Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think life would be better in Canada?

244 replies

ButtercupsAndBluebells · 30/09/2022 15:20

I've always been very happy with my life in the UK, but I am starting to feel so disillusioned (as many others are too, judging by several other threads I've read today). My brother moved to Canada (Calgary, Alberta) a few years ago and is currently staying with us for a visit. Although he hasn't been openly critical or boastful, it's obvious that he's been taken aback by how things have deteriorated here. He seems to have such a wonderful life, and it's left me feeling very flat about my own.

I know I shouldn't compare, but it's hard not to. DH and I have similar jobs to my brother and SIL. They have the huge house and cars, a fantastic family doctor, a mobile home that they take into the mountains most weekends, access to the most incredible wilderness despite living in a city. In contrast, we have a small 3 bed terrace without any parking, disposable income is shrinking month by month and let's not even mention the state of the NHS. We live in a really nice area, but there's still litter everywhere and it's like nobody cares about their surroundings.

I have done some reading online and I think we'd have a good chance of being accepted to migrate ourselves, but would it really be that different? I'm tying myself in knots thinking about it. Please can someone either talk me down or give me some encouragement!

OP posts:
onlythreenow · 05/10/2022 03:17

Why did this become a Canada bashing thread?

Probably for the same reason that any thread about life in another part of the world becomes a bashing thread. There is a faction on MN who really think that the UK is some sort of superior place and anyone who dares to consider living anywhere else is treated with disdain. Those people also visit other countries with closed minds to anything good about the place, and they are extremely vocal about anything they percieve to be not as good as in the UK.

Pilipalapal · 05/10/2022 03:08

MangyInseam · 05/10/2022 02:41

Covid requirements in Canada went well beyond needing vaccination to get in the country.

Many people had to be vaccinated in their jobs, the whole of the civil service, for example, no matter what they did.

They also encouraged all kinds of other employers to do the same, they took this approach because that meant it wasn't a government policy. But as examples, my co-workers husband works in the woods, he sells pulp products to a mill. He was required, in order to sell to the mill, to be vaccinated - even though he basically works outside alone. Similarly, another person I know who owns a gas station where trucks from a hospital fill up, was told he could no longer have the hospital contract if his employees weren't vaccinated.

Had I not been vaccinated I would have had to take an unpaid leave of absence from my job at the library. My husband's co-worker had to do s o - even though they were mandated to work from home up until this past month.

Many shops and restaurants required a proof of vaccination card, for a long time.

I had a friend visit from Scotland during the mask mandate, she found the attitude to things like making really oppressive. I was surprised as I thought Scotland was more gung-ho that way than much of the UK.

Sorry you’re quite right, I was meaning to address the mandate that was the original subject of the Freedom Convoy protest.

I actually didn’t find Covid restrictions particularly bad, but we seemed to avoid the worst of it in BC. We certainly didn’t have the same level of restrictions, or for the same duration, as in the UK (but I appreciate that it varied by province).

Mumtobabyhavoc · 05/10/2022 03:06

Why did this become a Canada bashing thread? Aren't we all in the Commonwealth fcou?
There is good and not so good aspects of each country. As far as Covid goes, UK is 7th for infection rates while "oppressive" Canada ranks 33rd. (Quick google search) That alone makes me become suddenly deaf to the Canada bashers moaning about.
Moving to another country is always risky. But, you only live once. I've done my share of travelling and found it immensely enlightening and feel I'm better of for it. I'd encourage the move. No one says it's forever.

MangyInseam · 05/10/2022 02:41

Covid requirements in Canada went well beyond needing vaccination to get in the country.

Many people had to be vaccinated in their jobs, the whole of the civil service, for example, no matter what they did.

They also encouraged all kinds of other employers to do the same, they took this approach because that meant it wasn't a government policy. But as examples, my co-workers husband works in the woods, he sells pulp products to a mill. He was required, in order to sell to the mill, to be vaccinated - even though he basically works outside alone. Similarly, another person I know who owns a gas station where trucks from a hospital fill up, was told he could no longer have the hospital contract if his employees weren't vaccinated.

Had I not been vaccinated I would have had to take an unpaid leave of absence from my job at the library. My husband's co-worker had to do s o - even though they were mandated to work from home up until this past month.

Many shops and restaurants required a proof of vaccination card, for a long time.

I had a friend visit from Scotland during the mask mandate, she found the attitude to things like making really oppressive. I was surprised as I thought Scotland was more gung-ho that way than much of the UK.

Pilipalapal · 05/10/2022 02:32

Windowboxgardener · 05/10/2022 01:14

I have family in Canada too, some who live in one of the nicer cities and some out in more remote areas.
Healthcare system is dire (long waiting times, free COVID tests didn’t exist there). Rents in the city are worse than London, and forget buying unless you are a multi-millionaire. Massive drug, homelessness and inequality problems. Gender woo-woo is off the scale nuts. My relatives send their kids to private school because the state system is falling apart. Also being badly affected by climate change - fire risk and drought risk are becoming a constant.

But the people are very nice and polite, even despite all that, and there’s lots of skiing and canoeing if you like that sort of thing….

I agree with some of this, but there’s a lot of hyperbole too.

Canada’s education system consistently ranks in the top 5 in the world.

Inequality is bad, but not quite as bad as in the UK.

You can buy an apartment in even the most expensive city, Vancouver, for about £350,000, but an actual house likely would start at closer to £1m. Housing prices are actually lower than in the City of London, but the issue is an absence of cheaper commuter-towns.

It’s no big surprise that Canada has a higher incidence of forest fires than the UK; Canada’s forests alone are 20 times larger in area than the whole of the UK.

Our public healthcare system is undoubtedly poor, though, and the level of homeless in some cities is genuinely shocking (although, oddly enough, we do have lower rates of poverty than the UK).

Windowboxgardener · 05/10/2022 01:14

I have family in Canada too, some who live in one of the nicer cities and some out in more remote areas.
Healthcare system is dire (long waiting times, free COVID tests didn’t exist there). Rents in the city are worse than London, and forget buying unless you are a multi-millionaire. Massive drug, homelessness and inequality problems. Gender woo-woo is off the scale nuts. My relatives send their kids to private school because the state system is falling apart. Also being badly affected by climate change - fire risk and drought risk are becoming a constant.

But the people are very nice and polite, even despite all that, and there’s lots of skiing and canoeing if you like that sort of thing….

Pilipalapal · 05/10/2022 01:11

I can only assume that people who were supportive of the Freedom Convoy either did not really pay attention to the story or are violent anarchists. The right of protest is vitally important but a small minority of the populace holding the majority to ransom for weeks on end, particularly under threat of violence, should never be acceptable in a democracy.

Pilipalapal · 05/10/2022 00:36

Cassillero · 05/10/2022 00:14

Well seizing bank accounts of not just people peacefully protesting, but anyone donating to the peaceful protestors isn't really what you'd expect in a democracy is it? Then there was the demonising of the unvaccinated, the mandates, the whole masking except for him when he went partying abroad.

Then the times he conveniently got covid at exactly the time he could really have done with addressing protesters. I think this was at least 2 times but may have been more. The black face stuff isn't exactly inspiring.

I'll be honest, I've got the day off tomorrow and am pretty drunk. So that's just off the top of my head. I'm sure someone more coherent will give a better answer than me.

Thanks for replying.

First off, the mandates were broadly the same as those in the majority of countries, including the UK. During the peak of Covid, you needed proof of vaccination to enter the country.

This affected a small proportion of truckers, whose routes crossed the US border (the US also required proof of vaccination btw, so this wasn’t even a matter within Canada’s control).

Most unvaccinated truckers were reassigned by their employers to internal routes, but a small number could not be reassigned, and others refused.

As to the protest itself - it would not have been allowed in the UK or most other countries. Canadians have less restrictions on the right to protest that Brits do.

In the UK, when Extinction Rebellion, Insulate Britain or whoever else try similar protests, they are cleared out by police on the same day.

The ‘Freedom Convoy’ occupied a large section of Canada’s capital, and disrupted the import and export of food and other goods into the country, for a whole month.

And they weren’t simply blocking roads in Ottawa, but causing a deliberate and active nuisance to residents, by blaring their horns 24 hours per day. Various residents (including vulnerable people) were all but trapped in their homes for weeks.

Elements of the convoy were also stockpiling guns and large quantities of ammunition.

Freezing the bank accounts of those associated with and funding the convoy was very much a last-resort and the only realistic alternative was sending in the army, and the violence that comes with that.

Ask yourself this, do you really, honestly think that if 1,000s of climate protestors occupied the City of London and blocked the channel tunnel, harassed residents for 24 hours per day, for a whole month, shutting down businesses, whilst being largely funded by donations from EU countries and stockpiling guns and ammunition, what do you think the UK would have done about it?

Cassillero · 05/10/2022 00:14

Pilipalapal · 04/10/2022 23:46

What was terrifying about Trudeau’s behaviour during Covid?

(apologies for responding twice, the second one was to @ you, in the hope that you’ll be the exception to the rule and actually meaningfully engage on this point).

Well seizing bank accounts of not just people peacefully protesting, but anyone donating to the peaceful protestors isn't really what you'd expect in a democracy is it? Then there was the demonising of the unvaccinated, the mandates, the whole masking except for him when he went partying abroad.

Then the times he conveniently got covid at exactly the time he could really have done with addressing protesters. I think this was at least 2 times but may have been more. The black face stuff isn't exactly inspiring.

I'll be honest, I've got the day off tomorrow and am pretty drunk. So that's just off the top of my head. I'm sure someone more coherent will give a better answer than me.

Pilipalapal · 04/10/2022 23:46

BeethovenNinth · 04/10/2022 23:05

Couldn’t give me millions to want to live in Canada now. Trudeau’s behaviour during covid was frankly terrifying. The trans issue is nearly as bad

What was terrifying about Trudeau’s behaviour during Covid?

(apologies for responding twice, the second one was to @ you, in the hope that you’ll be the exception to the rule and actually meaningfully engage on this point).

Pilipalapal · 04/10/2022 23:44

Trudeau’s behaviour during covid was frankly terrifying.
How so?

BeethovenNinth · 04/10/2022 23:05

Couldn’t give me millions to want to live in Canada now. Trudeau’s behaviour during covid was frankly terrifying. The trans issue is nearly as bad

Pilipalapal · 04/10/2022 23:00

I’m also gobsmacked that people think Canadian politics is somehow worse than the farce we’ve been having in this country for years. I’m no fan of JT, but seriously, who would pick Liz Truss over him?!
I think that many people on the right have some pretty odd feelings about how the freedom convoy was handled, that are usually extremely inconsistent with their views on how protests that they do no support should be handled.

The UK has stricter laws than Canada regarding peoples’ right to protest, and the freedom convoy would absolutely have been illegal in the UK.

Yellownotblue · 04/10/2022 22:43

I’m Canadian (from Quebec) but have lived in the U.K. for decades and have British citizenship.

I agree that Canadians in general are dull/earnest. Of course this doesn’t apply to me or my friends, we’re all proudly messed up and loud about it 😁. But I’d say this is true of my sisters and their families and friends, and of Canadians generally. I could spend a long time elaborating on the cultural reasons for this, but my phone is acting up so I won’t.

I love Canadian summers. Proper heat, pools and lakes, festivals. I’m also gobsmacked that people think Canadian politics is somehow worse than the farce we’ve been having in this country for years. I’m no fan of JT, but seriously, who would pick Liz Truss over him?!

Also, while I agree that Canada has been broadly captured by the trans ideology, overall Canada is a much more egalitarian country than the U.K., where women have more rights, are better respected in the workplace, and face less abuse. I think there is now an awakening around trans issues and the pendulum is going to swing back.

But I would never move back. Not enough history, culture, art exhibitions, good theatre. I see more plays in a month in London than I would in a year in Canada. Public transport is bad, people drive everywhere. Travel is expensive, except if you want to go to New York/Punta Cana/Mexico.

Pilipalapal · 04/10/2022 22:43

In comparison to the USA though, I feel like people often seem to view Canada as though because it’s relatively emptier they can kind of stake a claim more readily?I may be getting that wrong but it’s just an impression I have based on the way people talk about it.

Honestly I’ve never heard anything of the sort. People generally immigrate to establish towns and cities, rather than trying to survive in the wilderness….

Secondly, while people are vary wary about some of the darker aspects of the USA - we see and read a lot about it whether we want to or not - my impression is that people think of Canada as very progressive in contrast (which it is in many ways) and may not have scratched the surface to gain an idea about history and the very much ongoing oppression of the indigenous people. I feel like never see it mentioned.

I agree that this wasn’t a matter that received a lot of coverage internationally until quite recently, but the ongoing discoveries of mass graves do seem to have made headlines worldwide. Awareness in Canada itself has certainly significantly improved, but the Calls to Action remain very much a work in progress…

FloorWipes · 04/10/2022 22:31

*might have put it there but we can’t always do a lot about it now

FloorWipes · 04/10/2022 22:30

I think there's a European tendency to ignore the blood on one's own hands because the results don't stare you quite so directly in the face every day.

This is absolutely true, again I will take it. But by the same token, it’s easy to just say ah well it was all the British as though that’s a thing of the past without acknowledging when one is literally sitting inside the legacy and very ongoing architecture of that oppression and not dismantling it. The British might have put it there but we can’t always do a lot. But I don’t want to emigrate to work in Canada’s oil sands because that definitely doesn’t seem right. I’m happy for Britain to return indigenous artefacts and I’m happy to apologise for residential schools until forever.

VestaTilley · 04/10/2022 22:26

Tranada? You couldn’t pay me to live there.

FloorWipes · 04/10/2022 22:18

The thing is, where do you live now? The country that did the plundering and whose economy was built on empire and resource extraction.

Yes I live here in the UK. Where else can I go? This is where my ancestors were from as far back as I can know. I lived for a brief time in the USA and I learned that it wasn’t my land. I’ll admit to whatever you want me to about Britain or Europe or wherever you like.

FloorWipes · 04/10/2022 22:07

A valid point of view, but of course similar concerns likely apply to all of North America, South America and Oceana, at a minimum.

Yes absolutely similar concerns apply, although obviously each place is different and has their own specific issues.

In comparison to the USA though, I feel like people often seem to view Canada as though because it’s relatively emptier they can kind of stake a claim more readily?I may be getting that wrong but it’s just an impression I have based on the way people talk about it.

Secondly, while people are vary wary about some of the darker aspects of the USA - we see and read a lot about it whether we want to or not - my impression is that people think of Canada as very progressive in contrast (which it is in many ways) and may not have scratched the surface to gain an idea about history and the very much ongoing oppression of the indigenous people. I feel like never see it mentioned.

It’s just that when you step back all these discussions about whether we could emigrate to a “better standard of living” which don’t even consider the unjust standard of living endured by the actual native people of these places seem quite awful on some level. Not saying no one can ever emigrate but it just feels like at a base there has to be some acknowledgment of the immense privilege of position here that some of us could move there and immediately enjoy a better life than the people who were there first for millennia.

knitnerd90 · 04/10/2022 22:00

FloorWipes · 04/10/2022 15:19

I’ve said this before on a similar thread. I loved Canada when I visited before but now I know more about its history I would feel reticent about becoming another settler on stolen land. That part doesn’t feel great to me and I’d need to think about the moral approach to it. It would definitely feel wrong to just move there for no reason that because it’s “better”, which to the extent that it may be true is probably partly due to the ongoing plundering of resources against the will of the custodians of the land and stuff…

The thing is, where do you live now? The country that did the plundering and whose economy was built on empire and resource extraction. I'm certainly not excusing any actions by the Canadian government, but I think there's a European tendency to ignore the blood on one's own hands because the results don't stare you quite so directly in the face every day.

Dotcheck · 04/10/2022 20:57

Ticksallboxes · 04/10/2022 15:39

Following with interest. I have UK and Canadian citizenship, but I've only been twice and that was in my teens to my birthplace, Montreal.

We considered moving a decade ago, but my DH worked out that Canada actually has less sun and more rain on average each year.

Canada has more rain and less sun? All of it? You know it is several times larger than the UK , and that it can be raining in Scotland and sunny and hot in Devon?
I think your husband needs to recheck his sources

Pilipalapal · 04/10/2022 20:12

FloorWipes · 04/10/2022 15:19

I’ve said this before on a similar thread. I loved Canada when I visited before but now I know more about its history I would feel reticent about becoming another settler on stolen land. That part doesn’t feel great to me and I’d need to think about the moral approach to it. It would definitely feel wrong to just move there for no reason that because it’s “better”, which to the extent that it may be true is probably partly due to the ongoing plundering of resources against the will of the custodians of the land and stuff…

A valid point of view, but of course similar concerns likely apply to all of North America, South America and Oceana, at a minimum.

Ticksallboxes · 04/10/2022 15:39

Following with interest. I have UK and Canadian citizenship, but I've only been twice and that was in my teens to my birthplace, Montreal.

We considered moving a decade ago, but my DH worked out that Canada actually has less sun and more rain on average each year.

DontSuitAJumpsuit · 04/10/2022 15:23

My friend lives in Calgary and although she likes it I think she misses the UK at times. It is expensive - her 3 bed bungalow in a smart part of Calgary was $650k about 8 years ago and she's had to spend a lot refurbishing it. Her daily life costs a lot. She does earn a massive amount of money but not everyone can do that.

The state of women's rights under Trudeau is shocking. Even worse than here in Scotland and that is saying something.

We visited Canada for a month a few years ago and I have to say it was one of the most boring places I've ever been. There was very little history or culture that resonated with me, not much for our toddler to do. Lots of sports-based entertainment which I didn't care about. The people were lovely and polite and some parts were very pretty.

Overall I have absolutely no desire to return or ever, ever live there.