Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think school should be more responsible for my childs' stuff?

133 replies

Mama234567 · 30/09/2022 16:31

My son (nearly 6) keeps losing his coat outside at lunchtimes. Today it was raining all day so coat got carried home wet while he got rained on. Lunchbox keeps getting left in the hall. He's in year one and we did not have this problem in reception. He's also come home in another child's trousers instead of his own, I sorted this with other mum and we laughed about it.

I do think this is partly down to his personality and I tell him everyday remember your lunchbox etc.. but he's not the only one. Another parent has had an expensive logo jumper lost already.

YABU- son should be more responsible for his things.

YANBU- school should help more.

OP posts:
howshouldibehave · 30/09/2022 18:21

Not the teacher’s job. You need to teach him strategies to help him
organise himself.

Teaismymiddlename · 30/09/2022 18:18

Oh, and they were sewn and non removable labels do definitely weren't pulled off by mistake 🙄

Walkermiss · 30/09/2022 18:18

Yes, we know they get into the rhythm of the "check" chants but me and the TA do a visual check as we ask them to hold up the item. This takes just a couple of minutes at the end of the day as we're waiting for parents to arrive.

Mama234567 · 30/09/2022 18:18

Pixiedust1234 · 30/09/2022 18:06

@Mama234567 quick question as you say "he's away with the pixies" a lot. Is he similar at home with not looking after things? What have you done to ensure he is more responsible? Are you starting to give him consequences rather than brushing it off?

I'm asking because there seems to be a inexplicably large amount of men/boys who have to keep asking the women in their lives where the mayo is, where did they leave their car keys, etc. Wonder if it stems back from "but he's only 5!" mentality? Girls always seem to be more aware from a young age for some reason. I brought this up as theres a running thread about men being unable to see things and calling the wife in another city or country. Its mind-boggling how they survive.

I do tell him off a little bit but I don't feel that it's something he's doing to be deliberately naughty. As he gets older I might get angrier. Some people are just airheads by nature, men and women can be. People have talked about their daughters also on this thread who are the same.

OP posts:
Butterflymosaic · 30/09/2022 18:18

First born I’m guessing.

would you rather a teacher didn’t encourage them to become independent?

would you rather a teacher lose 1.5 hours of learning with them per day to spend 1 min per child making sure they have everything after break, lunch and home?

would you be ok to have them ignore your child for the 1 hour 27 minutes that they were checking everyone else’s stuff?

He needs to learn for himself to look after his things.

Some get it quicker than others!

Teaismymiddlename · 30/09/2022 18:17

Get used to it unfortunately. My Son is nearly 11 and has had countless named and label items stolen.
His school jumpers are £22. New one for school photos as his was too small. They were told to put them on a bench while they did pe and some other kid took his home as the one left on the bench was 2 sizes smaller.
I asked on parent forums etc and it wasn't handed back so someone's cut the label out and now has a lovely new jumper at my expense.

This happens a lot and I've even seen parents picking up two at school uninform sales and trying to say they only have one

I'm more surprised that grown adults will steal things like this than kids for losing them

OfficiallyBroken · 30/09/2022 18:08

Some children need more prompting. My eldest certainly did (summer baby, don't know if that was a factor). Fortunately her teachers in KS1 felt sorry for me being in the cloakroom almost every day hunting for lunchbox/shoes/coat/jumper etc and started giving far more prompts during the day. It really helped.

I know it's not their responsibility, but I'm rather grateful that they took that little extra step to help a young child and her exasperated mother!

NotMeNoNo · 30/09/2022 18:08

As PP said, label clothes clearly so the child can recognise them. Clear sew in or stick in label with name and a picture or something on the neck or waist where it can't be missed. Maybe a keyring or fun zip pull that he will remember. Make a big thing of " Have you got your red bus lunchbox" etc.

Some children just take longer, or turns out they are overwhelmed by school and can't focus on the details. I was lucky our school let parents in to search the lost uniform box.

Pixiedust1234 · 30/09/2022 18:06

@Mama234567 quick question as you say "he's away with the pixies" a lot. Is he similar at home with not looking after things? What have you done to ensure he is more responsible? Are you starting to give him consequences rather than brushing it off?

I'm asking because there seems to be a inexplicably large amount of men/boys who have to keep asking the women in their lives where the mayo is, where did they leave their car keys, etc. Wonder if it stems back from "but he's only 5!" mentality? Girls always seem to be more aware from a young age for some reason. I brought this up as theres a running thread about men being unable to see things and calling the wife in another city or country. Its mind-boggling how they survive.

mathanxiety · 30/09/2022 18:01

I've seen children shout out 'check' without doing the actual checking. They get into the rhythm and just chant along.

Walkermiss · 30/09/2022 17:59

I've been a Reception teacher for 25 years and this happens day in, day out. Angry parents at the end of the school day demanding we find DC's jumper/cardigan/coat/bag/lunch box. Me, "is it named?", Parent, "No but it's an age 4 red/green/blue jumper". So, in a 3 form entry that's potentially 90 jumpers and lockers to check the following morning when we should be doing our formal teaching/learning. We do a "check" with the children at the end of the day as they collect their belongings ready for home. We call out an item and the children shout "check" (they love this). Goes something like this, "Jumper" check, "book bag", check, "lunch box" check. You get the idea. All of this encourages children to become independent and take responsibility for their own belongings. An invaluable life skill. Some children get this quickly, others take a while and this is ok. Schools are full of rules and routines and children's heads are full to bursting with all of this. They will get it! Give them time and encouragement. The school staff really do understand your frustration.

mathanxiety · 30/09/2022 17:58

@Pharos

I agree it's something to note, especially if it persists and also if it's a trait that is apparent at home too.

However, the average TA or playground supervisor may well be watching out for kids who have already been diagnosed with SN, or the kid who fell and cut his or her knee, twisted an ankle, banged his head, was stung by a wasp, etc.

RedHelenB · 30/09/2022 17:53

He will be reminded to fetch his coat at the end of play but as others have said there aren't enough staff to be checking the playground.

starfishmummy · 30/09/2022 17:52

I had a child (now adult) the same. I remember one winter week where every coat he owned was in school and he was told that if it was raining the next day he'd be wearing a binbag!

But mine has SN and was at Special School (same school from reception to 6th form) with only 6 to 8 kids and at least 3 staff members per class, so somewhat different to a teacher with a class of 30 in a big school.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 30/09/2022 17:51

You want (sometimes) 2 adults to look after 30 kids AND keep track of all their stuff?

Losing things at school is annoying, but it's realyl up to your son. Keep his stuff clearly labelled and check the lost and found ever so often. It's the only way around it. DD is not in year 4 and I get her to check the lsot and found when she's lost something, it normally shows up eventually (if her name is in it).

PuttingDownRoots · 30/09/2022 17:49

For winter I advise a cor through his sleeves with his gloves attached. Plus a multipack of matching gloves as they lose them singularly never in pairs.

Pharos · 30/09/2022 17:47

I'm with @Kite22 and @SkankingWombat . Looking at this from the perspective of an ADHD parent and teacher in mainstream and special school, some children will always find this more difficult and just a little bit of adjustment now could make a world of difference.

Yes, there are 29 other children in the class but that doesn't mean that a child who is obviously struggling to develop a specific skill others find easy should just be left to get on with it. A quick verbal reminder from a TA or lunchtime supervisor isn't arduous, equally a specific 'going home' checklist takes v little time to organise.

Dealing with it now will make life further on in school much easier, equally if you notice that his organisational skills are not keeping pace with his expectations, it would be something to flag with school.

mathanxiety · 30/09/2022 17:43

YABU

Your child needs to start being careful and more responsible.

What exactly are you expecting teachers should do with a school full of potentially featherheaded children? Spend half an hour every day sorting out lost belongings?

The natural consequence of leaving your coat in the playground after lunch is being rained on, and leaving your lunchbox in the hall is having no lunchbox next day. This is how children learn.

DysmalRadius · 30/09/2022 17:42

Are the school insisting that he wears his coat out to play? I think if they're making him take it out and he's instantly taking it off, maybe they could let him out without a coat to avoid the same thing happening repeatedly.

Choconut · 30/09/2022 17:42

Tell him that if he takes his coat off he needs to go hang it up not dump it on the ground! Mine was the same, just needs drumming in.

purfectpuss · 30/09/2022 17:41

Losing things and suffering the consequences is how children learn to look after their things.

I work in a primary school and some children just lose things constantly- general class reminders to hang coats on pegs, make sure you don't leave things in the dining hall etc. fall on deaf ears.

If everything is named it usually works it's way back to the child eventually as staff tidy up.

Dibbydoos · 30/09/2022 17:41

The school is not responsible, but your son obviously needs a little more direction, so ask the school if they'll try nudge ie signs that say

  • Have you got your coat, or did you put your coat on your hook?
  • put your lunch box away once you've finished eating or do you have your lunch box
  • Check the name on clothes are they yours?

You can use nudge too in his school bag - include labels that ask him to do the same checks and it'll hopefully trigger him to do it.

Good luck.

It's harsh to say its on a child to do ABC cos they all develop with their own skill sets and at different rates, so help him out. He'll get there or maybe not, I bet he's a genius at other stuff!

iklboo · 30/09/2022 17:40

An eight year old? Sure. A FIVE year old? No no. Someone should be looking after him.

There's barely enough teachers. You can't expect them to look after 30 children and all their stuff at once.

OP - does he get picked up? Could that person remind him about his lunch box?

Why is he taking his coat off all the time?

cantkeepawayforever · 30/09/2022 17:36

You can make your own ‘going hone checklist’ if that might help?

Card (laminated is good) inside his bag with pictures for him to check everything at the end of the day. You could sticker or stamp for every day he has everything and have a reward system?

Navigatingnewwaters · 30/09/2022 17:35

Mama234567 · 30/09/2022 16:48

I just want to say now I have nothing but respect for teachers and school staff and understand they're very busy. It just seems obvious to me that my son isn't capable yet as this is happening near enough every day. Other 5yr olds might be but he's a very 'out to lunch' type of child as my mum would say. I'm not actually angry with the school at all I was just considering bringing up that he might need more help to remember his stuff.

Thankyou for replies. Hopefully he will learn. And his name is in everything already.

Doesn’t seem like it

Swipe left for the next trending thread