Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not make an effort with MIL?

61 replies

Ray92 · 30/09/2022 13:56

I feel as though my MIL is incredibly rude to me, so much so that I feel like making zero effort with her from now on. Only problem is, my DD. Would this be unfair on her?
I'll explain more.

MIL complained from the offset that she "didn't know me" so I made an effort to go around and tried to start multiple conversations. Blanked or one word responses. Still went around despite this.
Fast forward to our wedding-no gift, no congratulations.
Christmas present from us was thrown in the bin. Which even more strangely she told me about, laughing.
I got pregnant, she says she wants to see us more to DH. I had HG and was signed off work. She complained to everyone I didn't make the effort to see her, knowing how ill I was. At no point did she come to visit us.
DD is born, she wants to be the first to come to hospital to see us.
She adds baby's name to family tree but not mine.
At the moment she wants us to bring DD to see her very regularly. Once a week minimum, but this involves us driving there. She won't come to us but won't explain why. My main issue with us going is how uncomfortable I feel there (MIL prone to outbursts of crying or shouting if not getting her own way) but also the dog jumps up at my baby and defecates on the floor and FIL smokes.
I hear from SIL and BIL that MIL is always complaining that she never sees DD. (MIL is also awful about SIL behind her back, making very hurtful comments about her mothering abilities but I would never say this to SIL.)
What do I do!?
Continue making an effort even though it makes me so sad and uncomfortable?
Christmas is approaching and MIL wants to do things with DD and we will be expected to attend Christmas family events but I am so hurt and angry that I don't want to have anything to do with her.
Am I being a baby and need to suck it up for DD?

OP posts:
WhereYouLeftIt · 30/09/2022 16:17

"At the moment she wants us to bring DD to see her very regularly."
As my dad used to say - "I want" doesn't mean "I get" .

"On reflection, I think I have been brought up to cause as little "drama" as possible and to actively placate anyone who acts out."
And that's where you have to start - with yourself. Embrace the drama Wink! Well, not really, embrace the saying 'no' and setting boundaries. For starters, stop visiting her. She brings nothing to your life other than stress and a health hazard for your DD.

What is your husband's view on this? Because he really should be prioritising his wife and child over his mother.

Ray92 · 30/09/2022 16:07

Also, much empathy and thanks for those with difficult family members who have posted.

OP posts:
inappropriateraspberry · 30/09/2022 16:04

Sounds like MIL will never approve of her darlings son's partners, no matter who they are! I wouldn't say anything to SIL unless she asks, but I wouldn't lie about it either.

Ray92 · 30/09/2022 16:02

On reflection, I think I have been brought up to cause as little "drama" as possible and to actively placate anyone who acts out.
I do not want to pass this on to DD.

Should I tell SIL, even though the things MIL will definitely hurt her?
For example, MIL states she wants BIL to divorce SIL.
Says SIL cannot look after the children.
Says the children would choose to live with her if they could.
Encourages BIL to leave SIL.
Says SIL doesn't work and relies on BIL for everything.
Comments on her cleanliness and looks.
MIL is delusional, as none of these things are true.

OP posts:
DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 30/09/2022 15:28

bofski14 · 30/09/2022 14:42

OP, you mention you are a peacekeeper......but what about the peace inside you? YOUR peace? This MIL is cruel. Step back. Waaaaaaay back.

This.
She makes you feel sad, uncomfortable, hurt and angry. In what way would your DD benefit from seeing her so frequently, in the dog pooh house, with a dog that jumps up at the baby and could potentially bite, whilst FIL sits there smoking.
She has been deliberately rude to you, bitches about other family members so you can bet she does the same to you. If your DH tries to discuss anything with her she starts a screaming match, storming out.

Do you really want your DD to be around such fine examples of adult behaviour? She will use your DD to further manipulate you. Stand up for yourself and your DD and your DH since he can't do it for himself or you. Consider what kind of behaviour do you want around your DD. Its all very well being a peacekeeper and a people pleaser, but what is the price you pay for doing that with people who sound wholly unreasonable and who are deliberately unpleasant to you? You are NOT obliged to do anything that troubles or distresses you, or that you think is unsafe for DD.

And why don't you tell SIL what MIL is saying about her behind her back - doesn't she deserve to know? Why shield MIL from her own bad behaviour.

bofski14 · 30/09/2022 14:42

OP, you mention you are a peacekeeper......but what about the peace inside you? YOUR peace? This MIL is cruel. Step back. Waaaaaaay back.

Fink · 30/09/2022 14:38

You go no contact. If your husband wants to facilitate a relationship between his mother and his child(ren), and himself, that's on him. She can visit you at your house if he's there to organise it. Set boundaries such as your child will not be going into the house with someone smoking indoors.

Pumpkinpatchlookinggood · 30/09/2022 14:37

Look in the mirror. Repeat parrot fashion until it sinks in

I don't give a fuck what mil thinks or says about me.
She sounds horrific.
Your dd isn't being hard done to staying away. Remind dh the road to your home goes both ways if he complains you refuse to visit her. I would guess they don't visit because the smoking wouldn't be acceptable in your home.

Scottishskifun · 30/09/2022 14:36

One of the best things I ever did was stop trying to keep the peace or please my narcissistic MIL!
I am fully aware she blames me and loudly to family members about lack of seeing GCs but my DH is very clear it's her behaviour.
My DH still sees her infrequently and so do GCs I however rarely do and it's blissful!

Bigbadfish · 30/09/2022 14:36

It always amazes me how women can write entire essays about how awful their MIL is, and never once mention their DH.

There is your problem.v

Escapingafter50years · 30/09/2022 14:34

Get her out of your life. My parents, especially covert narcissist mother, were awful and it took until my kids were adults before I realised how abusive they were. The emotional damage has been huge and I so wish I'd gone no contact when my children were babies.

Have a look at the current Stately Homes thread, there is a poster called Monkey something who has a disgusting MIL too, her DH is slowly beginning to distance himself, you may find her posts informative.

Mariposista · 30/09/2022 14:33

She sounds like hard work. Let your husband take your kid to see her without you and have some downtime

Imogensmumma · 30/09/2022 14:32

Yet again it’s not an MIL problem but a DH problem…. Your DH needs to have boundaries with his mother and talk to his parents about controlling the dog and it’s shit before he allows his innocent child there….

He needs to set boundaries ok mum as your house if full of smoke you need to visit us and if the waterworks start well then just keep walking

Sceptre86 · 30/09/2022 14:32

I'm all for making compromises for loved ones and taking one for the team but this takes the piss. She's outright rude to you, sounds like she's either a nasty woman or has some level of mental health problems going on, maybe both?

I wouldn't allow my dd to see me be disrespected or put her in unhealthy situations. I therefore wouldn't be engaging any further with this women. That being said I wouldn't stop your partner from seeing her but neither myself or my child would.

HiKelsey · 30/09/2022 14:32

Your husband needs to step in now.

I ended up no contact with In laws for similar issues around parenting and wanting me to drop everything to see them. Best decision I ever made, they wanted to see DD once a week, I made the effort they didn't. DD doesn't even realise and she's 3, she's happy that she's loved by my parents and me so in laws don't factor in anymore.

I was always putting out and got no thanks in return and they would make comments round DD so it wasn't worth it. Your little one will start understanding and she'll see MIL treats you differently

FLOWER1982 · 30/09/2022 14:27

I would stay away as much as physical possible and only show for things every now and then to be polite as it’s your dh family.

I barely see my in laws as mil was awful after our son was born. She complained that my mum saw us more even though I made the effort to visit every week. She was so rude to me and made me feel upset for days after each visit. I stopped going by myself and will now only occasionally visit with my dh there. My dh will normally just take the kids to visit when I’m busy now. His whole family is not my cup of tea and I come away feeling stressed so why bother. Life’s too short.

Ray92 · 30/09/2022 14:26

SnackSizeRaisin · 30/09/2022 14:22

She sounds awful and the house sounds like a health hazard. What benefit do you think she will bring your daughter?

I don't think she would benefit DD at all, honestly. Which reveals to me that I've been ridiculous to put up with this for so long.
I shall grow balls.
Big, hairy ones.

OP posts:
Hoppinggreen · 30/09/2022 14:26

Do nothing, literally nothing.
You don’t arrange visits, presents, cards, nothing.
If your H wants to thats fine
Ignore any whining to yourself or anyone else, it’s your Husbands Mother, she can be solely his problem

inappropriateraspberry · 30/09/2022 14:25

Is DD still a baby? She won't have any idea about all this. Get it set out now, so that when she is older, she'll know no different.
There is no way I'd be cowtowing to MIL. Reason enough with dog and smoking, let alone her actions.
Don't let your DH take your daughter there, if MIL wants to see her, she can visit you.

purpleboy · 30/09/2022 14:24

What a nightmare, don't feel guilty, you have made all the effort whilst she has made none, and it still isn't good enough! DH can take DD to see her but not in the house with dog shit and fag smoke Envy

SidTwaddell · 30/09/2022 14:23

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

YellowTreeHouse · 30/09/2022 14:23

This is really simple: you grow some balls.

I wouldn’t have my baby visiting a house with smokers or dogs. If they want to see baby they can come at a time convenient to you at your house or a mutually agreed place and there would be no smoking allowed.

SnackSizeRaisin · 30/09/2022 14:22

She sounds awful and the house sounds like a health hazard. What benefit do you think she will bring your daughter?

YumYummy · 30/09/2022 14:22

Your DH can take his DD to his DM.

Fudgemaker · 30/09/2022 14:21

Is your DH aware of how you feel? He really needs to be standing up to his mother. If he fears she will have a tantrum then he needs to grow a backbone to deal with her otherwise this situation will exist FOREVER!