Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not need mansplaining regarding my breasts?

185 replies

Minimalme · 30/09/2022 10:55

I have had some localised breast pain for last couple of months.

GP examined me and said she could feel "something" so referred me to the breast clinic.

Appointment today and was told the male
Consultant wouldn't wear a face mask but I had to.

He examined my breasts which I found really difficult because he is male.

He has concluded the pain I feel is because of my underwired bra being too tight. I told him it isn't and the pain has been consistent and I don't sleep in a bra and often wear non underwired bras.

He told me that he "still thinks it is" caused by my bra.

Then he refused to do a mammogram. He said as am 49 I will get one soon anyway.

DH has taken a day off work so I can be dismissed after a 5 minute examination.

I am upset, angry and importantly, still worried because this man has dismissed my GP's concern using his special powers of mansplaining.

I am now going private. We are not comfortably off by any stretch of the imagination.

OP posts:
starfishmummy · 30/09/2022 12:17

crowsfeet57 · 30/09/2022 11:52

OP are you sure he isn't right?

I had breast pain for over two years, it was so bad I was taking painkillers every day. I had mammograms and scans but they couldn't find anything. Finally I had an appointment with a breast nurse, she took one look and said "It's your bra!" I was wearing an underwired bra but with a very small bit at the front. She told me to make sure the front came higher up to give more support. I took her advice and have not had any problems since. That was probably 15 years ago.

When Inwas a teenager I remember Mum saying her elderly male GP had even recommended a particular brand and style to her when she had recurrent pain. He based this on many years of seeing women patients and what they had told him.

Hitchhikingghosts · 30/09/2022 12:17

We have mammograms from when you turn 40, and then you get called every year. We are strongly encouraged to go every year too, it doesn’t cost anything. I don’t get why it would be from the age of 50, I have several friends in the early 40’s who have had breast cancer sadly.

Cookiemonstersnana · 30/09/2022 12:16

Unfortunately you might not get a mammogram when you're 50.
It goes on areas so you could be 51, 52 or even 53 depending on how big your area
you live in is.
I was 51 before I had my first.
Please contact PALS and complain.
Good luck

TheOrigRights · 30/09/2022 12:16

Hitchhikingghosts · 30/09/2022 11:44

I’m not in the UK, but do you only get a mammogram when you’re 50? It’s 40 here.

Yes, it's 50 in the UK, though some regions are trialling earlier ones.
The issue is that the younger you are the more false positives you get, so it's a balance - increased risk of cancer in older women, resources, not putting women through unnecessary procedures and worry due to a false positive.

It's not just as simple as it being better to have them earlier.

BloodAndFire · 30/09/2022 12:15

SalviaOfficinalis · 30/09/2022 11:54

Because she was expecting that the outcome of the appointment could have been that she may have breast cancer. Quite obviously.

There's nothing obvious about it. I'm in my very early 40s and was referred to the breast clinic last year on the 2 week urgent pathway due to a lump in my breast.

Both of my grandmothers and 2 aunts died of breast cancer.

Clearly there was a genuine concern that it could have been cancer.

Equally clearly of course I didn't need my husband to miss a day's work for it.

Very odd.

Hitchhikingghosts · 30/09/2022 12:13

SalviaOfficinalis · 30/09/2022 11:54

Because she was expecting that the outcome of the appointment could have been that she may have breast cancer. Quite obviously.

She wouldn’t have found that out on the same day if it was.

Snowisfallinghere · 30/09/2022 12:11

I've been living abroad for the past 5 years and I've been to gynaecologists twice in the last year with breast pain - no GP first like the UK, instead you go directly to a gynaecologist for any issues relating to breasts, reproductive health etc. Both times, they used an ultrasound to investigate, as well as manually checking them.

I think mansplaining is the perfect term for it. Instead of trusting a woman to know the difference between bra-related discomfort and concerning breast pain, and investigating further, this male doctor was dismissive. Even if he suspected that the bra is to blame, surely you can't take chances?!

TheLoupGarou · 30/09/2022 12:07

I am in my 40s and got a free mammogram via action cancer. Maybe worth checking if this is offered in your area before going private?

TheGreatATuin · 30/09/2022 12:06

Yes, he's a medical professional, but unfortunately there is plenty of evidence that male doctors in particular often do dismiss women's pain and genuine health concerns, even when they are meant to be in that specialist field. Take the vaginal mesh scandal for example.
Mansplaining is unfortunately a thing that a lot of men do, and being a doctor doesn't preclude them from that. I hope you get a second opinion, OP and are able to get to the bottom of it.

MillyWithaY · 30/09/2022 12:04

YANBU. After my father and sister in law both died due to medical malpractice/negligence (both ended in court cases) I have very little faith in so-called medical experts.

I went to see my GP due to a throbbing pain in my neck (I rarely go to the GP so hardly a hypochondriac), and she was so dismissive. At one point she aubibly sighed and said "what were you hoping for today?" I said hopefully a blood test. She sent me away with a sheet of neck exercises - no blood test. I went for a private MRI which disclosed a cyst on my thyroid.

Go private OP. I don't have mammograms as they're too painful but I pay privately for thermal imaging.

Namechangehereandnow · 30/09/2022 11:58

I don’t think it was mansplaining.
Just because he’s male doesn’t mean he can’t understand about women’s breasts and underwear in his highly specialised medical field.

I think women can underestimate just how much pain can be caused by bras to be honest. One of my underwired causes pain after a few days, and takes days or longer to subside after stopping wearing it - it appears to be no different to my others so I can’t understand it, but it is what it is 🤷‍♀️

You're entitled to a second opinion, rather than go private, you could ask your gp for a referral elsewhere for one.

Sometimessometime · 30/09/2022 11:54

Also, mammograms involve radiation, it's not a good idea to have them if not medically necessary

ImHavingAnOldFriendForDinner · 30/09/2022 11:54

That's ridiculous and I would absolutely ask for a second opinion and insist on a Mammogram. Last year I had a lump under my arm that was slightly in breast tissue so I was referred. I ended up having a mammogram, ultrasound and a biopsy because the consultant said that even though he was 99% sure it was a cyst he wouldn't be doing his job correctly without sending me away knowing he was 100% certain and I was so thankful for that.

It was a cyst but coupled with my crippling health anxiety 99% wasn't good enough for me.

SalviaOfficinalis · 30/09/2022 11:54

Hitchhikingghosts · 30/09/2022 11:48

Why did your husband take a day off work..?!

Because she was expecting that the outcome of the appointment could have been that she may have breast cancer. Quite obviously.

crowsfeet57 · 30/09/2022 11:52

OP are you sure he isn't right?

I had breast pain for over two years, it was so bad I was taking painkillers every day. I had mammograms and scans but they couldn't find anything. Finally I had an appointment with a breast nurse, she took one look and said "It's your bra!" I was wearing an underwired bra but with a very small bit at the front. She told me to make sure the front came higher up to give more support. I took her advice and have not had any problems since. That was probably 15 years ago.

Sometimessometime · 30/09/2022 11:51

Oh the one hand I agree he sounded dismissive and failed to do his job because you are not reassured.

On the other hand he probably has quite a lot of qualifications in medical issues related to the breast and therefore this can't be called mansplaining. He was doing his job by examining you. He presumably felt only healthy breast tissue and should know what he's looking for much better than a GP. If he's right he's done a good job medically, but a bad job of explaining and if he's wrong then he's negligent. Neither is mansplaining.

I once had something similar and it was indeed caused by a tight sports bra. Have you tried not wearing any kind of tight fitting bra for 2 weeks and seeing if the pain eases?

Hitchhikingghosts · 30/09/2022 11:48

Why did your husband take a day off work..?!

reesewithoutaspoon · 30/09/2022 11:46

You wont automatically get a mammogram at 50. I was 52 before I was called for my first one. You could be waiting up to 4 years.

candycaneframe · 30/09/2022 11:45

How is it mansplaining when a male doctor offers a diagnosis

Ffs, get a grip

Musti · 30/09/2022 11:45

I’ve worn underwires bras for 30 years and they don’t cause breast pain because the wire isn’t on the breast! You’ve told him you don’t always wear them and it isn’t something you’ve always had. I would ask to see someone else. Go back to your gp and explain!

BloodAndFire · 30/09/2022 11:44

I don't understand why your husband took the day off work?

Hitchhikingghosts · 30/09/2022 11:44

I’m not in the UK, but do you only get a mammogram when you’re 50? It’s 40 here.

DoubleYolker · 30/09/2022 11:42

Minimalme · 30/09/2022 11:19

I used mansplaining because he is a man who has never worn an underwired bra and was telling me about it.

Having a man examine you intimately then refuse you a basic test and tell you twice that a piece of clothing is the issue made me feel like shit.

While I understand you are upset at the way the consultation went, I don’t think it’s appropriate to dismiss his opinion because he’s a man. And I don’t think it’s mansplaining either.

He is a specialist that has spent years studying and practising. Most doctors will never have personally experienced the symptoms or illnesses that they treat, regardless of whether they are the same sex as the patient or not. That doesn’t invalidate the knowledge and experience.

You were referred for an opinion, and you got one, which I appreciate you don’t agree with and you can chose a second opinion or to go private.

Wombat27A · 30/09/2022 11:40

Another one who was told it's my bra and to wear soft bras all the time. I do now and it is actually better. I do have a lump in that area, so was scanned tho. Had another mammogram since and still ok.

It's after 50, up to your 53rd year, I think, so it might be a while to wait. My routine one was done at 50 tho.

FarmerRefuted · 30/09/2022 11:40

Thing is though, unless he has xray vision then he can't say for certain whether the pain is from an underwire or whether it's due to changes in breast tissue which may or may not be cancerous in nature. So it would be acceptable to say "I think it's due to your underwire" but he should not rule out other causes without first checking those causes.

If you went to a doctor due to blood when wiping your bottom and abdominal pain, would you expect to be told "I think you need more fibre/I think its a temporary gastrointestinal inflammation" and sent on your way or would you expect bowel cancer to still be ruled out?