Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To all those wondering why police aren't investigating crime

268 replies

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 13:35

Prompted by a discussion on here.

I'm a police officer and today we received an email from out chief constable to say that only 17% of incidents police in our force attend are for crime .

The other 83% are non crime related - mainly mental health issues. Police forces are now taking on the work of other agencies which means that they are not dealing with crime .

Partner agencies are so stretched the fall out is now being dealt with by police because we don't shut shop, don't only work 9-5 , and cannot say no .

I read and see regularly that police are criticised for not dealing with crime .

Well - this is why . Because we are picking up the slack from mental health, social services and medical incidents.

I think it's time for people to decide what they want from their police . If we weren't dealing with the 83 % of incidents that are not crime related then perhaps we could spend more time on the 17% that are . ?
I don't think people realise that this is happening to this extent .

OP posts:
ChilliBandit · 30/09/2022 16:53

Snowberry3 · 30/09/2022 16:49

Please don't get to choose what they turn out to - if there is a reported incident they have to turn up.

No they don’t. I have reported at least 5 where a crime was in progress (fights, intimidation, drug dealing) they never turned up or got back to me.

I once rang 101 to report a particularly aggressive rogue trader as we have lots of potentially vulnerable people on our road. The call handler told me the police don’t deal with “sales people” and ended the call. I wasn’t expecting a blue light response to it!

Sugarplumfairy65 · 30/09/2022 16:50

Newnameforthistopic · 30/09/2022 14:32

Until "society" votes to put a Gvmnt into power that is willing to support the vulnerable in society, the problem will just continue to get bigger and bigger, now matter how much smoke and mirrors are used to try and pretend it isn't happening.
No, NO, NO. Much of this is not for us or Government departments to manage. It is the responsibility of families and of course the people themselves.

We have worked and saved and spent time and money on our own children and older relatives.
Don't take even more of my money subsidising the wastrels and rif-raf of society who don't bother.

Who exactly are the waitress and re-read of society? The vulnerable?

Snowberry3 · 30/09/2022 16:49

Please don't get to choose what they turn out to - if there is a reported incident they have to turn up.

WhoAre · 30/09/2022 16:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 16:46

Ted27 · 30/09/2022 16:41

what percentage of calls called be classed as preventative ? And isnt preventing crime part of the police’s role?

I have twice called the police about neighbours domestic disputes. One several years ago when I was concerned that the woman would end up seriously assaulted or worse.

The second only 2 weeks ago where the man was forcibly trying to put the woman out on the street, she had no shoes on, no bag, no phone, nothing.

Surely police intervention in these situations is better before an actual, potentially serious crime is committed?

That's a crime . Domestic assault . And domestics (even non crime domestics like an argument only ) are priorities in my force area . Along with child concerns. The idea is to prevent crime - or deal with it if it's happened. Dragging a woman out onto the street is domestic assault and is a crime .

OP posts:
plinkypots · 30/09/2022 16:44

The U.K. is slipping into developing nation status. It's been accepted that most of the country has no dental care, that the ambulance cannot attend within the medically appropriate timeframe, 1000 excess deaths per month according to ONS, police are stretched beyond being useful. And we are about to slash and burn more with Truss's budget. The bloody IMF is stepping in at this point. The pound is likely to hit parity with the dollar. Brits need a revolution. It's not going to get better.

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 16:43

Isaidnoalready · 30/09/2022 16:30

Madalaine mcann? Is she part of the 17%?

My ex threatened to set fire to my home with our children in it this wasn't deemed mental health or police worthy just "parental dispute" despite him being under investigation for an assault he was completely innocent 🙄

Madeleine McCann was abducted in Portugal. Slightly out of the remit of the uk . And didn't the Portuguese police bollocks that up ? At least any child abduction jobs I've had a hand in have been resolved. We have very good protocols in place for any big incidents. You do realise that the uk police have no power to police out of the uk ? We have intapol and can help if asked but if a crime occurs in another country that's not for the uk police to investigate it .

OP posts:
Ted27 · 30/09/2022 16:41

what percentage of calls called be classed as preventative ? And isnt preventing crime part of the police’s role?

I have twice called the police about neighbours domestic disputes. One several years ago when I was concerned that the woman would end up seriously assaulted or worse.

The second only 2 weeks ago where the man was forcibly trying to put the woman out on the street, she had no shoes on, no bag, no phone, nothing.

Surely police intervention in these situations is better before an actual, potentially serious crime is committed?

anniegun · 30/09/2022 16:40

jsof595 · 30/09/2022 14:11

All too busy nicking teenagers smoking a little bit of weed and pulling over people who are enthusiastic about cars...

Not dealing with these is the hottest subject of our neighbourhood watch group!

WhoAre · 30/09/2022 16:40

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

southlondoner02 · 30/09/2022 16:38

I used to work closely with police, including working in a police station and have always had a lot of sympathy with them, especially having seen the cuts they've experienced, plus as the OP says the impact of cuts to other services. Have always understood that they're over stretched etc.

But then the pandemic came and I witnessed on numerous occasions officers harassing individuals not following covid rules ( but not putting anyone at risk) driving round parks shouting at people to go home etc. I also saw videos and accounts of people having their houses raided if they had an extra person present or even for going on a walk. Also saw what happened at the Sarah Everard vigil. Suddenly they seemed to have lots of resources to be able to do this. To be honest it felt very political and I lost a lot of sympathy. I'm not saying this was what you were doing OP but it does feel problematic, especially when police were clearly turning a blind eye to what was going on in number 10

MangyInseam · 30/09/2022 16:37

BlueMongoose · 30/09/2022 16:28

I found your post interesting, even I was surprised at it, and I've observed for some time the police responding less and less to things like fraud, theft, and burglary, for example.
It just goes to show that we need not just to fund the police properly, which currently we aren't, but the NHS and other services- like local authority services. You can't do as the tories have done and cut 40% of funding to local authorities, as they did even before covid, and still expect them to be able to fund social services and so on to the same extent, and the NHS was facing large increases in waiting lists under the tories ( at least a doubling) well before covid too. But this is what people voted for, sadly.

The Tories came into a situation where there was no money though.

Had Labour won that election, they would almost certainly have had to make cuts as well.

I am not saying their management has been ideal, but I don't think it's accurate to imagine that any other government would have been able to do something wildly different. It's not like Labour hasn't also largely adopted neoliberal global economic policies. They were happy as any for the direction of the EU which demanded Greece radically cut public spending in response to crises.

And I wouldn't either blame Labour too much for the lack of funds - they were very much at the mercy of world economic events. Which they also didn't have much control over.

confessionstoday · 30/09/2022 16:36

But the police in our area came to visit me and accused me of theft for stealing my next door neighbours bins ( who is my ex and I had injunction against)

They can't be that bloody busy if they've got time to come out to my house for that shit

BlueMongoose · 30/09/2022 16:32

willingtolearn · 30/09/2022 16:22

@Nidan2Sandan It's not just the police that some people to expect to solve all their problems.

It's that they always expect SOMEONE ELSE to solve their problems.

Police, teachers, GP, Social Workers, government, family, friends, other taxpayers - as long as it's not them.

Yes, some people need help. But you cannot help someone who will not help themselves - not in drug addiction, not in mental health, not in physical health, not in debt, not in employment or issues with their housing.

You have to do some of the work yourself. Even if that feels impossible it is necessary.

Indeed. But if you do want to 'help yourself' then you will also need support to do that. And in many parts of life right now it has gone. Surestart, which helpd parents learn how to parent better, keping kids out of crime and parents out of court, is just one example, which this government has trashed. Addicts need help to get off drugs, that help is not there any more for most people. Mental health support for those in crisis- often hundreds of miles away from their families if they can get any at all.

OnaBegonia · 30/09/2022 16:32

@stillvicarinatutu
I read the thread you're referring to and the attitude of the OP and some PPs was appalling. I had to stop myself from really letting loose.
There should be on call SW and MH workers 24/7, sadly the police do not have the luxury of clocking off at 5.

ChilliBandit · 30/09/2022 16:32

Relevanceiskey · 30/09/2022 16:29

@Brefugee for the most part, crime is dealt with as effectively as possible. You would only be cutting your nose of to spite your face with that skewed perception. People latch on to whatever will fit their narrative so I agree, it won't change.

But the same could be said for you. If you believe the police can do no wrong then nothing will change for the better. Your view of the police is heavily warped because of your husband.

Isaidnoalready · 30/09/2022 16:30

Madalaine mcann? Is she part of the 17%?

My ex threatened to set fire to my home with our children in it this wasn't deemed mental health or police worthy just "parental dispute" despite him being under investigation for an assault he was completely innocent 🙄

Relevanceiskey · 30/09/2022 16:29

@Brefugee for the most part, crime is dealt with as effectively as possible. You would only be cutting your nose of to spite your face with that skewed perception. People latch on to whatever will fit their narrative so I agree, it won't change.

BlueMongoose · 30/09/2022 16:28

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 14:27

What I'm saying is for every 100 incidents called in to the police only 17 of those are for actual crimes - it's not that we are only attending 17% - it's that only 17% of the calls for our service are crime related.

I found your post interesting, even I was surprised at it, and I've observed for some time the police responding less and less to things like fraud, theft, and burglary, for example.
It just goes to show that we need not just to fund the police properly, which currently we aren't, but the NHS and other services- like local authority services. You can't do as the tories have done and cut 40% of funding to local authorities, as they did even before covid, and still expect them to be able to fund social services and so on to the same extent, and the NHS was facing large increases in waiting lists under the tories ( at least a doubling) well before covid too. But this is what people voted for, sadly.

Dinneronmybfpillow · 30/09/2022 16:26

Rinoachicken · 30/09/2022 15:55

In some areas of the country, ambulance, police, mental health and A&E have teamed up and created dedicated teams set up to respond to MH crises and ‘regular service users’. Instead of playing ‘pass the bomb’ between services they instead work together to support these people and so reduce the impact on all the services.

I think this should be funded more and rolled across the country. They are called High Intensity Partnerships.

www.sabp.nhs.uk/our-services/mental-health/shipp

We have this too. They go out together and discharge at scene almost all of the call outs. Reducing escalations in situations, use of 136 and A&E attendance.
We also have a MH drop-in which even when closed to the public in short staffing, the police can use as a priority.
We have a 136 suite that is fully staffed by MH staff and officers don't stay with the patient once there.
If they drop someone at A&E (often without medical need, other than MH which could be met at the drop-in much quicker and in a nicer environment), they don't stay with the patient.

Not sure how we're meant to jump in when people are on bridges/have weapons etc. Nurses and social workers have no legal powers to detain people/stop traffic and we have only have our teeny weeny badges to protect ourselves.

Namedifferentorquestion · 30/09/2022 16:26

@whingewhinge

"I work in mental health. We used to have a service where we worked alongside the police to manage these cases. It stopped being funded."

Lots of services that were really necessary went thanks to this government over the last 12 years. We are seeing the results which grow by the month. The country is in a mess and the government twiddle with tax cuts.... it's dreadful but not enough people seem to do anything to change it - how bad must it get before people actually realise what a mess this country is in.

Brefugee · 30/09/2022 16:25

How do you rectify that? It's not the same as 'one thing and I'm out on my arse' because there are MANY reasons to falsely accuse them of something.

I am talking specifically about other officers reporting on the fuckers like Couzens. How can someone like him work in the police with the nickname and background he had? That is what i mean. What's app groups with vile sexist stuff and "jokes" selfies with bodies. People know this is going on but aren't reporting for some reason. Or if they are (countless female officers have talked about this) nothing is done or the complainant is bullied out of the force.

I have worked in uniform, i know how it is, but the reputational damage? Will not be fixed. I now it's not the remit of this post, but were i still in the UK? I would think more than twice about calling in the police if i had been raped or attackd.

Namedifferentorquestion · 30/09/2022 16:23

Over the last 12 years of this government social care including mental health services have been badly underfunded. The knock on effect @stillvicarinatutu is that police forces, the NHS and other bodies are dealing with an increase in call outs. Doctors are also stretched and so patients cannot see them. Many end up with the police or A&E when they should have been seen by the appropriate service.

Unfortunately, whilst this despicable government continue to ignore the issues and instead issue a mini budget aimed to cut mainly taxes to the very well off then it will get worse.

Enough people need to actually vote for change rather than just moan and do nothing.

willingtolearn · 30/09/2022 16:22

@Nidan2Sandan It's not just the police that some people to expect to solve all their problems.

It's that they always expect SOMEONE ELSE to solve their problems.

Police, teachers, GP, Social Workers, government, family, friends, other taxpayers - as long as it's not them.

Yes, some people need help. But you cannot help someone who will not help themselves - not in drug addiction, not in mental health, not in physical health, not in debt, not in employment or issues with their housing.

You have to do some of the work yourself. Even if that feels impossible it is necessary.

stillvicarinatutu · 30/09/2022 16:21

The other thing is I have sympathy with mh issues - the police aren't immune.

Several of my colleagues have committed suicide- 2 alone in the past year.

I've been shot at , bitten, had to use pava against a 22 year old after he drunk 11 cans of lager and wanted a fight , dealt with hundreds of deaths including babies, sat murder scenes with the body still there , stood out all night on scenes , twice I've had to drive home on a plastic bag because I was on a period and could t get to a toilet . I've gone full shifts without a cup of tea or a loo break - so if you do see a cop buying a coffee - please remember we are human too and that coffee might be the only one they get that day - if they get to drink it before the next shout .

OP posts: