Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To all those wondering why police aren't investigating crime

268 replies

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 13:35

Prompted by a discussion on here.

I'm a police officer and today we received an email from out chief constable to say that only 17% of incidents police in our force attend are for crime .

The other 83% are non crime related - mainly mental health issues. Police forces are now taking on the work of other agencies which means that they are not dealing with crime .

Partner agencies are so stretched the fall out is now being dealt with by police because we don't shut shop, don't only work 9-5 , and cannot say no .

I read and see regularly that police are criticised for not dealing with crime .

Well - this is why . Because we are picking up the slack from mental health, social services and medical incidents.

I think it's time for people to decide what they want from their police . If we weren't dealing with the 83 % of incidents that are not crime related then perhaps we could spend more time on the 17% that are . ?
I don't think people realise that this is happening to this extent .

OP posts:
Macaroni1924 · 30/09/2022 16:18

MangyInseam · 30/09/2022 15:57

I just really think we need to stop and consider to what extent this is about staffing cuts.

You are right, teachers, police, etc were not having to do so much back in the day.

But when we stop and think - ok, who was doing this stuff, in a lot of cases the answer was no one was.

To use a very mundane example, large numbers of kids were not going to get speech therapy. Teachers weren't screening for it in the same way either.

There seems to be two types of things: problems that existed before but which people, to a larger degree, just took as normal. And then other problems which did not exist to the same degree. And then I think a smaller sub set of things, like more institutionalized people, where now they have not much support. (And not that institutionalization should be the answer for most.)

SO to me the real questions are around where these social problems are coming from, and to what extent maybe we are asking too much of the state in some cases to solve issues they really have no capacity to solve.

@MangyInseam this is a very good point. Intakes in schools whether mainstream or ASN are changing. Behavioural needs and mental health needs are at the forefront and these children are the adults of the future. Training in nurture and Adverse Childhood Experiences give a great insight into how difficult things can be for some families. The statistics are eye opening.

To all those wondering why police aren't investigating crime
whingewhinge · 30/09/2022 16:17

I work in mental health. We used to have a service where we worked alongside the police to manage these cases. It stopped being funded.

We're desperately trying to survive in mental health too, we don't want you to do our jobs either but we have no choice, we aren't funded well enough to do better than we're doing.

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 16:16

DeeCeeCherry · 30/09/2022 16:08

I think it's time for people to decide what they want from their police

The problem is 'people' being blamed, 'people' being asked to come up with a solution - When its the Government that need to be lobbied. The government that must take this serious issue in hand, and must be called to sit down at the table with the Police and these agencies, sort this mess out. If thats not happening then, why?

I'm not blaming "people " but it's us that vote and it's us that vote governments in that are and have decimated our public services. I'm trying to highlight what many people not working in these services know and what the population who don't work in them may not be aware of .

OP posts:
Relevanceiskey · 30/09/2022 16:15

@Brefugee they can't vet them any more than that. Also they are vetted constantly. But with all the complaints they get it's hard to figure out which ones are legitimate. If they sacked everyone who had a complaint they wouldn't have a police force. My sister has 2 complaints against her at the moment 1 of which has been disproved with video evidence but is STILL going through the motions, the other has multiple civilian witnesses against the complainant (a known criminal) but it will still likely take a year to finish. How do you rectify that? It's not the same as 'one thing and I'm out on my arse' because there are MANY reasons to falsely accuse them of something.

Thegroaninggurner · 30/09/2022 16:14

Florenz · 30/09/2022 14:14

The police need to prioritise properly. I know they're underfunded but fighting crime should always be the priority for the police force.

Priority is saving lives quire often the police are having to do section 136's which means lots of time spent at the hospital with patients as they can't just be left, there can be a large amount of officers at the hospital with sucidal patients which then means they are not on the streets, Because mental health services are so underfunded the police have to chose either save a sucidal person or visit someone who had their house robbed and saving a life comes first! Perhaps if the government funded the services properly we would not be in this predicament.

Scoobyblue · 30/09/2022 16:14

I have been a victim of crime several times. The police have never ever shown up. I have no confidence in the ability of the police to solve or prevent crime. The only time I ever see the police is buying coffee in the coffee shop. I have completely lost faith in the police as an institution.

ChilliBandit · 30/09/2022 16:14

@Relevanceiskey - but they did do wrong at the Sarah Everard vigil. They lost a court case over it and have been refused right to appeal twice. I have also criticised my local police’s response to matters I have personally reported. I have also acknowledged a lot of it comes from lack of resources. I am not blindly criticising them for nothing. I have also several times sent emails to my local police praising them for situations I’ve witnessed, being in A&E was one of those times when I observed the police patiently dealing with people in psychosis. I do think they need reform and I do think they should be held accountable where there are issues. I don’t think that’s controversial. The Met in particular seem to have a lot of issues with misogyny as also shown with Sarah Everard/ the Charing Cross station texts. I know there are police officers who do incredible work and I know there are some right twats. I’m related to some of both. The problem is the twats also have the same power as the nice ones and they are doing huge damage. Especially those setting the cultures at the top.

I also don’t know what to say about salaries, those are my experiences from forces around the SE. I also work lots of overtime, sometimes 25 hours of it unpaid. It’s definitely a perk believe me to have paid overtime.

WhatALoadOfWankyness · 30/09/2022 16:13

I feel your frustration @stillvicarinatutu , all services are having to deal in areas they're not really qualified to deal with , I'm including schools in that
There is no support , its just a babysitting service

DeeCeeCherry · 30/09/2022 16:08

I think it's time for people to decide what they want from their police

The problem is 'people' being blamed, 'people' being asked to come up with a solution - When its the Government that need to be lobbied. The government that must take this serious issue in hand, and must be called to sit down at the table with the Police and these agencies, sort this mess out. If thats not happening then, why?

TortugaRumCakeQueen · 30/09/2022 16:07

My DH is a Police Officer. There are so many calls now from people with mental health problems, that it's becoming unsustainable. Lots of people who can't manage their own lives, take no responsibility for themselves, everything needs to be spoon fed, and everything is someone else's fault. Can't imagine how these people would cope, if they had to face what the Ukrainians have. Or of they had to live through WW1 or WW2.

Brefugee · 30/09/2022 16:07

security checks take 3 months and they dive as deep as digging into your family members and any partners you have lived with. Aside from letting them go through your personal messages, there isn't much else you can do.

@Relevanceiskey then they need to be better vetted in the first place, and monitored while serving.

I had a job where i was vetted constantly. Deeply deeply. And it was constantly under review. And one false step on my part? Disciplinary and out on my ear. Even if it isn't true, you must admit the perception of the vetting isn't good if behavours that have been revealed are prevelant and, more importantly, ignored.

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 16:06

LivingMyBestLie · 30/09/2022 16:04

That percentage is skewed by the fact that police choose not to investigate all crime. Burglary for example, may as well be made legal.

And I don't believe those figures anyway. How are they recorded domestic abuse crimes? Hate crimes? They're much more common than I expect your stats account for.

Never believe any stats at face value.

These are the stats for my force - not nationally. And we do investigate burglary- we have a burglary squad .

OP posts:
LivingMyBestLie · 30/09/2022 16:04

That percentage is skewed by the fact that police choose not to investigate all crime. Burglary for example, may as well be made legal.

And I don't believe those figures anyway. How are they recorded domestic abuse crimes? Hate crimes? They're much more common than I expect your stats account for.

Never believe any stats at face value.

Relevanceiskey · 30/09/2022 16:04

@Brefugee security checks take 3 months and they dive as deep as digging into your family members and any partners you have lived with. Aside from letting them go through your personal messages, there isn't much else you can do.

AntlerRose · 30/09/2022 16:03

Yes, my sons safety plan, developed by CAHMS has 'call the police' on it in certain situations.

What we actually want is therapy for ptsd but austerity.

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 16:02

Brefugee · 30/09/2022 15:58

The flack that police get is unbelievable and it’s not because they are all crap at their jobs it’s because of the reasons outlined by the OP.

that is not entirely true. And while OP says it's not their force, but this is what sticks in a lot of people's minds (not saying it's right, just that it does happen)

the optics of the police painting their cars in the flag of one protected characteristic to the exclusion of all others (where the colourful public support on police cars for the disabled, for example?) and patting leather-clad 'pup play' fetishists or dancing the Macarena at Pride parades and - worse than either of those things - turning up at people's homes and workplaces to "check their thinking" for tweeting a limerick or a photo of some ribbon

So i think one of the first things the police really ought to be doing is to stop berating the public for "using them wrongly" while these things are being so prominently posted. Back to basics. Visible presence where they can be a deterrent to low-level spontaneous crime, etc etc.

I fully agree with you on this .

OP posts:
Brefugee · 30/09/2022 16:01

the fact that there are members of the police who would actually take those pictures, tells me the police have to do far far better in recruiting better candidates.

And that they need to have much more of a grip of behaviours, and make reporting this kind of behaviour (and all the whatsapp stuff etc that came out of the Everard thing) to higher-ups.

Relevanceiskey · 30/09/2022 16:01

@ChilliBandit maybe with overtime, which is the equivalent of someone with a 9-5 getting another job. Lots of people especially families dont have that extra time. My dad is on 42 and he has worked in the police for 25 years.

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 16:00

Rinoachicken · 30/09/2022 15:55

In some areas of the country, ambulance, police, mental health and A&E have teamed up and created dedicated teams set up to respond to MH crises and ‘regular service users’. Instead of playing ‘pass the bomb’ between services they instead work together to support these people and so reduce the impact on all the services.

I think this should be funded more and rolled across the country. They are called High Intensity Partnerships.

www.sabp.nhs.uk/our-services/mental-health/shipp

That's a really good idea - but if forward thinking . Sadly common sense appears to have gone out the window in most places . I wonder how ell it works ? Saying that - I tried to get a solution to the issue of repeat nuisance callers - loads of good ideas came up - my superiors poo pooed it all in favour of prosecution. Which doesn't work . And never will. I sometimes feel stuck between a rock and a hard place.

OP posts:
MissConductUS · 30/09/2022 16:00

FromageRouge · 30/09/2022 15:24

Interesting. Especially as NYC was the cradle of zero tolerance and broken window theory.

The two are not incompatible. The unit allows dispatchers to respond to such calls that without tying up an officer.

Relevanceiskey · 30/09/2022 15:59

@ChilliBandit sure, be critical of the things they do wrong. But at least have understanding of what you are accusing them of. Most of the criticisms I see of the police is due to a complete lack of knowledge of what they can and can't do and the procedures/red tape they are bound by. Hence people jumping on the "omg did you see them arrest that red head at the vigil!!" without realising that is literally what they are taught to do. Why don't you stop wasting your energy and criticise them for stuff they have actually done wrong. Like, for example, the officers who were taking photos of victims dead bodies.

ChilliBandit · 30/09/2022 15:59

@Relevanceiskey - yes I do, as a family we are very open about money. I also do tax returns for some of them. Don’t know what to tell you, none of them are on less than £45k even 5 years into the job for the youngest. Again it must be region specific, we are SE.

Brefugee · 30/09/2022 15:58

The flack that police get is unbelievable and it’s not because they are all crap at their jobs it’s because of the reasons outlined by the OP.

that is not entirely true. And while OP says it's not their force, but this is what sticks in a lot of people's minds (not saying it's right, just that it does happen)

the optics of the police painting their cars in the flag of one protected characteristic to the exclusion of all others (where the colourful public support on police cars for the disabled, for example?) and patting leather-clad 'pup play' fetishists or dancing the Macarena at Pride parades and - worse than either of those things - turning up at people's homes and workplaces to "check their thinking" for tweeting a limerick or a photo of some ribbon

So i think one of the first things the police really ought to be doing is to stop berating the public for "using them wrongly" while these things are being so prominently posted. Back to basics. Visible presence where they can be a deterrent to low-level spontaneous crime, etc etc.

Ponoka7 · 30/09/2022 15:58

Labour and experts constantly point out that cutting the budget of one department puts pressure elsewhere. Now we have a situation were every public service is cut to the bone.
Can't say that I'm a fan of the Police. I've never had a positive experience as a member of the public, or professionally. Recently Serena Kennedy seemed to enjoy the orders that she can give out, rather than call an amnesty and quickly have the Olivia Pratt-Korbel murder solved.

MangyInseam · 30/09/2022 15:57

Macaroni1924 · 30/09/2022 15:48

I would hate to work in the police nowadays something that was such a highly respected position before much like my own job. The flack that police get is unbelievable and it’s not because they are all crap at their jobs it’s because of the reasons outlined by the OP. Services everywhere are stretched and it all falls to someone else. The pressure is immense for those in the role and instead of the constant criticism some support would be great for those who tirelessly try to do their best in difficult circumstances. Unfortunately this is the case now in most professional settings.
I can only speak for the role I know which is as an ASN teacher. We now deal with mental health, social work issues, speech and language, physio, medical duties. The list is endless, with this the standard job has to be done but there are no more hours in the day, no more staff to facilitate it. Nothing but staff cuts. The nhs support has mostly been withdrawn due to their own staffing crisis.
When you start roles such as police, paramedic, nurse, teacher it’s a calling, you want to do good. Doing good is getting harder each day.
If the police didn’t bother with the mental health call-outs then who would? Nobody. It’s someone’s mother, daughter, sister and they need someone to step up for them. When a crime is taking place and police are unable to leave someone threatening to take their life or hurt others what can they do they cannot be in two places at once.

I just really think we need to stop and consider to what extent this is about staffing cuts.

You are right, teachers, police, etc were not having to do so much back in the day.

But when we stop and think - ok, who was doing this stuff, in a lot of cases the answer was no one was.

To use a very mundane example, large numbers of kids were not going to get speech therapy. Teachers weren't screening for it in the same way either.

There seems to be two types of things: problems that existed before but which people, to a larger degree, just took as normal. And then other problems which did not exist to the same degree. And then I think a smaller sub set of things, like more institutionalized people, where now they have not much support. (And not that institutionalization should be the answer for most.)

SO to me the real questions are around where these social problems are coming from, and to what extent maybe we are asking too much of the state in some cases to solve issues they really have no capacity to solve.