Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Did anyone watch the panorama documentary about the psych hospital and wasn't shocked?

67 replies

missbipolar · 30/09/2022 09:10

As someone who's had several psych admissions, the panorama doc didn't shock me. When I was one of the wards one of the support staff told me if I really wanted to die DESCRIPTION OF SUICIDE METHODS WITHDRAWN BY MNHQ we used to hear the night staff bitching about patients, checks often weren't preformed correctly- I was 5 minute checks for awhile and on multiple occasions wasn't checked for 45mins to an hour. Patients get locked out of their rooms as its "easier" for staff to deal with but this can sometimes be for over 24 hours and there's not really any place for them to sleep outside of the room. And then when you get discharged in alot of cases there's almost zero follow up for a while which means people end up bouncing back in. Rooms where frequently stripped and it took could weeks for people to get their stuff back, with some often wearing the same clothes for several days.

Obviously what happened at the hospital on panorama was dangerous and they absolutely deserve to be shut down but did anyone else not actually find it shocking?

POST EDITED BT MNHQ

OP posts:
RheanaT · 30/09/2022 12:20

The reporter had probably got wind of how bad it was in there and then decided to do an undercover report on the unit.

I work in an inpatient female forensic unit and it's really well run and majority of the staff are brilliant, it's sometimes difficult to discharge the service users as they don't want to leave.

However, I have seen staff bitten , punched , kicked, spat at by service users all while trying to provide care, and they still go back to care for those same service users.

Miffee · 30/09/2022 12:14

OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 12:06

ITS BECAUSE YOU DONT UNDERSTAND THE ISSUE.

You do realise I have said I have had these experiences upthread? It happened because of abusive staff, nothing to do with funding. No one else in that organisation abused me except for one person.

I think I probably have more understanding as an expert by experience of abuse by health care professionals and why it happens than you and your "frontline" experience.

A job that is draining and soul destroying (and there are many) does not lead to someone abusing people.

Did you not read my post at all? I never said a bad job makes people abusive, not even close. I was very clear.

missbipolar · 30/09/2022 12:11

Yes sorry for mentioning suicide methods- I think I'm slightly desensitised to it now and didn't stop and think. Thank you mn for removing it

OP posts:
OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 12:07

And for everyone commenting - it's best practice not to detail suicide methods and has always been an MNHQ policy for as long as I can remember (it's also why journalists don't detail methods).

Just look at the case going on with instagram at the moment.

OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 12:06

ITS BECAUSE YOU DONT UNDERSTAND THE ISSUE.

You do realise I have said I have had these experiences upthread? It happened because of abusive staff, nothing to do with funding. No one else in that organisation abused me except for one person.

I think I probably have more understanding as an expert by experience of abuse by health care professionals and why it happens than you and your "frontline" experience.

A job that is draining and soul destroying (and there are many) does not lead to someone abusing people.

AntsGoMarchingOneByOne · 30/09/2022 12:06

AthenaPopodopolous · 30/09/2022 09:38

Sorry but I’ve reported this post as you’ve detailed two methods of suicide. Can you take this down?

🙄🙄🙄

Miffee · 30/09/2022 12:00

Another aspect of this is institutionalisation of staff. What struck me from the reports in Manchester was the phrase "she's the cancer of the ward and needs cutting out".

Obviously on the surface its fucking horrific but I think it speaks to something even more troubling about the way staff have a very warped view of their workplace. Too much ownership of it? I can't quite put into words what I mean.

x2boys · 30/09/2022 12:00

missbipolar · 30/09/2022 11:56

I do think underfunding does come into it to some degree although the fact they're understaffed is the biggest problem. The ward I'm talking about here (I've been on 4 in the last 18 months, while the others had their issues this ward was by far the worst) didn't really have the budget for agency staff etc, so sometimes there was only 1 nurse and 4 support staff on during the day when it's supposed to have 2 nurses and 6 support staff when fully staffed. The ward manager was almost never seen often working from home, and when your work from home you don't actually get to see the issues that are going on.

And even if they are in the building ,they attend countless meetings so don't actually spend much time physically on the ward.

Miffee · 30/09/2022 11:56

OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 11:27

UNDERFUNDING DOES NOT LEAD TO ABUSIVE BEHAVIOUR.

So fed up of this argument.

Schools are underfunded, do you expect your children to be abused at school?

ITS BECAUSE YOU DONT UNDERSTAND THE ISSUE.

It leads to bad staff, all bad staff are not abusive (some are just lazy and disinterested) but all abusive staff are bad.

I worked in front line services. It's a fucking nightmare. Lack of services and funding with statutory duties we cannot possibly fulfil due to lack of resources. I want to do my job right, I care passionately. It's draining and soul destroying. Such an environment filters out good staff and retains shit staff. If you don't care it doesn't bother you that you can't work by your values.

Even worse this encourages terrible leadership. If your job (Lead an institution/team/service were you carry out statutory duties while providing best practice care and meeting needs holistically) is impossible you are going to attract bullshitters who can blag that they can do impossible. Senior leadership are often little better than fucking grifters who exist only to provide plausible deniability to politicians.

missbipolar · 30/09/2022 11:56

I do think underfunding does come into it to some degree although the fact they're understaffed is the biggest problem. The ward I'm talking about here (I've been on 4 in the last 18 months, while the others had their issues this ward was by far the worst) didn't really have the budget for agency staff etc, so sometimes there was only 1 nurse and 4 support staff on during the day when it's supposed to have 2 nurses and 6 support staff when fully staffed. The ward manager was almost never seen often working from home, and when your work from home you don't actually get to see the issues that are going on.

OP posts:
OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 11:53

There is zero reason someone displays abusive behaviour apart from the fact that they are abusive.

There were countless times in the documentary where there were multiple staff involved, there are countless schools currently going through child abuse inquiries (SCAI) where multiple children were allegedly (sorry I am giving evidence soon) abused, all because people were abusive. There is no other excuse or causation for abuse other than the person is an abuser.

Every other argument just dilutes what is actually happening, complete failures of systems, DBS is simply not fit for purpose, reporting and whistleblowing is not fit for purpose, patients (as a collective rather than the minority) voices are not being heard.

x2boys · 30/09/2022 11:48

willingtolearn · 30/09/2022 11:42

@OhFrogOff

It's a bit different in education as someone will always be put in front of the children.

But underfunding in the NHS = fewer staff, fewer experienced staff, lower qualified staff.

This leads to

Good staff leaving understaffed unit, struggling to recruit, unit being even more understaffed, poorer quality staff being recruited. Poor care becomes tolerated.

Which leads to

Poorer practice as even more good staff empty out, followed by reasonable staff leaving only poor quality or desperate staff who haven't found a way out yet. Poor care becomes normal. Incidents of abuse are tolerated by staff.

which then leads to

Critical shortage of staff, shoestring staffing with recruitment of warm bodies. Incidents of abuse become normal.

The very same trust keeps opening and closing ward,s at the drop of a hat and spending millions on refurbishment, and then closing the ward less then 12 months ,so they are not exactly being sensible with the funding they do get
They also redeployed me twice in 12 months between 2005 and 2006 due to cuts ,so they have had issues for years.

watcherintherye · 30/09/2022 11:47

Underfunded and understaffed - Under paid and under trained.

I do agree with the above, but….
There are many, many underpaid and under-trained staff who would not behave like this. The appalling behaviours we see time and time again aren’t caused by being underpaid and under trained. They are facilitated by the apparent inability to sift out the unsuitable staff who are given access to jobs ‘caring’ for vulnerable people, because ‘staffing crisis.’

The staff we see behaving appallingly wouldn’t undergo a miraculous transformation if they were given more training or more money. They would still be scum. A staffing crisis shouldn’t be an excuse for allowing the dregs of society to be let loose on people who have no means of protecting themselves.

ChagSameachDoreen · 30/09/2022 11:46

AthenaPopodopolous · 30/09/2022 09:38

Sorry but I’ve reported this post as you’ve detailed two methods of suicide. Can you take this down?

What?

Talking about suicide isn't forbidden.

willingtolearn · 30/09/2022 11:42

@OhFrogOff

It's a bit different in education as someone will always be put in front of the children.

But underfunding in the NHS = fewer staff, fewer experienced staff, lower qualified staff.

This leads to

Good staff leaving understaffed unit, struggling to recruit, unit being even more understaffed, poorer quality staff being recruited. Poor care becomes tolerated.

Which leads to

Poorer practice as even more good staff empty out, followed by reasonable staff leaving only poor quality or desperate staff who haven't found a way out yet. Poor care becomes normal. Incidents of abuse are tolerated by staff.

which then leads to

Critical shortage of staff, shoestring staffing with recruitment of warm bodies. Incidents of abuse become normal.

x2boys · 30/09/2022 11:37

OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 11:27

UNDERFUNDING DOES NOT LEAD TO ABUSIVE BEHAVIOUR.

So fed up of this argument.

Schools are underfunded, do you expect your children to be abused at school?

Very true and a lot of the situations shown were totally mismanaged they might not have had to restrain that patient had the just spent a bit of time alleviating her fears about having her injection,
And when Harley said give me a minute to get to my feet they didn't they just dragged her into seclusion
Not to mention the outright pinching and slapping patients

OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 11:27

UNDERFUNDING DOES NOT LEAD TO ABUSIVE BEHAVIOUR.

So fed up of this argument.

Schools are underfunded, do you expect your children to be abused at school?

Laiste · 30/09/2022 11:22

Saddened, not surprised.
Underfunded and understaffed - Under paid and under trained. Just like everywhere else.

The above is not going to result in good working practices. When combined in a healthcare setting with vulnerable people it's completely disastrous.

Chouetted · 30/09/2022 11:21

No, not shocked, particularly about the young woman in isolation - we've known this sort of thing was going on for years due to parents and relatives campaigning. Hopefully the Panorama documentary will embarrass some people sufficiently that conditions improve.

OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 11:17

No, I didn't find it shocking - it's pretty much how I have been treated in A and E multiple times so really not surprised it happens in a psych ward.

To be honest the entire psychiatric (which ever polarised model you look at world) is fucked because it is so divided. You have people shouting out about how awful the abuse is, yet at the same time they are asking vulnerable people to be involved with research that's not been through any ethics committees, then that research is being published, and used to inform services - the whole situation is absolutely fucking shit and no one seems to realise that it's a lack of ethics that are the very cause of abuse. NHS services don't look into what research they are using to inform their services (it's usually the "good patients" who actively exclude those who have different views).

I am so done with it all, there are so many trauma informed services going down the same path as GIDS purely because of stuff like this - and whilst I wouldn't say i have been abused in these services, they certainly stopped being helpful a long time ago (and are detrimental now).

Everywhere has problems retaining staff because who the hell in their right mind wants to work in a profession that spends the entire time arguing over which side is right or wrong, not just quietly but publicly and to the detriment of patients as well.

They then shout its because services are poorly funded (which they are) but they would certainly be a lot better funded if staff actually worked together and forged a way forwards rather than constantly slinging shit at each other and basing their work on shitty research done my unorthodox "charitable" bodies.

megletthesecond · 30/09/2022 11:04

I haven't watched it but I've seen the reports. It doesn't surprise me one bit. I've dealt with a few people in MH who are utter wankers who shouldn't be looking after people.

x2boys · 30/09/2022 11:00

willingtolearn · 30/09/2022 10:53

I'm not shocked but saddened. I have experienced a secure mental health ward in the 90s that had its struggles but provided much better care and opportunities for patients.

Secure mental health can be more about containment than treatment. One thing I was shocked at was how long people had been there. If treatment is running into years then a new environment and plan is needed.

The fact that staff were leaving and that they couldn't recruit means that many nurses and support staff were not okay with what was going on and refused to participate - but this leaves behind those that were.

Panorama were called in by whistle-blowers - I would imagine these were staff that had left and wanted to make sure it was dealt with. They may have put themselves into worse employment situations to do this and I hope they can now feel that this situation is going to be dealt with.

Some of it is down to poor management - the newly qualified nurse should not have been managing the ward. She needed supervision and guidance from someone who was not part of the toxic culture - but that clearly wasn't happening. She had absorbed the bullying and unprofessional culture and now seemed to see it as normal, which means she would continue to reinforce this pattern with any students/ new support staff.

I'm not sure they are going to be able to keep that unit going once they have got rid of all the problematic staff. They might have to rotate staff from other areas, which might be an idea in the future so that individual staff can be prevented from their clique like group dynamics.

I did laugh at the 'top' Pyschiatrist/ mental health nurse going 'that shouldn't be happened, that's not protocol' - no shit Sherlock.

I don't know what they will do but its huge unit is has 11 wards ,the trust has issues retaining staff anyway ,newly qualified nurses do get a preceptorship and they are supposed to be signed off from it but I guess how good that is,will be variable ,I worked in a different part of the trust ,but itcwasent unusual for trained staff to work long days ie 12 hrs as the only qualified nurse ,it was very difficult to take a break..

Explaintome · 30/09/2022 10:58

I didn't see the documentary hut I've read the news articles.

Unfortunately no it doesn't surprise me that people often behave unimaginably cruely when put in a position of power over vulnerable people.

willingtolearn · 30/09/2022 10:53

I'm not shocked but saddened. I have experienced a secure mental health ward in the 90s that had its struggles but provided much better care and opportunities for patients.

Secure mental health can be more about containment than treatment. One thing I was shocked at was how long people had been there. If treatment is running into years then a new environment and plan is needed.

The fact that staff were leaving and that they couldn't recruit means that many nurses and support staff were not okay with what was going on and refused to participate - but this leaves behind those that were.

Panorama were called in by whistle-blowers - I would imagine these were staff that had left and wanted to make sure it was dealt with. They may have put themselves into worse employment situations to do this and I hope they can now feel that this situation is going to be dealt with.

Some of it is down to poor management - the newly qualified nurse should not have been managing the ward. She needed supervision and guidance from someone who was not part of the toxic culture - but that clearly wasn't happening. She had absorbed the bullying and unprofessional culture and now seemed to see it as normal, which means she would continue to reinforce this pattern with any students/ new support staff.

I'm not sure they are going to be able to keep that unit going once they have got rid of all the problematic staff. They might have to rotate staff from other areas, which might be an idea in the future so that individual staff can be prevented from their clique like group dynamics.

I did laugh at the 'top' Pyschiatrist/ mental health nurse going 'that shouldn't be happened, that's not protocol' - no shit Sherlock.

x2boys · 30/09/2022 10:50

In all the years I worked in mental health ,I will say that not everyone is cut out for the job and some people do get a power kick having authority over others,but I have never seen behaviour by whole teams like was shown ,something has gone very ,wrong for staff to think it's acceptable to behave as they did

Swipe left for the next trending thread