Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Did anyone watch the panorama documentary about the psych hospital and wasn't shocked?

67 replies

missbipolar · 30/09/2022 09:10

As someone who's had several psych admissions, the panorama doc didn't shock me. When I was one of the wards one of the support staff told me if I really wanted to die DESCRIPTION OF SUICIDE METHODS WITHDRAWN BY MNHQ we used to hear the night staff bitching about patients, checks often weren't preformed correctly- I was 5 minute checks for awhile and on multiple occasions wasn't checked for 45mins to an hour. Patients get locked out of their rooms as its "easier" for staff to deal with but this can sometimes be for over 24 hours and there's not really any place for them to sleep outside of the room. And then when you get discharged in alot of cases there's almost zero follow up for a while which means people end up bouncing back in. Rooms where frequently stripped and it took could weeks for people to get their stuff back, with some often wearing the same clothes for several days.

Obviously what happened at the hospital on panorama was dangerous and they absolutely deserve to be shut down but did anyone else not actually find it shocking?

POST EDITED BT MNHQ

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Miffee · 30/09/2022 16:57

Notplayingball · 30/09/2022 13:47

"Built in with the bricks"

It's a well known phrase used for staff like this.

I have only used that phrase used positively, although admittedly outside of institutional settings.

OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 16:40

Have you been able to complain about the care you received and has anyone listened to you?

No, Yes (after several months and I had to quit services for someone to listen and then it was only done because they realised they were implicated by not raising it, not because they actually wanted to raise it), and currently a big fat No.

Suedomin · 30/09/2022 16:21

I was shocked and very saddened by it.
I'm sorry that you have experienced such terrible care. Have you been able to complain about the care you received and has anyone listened to you?

Mrsherdwick · 30/09/2022 16:16

Just watched this programme on catch-up. Absolutely appalling behaviour by staff. I’ve worked on understaffed wards (general wards- 1 nurse to 16 patients) and I’ve never seen such behaviour as this. It’s cruel, bullying behaviour and I hope something is done very quickly.

Eightiesgirl · 30/09/2022 13:56

My dh ended up on one after an episode of psychosis. It was a terrible place but there was no where else for him to go and we were in the dark about these things. We've since had mental health nurses visiting him at home and the majority have been marvellous people.

Notplayingball · 30/09/2022 13:47

Miffee · 30/09/2022 12:00

Another aspect of this is institutionalisation of staff. What struck me from the reports in Manchester was the phrase "she's the cancer of the ward and needs cutting out".

Obviously on the surface its fucking horrific but I think it speaks to something even more troubling about the way staff have a very warped view of their workplace. Too much ownership of it? I can't quite put into words what I mean.

"Built in with the bricks"

It's a well known phrase used for staff like this.

Goldyfishy · 30/09/2022 13:35

Professionals are also frightened to whistleblow for fear of losing their career - it’s is a realistic fear as well. the supposed protection in place isn’t sufficient and there is a real risk of senior staff banding together to cover up.

Goldyfishy · 30/09/2022 13:31

Used to work in mental health, supporting young people when they came out of psychiatric units - not shocked at all, unfortunately

Junipercrumble · 30/09/2022 13:25

Sadly not surprised at all.
This goes on far more than most people realise, up and down the country, wherever vulnerable people are being looked after.

I have an extremely vulnerable family member who has been treated appallingly by many so called professionals their whole life, including being punched in the face, being lifted up by their neck, having their complaints totally dismissed time and time again, stopped from eating, physically prevented from using the toilet, manipulated and lied to, been screamed abuse at, name calling, told they are hated by professionals.
When this family member eventually attempted to commit suicide after months of self harming, was told by mental health professionals that it was their family that was responsible for making them feel suicidal, as apparently, suicide and self harm issues are deemed to be the fault of whoever cares for the person, if they cannot find another plausible reason within a short counselling session.
This is despite family members repeatedly detailing a comprehensive list of support that this person needs, which social care agree needs to be put in place, but with the red tape and politics that surround securing funding and the way providers of support are expected to wait months for payment, even once funding has been agreed, many providers cannot afford to wait and are now insisting upon payment up front, leaving my relative without the necessary support, but apparently, it is all the fault of the family that family member is suicidal and self harming. 🤔

x2boys · 30/09/2022 13:22

I think if you go to work in a toxic environment, if you are quite naieve it's easy to get sucked into that cycle of abusive behaviour ,I remember the first ward i worked on as a newly qualified mental health nurse back in the 90,s there were quire a few stsff with really strong characters ,who were not necessarily the most caring nurses, they were not anything like the staff shown on this documentary, but they had a low level.dislike of some patients ,mainly patients with challenging behaviour, its easy to get drawn in ,I think sometimes staff have t9 step back to see the bigger picture and realise sometimes they are part of the problem.

Mischance · 30/09/2022 13:13

OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 11:27

UNDERFUNDING DOES NOT LEAD TO ABUSIVE BEHAVIOUR.

So fed up of this argument.

Schools are underfunded, do you expect your children to be abused at school?

It does if it results in the employment of unsuitable staff.

Laiste · 30/09/2022 13:10

It's a simplified message - but under funding does lead to abuse going unchallenged.

Laiste · 30/09/2022 13:08

OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 11:27

UNDERFUNDING DOES NOT LEAD TO ABUSIVE BEHAVIOUR.

So fed up of this argument.

Schools are underfunded, do you expect your children to be abused at school?

Schools are also underfunded, yes, and the most minimum result of that is that children aren't getting the help they need with their education. There are shit staff in schools which don't pay well or provide decent training. Support for the most vulnerable children is bad/missing. Safe gaurding situations are missed.

If children were in their state schools round the clock, i don't doubt there would be abuse in some cases.

Bad practice, careless attitudes and abusive behaviour thrive in under funded, understaffed and under trained jobs.

As pp said: not all bad staff are abusive, but all abusive staff are bad. Bad work places attract bad staff and repel good ones.

Oblomov22 · 30/09/2022 13:01

Haven't see it. But I doubt it will surprise me. My parents are retired social workers and went to such places weekly.

Why was the post taken down describing suicide. Surely we should be able to talk about these delicate issues?

OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 12:57

www.itv.com/hub/secure-hospital-uncovered-exposure/10a1607

(Apologies Stacey Dooley was not undercover)

OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 12:56

www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/p082bxzn

OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 12:56

www.channel4.com/press/news/dispatches-undercover-inside-priory

There was also one on people detained for extended periods with learning difficulties - i cannot remember the title.

Antarcticant · 30/09/2022 12:49

LuckyLil · 30/09/2022 12:23

All I really thought was that nothing whatsoever was learned from the Panorama program about Winterbourne View a decade ago. Maybe as a society we need to stop being shocked and appalled and actually do something about it.

Exactly my thoughts, and there have been other undercover investigations after Winterbourne as well.

OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 12:43

@LuckyLil agreed, but nothing is learnt because the same lines are wheeled out "understaffed, underfunded, under resourced"

Fififi1303 · 30/09/2022 12:37

x2boys · 30/09/2022 12:27

It ,s a forensic unit
In fact I'm not sure why Harley the girl with autism was detained there because they said she didn't have a criminal record ,maybe there were just no other suitable places for her to go?

People without criminal records are sent to MSU usually because they show extreme levels of violence and aggression towards staff and other patients. They can't be safely managed in other environments that's why the staff said they can't move them as no one will take them. The only level above is Rampton for females. That bit was glossed over in the documentary. I found it awful swearing calling patient names , pinching just evil. No professional boundaries or care. A toxic work culture with no leadership. If someone hates their job just leave there's loads of caring jobs out there. Personally I would never choose to work in a female MSU I know it's just not for me.

People do have things taken out of their bedrooms to manage risk. There's a high level of risk I personally don't think long term inpatient for PD does patients any good it tends to make them worse.

DontKeepTheFaith · 30/09/2022 12:31

missbipolar · 30/09/2022 11:56

I do think underfunding does come into it to some degree although the fact they're understaffed is the biggest problem. The ward I'm talking about here (I've been on 4 in the last 18 months, while the others had their issues this ward was by far the worst) didn't really have the budget for agency staff etc, so sometimes there was only 1 nurse and 4 support staff on during the day when it's supposed to have 2 nurses and 6 support staff when fully staffed. The ward manager was almost never seen often working from home, and when your work from home you don't actually get to see the issues that are going on.

Staffing is an issue but safe staffing levels should always be maintained and that is very senior management that need to be held responsible for that.

I hold management entirely responsible and they need to be facing investigations and consequences.

As a ward manager who has worked on the wards as a staff nurse and charge nurse for years, I won’t work from home for that reason, you need to have eyes and ears on the ward, to ensure patient care needs are met and staff feel supported.

I’m not in today because of a sick husband before anyone asks why I’m on MN😉

x2boys · 30/09/2022 12:27

OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 12:21

@missbipolar no worries - I don't think it's anything to be sorry for was just explaining to the people who don't understand why specific methods should not be mentioned.

What really worries me about this is there are trusts on twitter that are being discussed openly, yet they haven't been picked up.

Also, I wondered why they had a forensic psychiatrist (personality disorder background) being interviewed (actually I thought she came across well), but why not someone with expertise in autism, and, why was it a forensic person? Surely there are many other people they could have approached.

I am glad she named abuse as abuse very early on though.

It ,s a forensic unit
In fact I'm not sure why Harley the girl with autism was detained there because they said she didn't have a criminal record ,maybe there were just no other suitable places for her to go?

LuckyLil · 30/09/2022 12:23

All I really thought was that nothing whatsoever was learned from the Panorama program about Winterbourne View a decade ago. Maybe as a society we need to stop being shocked and appalled and actually do something about it.

OhFrogOff · 30/09/2022 12:21

@missbipolar no worries - I don't think it's anything to be sorry for was just explaining to the people who don't understand why specific methods should not be mentioned.

What really worries me about this is there are trusts on twitter that are being discussed openly, yet they haven't been picked up.

Also, I wondered why they had a forensic psychiatrist (personality disorder background) being interviewed (actually I thought she came across well), but why not someone with expertise in autism, and, why was it a forensic person? Surely there are many other people they could have approached.

I am glad she named abuse as abuse very early on though.