until the end of secondary that school thought there might've something else going on. She's now on a waiting list to be assessed for ADHD. If she'd had a diagnosis years ago, I think she would have received a lot more support in school, and we'd have understood why she'd do things like not be aware she could get run over if she steps in front of a car (age appropriate at 6, but not 16).

I'd push for the school to have him observed by an educational psychologist. You'll then know what his behaviour is like in school, and school will be given tips how best to handle him in the classroom.

Underhisi · 01/10/2022 06:43

I don't think a diagnosis of adhd will be given before age 6. The school can give him/ seek for him any support he needs without a diagnosis.

MintJulia · 01/10/2022 05:45

OP, I had the same from our primary. My ds is August born.

There were 5 boys in the year who were all July or August born, the school said they all showed signs of adhd. The GPs all said no. In the end, the TA took the five of them plus the youngest girl in the year for separate sessions in Writing, and reading.

The gap had disappeared by year 3.

DS is now on an academic scholarship at an independent school.

Push back at the school. The GP has said not and they aren't willing to involve senco so I think that's the end of the conversation.

Keep supporting your ds at home as you have been. Get to know his form teacher & TA if you can. Your little boy sounds lovely.

tealandteal · 01/10/2022 05:18

Also, given the referral and assessment process is so long, I would ask what adaptations are being made now, while you wait for this. Again this would be helpful to come from the SENCO. My DS has some things put in place to help him already, and Y1 has been much smoother than reception already.

mathanxiety · 01/10/2022 05:17

If your son were in an American school he would be just starting to listen to initial sounds in words at this stage of his school life. He would be in Kindergarten. He would be expected to fidget and to need frequent opportunities for physical movement in the classroom.

By the end of the school year he would be reading some cvc words and would be able to identify some sight words (I, me, you, he, she, the, a, go, to, and other high frequency words).

He would be expected to make much more progress in first grade, when he would be six with many of his peers turning seven.

The British approach is lacking in understanding of what average children's brains are capable of. Children are pushed too far, too young.

tealandteal · 01/10/2022 05:16

My DS was born at the end of July and is also in year one. He is currently on the waiting list for ASD assessment, having done the first part where we fill in the forms with the SENCO and based on the evidence it was agreed he should proceed to the next phase of assessment. We could be waiting 2+ years though.
For what it is worth, he is reading stage 5 but lots of other children in his class are at stage 2/3/4 and some not even reading yet. His needs are different but they are not pushing those children who can’t read for an assessment.

I would just repeat to the school “If you believe there is SEN, I would like to speak to the SENCO. I have already spoken to the GP and cannot pursue this any further without the SENCO.” I’m not sure why they keep pushing it.