Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think she's being entitled?

258 replies

dnalger · 30/09/2022 09:52

NC’d as this could be outing.

Been with partner for nearly 4 years, house is in both of our names, we currently don't have children together but we are ttc, he has a 15 year old with his ex and they split when he was 9 or 10 and are friends.

About a month ago, his son told DP that his exs partner was being abusive towards his mum. DP said they could stay with us, including her 11 month old that she has with the (now) ex. He said it would be for a few days as it was almost his sons birthday.

It has now been a month and they're still staying here, his ex has said she's looking for a house to rent but she isn't paying anything to contribute to food etc as DP has said she doesn't need too.

Anyway, DP has been watching the baby (which I don't think he should be as he isn't the father) and this morning the ex has asked if he can watch him this afternoon as the baby is unwell so can't go to nursery and she has an appointment, DP has plans later and has said I will as I'm off work this afternoon (I didn't agree!)

AIBU to think she's being entitled?

OP posts:
SleepingStandingUp · 30/09/2022 13:25

YetAnotherSpartacus · 30/09/2022 13:22

And that’s all you need to do. You are doing just fine. Honestly just ignore the people overreacting.

That's all anyone would expect if you didn't have breasts, a womb and a vagina.

Nope. If someone was stopping here with their 11 month old, I'd expect penis owning DH to act like a mature adult and not "not interact because he isn't blood".

buggeringbuggery · 30/09/2022 13:26

What is her long-term goal re; living arrangements?

If she wants to be rehoused by the council, then that wouldn't happen whilst she is living with you (it certainly would never happen in my area, as overcrowding is a very low priority and she has somewhere safe to live.

So if she wants to get rehoused, then she will have to present to the local council as homeless, If she wants to rent somewhere, then she should be actively looking, and it sounds like she isn't.

I say this as someone who was thrown out of home, with a baby, by my parents.

I also say this as someone who was brutally beaten by my son's father (before and after his birth - even though we split before birth). He broke my leg so badly before I became pregnant, that now - over 30 years later, I can hardly walk as my tibia never joined together properly, causing my hips and knees to come out of alignment and my ankle is so damaged it needs to be fused.

My son's father also came round and tried to kill us when DS was 13 - he was sent to prison for 5 years for this. So it's not that I don't have sympathy, but she does need to take some action herself.

funinthesun19 · 30/09/2022 13:26

YetAnotherSpartacus · 30/09/2022 13:22

And that’s all you need to do. You are doing just fine. Honestly just ignore the people overreacting.

That's all anyone would expect if you didn't have breasts, a womb and a vagina.

You’ve lost me there. Could you elaborate please?

YetAnotherSpartacus · 30/09/2022 13:27

Nope. If someone was stopping here with their 11 month old, I'd expect penis owning DH to act like a mature adult and not "not interact because he isn't blood".

Feck. Most males posted about on MN do SFA too look after their own kids!

IsleofDen · 30/09/2022 13:27

Sometimes situations happen where you cannot win, this is one of them and I suspect your relationship won’t survive.

He's assuming that you naturally want to help, you are bubbling with resentment over the situation and both of you feel justified. Does it really matter who’s right and who’s wrong?

For the sake of everyone involved, you should probably stop TTC and reassess what you want long term.

WhereYouLeftIt · 30/09/2022 13:28

No, she is not being entitled. She needs to go to the dentist, the baby's not well so shouldn't go. She ASKED if he could mind the baby whist she was at the dentist, that is not entitlement. (And as an aside, even if the baby had been hale and hearty I think it should not have been taken to the dental appointment.)

The person in the wrong is your husband for not asking you if you could look after the baby, instead volunteering your services, presumably because he knew you had the afternoon off. He shouldn't have done that. If he'd said he couldn't, it's perfectly possible she'd have asked someone else for the favour (not you). So if you're feeling resentful at your plans being upended, apportion blame where blame is due, and that's with your partner.

"The baby is around the house but I've not interacted with him as he's not related to me so I don't think that's my job, so no even though he's been here for a month I don't know him."
That's actually quite disturbing. I cannot imagine not interacting with someone who has been living in my house for a month. How do you even manage that, do you stay in your bedroom all the time? Behave in such a way that his ex keeps to her bedroom out of your way? Just - how? And why? You're clearly resenting his ex and her baby being there (and possibly stepson too for being there all the time as opposed to half the time. I get that it must feel like your home is no longer your haven, but can you really not muster any fellow feeling for a woman who has just escaped an abusive relationship? This is a temporary situation, albeit not quite as temporary as it first seemed, but instead of just nursing your resentment at her, why not act like an adult and point out to partner and his ex that you all need to sit down and plan the domestic future of the household. You've mentioned food costs, maybe she'd like to contribute but feels she can't raise the subject because then it sounds like she plans to stay longer. Just a suggestion.

The three adults need to talk honestly about what's happening now and what's going to happen. At no point in this discussion must she feel her only option is to return to an abuser. But some clarity on plans would benefit all three of you.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 30/09/2022 13:29

For the sake of everyone involved, you should probably stop TTC and reassess what you want long term.

Short term I'd be making an excuse to be absent (somewhere nice) so the DP could not volunteer me for childcare.

LovePoppy · 30/09/2022 13:30

IsleofDen · 30/09/2022 13:27

Sometimes situations happen where you cannot win, this is one of them and I suspect your relationship won’t survive.

He's assuming that you naturally want to help, you are bubbling with resentment over the situation and both of you feel justified. Does it really matter who’s right and who’s wrong?

For the sake of everyone involved, you should probably stop TTC and reassess what you want long term.

This is how I feel as well

I would not be surprised at DP and ex getting back together with ing days of op giving up

she’s being treated as a third wheel/babysitter in her own house while the adults make the decisions

Sushi7 · 30/09/2022 13:31

@dnalger tell your DP that the baby (that isn’t his) has to go back to his mum or a grandparent etc. DP’s DS can continue to live with you and DP.

nozbottheblue · 30/09/2022 13:32

None of this is the baby's fault. Maybe just be nice and look after the poorly baby as a one-off? Hopefully DP will really appreciate it and love you more for it. But do discuss your feelings with DP or your resentment is only going to increase.

JudgeJ · 30/09/2022 13:35

10HailMarys · 30/09/2022 10:03

She's not being entitled. She had nowhere else to go. It's not easy to find a new home in such a short space of time. And more to the point, your DP said it was OK.

I completely understand why you feel awful about your DP's ex being in your home - I would too. But this isn't her fault. And while she is there, it's incredibly churlish to resent your DP keeping an eye on her baby now and again. It will be a lot easier for her to get her life in gear again if she doesn't always have to have the baby in tow every time she needs to sort something out, and it's in your interests if you want her to leave.

The problem here is your DP, not his ex.

So for how long would you expect the OP to tolerate this non-paying guest in their home? As things stand she, the ex, is sitting pretty, living for free with the expectation of a built in baby sitting service for another man's child. She needs to be given a dealine for finding somewhere else to live, the child she shares with OP's partner could stay longer if necessary.

andtheweedonkey · 30/09/2022 13:36

You need to have a serious and very private talk with your DP before this goes on any longer.

She needs to move out ASAP. It is not a case of her contributing to the bills/paying rent, because it's not her home.

This was a very temporary measure giving her an escape.

She should have been looking for somewhere else or approached the council as homeless already.

LosingMyPancakes · 30/09/2022 13:36

I wonder how many people posting here claiming OP is right to be annoyed and to want the ex and her kids out are also the ones who jump on every other thread telling the OPs to LTB... No surprise it is SO hard for people to ask for help in these situations when they can read the resentment in some of these comments.

FiveGreenBottles · 30/09/2022 13:37

The problem is this arrangement benefits everyone excerpt you., so you’re the only member of the household wanting to end it.

DP gets to have his cake and eat it (ex and child living with him, new partner to help fund it)

Ex gets free food and accommodation

DSS gets mum & dad ostensibly back together.

You get the awkwardness of living in (and Co funding) an effective ménage a trois, where (even worse), DP and ex are starting to treat you as the live in nanny.

When you mention the ex moving out, you become the bad guy wanting to throw a vulnerable woman and her children out on the street.

The reality is that the ex is likely to be in a very vulnerable coming out of abusive relationship, and it will take the concerted effort of you and your DP working as a team to support her in finding new accommodation.

If , after a clear conversation between you, your DP shows no inclination to set a timeline for the ex to move out, the nuclear option is to put the house up for sale and leave your DP and the ex to it.

Crumpleton · 30/09/2022 13:39

DeadDonkey · 30/09/2022 12:52

How can you be so cold as not interact with a baby in your house?

Maybe OP feels that by interacting with the baby her DP and his EX will assume she's happy to look after him and start putting more onto her.

It's not helping the EX move on with her life if she continues living there, she needs support with going to her local authorities to see about accommodation with two DC she'll stand a chance of being housed, unfortunately it may not be a three bedroomed house to start with but whatever she's offered it will be her own place.

Those saying the baby is family because they're the DS half sibling would you still say that if his DM abusive EX had other DC and they suddenly turned up, after all they're still DS half siblings...
They'll be as related to the DP and his EX about as much as the EX's DC by abuser is related to the OP and her DP...
But they'll still be DS half siblings.

YetAnotherSpartacus · 30/09/2022 13:41

The reality is that the ex is likely to be in a very vulnerable coming out of abusive relationship, and it will take the concerted effort of you and your DP working as a team to support her in finding new accommodation.

If , after a clear conversation between you, your DP shows no inclination to set a timeline for the ex to move out, the nuclear option is to put the house up for sale and leave your DP and the ex to it.

Agree with this and your whole post really.

dnalger · 30/09/2022 13:44

I did agree to them staying at first as DP told me it’d be a week maximum as it was stepsons birthday and so his ex could sort something out, whether it was going to the council or staying at a family members, but he's now saying she can stay until she finds somewhere to rent and so she can save, she does work part time.

DPs plans for this afternoon were going to the gym and then going to the pub with his mates, he knew about my plans as he asked if id still be able to pick stepson up from school which I agreed to, I didn't agree to looking after the baby though and I know DP is to blame for that and not his ex.

OP posts:
Dacadactyl · 30/09/2022 13:44

Crumpleton · 30/09/2022 13:39

Maybe OP feels that by interacting with the baby her DP and his EX will assume she's happy to look after him and start putting more onto her.

It's not helping the EX move on with her life if she continues living there, she needs support with going to her local authorities to see about accommodation with two DC she'll stand a chance of being housed, unfortunately it may not be a three bedroomed house to start with but whatever she's offered it will be her own place.

Those saying the baby is family because they're the DS half sibling would you still say that if his DM abusive EX had other DC and they suddenly turned up, after all they're still DS half siblings...
They'll be as related to the DP and his EX about as much as the EX's DC by abuser is related to the OP and her DP...
But they'll still be DS half siblings.

This is exactly my point about it. All too messy for everyone concerned. I'd hitch myself to a man with no kids rather than have all this drama and confusion in the air. Step siblings, half siblings, siblings by virtue of being dad's latest woman...I mean, come on?!

picklemewalnuts · 30/09/2022 13:45

Well that's outrageous- he can change his plans, why should you?

YetAnotherSpartacus · 30/09/2022 13:47

DPs plans for this afternoon were going to the gym and then going to the pub with his mates, he knew about my plans as he asked if id still be able to pick stepson up from school which I agreed to, I didn't agree to looking after the baby though and I know DP is to blame for that and not his ex.

Oh why, oh why did I know that DP's plans would not involve donating blood, helping in an aged-care centre or attending an important interview but would be about him and his male privilege of a leisure time while you did the wimmin's work.

He's not a catch, OP.

RUN.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 30/09/2022 13:49

I'd be making a stand after a month - she either finds somewhere pretty quick or she starts paying her way. I'd also continue with my plans for the afternoon, DH can change his or the ex can ask someone else.

SuperCamp · 30/09/2022 13:49

Your DP has a child and there should surely never be any quibble or question about him housing or caring for his child? And treating the child and their half sibling equally is kind.

I see no problem with your DP caring for his child’s half sibling. It’s what Bob Geldof did when Paula Yates died!

Fair enough, he shouldn’t have presumed that you could or would offer childcare, but how can you say you don’t know the baby when the baby has been in your home for a month?

I don’t think she is ‘entitled’, I think she is an abused woman, looking to sort out housing etc as a single mum. Rentals are impossible atm.

Crumpleton · 30/09/2022 13:50

DPs plans for this afternoon were going to the gym and then going to the pub with his mates, he knew about my plans as he asked if id still be able to pick stepson up from school which I agreed to, I didn't agree to looking after the baby though and I know DP is to blame for that and not his ex.

I'm thinking you're being taken for a ride. Neither of these excuses are reasonable enough to suggest that you look after his EX's baby.
Did/will you do it though?

WhereYouLeftIt · 30/09/2022 13:51

dnalger · 30/09/2022 13:44

I did agree to them staying at first as DP told me it’d be a week maximum as it was stepsons birthday and so his ex could sort something out, whether it was going to the council or staying at a family members, but he's now saying she can stay until she finds somewhere to rent and so she can save, she does work part time.

DPs plans for this afternoon were going to the gym and then going to the pub with his mates, he knew about my plans as he asked if id still be able to pick stepson up from school which I agreed to, I didn't agree to looking after the baby though and I know DP is to blame for that and not his ex.

He wanted to go the gym and the pub with his mates. In what way does that trump you meeting a friend for coffee? Answer - it doesn't.

So what actually happened? Who looked after the baby in the end?

AbsoluteTruths · 30/09/2022 13:53

he's now saying she can stay until she finds somewhere to rent and so she can save, she does work part time That's what he's saying, but he doesn't get to make all the decisions. A normal partnership involves discussion and agreement and it seems in your relationship he decides and you are expected to go along with it. Unheallthy.