Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not need mansplaining regarding my breasts?

185 replies

Minimalme · 30/09/2022 10:55

I have had some localised breast pain for last couple of months.

GP examined me and said she could feel "something" so referred me to the breast clinic.

Appointment today and was told the male
Consultant wouldn't wear a face mask but I had to.

He examined my breasts which I found really difficult because he is male.

He has concluded the pain I feel is because of my underwired bra being too tight. I told him it isn't and the pain has been consistent and I don't sleep in a bra and often wear non underwired bras.

He told me that he "still thinks it is" caused by my bra.

Then he refused to do a mammogram. He said as am 49 I will get one soon anyway.

DH has taken a day off work so I can be dismissed after a 5 minute examination.

I am upset, angry and importantly, still worried because this man has dismissed my GP's concern using his special powers of mansplaining.

I am now going private. We are not comfortably off by any stretch of the imagination.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LovePoppy · 30/09/2022 21:42

ChangedNameAgain99 · 30/09/2022 10:57

He’s probably tested himself for covid. And perhaps he’s seen that pain before? He probably looks at and analyses more breast/breast pain than you do?

he completely dismissed what she was saying though

VroomVrooom · 30/09/2022 20:28

I’m sorry I upset you with the comment. Genuinely.

Personally, I felt extremely vulnerable, frightened, and exposed while moving between the different parts of the breast clinic, waiting to see if I had the same disease that's killed most of my female relatives.

This sticks out to me, though.

This feeling is exactly why some people want to have someone with them. And it’s exactly why some partners want to go with the person having the appointment.

I have had several routine screenings, where I’ve gone by myself, because it’s routine and I didn’t feel I needed anyone.

But one time I went because I had specific concerns and symptoms, and DH came with me.

I felt frightened and vulnerable, and wanted someone with me - likewise, breast cancer killed both my grandmothers before I was even born.

Yesterday, for my routine screening, DH asked me if I wanted him there, and I said no. That wouldn’t necessarily always be my answer, though.

BloodAndFire · 30/09/2022 20:19

VroomVrooom · 30/09/2022 19:53

I actually think not allowing extra people into all medical settings during covid (obviously except for children or those who are vulnerable/need additional assistance etc.) generally made hospitals/clinics much more bearable.

It made it much more bearable for you.

It no doubt made it much more stressful for other people, though.

I’m the first to not want men on ante- and post-natal wards, for example - especially outside visiting hours - when women are actually vulnerable, frightened, exposed, and in need of privacy and dignity.

But in a waiting room? No, I’m fine with people who need someone with them to have that.

Sorry, I hadn't realised you were the same poster who made the very nasty dig about 'some people actually like their partner'. I wouldn't have bothered responding if I'd realised.

GordonShakespearedoesChristmas · 30/09/2022 20:15

Just because someone is wrong doesn't make it mansplaining.

BloodAndFire · 30/09/2022 20:14

VroomVrooom · 30/09/2022 19:53

I actually think not allowing extra people into all medical settings during covid (obviously except for children or those who are vulnerable/need additional assistance etc.) generally made hospitals/clinics much more bearable.

It made it much more bearable for you.

It no doubt made it much more stressful for other people, though.

I’m the first to not want men on ante- and post-natal wards, for example - especially outside visiting hours - when women are actually vulnerable, frightened, exposed, and in need of privacy and dignity.

But in a waiting room? No, I’m fine with people who need someone with them to have that.

I agree with you about ante/postnatal wards, based on first-hand experience. But that's part of why (in retrospect) I felt so much more comfortable in a clinic without male partners hanging around - because I learned that men really don't have any respect for women undergoing medical procedures, regardless of whether or not their own partner is one of them.

Personally, I felt extremely vulnerable, frightened, and exposed while moving between the different parts of the breast clinic, waiting to see if I had the same disease that's killed most of my female relatives.

Clearly there are differences of opinion here. I recognise you feel differently to me. It would be nice if we all had a choice, but given that getting any treatment at all on the NHS is like winning the lottery at the moment, that's obviously a pipe dream.

Scianel · 30/09/2022 20:11

It’s not mansplaining, it’s doctorsplaining. He’s the expert. Listen to him..

Why do people still have such faith in doctors? I've read horror story after horror story of issues being misdiagnosed and missed.

My FIL has only a 30% chance of being alive in five years due to being told he was suffering from piles - for five years. Now has a Gleason score of 9.

My friend's mother was so ill with bowel cancer she was hospitalised and they somehow still missed it. By the time that was diagnosed she was terminal.

I have permanent injuries from a medication that a doctor should not have prescribed to me.

People have to inform themselves, and advocate for themselves. "Listening to the expert" could just as easily kill you.

VroomVrooom · 30/09/2022 19:53

I actually think not allowing extra people into all medical settings during covid (obviously except for children or those who are vulnerable/need additional assistance etc.) generally made hospitals/clinics much more bearable.

It made it much more bearable for you.

It no doubt made it much more stressful for other people, though.

I’m the first to not want men on ante- and post-natal wards, for example - especially outside visiting hours - when women are actually vulnerable, frightened, exposed, and in need of privacy and dignity.

But in a waiting room? No, I’m fine with people who need someone with them to have that.

BloodAndFire · 30/09/2022 19:49

Buzzinwithbez · 30/09/2022 17:48

The waiting room for the breast clinic at our hospital covers every sort of reason for which there might be an x-ray or ultrasound. Once you are called, it's a conveyer belt of change into a gown, mammogram, ultrasound. No one goes back there but the patient, but it's so slick that you don't bump into any other patients either, then it's back to a mixed waiting room to wait to see a consultant.

I know now how my body responds to a painful procedure, so know to have someone with me to drive me home. I'd also want something there to do extra remembering of conversations etc. If there was a next steps type conversation to be had, because dealing with the shock and emotion could make that quite hard I imagine.

The breast clinic I attended was very specifically a breast clinic, nothing else being done there, and it was the height of covid so very strict rules about entering the hospital. You couldn't even go in to get a coffee before your appointment.

It's only my personal experience but there was a genuine sense of camaraderie, mutual support and respect for other patients (all of whom were women on that day at least) which I found comforting at a very difficult time.

Quite the opposite of attending antenatal clinics where blokes sprawl across chairs looking at their phone while pregnant women have to stand.

I respect your view and that others feel differently.

i'm not responding to those other posters (not you) who thought it was appropriate to mock me, say I don't like my own husband or that I'm 'scared of men'. There's no need to insult people because they feel differently about something.

BloodAndFire · 30/09/2022 19:43

longtompot · 30/09/2022 18:38

It was before covid so things might have changed but my dh went to our local breast clinic as he had some lumps and he waited in the same waiting rooms as the women

Sorry to hear about your husband..I hope he's OK now?

Personally I feel differently about men who are there as patients themselves. I feel the same empathy/sympathy with them as with female patients.

I actually think not allowing extra people into all medical settings during covid (obviously except for children or those who are vulnerable/need additional assistance etc.) generally made hospitals/clinics much more bearable.

Having twice the number of people in a clinic, only half of whom need to be there, just makes everything more overcrowded, uncomfortable,noisy and stressful.

longtompot · 30/09/2022 18:38

BloodAndFire · 30/09/2022 16:49

In fact, I was interested so I looked this up, and you're wrong. In all of the information I could find, male patients are seen separately from female patients. So, it's not just extremely statistically unlikely that a male patient would be there but in fact the NHS - apparently unlike you - understands that women (and men) deserve privacy and single-sex facilities.

See for example:

Although, at the Linda McCartney Breast Unit, we do not run a separate clinic for men, you will wait and be seen in a private and separate area from women attending the same clinic.
www.rlbuht.nhs.uk/departments/medical-specialisms/breast-unit/i-am-a-man-with-a-breast-symptom/

It was before covid so things might have changed but my dh went to our local breast clinic as he had some lumps and he waited in the same waiting rooms as the women

Toddlerteaplease · 30/09/2022 18:10

@BloodAndFire my friends husband is currently being treated for Brest cancer, he's had a mastectomy and chemo. My friend is upset that the Breast Institute is all painted pink!

Buzzinwithbez · 30/09/2022 17:48

The waiting room for the breast clinic at our hospital covers every sort of reason for which there might be an x-ray or ultrasound. Once you are called, it's a conveyer belt of change into a gown, mammogram, ultrasound. No one goes back there but the patient, but it's so slick that you don't bump into any other patients either, then it's back to a mixed waiting room to wait to see a consultant.

I know now how my body responds to a painful procedure, so know to have someone with me to drive me home. I'd also want something there to do extra remembering of conversations etc. If there was a next steps type conversation to be had, because dealing with the shock and emotion could make that quite hard I imagine.

mam0918 · 30/09/2022 17:18

BloodAndFire · 30/09/2022 16:52

I will never, ever understand why some women are so determined to insist on the right of men to be in every single space, even those spaces where the overwhelming majority of women feel vulnerable, frightened, exposed, and in need of privacy and dignity. Is it really the worst imaginable offence to suggest that men might not be welcome somewhere?

Most women aren't so irrationally scared of men they cant share a waiting room with a man who is doing absoloutly nothing wrong - your views is the abnormal one.

If you are upset that a womans chaperone has a penis thats YOUR issue to deal with, it doesnt remove anyone elses rights.

As I said I have been through this, most people had a chaperone, many where men and no one appeared upset... I can say for a fact I wasn't and that a man comforting his wife in no way impacted on my experiance.

VroomVrooom · 30/09/2022 17:15

BloodAndFire · 30/09/2022 16:52

I will never, ever understand why some women are so determined to insist on the right of men to be in every single space, even those spaces where the overwhelming majority of women feel vulnerable, frightened, exposed, and in need of privacy and dignity. Is it really the worst imaginable offence to suggest that men might not be welcome somewhere?

We are talking about the waiting room, right?

Random men aren’t following you through to your consultation space, are they?

I had a mammogram yesterday at the Radiology clinic. What with it servicing both men and women (i.e. mammograms are one of many services), there were men there with their wives/partners and women with husbands/partners.

I was alone, but I have had DH with me in the past, and I don’t begrudge anyone taking someone with them, if it’s what they need.

Some people actually like and care for their partner. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Shortname · 30/09/2022 16:57

This doesn't sound at all like your're being unreasonable. My experience last year, found a lump GP thought prob nothing but referred to breast cancer clinic 'just in case' consultant thought prob nothing but referred for mammogram 'just in case' mammogram not conclusive so sent for ultrasound 'just in case' ultrasound not conclusive so biopsies taken same day. Biopsy confirmed all ok. To summarise everyone i saw thought it was nothing but wanted to be 100% sure, surely that's how this should work.

WildFlowerBees · 30/09/2022 16:55

Op get a second opinion, why some still treat medical 'professionals' as gods I do not know. You have to be happy I hope your next consultation puts your mind at ease.

BloodAndFire · 30/09/2022 16:52

I will never, ever understand why some women are so determined to insist on the right of men to be in every single space, even those spaces where the overwhelming majority of women feel vulnerable, frightened, exposed, and in need of privacy and dignity. Is it really the worst imaginable offence to suggest that men might not be welcome somewhere?

BloodAndFire · 30/09/2022 16:49

Giveaschitt · 30/09/2022 13:56

It would have been a thousand times worse if there had been men there who weren't staff members.

You know men can get breast cancer too? So you could very easily have found yourself in the waiting room with men who weren't staff members...

In fact, I was interested so I looked this up, and you're wrong. In all of the information I could find, male patients are seen separately from female patients. So, it's not just extremely statistically unlikely that a male patient would be there but in fact the NHS - apparently unlike you - understands that women (and men) deserve privacy and single-sex facilities.

See for example:

Although, at the Linda McCartney Breast Unit, we do not run a separate clinic for men, you will wait and be seen in a private and separate area from women attending the same clinic.
www.rlbuht.nhs.uk/departments/medical-specialisms/breast-unit/i-am-a-man-with-a-breast-symptom/

BloodAndFire · 30/09/2022 16:47

Giveaschitt · 30/09/2022 13:56

It would have been a thousand times worse if there had been men there who weren't staff members.

You know men can get breast cancer too? So you could very easily have found yourself in the waiting room with men who weren't staff members...

I mean, yes, fewer than 1 in 100 cases of breast cancer, and no men at all are sent for routine mammograms, so yes, it's just about possible - although I think 'very easily' is pushing it - that one of the patients that day might have been male.

Although none were.

However, there is very clearly a difference between a man who is also going through the same experience - and has a reason to be there, like a staff member does - with whom you would feel empathy and pity - and a man who's just there as a spectator, needlessly taking up space and making all of those who are there feel less comfortable and more exposed.

KnickerlessParsons · 30/09/2022 16:05

If it had been a small breasted woman, or a woman who had had a mastectomy telling you that the pain was caused by your bra, would you also dismiss the non diagnosis?

Would you suggest that a female consultant who examined a male for eg prostrate cancer was also being inappropriate for not wearing a mask and would you dismiss her diagnosis if she gave a patient the all clear?

Hydrangeatea · 30/09/2022 15:54

DoubleYolker · 30/09/2022 11:42

While I understand you are upset at the way the consultation went, I don’t think it’s appropriate to dismiss his opinion because he’s a man. And I don’t think it’s mansplaining either.

He is a specialist that has spent years studying and practising. Most doctors will never have personally experienced the symptoms or illnesses that they treat, regardless of whether they are the same sex as the patient or not. That doesn’t invalidate the knowledge and experience.

You were referred for an opinion, and you got one, which I appreciate you don’t agree with and you can chose a second opinion or to go private.

Perfectly put

longtompot · 30/09/2022 15:52

DrBlackbird · 30/09/2022 14:50

Why are so many focusing on one word and ignoring the bigger picture? This is a bigger MN pile on than usual. Yet, it’s an issue that we should all be aware of and be concerned about.

Have you so quickly forgotten Ian Paterson? Or, as a PP mentioned, the wire mesh scandal where women’s pain only became an issue when their male partners complained? Or indeed the sexism female doctors face? How women’s health has long been more at risk because of being seen as hysterical.

In her book Sex Matters, the US physician Alyson McGregor describes how women who are in pain often have trouble convincing the doctor treating them of how serious that pain is. The more they protest and try to convince the physician, the more their behaviour is perceived as hysterical.

For those jumping on the OP asking how’d she respond to a female doctor. Well, the recent research finds that for female patients it does matter if your doctor is male or female. A 12 year canadian study on common surgeries found worse outcomes for female patients treated by male surgeons (compared with female patients treated by female surgeons. Whereas, for heart attacks this is literally life threatening in that women with heart disease are more likely to be misdiagnosed than men, and will have worse outcomes for surgery.

This thread is utterly depressing because women need to fight to be heard when their health is at stake. Yet it’s women dismissing and denigrating the OP because they didn’t like one word she used.

I totally agree. The amount of times drs haven't listened to me or my dds but as soon as my dh goes in with them or me for the appointment suddenly things get done and he is listened to. It frustrates him as much as it does us that his mere presence makes this happen.
Even if you aren't replying op I do hope you are still reading some of the replies. Most of us are behind you and here to support you💐

VoiceOfCommonSense · 30/09/2022 15:25

It’s not mansplaining, it’s doctorsplaining. He’s the expert. Listen to him..

Whatsthestorytomorrow · 30/09/2022 15:17

longtompot · 30/09/2022 12:43

The type of bra aside, your GP felt a lump and that should be investigated. I would contact PALS and see what they can do to help you, and get back to your GP about his refusal to do a mammogram. I hope the lump turns out to be nothing, but as they say with these things, time is critical. Why have a two week pathway available if it isn't?

Tbf the 2 weeks is so you can be seen by a specialist, it doesn’t mean you get every test/investigation.
Op has been seen, the consultant has decided no investigations are necessary. OP is going to be seen privately to be sure.

Re the mask issue -I’m wondering if he was wearing glasses? I’d rather he had a clear view than fogged up specs for such an important examination.

CandyLeBonBon · 30/09/2022 15:14

Women are very often not taken seriously when it comes to their health, and often we don't speak up and fight for ourselves for a variety of reasons,

This^^ There is still a lot of frankly sexist dismissal by male HCPs who don't take women seriously.

When I was pregnant with my first, I developed abdominal/flank pains when I was 6 months pregnant. My horribly sexist consultant chastised me for overdoing it at the gym and causing nerve root pain, for which he prescribed hydrotherapy.

It turned out that the baby was lying across my ureter, causing my kidneys to back up (causing a similar effect to kidney stones) meaning I had to have an emergency nephrostomy for the last 3/4 months of pregnancy to avoid dying!! My pain was dismissed, and I was deemed just a silly, hysterical woman who was exaggerating her pain and just needed to get a grip.

So apart from the use of the word mansplaining here which is possibly questionable, you're not wrong to want better care OP.