Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the buyer’s risk in house prices is not my problem?

117 replies

Eeksteek · 30/09/2022 11:46

I’m selling a buy to let house to an investor. They offered below the asking price back in August, and so far as I can see, no progress has been made on the sale (I thought we were waiting for a survey, but last week they moved to a cash offer and now they are deciding if they want a survey)

The buyer emailed me yesterday to ask for a ten percent reduction on their offer, citing a potential 10-20 percent decrease in property prices and asking me to view it as ‘splitting the risk evenly between buyer and seller’

Firstly, the risk is not my problem. As an investor, it’s hers to take, or not, as she feels comfortable. Why should I share it? If I wanted to take risks like that, I’d be keeping the house. Secondly a ten percent reduction on the asking price is not a ten percent reduction on the offer, lady. And thirdly, a ten percent reduction in agreed price is an ACTUAL HIT to me, not a potential one. It’s not a even comparison!

She has also said that if I accept she will instruct her solicitors to proceed ‘as expeditiously as possible’. Well, why hasn’t she done that already? I’ve instructed mine, and paid them, and completed all the paperwork. She also smugly reminded me that she is a cash buyer, and not affected by interest rates.

I feel like writing back and saying:

  1. The risk is hers to take or not. It’s neither my business or my problem.
  1. If she wants to reduce her offer by ten percent then say so. The asking price is neither her nor there, as she didn’t offer it.
  1. Inflation is running at around ten percent and forecast to rise. Her cash is already losing 10%. She swapping an actual 10 percent depreciation rate which will always be a depreciation, for a potential one which will likely be a gain over time. I am doing the reverse. (Although I suppose she could counter that with interest rates)
  1. She is also benefitting from a (I think) five percent reduction in stamp duty. Shouldn’t we be sharing that, as well?

Obviously, I can choose whether to accept or not, and ultimately is doesn’t really matter why she’s reducing her offer. I do have some bargaining power. I bloody hate this sort of game, but I really, REALLY need to sell this house. God knows if I’d get another offer. It’s making an ever increasing loss, and is on a variable rate (couldn’t fix, as selling). Should I just suck it up, negotiate, or continue being silently indignant (which is obviously not very productive!). I really do need this money. I’m widowed and this business supports me and my child. It’s not paper money. Or just not having a holiday or a new Range Rover!

OP posts:
Eeksteek · 03/10/2022 21:53

Thanks you all for your thoughts. I sent the following. I wanted a mix of we’re-all-women-of-the-world-here reasonableness and I-didn’t-come-down-in-the-last-shower-so-don’t-try-it-with-me.
^^
I do appreciate that we are experiencing very different conditions to when they offer was made. I can well understand that the buyer may be experiencing some misgivings due to the expedited interest rate increases, and possible falls in housing prices.
^^
However, the falls in housing prices and rises in interest rates have long been predicted. Any potential falls in house price are likely to be short-medium term, and as the buyer points out, interest rates will not affect a cash buyer. I’m sure the buyer is also aware of the 5% reduction in stamp duty that they will also now benefit from.
^^
As a gesture of good faith, I am prepared to accept a £2,500 reduction in the offer price to reflect current conditions. This represents close to 1 percent of the offer price, and with the 5 percent reduction in stamp duty, seems a reasonable spread of benefits and risks between buyer and seller.

I expect her to come back asking for 5% which is tolerable (although I’m pissed off about it. If I wasn’t desperate to sell I’d have flatly refused to engage in this rigmarole. An off is an offer). I shall agree, so long as she agrees to exchange in four weeks, and my conveyancer is convinced she’s committed. I agreed this offer almost six weeks ago, and we’re nowhere. I think she has been holding off especially to try and negotiate down. (My conveyancer actually snorted when I told her about the risk splitting nonsense! She lovely, very efficient and made my day. I shall never use anyone else!).

OP posts:
Bodgejobvendors · 30/09/2022 18:09

A house is only worth what someone will pay for it.

You are desperate to sell and the market is probably about to tank. She faces the risk of overpaying at the top of the market, you face the risk of not being able to sell and eventually accepting an even lower price. Maybe it’s a game of chicken and she’ll blink but don’t kid yourself that you’re not also facing risks.

red4321 · 30/09/2022 18:08

If you're feeling brave, say you won't accept a reduced offer and tell your EA that, if you don't get an offer at this level from the current buyer, or another buyer, you're going to pull the property off the market altogether and wait for a better time to sell.

None of which is likely to be true or a good idea but it might incentivise your estate agent to earn their fee and stop the buyer from mucking around. No EA likes to lose a sale.

WhoppingBigBackside · 30/09/2022 18:05

what @muchprefersummer said.

mathanxiety · 30/09/2022 18:03

Haggle.

Accept no more than a 5% reduction.

The housing bubble is about to pop. Take your money now.

Aintnosupermum · 30/09/2022 17:35

Real estate is a good hedge against inflation. They are being cheeky chancers. Don’t give her a 10% discount.

If they don’t honour the existing agreement put it back on the market. I would hold on now and not sell as going through this bumpy ride. Rates will come back down again and prices will be less volatile.

snowspider · 30/09/2022 17:28

It's a risk and depends how confident you are to sell at the price if she pulls out. I a lot of places the market has spun to a buyers' market, you have to weigh the odds for your situation especially if it is the type of house that sits at buy to let or fab end of the market as things are sticky and it may any bird in the hand and all that.

Kumri · 30/09/2022 17:26

Arenanewbie · 30/09/2022 16:45

She is trying you on, your EA has definitely indicated her that you want to sell.
It depends how desperate you are to sell and where you are. I don’t anticipate any price drops any time soon in my area, good family houses are like pure gold here.

Also this.

Kumri · 30/09/2022 17:26

That’s really bad behaviour. And now they’re trying to bully you. They’ve watched the mortgage market change and are trying to work out how to profit from it.

So much depends on how badly you need to move, but you’d be a fool to simply agree.

Communicate via the estate agent and lay out the facts. I’d say something like a below asking price offer was accepted, the seller considers the price fair, and will not be offering a further discount in addition to the reduction already given. Can the buyer please advise asap whether they are in a position to proceed or whether they are withdrawing from the purchase.

Arbesque · 30/09/2022 17:24

If you really think you will get another buyer with the same bid then put it back on the market.
If you think this buyer is your best bet then I would think carefully.

BruisedPear · 30/09/2022 17:12

Unpopular opinion but the market has changed dramatically affordability has reduced. I’d proceed with caution especially if you’re around the first time buyer/ buy to let price range.

She’s being cheeky but a house is only worth what someone is willing to pay for it. By all means pull out and put it back on the market but be aware the market has slowed significantly and it might take some time to shift.

Butterflyfluff · 30/09/2022 17:11

The trouble is, her not buying your property, whatever the reason, is your problem if you NEED to sell it.

With the mortgage market the way it is and fears over interest rates I’d think long and hard about losing a cash buyer.

A new buyer may also offer less in the current climate

Highfivemum · 30/09/2022 17:02

I had this done to me a long time ago. I agreed to it as had a job secure and had spent money on the new house purchase. Trouble was they did it again on the day of exchange. !! Don’t trust them. Walk away and re advertise

MadeForThis · 30/09/2022 16:51

Do buy to let investors save on stamp duty?

Arenanewbie · 30/09/2022 16:45

She is trying you on, your EA has definitely indicated her that you want to sell.
It depends how desperate you are to sell and where you are. I don’t anticipate any price drops any time soon in my area, good family houses are like pure gold here.

Namedifferentorquestion · 30/09/2022 16:43

@Eeksteek YANBU

So you take the actual hit to your current value so she can avoid the potential hit to her future value.

Nope - don't do it.

sst1234 · 30/09/2022 16:25

They are taking you for a ride. Pull out and sell to someone else. Marketing at 10% lower if you have to.

muchprefersummer · 30/09/2022 16:23

I'd put it back on the market, but Im known for cutting my nose off to spite my face. But, she's messing you around at this point, she'll carry on at every point down the line. I wouldn't trust her.

Booklover3 · 30/09/2022 16:22

Nah tell her you are putting it back on the market. I agree that she is messing you around

Blocked · 30/09/2022 16:22

Talk to your solicitor...I would calculate what she's going to save on stamp duty and point that out to her but as you are desperate to sell, say that you are willing to reduce the agreed sale price by say 5% with no further negotiations otherwise the house is going back on the market.

GasPanic · 30/09/2022 16:17

And so it begins.

Re 1. It is your problem surely if you want to sell it ?

FTR, investors aren't generally known for giving money away readily. If they do, they don't tend to be investors for very long.

W0tnow · 30/09/2022 16:11

Tell her it goes back on the market Monday?

easy for me to say, it’s not my money, or my house….

RincewindsHat · 30/09/2022 16:10

Just say no, or give your buyer a deadline. The agreed price is not going to change, you have until Monday to let me know if you want to go ahead and if you don't the house is going back on the market. Her message would annoy me, too.

KassandraOfSparta · 30/09/2022 16:08

I wouldn't get into a discussion with your points 2 and 3. just the first bit - The risk is hers to take or not. It’s neither my business or my problem. - is relevant. Just say that.

iekanda · 30/09/2022 16:07

I mean so she’s taking the piss

Swipe left for the next trending thread