Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think student loans based on household income are unreasonable

105 replies

Starsinyoureyes13 · 30/09/2022 08:48

My daughter will only be 17 when she starts uni next year, im hoping she gets into the halls of residence as then she will have her own room as currently she shares a room with her very messy and loud sister. Right now I'm currently the main earner in my home, I earn a little over 25k to support 4 of us, My partners business is going down the tubes and may have to call it a day as anything he earns is being put into the company. So come next year my daughter will get about £600 in bursary and 6100 in a loan, she won't be able to get a bar job as she is under 18 and any work she does will pay bare minimum due to her age, so looks like I'll have to fund her until she's 18 which won't be until next January. How do other parents cope with their kids at uni do you part fund them?
Its all confusing
Though still see it as unreasonable that household income dictates who gets what

OP posts:
RubyWho · 30/09/2022 17:24

This was why I couldn’t go to Uni in 2003 when I was 18. Household income was high but my parents had a huge mortgage, three kids, massive debts. Even if I’d taken a year off and worked full time it wouldn’t have been enough to pay for tuition, and commuting costs (no way could I have afforded halls etc so would have had to go to uni locally, I live in London so not as limiting as jr sounds).

no way around it so I waited till I was 21, and a “mature student”, did the application on my income alone and got 2 x loans - maintenance and tuition.

is taking a year out to work an option for your DD?

Starsinyoureyes13 · 30/09/2022 17:12

Why would she not go to uni at 17? Age wise she'll we a few months younger than others from her school class who are also going to uni? And being a few months younger didn't stop great exam results. She wants to go to uni so she has her own bedroom, something she never had and personally think it would be making of her. If she gets a job in a food place, I'd not be happy not because there's anything wrong with working in a food place, because then she'd have pulled a blinder pretending she couldn't cook and having me make all her dinners..

OP posts:
worriedniece · 30/09/2022 13:39

Why is she going when only 17 and a year early? Maybe she could get a gap year job and defer?

mrsjohnnylawrence · 30/09/2022 10:30

I graduated in 2004 and got the full loan as my parent was on 13K

But you say 25K which sounds to me like it would be the equivalent of that now, as in it's a very low income.

I did a calculation based on 9K a year student fees and this is the entitlement:

Tuition Fee Loan
You could get a £9,000 Tuition Fee Loan each year to pay for your course.
Maintenance Loan
You could get a £9,706 Maintenance Loan to contribute towards your living costs.
How your Maintenance Loan is calculated:
£9,706 (the maximum Maintenance Loan available)

  • £0 (the amount you might not be eligible for, based on your answers)
= £9,706 (the amount you could be eligible for, based on your answers)

I didn't live in extortionate halls and rented but the loans only covered my rent so I worked more or less full-time doing care work.

The uni will have an employment agency and you can actually get some decent jobs from it too.

I lived it up and ended up with a 2:2 which was fine. Because I'd ben working throughout uni, and had my previous work experience, I walked into a job straight out of uni.

She's starting her adult life here. My parents gave me zilch when I was at uni as they were very poor.

Hoppinggreen · 30/09/2022 10:23

I agree, it’s a loan to be paid back. I don’t see how the income of people who won’t be paying the loan back is relevant at all.

hangonsnoopy · 30/09/2022 10:21

If your combined income is around 25k, your daughter will get the full loan. The form to fill in for current year income rather than previous years is very straightforward.

Both my kids got their income based bursaries automatically from the uni,based on the figures provided from their loan application. They didn't even apply to the uni for them.

whirlyhead · 30/09/2022 09:56

I took a year out at 17 and worked to earn money to go as my parents couldn't afford to subsidise me (and I didn't expect them to either). I just did an admin job in an accountancy firm which was fine and provided me with enough cash. Could she not do something like that? Hairdressers are also good places to work when you're young.

I don't quite understand why people think students shouldn't have a job as well as studying nowadays. Everyone had a part time job when I was a student and plenty of people got very good degrees. It's good training for the world of work as well.

KassandraOfSparta · 30/09/2022 09:55

DD is 17 and in her last year at school, lots of her friends have jobs already and are putting money aside. It is harder getting jobs in hospitality under 18 as you are not allowed to serve alcohol in restaurants/bars so most of them are working in retail, local cafes, ice cream parlours etc etc etc. Bar work as a student is crap because you're working when everyone else is out having fun.

She needs to think outside the very narrow box of bar work, and so do you.

ChristmasJumpers · 30/09/2022 09:53

I topped up my student loans with part time office work (evenings/weekends). I've never worked in a bar but managed to work throughout my 3 years in various places. There's tons of options. I do hate that young people are paid less but they are still paid so it's worth having a job if her loan won't be enough

Lifeisgood1 · 30/09/2022 09:53

Is she doing nursing? Care work/agency

Explaintome · 30/09/2022 09:50

If your household income is just over £25k she'll get £9568 maintenance loan?

WagathaChristieMystery · 30/09/2022 09:50

Can she apply for a bursary from her uni? Lots of them offer bursaries, and many offer scholarships too

TheLoupGarou · 30/09/2022 09:50

When I was a student absolutely loads of us used to do waitressing and hotel work - pay used to be good for silver service/functions.

KangarooKenny · 30/09/2022 09:47

There are other jobs than bar work.

CollieWobble22 · 30/09/2022 09:47

Those things called shops....

When I went to university I saved before going by working as a waitress and when I got there and had settled in - I worked in a supermarket. 😁

TheLoupGarou · 30/09/2022 09:46

Agree your DD could either defer for a year and work or look for a job in retail/coffee shop that she could maybe transfer to her uni town?

TheLoupGarou · 30/09/2022 09:44

Shared rooms is definitely not the norm in most places. I went to uni in Manchester in the late 90's and I think only one of the halls had shared rooms and that has since gone.

My mum had shared 'digs' at Sheffield uni but that was in 1970!

Phos · 30/09/2022 09:42

No they're not unreasonable, what else would you base it on? I understand that £25k supporting 4 is different from £25k supporting 2, for example, but they can't look at it all on a case by case basis, there are too many.

And although she can't do bar work, there are plenty jobs she can do at her age and not all pay "bare minimum" - I worked at McDonalds at 16-17 and earnt a LOT more than friends working in shops and cinemas. Jobs involving food prep generally pay a bit more.

Explaintome · 30/09/2022 09:42

Why is she going so young?

Most DC I know work at least the summer beforehand to save something towards their living costs. DS did McDonalds. Work FT for 3 months from when Alevels finish, she should be able to save £3000, which is enough to cover expenses other than accomodation for the year. There's lots of work she doesn't need to be 18 for.

I think most families expect to have to contribute something and plan for that though. Maybe she needs a year out so you can all save some money?

DashboardConfessional · 30/09/2022 09:37

Some universities are cheaper to live at than others. She will get her own room whether she is in halls or not. Students don't share rooms. That's an American thing.

Not true. Absolutely tons of shared rooms at Durham where I went.

CasaDelSoot · 30/09/2022 09:36

@Alexandra2001 Scotland has no tuition fees for Scottish students but we still have to fund our DD. Her student loan only just covers her accommodation. And if she were in a more expensive city it wouldn't even cover that on minimum loan.
Her living expenses still have to be paid by us and by her working.
So no tuition fees doesn't mean its cheap for parents to send their kids to university. Yes cheaper for the student in the long run as no repayments once working but not cheaper for the parents.

Summerfun54321 · 30/09/2022 09:36

Also agree with other PPs that she could take a year out to work and save before uni as well.

Summerfun54321 · 30/09/2022 09:35

Why would she want bar work anyway? Sounds pretty grim. I did admin work and hotel work as a student. Much better to be in a quiet calm work environment as respite from busy student life. Yes it’s not fair but life isn’t fair, be positive for your DD and help her think of different work options. If she can get some work experience as a student she’ll be more employable than a student who’s lived off of hand outs and never worked.

MintJulia · 30/09/2022 09:35

Why is she going to uni a year early. Why not let her take a year out, get a job, save some money. Also gives your partner time to get sorted.

And there are loads of jobs a 17yo can do.

Runnerduck34 · 30/09/2022 09:33

YANBU
It is unfair to base a loan to students on their parents income. Not all parents can or will support young adult offspring .
At 18 you are legally an adult and can vote, get married, die for your country etc but then the govt. look at your parents income to see how much of a student loan you can get.
The full loan amount of 9.5k is what you really need to live on when at uni so if you don't qualify for it the difference does need to be made up somehow- it is unfair.
If your income is 25k you should get the full amount though.
Does your DH accounts show he isn't taking a salary from his business? I think they look at the earnings for previous years though. If circumstances have changed phone Student finance for advice.
She may need to find work, can she find a job now and save as much as possible before she goes. Might be some Xmas jobs coming up.