Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the buyer’s risk in house prices is not my problem?

117 replies

Eeksteek · 30/09/2022 11:46

I’m selling a buy to let house to an investor. They offered below the asking price back in August, and so far as I can see, no progress has been made on the sale (I thought we were waiting for a survey, but last week they moved to a cash offer and now they are deciding if they want a survey)

The buyer emailed me yesterday to ask for a ten percent reduction on their offer, citing a potential 10-20 percent decrease in property prices and asking me to view it as ‘splitting the risk evenly between buyer and seller’

Firstly, the risk is not my problem. As an investor, it’s hers to take, or not, as she feels comfortable. Why should I share it? If I wanted to take risks like that, I’d be keeping the house. Secondly a ten percent reduction on the asking price is not a ten percent reduction on the offer, lady. And thirdly, a ten percent reduction in agreed price is an ACTUAL HIT to me, not a potential one. It’s not a even comparison!

She has also said that if I accept she will instruct her solicitors to proceed ‘as expeditiously as possible’. Well, why hasn’t she done that already? I’ve instructed mine, and paid them, and completed all the paperwork. She also smugly reminded me that she is a cash buyer, and not affected by interest rates.

I feel like writing back and saying:

  1. The risk is hers to take or not. It’s neither my business or my problem.
  1. If she wants to reduce her offer by ten percent then say so. The asking price is neither her nor there, as she didn’t offer it.
  1. Inflation is running at around ten percent and forecast to rise. Her cash is already losing 10%. She swapping an actual 10 percent depreciation rate which will always be a depreciation, for a potential one which will likely be a gain over time. I am doing the reverse. (Although I suppose she could counter that with interest rates)
  1. She is also benefitting from a (I think) five percent reduction in stamp duty. Shouldn’t we be sharing that, as well?

Obviously, I can choose whether to accept or not, and ultimately is doesn’t really matter why she’s reducing her offer. I do have some bargaining power. I bloody hate this sort of game, but I really, REALLY need to sell this house. God knows if I’d get another offer. It’s making an ever increasing loss, and is on a variable rate (couldn’t fix, as selling). Should I just suck it up, negotiate, or continue being silently indignant (which is obviously not very productive!). I really do need this money. I’m widowed and this business supports me and my child. It’s not paper money. Or just not having a holiday or a new Range Rover!

OP posts:
MacaroniBaloney · 04/10/2022 09:57
  • investment not inveterate!
MacaroniBaloney · 04/10/2022 09:56

@swanbuster

£10 will always be £10 but it is what you can buy with the £10 that is eaten away by inflation.

Sitting on £250k for the next 10 years will yield far less than buying a property and keeping it for 10 years.

It's exactly why property is such a good inveterate. It's an appreciating assest.

Cash is a deprecating asset due to inflation, which is going to be quite high for a while.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 04/10/2022 09:54

Eeksteek · 03/10/2022 23:57

I’m such a wordy person. I can’t seem to help it, however hard I try to condense things, they just get longer!

I suck at negotiating, too. I just don’t DO this. I decide what I want, and if I can pay the price on the label, and then I buy it, or not. I don’t play games. She does though. I had a best and final offer three times.

I want it to bloody sell. Now! I decided to put it on the market in May! It was a tough decision (and I left it too long, I admit). I’m prepared to take 5k to get it moving, and not to have to mess about with clearing the property, vacant possession and another two months losses on it. She’s probably right that I wouldn’t the get the same offer now. It’s not a great property.

In that case I'd go with this buyer even if she won't accept the 2.5k reduction.

MacaroniBaloney · 04/10/2022 09:51

This is a dip for housing, it will return and boom again. Like all investments, they fluctuate but over time, inflation always reduces cash.

Salome61 · 04/10/2022 09:51

Don't be tempted to go to auction, I lost big bucks doing that and the commission was eye watering. I wish I'd continued with the EA, the cheeky robber really wanted it and in hindsight if I'd stood my ground, would have paid in the end.

SwanBuster · 04/10/2022 09:48

Basically almost all asset classes and sectors are juiced up from years of cheap credit. Thus there are absolutely no guarantees.

SwanBuster · 04/10/2022 09:47

MacaroniBaloney · 04/10/2022 09:39

Someone cleverer than me would be able to work out how the rising inflation is hitting her cash. It was on another thread a week or so ago, something along the lines of 500k in cash is loosing 5k per week? (Example only for dramatic effect). She needs to get her cash into an assest pdq.

I'd not make anymore reductions on that basis. The current economic situation is hitting her hard too.

Find me an asset guaranteed to have a positive real return, right now.

cash might be trash, but it is at least going to retain its nominal value.

MacaroniBaloney · 04/10/2022 09:39

Someone cleverer than me would be able to work out how the rising inflation is hitting her cash. It was on another thread a week or so ago, something along the lines of 500k in cash is loosing 5k per week? (Example only for dramatic effect). She needs to get her cash into an assest pdq.

I'd not make anymore reductions on that basis. The current economic situation is hitting her hard too.

FiveShelties · 04/10/2022 08:31

Did you get any other interest/offers before you agreed the sale?

Do you think you will get a better offer if you return it to the market?

Eeksteek · 04/10/2022 08:21

Blowthemandown · 04/10/2022 00:23

@Eeksteek why are you even entertaining this reduction with the big fall in SDLT? Just say No. You do not have to explain yourself.

Because I’m beyond broke. No way I’d be selling a tenanted property if I didn’t absolutely have to. This house is making a loss (for reasons largely outside of my control) and I really, really need to sell, stat.

OP posts:
Blowthemandown · 04/10/2022 00:23

@Eeksteek why are you even entertaining this reduction with the big fall in SDLT? Just say No. You do not have to explain yourself.

Eeksteek · 04/10/2022 00:13

jackstini · 03/10/2022 23:04

I would put it back on the market if your offer isn't accepted

As a BTL purchaser, they will probably not be eligible for the stamp duty saving

However, other buyers now will, so worth a try

Yes, we do. It’s not zero, but it is less. You (used) to pay the normal residential rates, then an additional 3% if it’s not your main residence. Now you just pay the 3%. Her SDLT has gone from £12k to £3750. (I double checked on the .gov calculator with dates pre and post ’fiscal event’ so I’m sure)

OP posts:
SwanBuster · 04/10/2022 00:04

Eeksteek · 03/10/2022 23:57

I’m such a wordy person. I can’t seem to help it, however hard I try to condense things, they just get longer!

I suck at negotiating, too. I just don’t DO this. I decide what I want, and if I can pay the price on the label, and then I buy it, or not. I don’t play games. She does though. I had a best and final offer three times.

I want it to bloody sell. Now! I decided to put it on the market in May! It was a tough decision (and I left it too long, I admit). I’m prepared to take 5k to get it moving, and not to have to mess about with clearing the property, vacant possession and another two months losses on it. She’s probably right that I wouldn’t the get the same offer now. It’s not a great property.

Put yourself in her shoes. You’ve just admitted you probably wouldn’t get the same offer now, and it’s not a great house.

She’s playing hardball, but she’s a cash buyer. We aren’t talking about chicken feed - this is a 250k house from what you said. Damn right she should be negotiating.

But so should you. Just keep it all business - cut the waffle. Work out your bottom price, and stick to it. She will either take it or leave it.

Eeksteek · 03/10/2022 23:58

AlecTrevelyan006 · 03/10/2022 23:16

You’ve given her an inch..,

I’m trying to think of it as a golden bridge!

OP posts:
Eeksteek · 03/10/2022 23:57

ChicCroissant · 03/10/2022 22:46

OP, I think your response was way too wordy! Have sold prices in your area actually dropped by that kind of percentage, because your buyer is purchasing the property under the current conditions, not potential ones - so that's what you need to deal with.

I'd put your property back on the market.

I’m such a wordy person. I can’t seem to help it, however hard I try to condense things, they just get longer!

I suck at negotiating, too. I just don’t DO this. I decide what I want, and if I can pay the price on the label, and then I buy it, or not. I don’t play games. She does though. I had a best and final offer three times.

I want it to bloody sell. Now! I decided to put it on the market in May! It was a tough decision (and I left it too long, I admit). I’m prepared to take 5k to get it moving, and not to have to mess about with clearing the property, vacant possession and another two months losses on it. She’s probably right that I wouldn’t the get the same offer now. It’s not a great property.

OP posts:
billybear · 03/10/2022 23:18

sounds like they are trying it on for more money off, from experience last year mine was up for sale,85 people wanted to view,first person to look was well in with the estate agent,i now know.had few to view, all offered over price,picked a lady, she pulled out,went with person buy to let who knew estate agent, he was a bully dragged it out, demanded money off,was shocking experience,in the end we told him where to go, back on market sold fast for 20 grand more,,dont be fooled ,

AlecTrevelyan006 · 03/10/2022 23:16

You’ve given her an inch..,

Lonelykettleshed · 03/10/2022 23:15

It's a difficult situation and I'm in a similar position to your buyer right now, although buying from a developer and buying a property to live in.

Do I want to pay £500k for something that will probably only be worth £4-450k in 12 months time? I'm tempted to go back to the developer and renegotiate. I'm also willing to walk away if I think that the risk is too big but I know that it would create a problem for my buyer who is a first timer and has funding in place at a good rate and won't want to lose that deal. I don't want to create a problem for her but that can't be my primary concern.

I also understand that the risks to me aren't as bad as for many - the difference between sales and purchase price is c£150k and so that is what I am really risking as the value of my current home will also drop. I will also have a fully offset mortgage and so will pay no interest.

It's now a buyers market. She has every right to ask but you have every right to refuse and look for another buyer. I'm also not sure that the investor will benefit from lower stamp duty as I don't think that it was cut for owners of multiple homes.

Salome61 · 03/10/2022 23:14

Someone on MSE was selling their late Mum's house to a developer who had just asked to reduce their offer by 9% before exchange. The seller's EA recommended they go back with a counter offer - the developer lowered their offer even more, and the seller is remarketing.

Have a look at the House Buying, Selling forum on MSE if you have a minute.

iekanda · 03/10/2022 23:13

I hope it works out for you op but I agree with a pp that your response was too wordy. It contained speculation and opinion, rather than the cold hard fact of:

It’s either take the £2.5k reduction or don’t.

Nothing else is relevant. You are too nice. Those of us who aren’t learnt the hard way!

jackstini · 03/10/2022 23:04

I would put it back on the market if your offer isn't accepted

As a BTL purchaser, they will probably not be eligible for the stamp duty saving

However, other buyers now will, so worth a try

SwanBuster · 03/10/2022 22:50

🤷🏻‍♀️

tbh - if I was her I’d be being much more hard nosed about it. It’s a quarter of a million quid purchase. A few months ago, someone could have funded that for £1000 p/m with a mortgage. Now it’ll be 1500.

But she doesn’t need that. And quite frankly I think she’s probably overpaying given the level of disparity between asking prices and actual current affordability for anyone other than cash buyers.

All that said though, you hold the asset. And you should only sell for what you are comfortable with.

ChicCroissant · 03/10/2022 22:46

OP, I think your response was way too wordy! Have sold prices in your area actually dropped by that kind of percentage, because your buyer is purchasing the property under the current conditions, not potential ones - so that's what you need to deal with.

I'd put your property back on the market.

2bazookas · 03/10/2022 22:40

Buyer is a timewaster ; cut your losses. I'd instruct my solicitor to inform hers that you refuse the reduction, and as the buyer clearly is unwilling to proceed the sale is void and property is going back on the market.

DO NOT engage in personal bargaining with buyers.

altmember · 03/10/2022 22:19

Well, seeing as you really, really need to sell, she has you in a corner (especially if she knows). I'd have been inclined to offer her a 5% reduction but only if you've exchanged/completed by a certain date (offer a short but achievable time frame). Meanwhile instruct the estate agent to remarket it as 'under offer'. You could tell the buyer that, and if a better offer comes in before exchange you will be taking that instead.

Swipe left for the next trending thread