Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not make an effort with MIL?

61 replies

Ray92 · 30/09/2022 13:56

I feel as though my MIL is incredibly rude to me, so much so that I feel like making zero effort with her from now on. Only problem is, my DD. Would this be unfair on her?
I'll explain more.

MIL complained from the offset that she "didn't know me" so I made an effort to go around and tried to start multiple conversations. Blanked or one word responses. Still went around despite this.
Fast forward to our wedding-no gift, no congratulations.
Christmas present from us was thrown in the bin. Which even more strangely she told me about, laughing.
I got pregnant, she says she wants to see us more to DH. I had HG and was signed off work. She complained to everyone I didn't make the effort to see her, knowing how ill I was. At no point did she come to visit us.
DD is born, she wants to be the first to come to hospital to see us.
She adds baby's name to family tree but not mine.
At the moment she wants us to bring DD to see her very regularly. Once a week minimum, but this involves us driving there. She won't come to us but won't explain why. My main issue with us going is how uncomfortable I feel there (MIL prone to outbursts of crying or shouting if not getting her own way) but also the dog jumps up at my baby and defecates on the floor and FIL smokes.
I hear from SIL and BIL that MIL is always complaining that she never sees DD. (MIL is also awful about SIL behind her back, making very hurtful comments about her mothering abilities but I would never say this to SIL.)
What do I do!?
Continue making an effort even though it makes me so sad and uncomfortable?
Christmas is approaching and MIL wants to do things with DD and we will be expected to attend Christmas family events but I am so hurt and angry that I don't want to have anything to do with her.
Am I being a baby and need to suck it up for DD?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Calphurnia88 · 01/10/2022 09:35

With your help, I've spoken to DH tonight. He has apologised and agreed that we are to make no effort to see MIL. She can come to us if she wants a relationship with DD. He acknowledges that she is highly unlikely to make the effort.

Sorry OP, I've just seen your latest update (I think I was too taken aback by the dog poo on the floor and smoking around a 6mo to finish the thread in full).

Good for you, hopefully that puts an end to it.

Calphurnia88 · 01/10/2022 09:33

The dog jumps up at my baby and defecates on the floor and FIL smokes.

This is enough of a reason not to go to their house. If your 6mo isn't crawling now they will be soon, so dog poo on the floor is a major health hazard, especially since babies love to put things in their mouths. As for the smoking... Second hand smoke can lead to asthma, chest infections and worse for babies so they should have stopped this from day one (or you should have refused to visit until they did).

Agree with all the PP though, why doesn't your DH grow some balls and sort this out? I understand avoiding conflict over an unwanted birthday present, but surely his daughters health warrants some assertiveness on his part?

GobbolinoTheWitchesCat · 30/09/2022 23:01

Your MIL can do one.

Focus on yourself and your daughter Flowers

Brigante9 · 30/09/2022 22:33

No way would I take a baby into a smoker’s house, I find that disgusting.

billy1966 · 30/09/2022 22:30

Well done OP.

No need for any further conversation, as the decision has been made.

You, nor your daughter will be setting foot in her house again.

Also do not contact her again.

If your husband wishes to contact his mother that is his business but it has nothing to do with you as you will no longer be involved.

Nothing wrong with exchanging information with your SIL.

See them separately and live your lives without this poison in it.

Fink · 30/09/2022 22:25

Well done you, great news OP that you're on the same page as your DH and you're doing what's best for all of you.

Ray92 · 30/09/2022 20:19

DD is 6 months.
I don't drive and they live about 30 minutes away by car.

Before we had DD there was less pressure to see MIL, she complained about not knowing me so I thought if I made the effort to go around that would solve the problem.
It didn't.
DH then said that he wanted MIL to have a relationship with with DD, so I tried regardless of my feelings about how she had treated me.

With your help, I've spoken to DH tonight. He has apologised and agreed that we are to make no effort to see MIL. She can come to us if she wants a relationship with DD. He acknowledges that she is highly unlikely to make the effort.

As for SIL, I've said DH needs to talk to his brother who we are seeing this weekend.

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 30/09/2022 19:30

Ray92 · 30/09/2022 16:02

On reflection, I think I have been brought up to cause as little "drama" as possible and to actively placate anyone who acts out.
I do not want to pass this on to DD.

Should I tell SIL, even though the things MIL will definitely hurt her?
For example, MIL states she wants BIL to divorce SIL.
Says SIL cannot look after the children.
Says the children would choose to live with her if they could.
Encourages BIL to leave SIL.
Says SIL doesn't work and relies on BIL for everything.
Comments on her cleanliness and looks.
MIL is delusional, as none of these things are true.

I assume the DHs are brothers? I'd tell my DH that he needs to have an honest talk with his DB and tell him the things their mother is saying about his wife. If he refused then, yes, I'd talk to my SiL. Especially if she is a frequent visitor or her DC spend time with MiL. God knows what poison MiL is dripping in the DC's ears!

And yes, I'd go NC and refuse to have DD around her. Let your DH deal with her reaction. Since he won't stick up for you he deserves it.

AnneLovesGilbert · 30/09/2022 19:06

I’m usually all for the “it’s a DH problem” argument but I’ve seen many threads on here over the years where the wife has decided her husband is wrong to keep his parents at arms length, ignoring what he knows and explains is wrong with them, because she’s got ideas about family obligation, peacekeeping or a fantasy of lovely grandparents. This has gone as far as women contacting inlaws her DH was NC with for years for his own well-being.

It’s not always as simple as a man not protecting his family from his parents.

TeaMoreToast · 30/09/2022 18:41

If DH saw her only infrequently before, why on earth is he making you see more of her than he ever wanted to himself? Seems like he's offloaded the responsibility to you.

My DP family is very claustrophobic and he likes me to visit them. But at least they are OK to me. I only see them so often because it's important to him and he always spent lots of time with them. I wouldn't agree to this if he hadn't been bothered himself before we met and if they were nasty to me / about others.

AnnaMagnani · 30/09/2022 18:40

I hear from SIL and BIL that MIL is always complaining that she never sees DD. (MIL is also awful about SIL behind her back, making very hurtful comments about her mothering abilities but I would never say this to SIL.)

Whyever have you not shared with SIL?

Firstly, SIL appears to tell you the crap MIL comes out with
Secondly, she needs putting straight
Thirdly, and most importantly - SIL is your only potential ally here.

Stop being a martyr where everyone dumps their (fictional) hurt on you, and stand up for yourself and your feelings.

It should be obvious to your MIL that the way to see a grandchild more often is to be nice to it's mother. If she isn't capable of figuring this out, why would you spend any time with her.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 30/09/2022 18:34

Respect is a two way street.

If she is not willing to be kind and respectful then tough shit.

I would be unfair on DD to allow her continue to treat you badly.

She might change once she realises you're not a door mat.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 30/09/2022 18:31

How about inviting Bil and Sil over and compare notes about what she's said?

Yes it will probably sting, but maybe not as much as you think when you realise you are not alone being on the receiving end of these unfair and unhinged comments. It might help you both to put things in perspectiv, because MIL's behaviour is unusual to say the least.
DH and his bro can hear it all from both of you. Maybe they just can't see it as they are so used to it, or each of them thinks their wife is oversensitive or exaggerating. What is the point in keeping secrets. This is becoming such an issue that being more open and transparent about everything might help.

The idea is not to be aggressive to MIL or gang up on her but for both of them to face what her actual behaviour towards you and SIL is and for them to see the effect it has on both.

Iateallthechocolate · 30/09/2022 18:10

Do nothing. Just don't go to her house, don't take DD, don't remember birthdays or Christmas for her.
How are her nasty words getting back to you? who is telling you what she says behind your back? Tell them she does the same about them, and you think she's not a nice person.

TheLadyofShalott1 · 30/09/2022 18:02

As a MiL (in Mumsnet only the male partner's mum seems to be a MiL, but I suppose that is understandable as Mumsnet is predominantly - and quite rightly imo - a site for females), I am appalled by your MiL's behaviour @Ray92. You have not told us one thing about her, or her behaviour, that I can relate to. The way she treats you means that unless, and/or until that changes, she does not deserve to have any contact with you.

Also, there is absolutely no way that your DD should be visiting a house that has someone who is allowed to smoke indoors, living in it. As for the dog faeces on the floor, old dogs can become incontinent, and unfortunately even if their faeces are cleared up straight away, and the flooring is cleaned thoroughly with a safe disinfectant, I would still be worried that the cleaning had not managed to get rid of all the germs - especially if it is on a carpeted surface rather than a hard one. So if your DD is crawling, or at an age when she spends time playing on the floor, then I don't think she should be visiting with either you or your DH.

These points do lead me to asking you two questions, even though I don't see how any potential answers should make much, if any difference, to the advice you have already been given by PPs, but they are:

How old is your DD at the moment OP, and

How far away do your in Laws live from you?

Sorry, I have just realised that your answer to my last question could lead to me asking if they can drive and if they have a car?

I am so sorry that you are living in such a horrible scenario with your PiL, your DH must be very lovely for you to have kept going out with him after you met your potential MiL for the first time! 💐

LookItsMeAgain · 30/09/2022 17:59

So your DH doesn't want to raise the issue with his mother because he wants to avoid confrontation.

Then you just stop going to visit the woman, either as an entire family or at the minimum you and your DD. She is adding nothing positive to the equation so I'd just stop going.
Then when she does kick off about it, and she will, you let your DH deal with it. He won't raise it but he will have to deal with her. She doesn't get to call the shots. You arrange to be doing something, anything, with your DD when your DH plans to visit his parents. He can continue to do that if he wants to (and I wouldn't be surprised if he stops going as it won't be as fun without you taking the heat being there). Your DH has to stand up for his wife and no amount of tears from his mother will change the situation.

I have a son and I honestly don't think I'd be behaving like your MiL if and when he decides to settle down. I certainly wouldn't be making demands or turning on the waterworks if I didn't get my way (who does that as an adult).

Why don't you turn on the waterworks when you don't get your way against his mother??? See if what works on your DH.

WhiskersPete · 30/09/2022 17:26

Sorry just seen that he doesn't want to to avoid confrontation

WhiskersPete · 30/09/2022 17:23

The only thing that matters is your husband's role in all this but you aren't answering that question despite many posters asking it.

Blueblell · 30/09/2022 17:15

She probably says the same things about you that she does about SIL- tell her and she will probably tell you the same! Imagine what this woman will say to your DD in the future. Best to keep away from her!

billy1966 · 30/09/2022 17:03

Absolutely not.

I cannot imagine why anyone would bring their children to a filthy smoking house with an abusive grandparent there.

I would go so far as to say you are really failing your children by doing it.

She showed you who she was along time, so believe her.

It's not worth remaining married to a man if he insists his abusive family members are more important than you are.

Better to get out early IMO.

LizzieSiddal · 30/09/2022 16:53

I think he should have spoken to her, but having seen her reaction when someone tries to discuss anything with her that she doesn't like, I understand why he hasn't. Think storming off and dramatics.

Then let her storm off and have dramatics. Her reaction is not your problem, put yourself and your DD first! Big Girl Pants are needed Flowers

DWMoosmum · 30/09/2022 16:49

She sounds like a narcissistic nightmare who has been bowed down to by her family all her life. Don't do anything you don't want to do. Your family is now your kids and your DH and if she doesn't want to make an effort then she goes without. Be prepared for her to throw her toys out of the pram and tell everyone what a bad DIL you are and how she was right all along!

Ray92 · 30/09/2022 16:48

It was an edible gift that she is well known to like and is often seen eating, from a luxury retailer.

I'd asked previously what she likes, months in advance to make sure she was happy.
It hurts more because she knew we had very little money as we were savings up for a house and our DD's birth.
It was almost as though she was proud to hurt me.

OP posts:
MatildaTheCat · 30/09/2022 16:38

Sorry, it’s not answering your question (YANBU btw) but isn’t anyone else dying to know what the present was that ended up in the bin?!

35965a · 30/09/2022 16:33

All those things she says behind SILs back she’s probably saying behind yours. Does your husband make an effort with your MIL? I would back away and just make no effort. Don’t arrange visits any more. Her house sounds disgusting, definitely don’t take your baby there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread