Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not need mansplaining regarding my breasts?

185 replies

Minimalme · 30/09/2022 10:55

I have had some localised breast pain for last couple of months.

GP examined me and said she could feel "something" so referred me to the breast clinic.

Appointment today and was told the male
Consultant wouldn't wear a face mask but I had to.

He examined my breasts which I found really difficult because he is male.

He has concluded the pain I feel is because of my underwired bra being too tight. I told him it isn't and the pain has been consistent and I don't sleep in a bra and often wear non underwired bras.

He told me that he "still thinks it is" caused by my bra.

Then he refused to do a mammogram. He said as am 49 I will get one soon anyway.

DH has taken a day off work so I can be dismissed after a 5 minute examination.

I am upset, angry and importantly, still worried because this man has dismissed my GP's concern using his special powers of mansplaining.

I am now going private. We are not comfortably off by any stretch of the imagination.

OP posts:
Toddlerteaplease · 30/09/2022 14:53

He may never have worn an underwired bra. But as a consultant Brest doctor or surgeon. I don't think you can accuse him of mansplaining. If a female doctor had said the same, should you have felt angry? Probably not. And pain caused by underwing is a reasonable diagnosis, in the absence of anything else.

SallyWD · 30/09/2022 14:51

A highly qualified man giving his professional opinion is not mansplaining. Good to push for a mammogram though.

DrBlackbird · 30/09/2022 14:50

Why are so many focusing on one word and ignoring the bigger picture? This is a bigger MN pile on than usual. Yet, it’s an issue that we should all be aware of and be concerned about.

Have you so quickly forgotten Ian Paterson? Or, as a PP mentioned, the wire mesh scandal where women’s pain only became an issue when their male partners complained? Or indeed the sexism female doctors face? How women’s health has long been more at risk because of being seen as hysterical.

In her book Sex Matters, the US physician Alyson McGregor describes how women who are in pain often have trouble convincing the doctor treating them of how serious that pain is. The more they protest and try to convince the physician, the more their behaviour is perceived as hysterical.

For those jumping on the OP asking how’d she respond to a female doctor. Well, the recent research finds that for female patients it does matter if your doctor is male or female. A 12 year canadian study on common surgeries found worse outcomes for female patients treated by male surgeons (compared with female patients treated by female surgeons. Whereas, for heart attacks this is literally life threatening in that women with heart disease are more likely to be misdiagnosed than men, and will have worse outcomes for surgery.

This thread is utterly depressing because women need to fight to be heard when their health is at stake. Yet it’s women dismissing and denigrating the OP because they didn’t like one word she used.

LetMeSpeak · 30/09/2022 14:48

I wonder what MNs opinions would be if the genders were reversed…

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 30/09/2022 14:45

Actually, a mammogram isn't a "simple test" really due to the level of radiation - much higher than a normal xray. This is one of the reasons you would generally only get them every three years. I receive yearly mammograms as I am high risk, and am warned to ensure I don't have one in the intervening period without discussion with the team. I'm to request ultrasound at other times.

If there was no chaperone offered you really should complain. Unfortunately, the vast majority of all consultants are male, so you can't be guaranteed a female to examine you - but there should be the offer of a female chaperone for all appointments such as breast or pelvic exams. Your hospital should have a dedicated breast clinic - speak to your GP and ask for a referral to that under 14 day pathway (though it is likely to be a little longer than 14 days at the moment)

ByTheGrace · 30/09/2022 14:29

I've twice been referred for a mammogram on the back of symptoms like this, if I hadn't I'd have scraped up the funds to go private.
I was horribly dismissed by a condescending male GP when I was suffering awful pain on one side in early pregnancy. I was apparently "very silly" for expecting pregnancy to be pain free. I was in tears walking back through the waiting room, the lovely receptionist took me to one side and when I explained she got one of the other doctors to take a look. She was concerned and I was sent straight for a scan, a cyst was found and I ended up needing surgery.

justasking111 · 30/09/2022 14:23

I had a woman consultant who told me it was underwire I wasn't insulted . From now on I was told no bralettes also. I was to wear non wired bras 24/7 only removing for bathing purposes. The pain went.

Cait33 · 30/09/2022 14:18

I was at the breast clinic this week with what my GP said was hopefully lumpy breast tissue but possibly a discreet lump. I also had breast pain. The lump was difficult to find but my GP could feel it and the (male) doctor who did the ultrasound could too. The main consultant (also make) however couldn't feel anything and made me feel like a time wasting twat as both my mammogram and ultrasound showed "nothing of concern".

I sympathise OP and agree you need to have your mammogram. Some medical professionals are dicks. Just as in all other walks of life. We're told never to ignore breast changes and then treated like hysterical females by the men running the breast clinics. Go figure.

candycaneframe · 30/09/2022 14:10

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 30/09/2022 13:48

PMSL at those who think a consultant doctor can't be dismissive of a woman with a medical issue!

Whose said that?

People are merely pointing out being dismissive isn't the same as mansplaining

LuaDipa · 30/09/2022 14:01

You should definitely complain.

My GP referred me for a breast lump not too long ago. She said the criteria for urgent referral was my age (early forties) and that she could feel the lump.

Fwiw I was pretty sure from Google search that it was nothing, as was the GP, and this was pretty much confirmed by the consultant after the first examination during my appointment. She still followed the correct procedure and I had a mammogram, scan and biopsy on the day. Although I was told I could shoot straight off afterwards and just wait for my letter.

This consultant should not disregard you or your GP in this haphazard manner. Clearly if there was no issue your GP wouldn’t have made the referral. You were there for tests and you should have been given the tests. It’s ridiculous the number of consultants who disbelieve or minimise their patients experiences.

I hope all goes well with your private appointment op.Flowers

Hercules12 · 30/09/2022 13:58

Can’t believe this thread. It’s well known that woman’s health issues are a massive area of concern. Op - I would go Back to your original gp and ask for 2nd opinion.

MrsPnut · 30/09/2022 13:57

Ginisatonic · 30/09/2022 13:53

I did

So did I, but in my case I'd had a CT scan for another cancer and it showed up the breast cancer and lymph node involvement clearly.

Giveaschitt · 30/09/2022 13:56

It would have been a thousand times worse if there had been men there who weren't staff members.

You know men can get breast cancer too? So you could very easily have found yourself in the waiting room with men who weren't staff members...

saleorbouy · 30/09/2022 13:53

You obviously know about your body and he has studied medicine and then his specialist filed for many years, involving many breast examinations along the way.
To dismiss his experience as 'mansplaining' is very derogatory.
If you are not happy with the opinion ask for another 2nd opinion, in the meantime avoid underwired bras and give his theory the test.

Ginisatonic · 30/09/2022 13:53

Hitchhikingghosts · 30/09/2022 12:13

She wouldn’t have found that out on the same day if it was.

I did

NeedAHoliday2021 · 30/09/2022 13:51

@Lessofallthisunpleasantness she literally stated she wears different bras and sometimes none in her op.

MrsPnut · 30/09/2022 13:51

I'm sorry you didn't get the service you wanted, our breast clinic is nurse led which does somehow make it feel slightly friendlier.

If your MRI shows nothing then I would suggest asking to be referred to your nearest breast pain clinic for their advice.

Ours is run by a breast surgeon and she is lovely.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 30/09/2022 13:50

From a clinical point of view, breast pain is very rarely a sign of cancer and location will matter on that too. I don’t think it’s mansplaining but I wouldn’t be happy to be so dismissed. I’d contact gp and request mammogram referral or contact pals to see if they can get a second opinion from another consultant.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 30/09/2022 13:48

PMSL at those who think a consultant doctor can't be dismissive of a woman with a medical issue!

Lessofallthisunpleasantness · 30/09/2022 13:45

The fact that you 'feel shit' is on you not on him. He examined you and gave his diagnosis. If you are not happy with it then you are of course at liberty to go private. Particularly if you have particular needs as to the the sex of your doctor.

Have you considered not wearing a bra or just wearing a very soft bra for a couple of weeks to see if it could be that?

Theluggage15 · 30/09/2022 13:45

I don’t understand why you say he was mansplaining, if a female consultant had given the same answer would you have happily trotted off. What’s his sex got to do with it?

Itloggedmeoutagain · 30/09/2022 13:42

Minimalme · 30/09/2022 13:27

The Dr just said for a scan. I am so done with this thread though thanks for asking an actual question rather than bullying me like many other posters have done.

Bullying?
You mean they don't agree with you?

blubberyboo · 30/09/2022 13:42

OP

nobody derided you for having concerns about your breast.
people have merely pointed out that your thread title is entirely sexist and dismissive of a persons qualifications.
You have to remember this man has seen , felt and scanned more boobs than you will ever see in your lifetime.

if you have started with….
“AIBU to ask for a second opinion ……”

people would have given higher responses in your favour.

it is very common for people to disagree with their doctor but they are people of all sexes and all conditions.

of course you have a right to go private for a second opinion

BloodAndFire · 30/09/2022 13:41

BenCoopersSupportWren · 30/09/2022 13:32

You have absolutely no idea whether every other woman there managed "fine" or not. When I had to have extensive follow-up investigations alone during Covid - further mammogram, ultrasound, two biopsies, titanium marker insertion at a 'one-stop shop' clinic - the other women in the waiting room only saw me reading on my phone or making polite small talk. They didn't see me pulled over in the layby on my way home sobbing because I'd been internalising so much stress for two weeks.

There is nothing bizarre or odd about wanting support from one's husband at a potentially stressful time. What is bizarre is the prevailing attitude on MN that taking any kind of comfort in or enjoyment of one's partner's company is some kind of weakness.

I'm sorry you felt dismissed, OP. I think many of us who have been on the receiving end of it recognise the "here's another hysterical woman" mindset of some medical professionals, which is a very different thing from hearing an unexpected (whether for better or for worse) outcome but at least feeling like you've been listened to and investigated comprehensively. I echo the suggestion to go back to your GP and explain what happened - and what didn't - at the appointment to see if there is an alternative referral she can make.

I was also distressed and was comforted by my husband before/after the appointment. I'm talking about during the clinic itself.

There were women there of all ages from maybe 20 years old up to very elderly women, all of us in various states of stress, fear, pain, embarrassment, etc., having to repeatedly undress and undergo painful and humiliating procedures. It would have been a thousand times worse if there had been men there who weren't staff members.

There is nothing bizarre or odd about wanting support from one's husband at a potentially stressful time. What is bizarre is the prevailing attitude on MN that taking any kind of comfort in or enjoyment of one's partner's company is some kind of weakness.

It is also bizarre not to recognise that having people there who are male, not staff or patients, and not related to you can make an already traumatic experience much worse.

You may want your husband there - none of the other women there benefit from his presence - quite the reverse.

Not to mention that the clinic I attended during covid was already extremely crowded with only just enough chairs for the patients. Having had to attend antenatal clinics and stand up several times during late pregnancy while male partners took up chairs, I unfortunately know perfectly well that many men do not have the consideration or decency to allow women who are actually having treatment to sit down.

I know I am likely to have another referral in the not-too-distant future and I'm dreading it. Get comfort from your partner outside the clinic, not in a way that invades other women's privacy and takes up vital space.

The OP seems to think that her husband taking the day off work is the NHS's fault.

iekanda · 30/09/2022 13:39

Oh and let me say this re the 2 week wait/referral pathway. We think that this is fantastic because you aren't on a waiting list of months/years. It is actually shit and in other developed countries, you'd be seen the next day. We are totally brainwashed. We don't have enough docs, hospitals or anything. Wake up everyone!!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread